I ran 962 Louisville listings through a rental screen. Only 25 cash flow at list pric
I wanted an honest answer to a question I get a lot: do houses in Louisville still cash flow at today's rates? So I ran every move-in-ready single-family listing in Jefferson County through the same set of numbers and looked at what survived.
I started with about 2,000 active single-family listings under $400k from the MLS. Then I removed anything that wasn't a straightforward rental purchase: condos and townhouses, auctions, cash-only or court-approval sales, listings mentioning major rehab, fire damage or as-is condition, properties with tenants in place, and listings with too few photos to judge. That left 962 houses.
For financing, I used 20% down on a 30-year investor loan at 8%. The Freddie Mac average was around 7.25% last week, and investor loans usually price higher than that. I estimated property taxes using actual local tax rates and insurance at the greater of $1,100 a year or 0.45% of the price. I set aside 17% of rent for vacancy, maintenance and capex, and calculated cash flow both self-managed and with an 8% property manager. Every house was run at full list price with no negotiation.
Rent was the part I cared most about getting right. Instead of using Zillow estimates, I based rents on about 1,000 actual single-family leases in the MLS from the last 12 months, plus current asking rents reduced by 3% to account for the gap between asking and achieved rent. Each estimate accounted for square footage, beds, baths, age and ZIP code, then got checked against the ten closest comparable leases within two miles. Where the estimate came in well above the nearby comps, I treated that as a warning sign.
The results were humbling. Only 25 of the 962 houses cash flowed at list price self-managed, and only five still worked after paying a manager. Nearly all the ones that worked were in a few South End ZIPs and 40217, mostly under $200k. The best one came in around $360 a month self-managed. Most were closer to $100 to $150.
My main takeaway is that at 8% money, the deal comes from the purchase price, not the list price. For every house I also calculated the break-even price and the price that would produce $200 a month. That's the number I'd use as a ceiling when writing an offer. With homes sitting longer here, plenty of sellers have room to negotiate.
One caveat: these rents are estimates, not signed leases. Before buying, I'd still pull the actual comps, walk the property and verify condition.
For those of you running similar screens in your markets, what reserve percentage are you using, and are you finding anything that cash flows at list price?