I ran 962 Louisville listings through a rental screen. Only 25 cash flow at list pric

I ran 962 Louisville listings through a rental screen. Only 25 cash flow at list pric

Ryan BrownPro Member
Real Estate Agent · Louisville, KY · Member since 2022 · 128 posts · 44 votes

I wanted an honest answer to a question I get a lot: do houses in Louisville still cash flow at today's rates? So I ran every move-in-ready single-family listing in Jefferson County through the same set of numbers and looked at what survived.

I started with about 2,000 active single-family listings under $400k from the MLS. Then I removed anything that wasn't a straightforward rental purchase: condos and townhouses, auctions, cash-only or court-approval sales, listings mentioning major rehab, fire damage or as-is condition, properties with tenants in place, and listings with too few photos to judge. That left 962 houses.

For financing, I used 20% down on a 30-year investor loan at 8%. The Freddie Mac average was around 7.25% last week, and investor loans usually price higher than that. I estimated property taxes using actual local tax rates and insurance at the greater of $1,100 a year or 0.45% of the price. I set aside 17% of rent for vacancy, maintenance and capex, and calculated cash flow both self-managed and with an 8% property manager. Every house was run at full list price with no negotiation.

Rent was the part I cared most about getting right. Instead of using Zillow estimates, I based rents on about 1,000 actual single-family leases in the MLS from the last 12 months, plus current asking rents reduced by 3% to account for the gap between asking and achieved rent. Each estimate accounted for square footage, beds, baths, age and ZIP code, then got checked against the ten closest comparable leases within two miles. Where the estimate came in well above the nearby comps, I treated that as a warning sign.

The results were humbling. Only 25 of the 962 houses cash flowed at list price self-managed, and only five still worked after paying a manager. Nearly all the ones that worked were in a few South End ZIPs and 40217, mostly under $200k. The best one came in around $360 a month self-managed. Most were closer to $100 to $150.

My main takeaway is that at 8% money, the deal comes from the purchase price, not the list price. For every house I also calculated the break-even price and the price that would produce $200 a month. That's the number I'd use as a ceiling when writing an offer. With homes sitting longer here, plenty of sellers have room to negotiate.

One caveat: these rents are estimates, not signed leases. Before buying, I'd still pull the actual comps, walk the property and verify condition.

For those of you running similar screens in your markets, what reserve percentage are you using, and are you finding anything that cash flows at list price?

3Reply
1,581 views

Most Popular Reply

Diana KhanPro Member
Attorney · 10451 Mill Run Cir #755 Owings Mills, MD 21117 · Member since 2024 · 813 posts · 292 votes
4d
Quote from @Ryan Brown:

I wanted an honest answer to a question I get a lot: do houses in Louisville still cash flow at today's rates? So I ran every move-in-ready single-family listing in Jefferson County through the same set of numbers and looked at what survived.

I started with about 2,000 active single-family listings under $400k from the MLS. Then I removed anything that wasn't a straightforward rental purchase: condos and townhouses, auctions, cash-only or court-approval sales, listings mentioning major rehab, fire damage or as-is condition, properties with tenants in place, and listings with too few photos to judge. That left 962 houses.

For financing, I used 20% down on a 30-year investor loan at 8%. The Freddie Mac average was around 7.25% last week, and investor loans usually price higher than that. I estimated property taxes using actual local tax rates and insurance at the greater of $1,100 a year or 0.45% of the price. I set aside 17% of rent for vacancy, maintenance and capex, and calculated cash flow both self-managed and with an 8% property manager. Every house was run at full list price with no negotiation.

Rent was the part I cared most about getting right. Instead of using Zillow estimates, I based rents on about 1,000 actual single-family leases in the MLS from the last 12 months, plus current asking rents reduced by 3% to account for the gap between asking and achieved rent. Each estimate accounted for square footage, beds, baths, age and ZIP code, then got checked against the ten closest comparable leases within two miles. Where the estimate came in well above the nearby comps, I treated that as a warning sign.

The results were humbling. Only 25 of the 962 houses cash flowed at list price self-managed, and only five still worked after paying a manager. Nearly all the ones that worked were in a few South End ZIPs and 40217, mostly under $200k. The best one came in around $360 a month self-managed. Most were closer to $100 to $150.

My main takeaway is that at 8% money, the deal comes from the purchase price, not the list price. For every house I also calculated the break-even price and the price that would produce $200 a month. That's the number I'd use as a ceiling when writing an offer. With homes sitting longer here, plenty of sellers have room to negotiate.

One caveat: these rents are estimates, not signed leases. Before buying, I'd still pull the actual comps, walk the property and verify condition.

For those of you running similar screens in your markets, what reserve percentage are you using, and are you finding anything that cash flows at list price?

@Ryan Brown, that's a pretty interesting result, especially with only 25 out of 962 properties showing positive cash flow. For reserves, I wouldn't rely on one percentage for every property. I think the age and condition of the home matter a lot, especially when the expected cash flow is only $100 to $150 a month. One major repair could easily wipe that out.

I'm a real estate attorney and broker based in Maryland, and I work with investors on property purchases and rental matters. When looking at a potential investment, I always think it's important to understand what you're actually buying, including the property's condition, existing rental agreements, and any expenses that might not be obvious at first.

I appreciate you putting this research together, @Ryan Brown! It's a great reminder that a property looking good on paper doesn't always mean it's a good investment. Happy to stay connected!

See this reply in the discussion

5 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2021 · 788 posts · 509 votes
    6d

    @Ryan Brown - I'm curious as to the discount off of the listing price that make the property meet your minimum criteria? Essentially, what type of discount would you need across those properties you analyzed?

    • Ryan BrownPro Member
      OP
      Real Estate Agent · Louisville, KY · Member since 2022 · 128 posts · 44 votes
      6d

      Greg, the 25 I mentioned didn't need any discount. They already cash flow at full list price, self-managed. Any negotiation on those just adds to the return.

      For the rest, the discounts get unrealistic quickly. The typical house needed about 25% off list just to break even, and quite a bit more to produce real cash flow or cover a property manager. That's more than most sellers will give, so for the majority of those listings, no realistic negotiation turns them into rentals at today's rates. I'd spend my time on the ones that already work and the handful that are close.

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 519 posts · 158 votes
    4d

    Using achieved leases instead of Zillow, and shaving 3% off asking rents, makes this screen worth reading. Your numbers give the honest answer. At full list with 20% down, very few do. Most DSCR lenders don't size the loan on net cash flow after vacancy and management. They divide gross rent by the full payment with taxes and insurance, and commonly want 1.0 to 1.25. So a house can fail your screen and still be financeable, it just isn't paying you yet.

    Outside Louisville it's a similar story, rent commonly covers the full payment only once the loan sits nearer 75% of value than 80%. Buying under list or putting more down lowers the payment and lifts coverage, adding value lifts the rent. How far under list did your near misses need to go?

  • Diana KhanPro Member
    Attorney · 10451 Mill Run Cir #755 Owings Mills, MD 21117 · Member since 2024 · 813 posts · 292 votes
    4d
    Quote from @Ryan Brown:

    I wanted an honest answer to a question I get a lot: do houses in Louisville still cash flow at today's rates? So I ran every move-in-ready single-family listing in Jefferson County through the same set of numbers and looked at what survived.

    I started with about 2,000 active single-family listings under $400k from the MLS. Then I removed anything that wasn't a straightforward rental purchase: condos and townhouses, auctions, cash-only or court-approval sales, listings mentioning major rehab, fire damage or as-is condition, properties with tenants in place, and listings with too few photos to judge. That left 962 houses.

    For financing, I used 20% down on a 30-year investor loan at 8%. The Freddie Mac average was around 7.25% last week, and investor loans usually price higher than that. I estimated property taxes using actual local tax rates and insurance at the greater of $1,100 a year or 0.45% of the price. I set aside 17% of rent for vacancy, maintenance and capex, and calculated cash flow both self-managed and with an 8% property manager. Every house was run at full list price with no negotiation.

    Rent was the part I cared most about getting right. Instead of using Zillow estimates, I based rents on about 1,000 actual single-family leases in the MLS from the last 12 months, plus current asking rents reduced by 3% to account for the gap between asking and achieved rent. Each estimate accounted for square footage, beds, baths, age and ZIP code, then got checked against the ten closest comparable leases within two miles. Where the estimate came in well above the nearby comps, I treated that as a warning sign.

    The results were humbling. Only 25 of the 962 houses cash flowed at list price self-managed, and only five still worked after paying a manager. Nearly all the ones that worked were in a few South End ZIPs and 40217, mostly under $200k. The best one came in around $360 a month self-managed. Most were closer to $100 to $150.

    My main takeaway is that at 8% money, the deal comes from the purchase price, not the list price. For every house I also calculated the break-even price and the price that would produce $200 a month. That's the number I'd use as a ceiling when writing an offer. With homes sitting longer here, plenty of sellers have room to negotiate.

    One caveat: these rents are estimates, not signed leases. Before buying, I'd still pull the actual comps, walk the property and verify condition.

    For those of you running similar screens in your markets, what reserve percentage are you using, and are you finding anything that cash flows at list price?

    @Ryan Brown, that's a pretty interesting result, especially with only 25 out of 962 properties showing positive cash flow. For reserves, I wouldn't rely on one percentage for every property. I think the age and condition of the home matter a lot, especially when the expected cash flow is only $100 to $150 a month. One major repair could easily wipe that out.

    I'm a real estate attorney and broker based in Maryland, and I work with investors on property purchases and rental matters. When looking at a potential investment, I always think it's important to understand what you're actually buying, including the property's condition, existing rental agreements, and any expenses that might not be obvious at first.

    I appreciate you putting this research together, @Ryan Brown! It's a great reminder that a property looking good on paper doesn't always mean it's a good investment. Happy to stay connected!

  • Chris SeveneyBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Investor · VA · Member since 2015 · 21k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    4d

    This is one reason why I wouldn't be looking at on-market properties and would be talking to property managers to see if they have any tired landlords that are looking to sell assets from their portfolio.

    7e investments53 Reviews
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.