Everybody calls the single-family starter home the safe choice. When I ran the number

Everybody calls the single-family starter home the safe choice. When I ran the number

Andrew BoscoBusiness Member
Rental Property Investor · NH · Member since 2023 · 449 posts · 421 votes

Everybody calls the single-family starter home the safe choice. When I ran the numbers, it was the expensive one

When my wife and I came back to the US, we were set on buying a single-family. Two corporate jobs. The whole plan.

Then we looked at the payments. Even at 3 to 4% interest, we were seeing $3,000 to $4,000 a month for houses we'd actually want to live in.

I couldn't justify it. That's money leaving every month with nothing coming back in.

So we bought a 2-family instead. Our payment was $2,700, and the tenant upstairs paid $2,000 of it.

Put those side by side:

→ Single-family: roughly $3,000 to $4,000 a month out of pocket

→ House hack: about $700 a month out of pocket

That's somewhere between $2,300 and $3,300 a month that stays yours. Every single month.

I'll be honest about the trade-offs. You share a building with your tenant. You're the one they call. And with FHA, you're committed to living there for at least a year.

For a lot of people early in their career, those are small prices for that gap. For some, they're not, and that's okay. Just make it a decision based on the math.

DM me directly if you want to run your own single-family vs. house hack comparison.

#HouseHacking #RealEstateWealth #NHRealEstate

Andrew Bosco - Candor Investment Group534 Reviews
0Reply
364 views

9 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Stuart UdisPro Member
    Attorney · Philadelphia · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1w

    You laid out the pros and cons of house hacking well. It can make sense for a younger single buyer especially when the home logically can become a rental. A wide open market is rental housing that serves as a bridge for the young family. I've specifically been evaluating the affluent younger households. As a society its instilled in us we need to be homeowners. I live in Philadelphia where many move to the suburbs for schools and buy the starter home for $500-700K in the city as a bridge to the eventual suburban move. l've seen many of my friends make this unnecessary purchase even after trying to plead my case.

    Transactional costs alone between the purchase and sale could be 12-13% of the home purchase. Then you look at the data. Ongoing carrying costs are also higher between interest rates, insurance, ongoing maintenance etc. Even those who bought when rates were 2% have low monthly mortgages but everything else has increased drastically and the transactional costs still make moving on difficult. As a society are getting married and starting families later. We have student debt, costs across the board are up and most families don't have school aged children until they are in our mid 30's. Renting until that point could wisely mean redirecting much of the down payment and transactional costs to building a stronger financial foundation, eliminating student and other debts, allowing careers to develop to a point where earnings increase and enter the home buying market when schools really matter and be in position to buy the long-term home in a much better financial position. I believe in many instances buying the starter home is actually causing a lot of financial strain and greatly impacting the financial trajectory of many young families.

    I've been focusing more on building direct entry duplexes and townhomes for this demographic. Giving these young families the single family living experience without the financial constraints of making the starter home purchase. Sadly, most still make the bad investment. I've even had real estate agents tell me how wrong my strategy and housing product is but that's because they want the commissions that come from sales. The minority of sensible renters is still significant enough that my earliest deliveries over the past few years have been my easiest to absorb and the tenants stay. I've connected with a few others who in my market and other markets have been building for the same demographic and they are having similar success.

  • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1w

    My biggest issues with multi family are ease of resale and they generally aren't as plentiful as SFH in Class A neighborhoods.

  • Real Estate Agent · Portland, ME · Member since 2021 · 28 posts · 11 votes
    1w

    Andrew, the part I'd underline is your trade-offs paragraph. The payment gap gets the attention, but being the landlord next door is usually what decides whether someone is still happy in a 2-family a year later. Some people find it easy to live a floor away from their tenant and some don't, and it's better to be honest with yourself about that before buying.

    The other thing I'd check on any 2-family is whether it still works as a straight rental once you move out. If both units' rents can cover the payment and expenses on their own, the house hack becomes a long-term hold rather than something you have to sell.

    What turned out different from what you expected once you were actually living below a tenant?

  • Chris SeveneyBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Investor · VA · Member since 2015 · 21k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    1w

    I will give an opposing perspective. Do people consider your primary residence an investment? I do not consider my primary home an investment even thought I built it and have great equity in it. I built it for my personal satisfaction and lifestyle, just like people may choose a sports car or SUV over a sedan. Now what the original poster did is a very wise move to be frank, but there are tradeoffs like he mentions, and for some they would rather not have a tenant living next door. That is the decision new investors have to make sure they truly understand is the tradeoffs as being a landlord with tenants next door can be challenging.

    7e investments4.34 Reviews
  • Ryan SpathBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Boise, ID · Member since 2017 · 617 posts · 391 votes
    1w

    This is exactly why I'm such a big advocate for house hacking. You're going to have a housing expense regardless, so why not have someone else help pay it?

    I think too many first-time buyers focus solely on what they can afford rather than what that purchase could do for them financially over the next 5–10 years.

    The other benefit is that when you're ready to move, you potentially have an income-producing property to keep building wealth. This is a strategy I used when I first began!

  • Real Estate Agent · Boston, MA · Member since 2025 · 127 posts · 33 votes
    1w

    Andrew — you nailed it. I did my first house hack in Revere in 2020, and living for a fraction of a full single-family payment while someone else covered most of the mortgage is what let me keep buying — I'm at 17+ units across five deals now. Your $700/month to live there versus $2,700 alone isn't just cheaper, it's lower-risk: if one unit turns, you still have the other rent coming in, separate utilities, and newer systems help too. The 'most expensive 2-family in Manchester' line only matters if the in-place rents don't work — yours do. That's not the risky choice, that's the disciplined one. Happy to connect — my DMs are open.

  • V.G JasonPro Member
    Investor · Member since 2022 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1w

    Which usually appreciate more-- multifamily(sub 4 units) or SFH?

  • Member since 2017 · 131 posts · 73 votes
    5d

    There is a third option that rarely gets put in the comparison: buy the single family and rent the other bedrooms. In a lot of towns a 4 bedroom house is easier to find in a good neighborhood than a 2-family, which also answers Jules' point about resale, because you sell it later as a normal house.

    The math works differently than the duplex. Instead of one tenant covering most of the payment, two or three people each pay for a room, and when one moves out you lose a third of the income, not most of it. The trade-off is the one Levi raised, only closer: you share a kitchen with your tenants, not a wall.

    A few things to check before running the numbers. Look up how many unrelated people your city allows in one house, because some cap it at three or four. Price each room from room listings in that neighborhood, not by dividing a whole-house rent. And give every person their own lease for their room, so one person leaving does not end the arrangement for everyone else.

    Then do what Levi said and test the exit: if you move out, does renting your room too cover the payment and every cost? If it does, the starter home became the first rental.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    3d

    What exactly are you offering please?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.