Developer · Ocala, FL · Member since 2009 · 8 posts · 2 votes
For those of you who've been through a full real estate cycle, I'm curious. What finally made you stop buying in a market that had been good to you?
Was it prices getting too far ahead of rents? More homes sitting on the market? Or was it something you started noticing just from being out there doing deals?
I've been watching housing markets for a lot of years, and one thing I've learned is that the market usually gives you some warning before prices start moving.
When listings keep piling up but pending sales aren't keeping pace, I pay attention. It's not a perfect signal, but I've seen it play out many times.
Of course, some of the best investors I know can feel a market changing before the numbers catch up.
I'd be interested to hear from those who've been through it. What made you decide to stop buying, and looking back, did you make that call too early, too late, or just about right?
I do not try to time a market, I watch whether deals still clear my buy box. I buy single-family BRRRR houses in Memphis under $100K, in 38109, 38111, 38112, 38114, 38116, 38117, 38118, 38122, and 38128, with an ARV of $180K-$265K. I run the 1% rule first, and for Section 8 I look at $1,395-$1,950 for 3-bed-plus houses. When prices get ahead of rents in those ZIPs, the deals stop penciling, and I stop buying. That is my signal. I target DSCR at 70-80% LTV on the refinance, so if the rent does not support the loan, the market has turned for me, even if prices are still rising. Deal flow is my bottleneck, so I would rather wait for a deal that pencils than buy a house that depends on appreciation.
I'd use the past as a reference: learn the nature of a market, then you know what to expect from it.
Some markets have big appreciation runs, and when something like an economic turn or a rate hike slows real estate down, values and even rents take a hit. Texas saw great rises, and then some rents and property pro formas went soft once rates slowed things down.
Other markets grow slowly and consistently without that volatility. You won't see the peaks, but you won't see the valleys either. It's a lower-risk proposition, and a market like that is easier to read.
As builders in our market, we pay close attention to how much we're building and where, so we don't dilute our own market. It's almost like the market moves in slow motion, and you have a much clearer sense of what's going on than in markets that boom and then drift.
Your listings versus pendings read is a good one, and it has a cousin on the financing side that you can see deal by deal. When a rental that used to carry its own payment on rent now needs a bigger down payment to get there, prices or rates have run ahead of rents. You don't have to wait for a market report to see that, it's right there in the loan math on every file. That doesn't tell you to stop buying. It tells you the deal now depends on appreciation instead of rent, which is a different bet than the one that made the market good to you. Did you see that coverage squeeze show up before the inventory build last time around?
I do not try to time a market, I watch whether deals still clear my buy box. I buy single-family BRRRR houses in Memphis under $100K, in 38109, 38111, 38112, 38114, 38116, 38117, 38118, 38122, and 38128, with an ARV of $180K-$265K. I run the 1% rule first, and for Section 8 I look at $1,395-$1,950 for 3-bed-plus houses. When prices get ahead of rents in those ZIPs, the deals stop penciling, and I stop buying. That is my signal. I target DSCR at 70-80% LTV on the refinance, so if the rent does not support the loan, the market has turned for me, even if prices are still rising. Deal flow is my bottleneck, so I would rather wait for a deal that pencils than buy a house that depends on appreciation.
I actually stopped buying in 2021 and 2022 and was selling assets during that time period. That is because the market was too hot and did not make sense.
Let's take Austin as an example, which has been the hardest-hit market since 2022. Costs were primarily driven by a lot of people moving there from out of state and artificially inflating home prices. The majority of the population in that area, if you look at their average salary, could not afford the median-income home.
Now that migration has slowed, it has taken a harder hit because the money is not flowing in there to afford overpriced houses.
On the contrary, you're starting to see more listings on the market, with some people moving and some from distress.
As somebody who invests long term in real estate, I prefer to buy in soft markets and hold long term, compared to buying in hot markets and chasing the FOMO.
This is correct. And why I have scaled Austin (aggressively) this year and from the trend looks like another 8-10 months of this.
It's going to be a satellite tech hub, primo Texas position, etc. I live here too and know it's a great, great city.
To answer the question in general-- If you want to know how the market moves against you as a buyer. I can give you a difficult one, or a simple one. The latter should suffice:
At the local level -- Inventory & DOM decline at the same time(not necessarily at the same rate).
Hi Ken, I watch the same listings-versus-pendings read you do, and I would add days on market and the number of price reductions, because those show up before prices move.
From the agent side, the moment a market has turned for a buyer is usually simpler than the headlines make it: it is when the deals stop clearing their numbers. If the rent no longer supports the price, the taxes, and the insurance at today's financing, I stop recommending that market for that buyer, even if prices have not fallen yet.
I agree with James that the buy box is the real test. The market can feel fine while the math quietly stops working, and the math is what I trust.
@James Jones and @Ametria Chaney, I like how you both put it: the buy box is the real test. Pretty much the same signal, just looking at one deal at a time.
@Chris Seveney, your Austin example got me curious so I went back and checked the numbers. In March 2022, Austin had around 1,600 homes for sale and 2,100 pending sales. By June, listings had jumped to 5,600 while pendings barely moved, around 2,300. And that's exactly when home values peaked.
Values are down about 25% since then, and even today there are almost 4 times as many listings as pending sales.
Pretty interesting how clearly that shift showed up in inventory before prices started falling.
I stopped buying in 2022 (my last purchase was a break-even bust) because things just got too out of hand. But I had slowed down pretty good by then anyway, as not only do I self-manage my portfolio but was also managing other investor properties as well and I'm looking to slow down now, not ramp up as I get older. So I passed on a few things that would have been good deals but I don't really have any regrets.
@JD Martin a break-even last deal and no regrets sounds like you called it about right.
V.G., I like that test, so I ran it on Austin. Not quite there yet by your measure: October listings were basically the same as a year ago (11,600 vs 11,500), and days on market went up (84 vs 79). The one thing that did change is values, which have been flat since July after sliding since 2022. So your 8 to 10 month window sounds right.
Running the test yourself instead of just nodding along is the right instinct, and your numbers say Austin has stalled rather than turned. The catch is that flat values can hide a falling price. When a seller pays for a rate buydown or closing costs, the sale usually still records at the full contract price, so concessions are where a soft market shows up before the median moves. Days on market going from 79 to 84 is about 6 percent longer on nearly the same 11,600 listings. That's buyers taking their time, not a supply build. For buy and hold, rent is the tiebreaker. Flat prices with flat rents leave the DSCR math right where it was, so the deal still has to carry itself on today's rent. What have Austin rents done since July?