Where's My Money?
How do you handle deposit refunds? Last month, two tenants disputed their deposit refunds.
Tenant #1: The Heavy Smoker
After four years, this tenant moved out. During my video walkthrough, I commented how hard it was to breathe. The walls were yellow with nicotine, and you could see exactly where pictures had hung. The bedroom carpet looked like someone had changed an engine on it.
This unit was completely remodeled before she moved in.
We sent her an accounting of damages above normal wear and tear. She argued for two days.
Then we shared the video.
Tenant #2: The Revisionist Historian
After eight months, this tenant moved out under a mutual lease-break agreement. Another story for another time.
She requested a joint walkthrough, which I declined. After 20-plus years in this business, I've learned those rarely end well.
We refunded 35% of her security deposit.
She argued that her move-out video showed the apartment was clean and in good condition. I agreed it was in good condition and you can see she cleaned, but that doesn't mean damage-free.
We compared her move-in inspection report, which SHE completed, against our documented move-out damages.
She then claimed the damage was preexisting and insisted we use her move-out video instead.
Talk about revisionist history!
The lesson:
Document the property's condition before move-in.
Give tenants 72 hours to submit their move-in inspection. Your lease should establish your condition report as the baseline if they fail to submit theirs, subject to applicable law.
Record your move-out inspection and provide an itemized accounting within your state's required timeline.
Without documentation, you're arguing opinions. With documentation, you're discussing evidence.
What's your process for handling security deposit disputes?
Do you conduct joint move-out walkthroughs or let your documentation do the talking?