Investor · Worcester, MA · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
As a buyer, I want to see an accurate renovation budget and a realistic ARV backed by solid comps. If you underestimate the work or inflate the resale value, the deal falls apart once we dig into the numbers. Bring me a deal that works with realistic assumptions, and we have something to talk about.
What makes the biggest difference in getting your deals closed—accurate numbers, the right buyers, the seller relationship, or something else?
From the buyer side, Andrew — it's the numbers, every time. I buy small multifamily in Worcester, and the wholesaler deals I actually close on are the ones where the rehab budget is honest and the ARV is backed by real, recent comps — not best-case ones.
When the budget is light or the ARV is stretched, it doesn't survive underwriting. I have to re-price it, trust takes a hit, and most of those deals just die on my desk. The ones with realistic assumptions? We can talk the same day, because there's nothing to unwind.
Right buyer list matters, but accurate numbers are what get a deal to the closing table. Happy to connect — DMs open.
From the buyer side, accurate numbers are the whole game.
I buy single-family in Memphis under $100K, looking for ARV $180K-$265K and rent that hits the 1% rule. When a wholesaler brings me real rehab numbers, real comps, and beds and baths as they are now and as they could be after a 2/1 to 3/1 or 3/1 to 4/2 conversion, I can say yes or no fast.
Deals fall apart when the ARV is a hope, the rehab is a guess, or the rent is made up. Deals close when I can run DSCR at 70-80% LTV and the rent still carries it. Bring me that, and bring it often. Deal flow is the bottleneck.
Accurate numbers get the deal started. Follow up is what gets it closed.
Deals rarely fall apart over one big number. They die in silence. The seller gets a better call, the buyer cools off, and nobody notices until it’s too late.
What keeps them together:
Numbers that hold up when the buyer digs in, just like you said. Real comps and a real repair budget.
One update to the seller every week, on the same day, even when nothing’s changed.
The buyer hears from you before they ever have to ask.
At what stage do you see most deals fall apart on your side?
From the sourcing side, the killer I see most is title problems nobody checked before signing: back taxes, municipal liens, open code violations, or an estate where the seller doesn't have authority to sell yet. All of that is in public records and takes maybe an hour to pull, but plenty of wholesalers skip it and find out from the title company two weeks in. I'd put it right next to an honest rehab budget and ARV, because a deal with realistic numbers still dies if the seller can't deliver clean title. Do you ask wholesalers for a lien check up front, or run your own?
From the buyer side, Andrew — it's the numbers, every time. I buy small multifamily in Worcester, and the wholesaler deals I actually close on are the ones where the rehab budget is honest and the ARV is backed by real, recent comps — not best-case ones.
When the budget is light or the ARV is stretched, it doesn't survive underwriting. I have to re-price it, trust takes a hit, and most of those deals just die on my desk. The ones with realistic assumptions? We can talk the same day, because there's nothing to unwind.
Right buyer list matters, but accurate numbers are what get a deal to the closing table. Happy to connect — DMs open.
The numbers have to work, but getting a contract signed is only one part of it. You still have to coordinate the seller, buyer, title company, and anybody else involved to get it closed.
My advice is to get title started early, know what your buyer actually buys, and be upfront about the property's condition. Ask what still needs to happen before closing and who is handling it. Don't assume everything is moving just because nobody has called with a problem.
A buyer saying “I'll take it” and a buyer actually closing are two different things. Stay involved until the money changes hands.
You put it well, Andrew — from the buyer side, the numbers are the trust. On the disposition side here in San Antonio, I have seen the same thing: when the rehab and the resale math are honest, a buyer can say yes fast, and when they are stretched, the deal just dies in underwriting. I also agree with the follow-up point others made — staying in touch with the seller and the buyer while title is worked through matters as much as the first numbers. Happy to connect here if you ever want to compare notes on what makes a buyer actually close.
Lee's question about where they fall apart is a good one. From the systems side, a lot of them die in the gap between getting it under contract and getting it to the buyer and title.
Most of those are a missing piece of information, not a missing person. When a deal goes under contract, whoever handles dispo should get the same things every time: contract price, close date, access notes, repair estimate, and anything the seller was promised. If one of those is blank, it doesn't go out to buyers yet.
Same when it goes to title. A short checklist with a name and a date on each step (title ordered, liens checked, buyer deposit in) beats someone remembering to send a text. Travis's "who is handling" question is that checklist in one line.
From the agent side, the ones that close have clean title, realistic timelines, and a buyer who's already underwritten the deal. The ones that die usually blow up on inspection surprises or a buyer who never had the cash lined up.
Deals usually fall apart for 2 reasons from my 3+ years of wholesaling:
It wasn't a DEAL at all. The numbers were never right, or the location never made sense, etc.
It was a deal but the wholesaler made a newbie mistake, such as not making the cash buyer put down SIZABLE and NON-REFUNDABLE EMD, and the buyer found another house they liked more, and poof! Went missing.
Accurate numbers, and it isn't close. From the buyer's side, the deals that die on me almost always die in the first ten minutes of checking: the ARV is built on comps that aren't really comparable — different street, renovated money on an as-is house — or the rehab is a round number with no scope behind it.
What makes a wholesaler's deal easy to say yes to is when the homework is visible: closed comps I can verify myself, and a rehab figure that reads like it came from an actual scope — roof, mechanicals, kitchen, baths as separate lines instead of '30k rehab, light cosmetics' on a house that needs everything. If your numbers survive my checking, I'll trust your next deal faster, and that trust is what gets your calls answered first.
The second separator is the early title check. Back taxes, liens, code violations, a seller who can't actually sign — finding that in week one saves the deal; finding it at the closing table kills it and burns the buyer relationship with it.
Andrew, I'm on the other side of this right now — just getting started wholesaling around Harrisburg, PA, so I'm learning this from the underwriting side before I bring anything to a buyer.
The math that finally clicked for me is how fast a small ARV miss kills a deal. Say ARV is $200k and rehab is $40k. At 70% that's a max offer of $100k (0.70 x $200k - $40k). If those comps are really worth $180k instead of $200k, the max drops to $86k. That's a $14k swing from a $20k ARV mistake, before you even get to holding costs or a fee. So when I look at a deal now I want to see 3 closed comps, same beds/baths, within about half a mile and the last 6 months, and a rehab budget broken out by roof, kitchen, baths, and mechanicals — not just "$30k rehab."
The other thing a few buyers here have already said that stuck with me is checking title early. A deal can pencil perfectly and still die if the seller can't deliver clean title.
Still early for me, no closed deals yet, so I'm mostly listening and running numbers on everything I look at. But that's what I'd want to see if I was the buyer.
@Casey Policastro, the ARV math is the right thing to fixate on early. I'd have two or three Harrisburg flippers check your first few ARVs before anything goes under contract, since their read on resale decides whether a buyer bites. Do you have a buyer or two there you already trust? Where does wholesaling sit in your longer-term strategy? I'm open to talking strategy if you'd like.
Appreciate the vote and the mention, Marc. I'm early in this — no closed deals yet — so ARV discipline is exactly what I'm trying to build before I ever make an offer: pull it from the closest sold comps, not the seller's number, and let the repair estimate set the offer instead of the other way around. Getting two or three Harrisburg flippers to check my first few ARVs before anything goes under contract makes a lot of sense — if their read on resale is what decides whether a buyer bites, I'd rather learn that before I tie a deal up than after. Curious how you sanity-check ARV when the comps are thin.
(This reply was drafted with help from my AI assistant.)
From the acquisitions side, most of the deals I've seen fall apart were broken before the seller ever signed. The fix is to underwrite for the buyer first.
I start from the buyer's net: after roughly 8% of ARV in buying and selling costs and about 5% in holding, the buyer should still clear at least 15% of ARV, or a dollar of profit for every dollar of rehab on a fixer-upper. If my number doesn't leave that, I don't lock it up.
ARV comes from sold comps that match the house, not the best sale on the street. Repairs come from walking it or from real photos of the roof, AC, kitchen and baths.
Then I set the seller's expectations: here's the as-is price and why. When the math is honest up front, there's nothing to renegotiate later, and that's what keeps buyers coming back.
Spot on—realistic ARV and true rehab numbers are what keep deals from dying in due diligence. For us, it starts even earlier with targeting the right off-market seller data; when you pull genuine distress indicators (like tax-delinquent or vacant high-equity properties) instead of chasing over-marketed lists, sellers are way more realistic on price, which makes the numbers actually work for cash buyers
From what I see, it's the numbers first. Deals die when the ARV was stretched or the rehab was light and the buyer finds out on the walkthrough. Three close sold comps and a line item repair estimate up front saves most of them. On your side as a buyer, how often does the ARV you're sent actually hold up?
@Andrew Freed, I agree on the numbers, and I'd add to what @Dan Worth said about title. Bad numbers usually kill a deal early. Title kills it late, after everyone has spent time and money.
Three habits that help from the Texas side:
1. Open title the day the contract is signed, and read the requirements list in the title commitment before marketing the deal, not after.
2. Confirm who can actually sign. Estates are the big one. If the deed is still in a deceased owner's name, the heirs need probate, a muniment of title, or an affidavit of heirship the title company will accept before anyone can deliver a deed. A signed contract from one heir isn't a deal yet.
3. In Texas, someone marketing a contract without a license has to tell buyers in writing that they're selling their interest in the contract, not the property itself. The wholesalers who follow that rule tend to be the ones whose paperwork holds together at closing.
Disclosure: I'm the broker at Summit Cove Realty in DFW.