Real Estate Broker · Chicago and Kansas City · Member since 2016 · 117 posts · 107 votes
I'd love to hear real numbers from people who have done this.
A lot of first time buyers in Chicago start with a 2 flat. That's how I began as well.
For me, number that matters most isn't cash flow. It's what it costs you to live there each month after the other unit's rent comes in. Then put that next to what you paid in rent before.
If you've done it, share any of these:
What you paid in rent before you bought
What it costs you to live there now, after the tenant's rent
The neighborhood and if you are glad you chose there.
I haven't paid rent since 2018/2019 when I started house hacking (I think it was around $1200 for a 2 bed/1 bath so only about $600 for me).
I'm house hacking a 3-unit property with the other two units rented. Last year after all income & expenses (including mortgage interest and depreciation) my "loss" on paper was about -$13k.
I'm living in Portage Park. Overall I like the area, however I'm in the flight path for O'Hare so I do find the noise from the planes a little annoying.
I'd love to hear real numbers from people who have done this.
A lot of first time buyers in Chicago start with a 2 flat. That's how I began as well.
For me, number that matters most isn't cash flow. It's what it costs you to live there each month after the other unit's rent comes in. Then put that next to what you paid in rent before.
If you've done it, share any of these:
What you paid in rent before you bought
What it costs you to live there now, after the tenant's rent
The neighborhood and if you are glad you chose there.
@Dan Nelson, I like how you're looking at what it actually costs someone to live in the property after collecting rent. I don't have firsthand Chicago two-flat numbers to share, but I'd also want to account for repairs, vacancies, and maintenance when comparing the monthly cost with renting. Those expenses can change the picture quite a bit.
I'm a real estate attorney, broker, and investor based in Maryland, and I work with landlords and property owners on leases, contracts, and real estate transactions. I've seen how important it is to understand the rental agreements and the responsibilities that come with owning an investment property, even when you're living in one of the units.
Thanks for starting this discussion, @Dan Nelson! I'd be interested to see what Chicago owners share about their actual numbers. Happy to stay connected!
I haven't paid rent since 2018/2019 when I started house hacking (I think it was around $1200 for a 2 bed/1 bath so only about $600 for me).
I'm house hacking a 3-unit property with the other two units rented. Last year after all income & expenses (including mortgage interest and depreciation) my "loss" on paper was about -$13k.
I'm living in Portage Park. Overall I like the area, however I'm in the flight path for O'Hare so I do find the noise from the planes a little annoying.
@Dan Nelson Love the way your framed it! Living cost after other unit's rent is a better yardstick than cash flow. Comparing it to what you paid in rent before makes a lot of sense.
Not a Chicago guy, but I've helped hundreds of people with this in the Twin Cities. I actually recommend focusing on cash flow upon move-out because 90% of my clients will not be owner-occupants for the majority of their ownership. Reducing housing costs while you occupy is great, but the long-term goal is to purchase a cash-flowing asset. Having said that, many of us are paying $1,200 or less for a decent two- to three-bedroom unit and enjoying all the other benefits of real estate investing along the way.
2 units are tough to make work nowadays. Nearly all my BiggerPockets type clients go for 3 or 4 units. You will get much better cashflow or out of pocket ratios the more units you have generally. The only time I have seen 2 units work is if they have a big duplex up unit that rents high for example a 4br 2ba 2 story top unit.
The north side Chicago house hack math gets better and better each year you hold it as the rents increase and your mortgage stays mostly the same. This was for a 4 unit not a 2 unit. My mortgage 2020 was $2850 and rents $3750 for 3 of 4 units. Now the 2026 mortgage is $3260 as taxes, etc. went up, rent for 3 of 4 units is $5400 so that's a much larger gain in rents than mortgage. I see the trend continuing from both growth and just inflation growing the rents each year while the principal and interest portion of mortgage is fixed. Bought in Rogers Park on boarder of Edgewater, awesome area seeing more gentrification each year.
Yo Dan, I have about five mortgages and I have not made a single one of those mortgage payments myself.
It's always been offset by the rents but I imagine you know that because that's why you're here.
The common example in my area is you could be paying $2,000 a month in rent and you go into a fourplex and then your monthly housing expense goes essentially to zero or very close to it.
That's the play in our region and then you rinse and repeat that move several times.
Then you've unlocked probably a solid $5,000 a month of income over a couple years that works for you for the rest of your life.
Dan, I will agree with what most have said above - from a strict #s perspective, a 2unit is hard to make work. 4units are ideal, and I find most of my house-hacker clients go for 3 units (they seem like less of a bite to chew vs a 4unit, and slightly less competition against investors). That said, 2units are a tad less competitive and sometimes easier to come across. If you can find one with a duplex up/down, that helps. The pro forma might not be gang busters, but at the same time they are the right fit for certain house-hackers. Slightly easier barrier of entry, and better than not getting in the market. My first property I ever bought was a 2unit (double duplex, large units) - back in 2003, before the term "house-hacking" existed. Since then, my value has almost doubled, rents have more than doubled, and it's now a cash-cow. Didn't start out with the strongest NOI, but now is a great investment.