1 family vs 2 family rental

1 family vs 2 family rental

Rental Property Investor · Boonton Township, NJ · Member since 2017 · 19 posts · 4 votes

Hello!

I'm looking for my next rental in my market (northern NJ). I already have a 2-family home and would love another one. However, a single family (1 family) home fits my budget much more comfortably while a 2-family would be a stretch but still possible for me. There is also a larger inventory of 1- family homes in my area compared to 2-family.

I've never invested in a single-family home. What are some considerations for a 1-family home vs. 2- family? Would the tenant be responsible for more costs and maintenance in a single? 100% vacancy when a tenant moves out?

Also, rents in my area for a single family would have to be over $3k/month to make the deal work. I feel like this high of a rent would be harder to rent out compared to getting an apartment rented? Less of a tenant pool?

Thanks!

0Reply
946 views

Most Popular Reply

Staten Island, NY · Member since 2013 · 153 posts · 78 votes
4d

I’d compare the actual numbers on each property rather than assume a single family is easier to rent. If the single family has one tenant, a move out means the rent stops until it is re rented; with a two family, one unit can still produce rent while the other turns over. For the $3k target, I’d check recent leased comps for similar single family homes nearby and include vacancy, taxes, insurance, repairs and any owner paid utilities in the underwriting.

See this reply in the discussion

19 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Staten Island, NY · Member since 2013 · 153 posts · 78 votes
    4d

    I’d compare the actual numbers on each property rather than assume a single family is easier to rent. If the single family has one tenant, a move out means the rent stops until it is re rented; with a two family, one unit can still produce rent while the other turns over. For the $3k target, I’d check recent leased comps for similar single family homes nearby and include vacancy, taxes, insurance, repairs and any owner paid utilities in the underwriting.

    • Rental Property Investor · Boonton Township, NJ · Member since 2017 · 19 posts · 4 votes
      1d

      Thanks @Jimmy Samaha agreed that you need to compare the actual numbers.

      Any tips on where to find actual lease comps for rents? I've been going off other listings but not actual signed leases. Where can I find this data?

    • Staten Island, NY · Member since 2013 · 153 posts · 78 votes
      21h

      Best source is a local agent who can pull closed rentals from the MLS, since those show what units actually leased for, not just the asking rent. Local property managers are good too, they'll usually tell you what they're getting on similar units. Listing sites are fine for a rough range but the asking rent isn't always what it leases for.

  • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4d

    I tend to prefer single family due to ease of resale in the areas I invest in, less moving parts, less liability with one tenant vs multiples and likely better quality of neighborhood when looking at SFH vs multi.

  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
    4d

    Ekrem, I owned both single-family and small multifamily long-term rentals in Orlando before I moved into mid-term and short-term, so here's how your questions played out for me.

    Costs and maintenance: Yes, a single-family tenant can carry more. In my single-family leases, the tenant paid all utilities and took care of the lawn and yard. Write both into the lease clearly: utilities in the tenant's name before move-in, and what "maintained" means for the yard. On a 2-family, shared items like common areas or a shared meter tend to land back on the owner.

    Vacancy: It's 100% when the tenant leaves, no way around that. But in my experience the single-family vacancies weren't harder to absorb overall, because those tenants tended to stay longer, so I had fewer turnovers. I'd budget reserves for a full vacant month or two on the single-family instead of relying on a vacancy percentage.

    The $3k tenant pool: Before you buy, check whether $3k actually fits the market. Pull rent comps in the immediate area, not just the town, and match them by property size: same bedroom and bath count and similar square footage. A tool like Rentometer is a quick way to see where $3k falls for that size home in that location. If $3k is in the normal range for comparable homes nearby, the tenant pool is there. If it's at the top of the range or above it, that's a sign to consider whether this is the right property for you right now.

  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 774 votes
    4d

    I only buy single-family, so I will give you that side plainly. At 236 doors in Memphis, I buy single-family BRRRR houses under $100K, with an ARV of $180K-$265K, and I run the 1% rule first. One house, one tenant, one roof, and my in-house property management team knows the layout, the rehab, and the street. A 2/1 I can turn into a 3/1, or a 3/1 into a 4/2, changes the rent math, and for Section 8 I look at $1,395-$1,950 for 3-bed-plus houses. Your $3,000 rent is the real test in northern New Jersey. If that rent is at the top of the market for that size house, I would not buy it hoping a tenant appears. If the numbers clear the 1% rule and the rent is normal for the street, single-family is simple to own and simple to exit.

  • Member since 2017 · 131 posts · 73 votes
    4d

    Ekrem, one more way to look at the single family, since $3k from one tenant is where it gets thin.

    A 4 bedroom rented by the bedroom doesn't need one family who can pay $3k. It needs four people each paying for one room, and that pool is much bigger. It also fixes your 100% vacancy worry. When one person leaves you lose one room's rent, not the whole house.

    The trade is that you pay the utilities and internet, furnish at least the shared spaces, and you turn rooms more often than you'd turn a whole house. So run it both ways with real room prices from Facebook Marketplace and Roommates.com for that town, not a guess.

    Before any of that, call the town and ask how many unrelated people can live in one house. A lot of northern NJ towns are strict, and that answer decides whether this is even an option. If it's not allowed there, I'd lean toward stretching for the second 2 family, since you already know how to run one.

  • Joseph ScoreseBusiness Member
    Banker · Philadelphia · Member since 2009 · 2k+ posts · 650 votes
    3d

    Ekrem, I work with investors on financing in NJ, and I’d be careful about stretching for a two-family just because that’s what you already own. Having enough reserves after closing matters as much as the property type.

    You’re right about vacancy: when a single-family tenant leaves, all the rent stops. A two-family gives you another income stream, although one occupied unit may still fall short of covering your expenses.

    For the $3,000-plus rent, I’d look at comparable homes that actually rented, how long they took, and what they offered in parking, condition, outdoor space, and location. The asking rents alone wouldn’t give me enough confidence to buy.

    You can outline tenant responsibilities for utilities, lawn care, and snow removal in the lease, subject to local requirements. I’d still budget for repairs, major systems, and ongoing upkeep as the owner.

    My preference would be the property that leaves you comfortable carrying it through a vacancy and an unexpected repair. A single-family with solid rental demand and healthy reserves could be a better next purchase than a two-family that leaves you stretched.

  • Realtor · NJ · Member since 2023 · 222 posts · 100 votes
    3d

    Hi Ekrem,

    NJ investor / realtor here.

    3K a month for a 3 bed 2 bath home in northern NJ is a very doable target. I'd be more worried about what it will cost you to get the home into rent ready condition. Renting by the room is also a viable option depending on your location.


    Personally, I see more value in a 2 family home in NJ so if budget allows, I would opt for that instead.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    2d

    If you're already successful with a 2-family, why wouldn't you copy that process or even upgrade to a 3 or 4 unit?

  • Simon W.Business Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Lehigh Valley PA & New York City · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 697 votes
    2d

    The piece I'd add is putting vacancy and reserves in dollars, because that's what makes Joseph's point about reserves concrete. A single family at $3,000 a month is $36,000 a year. If it's empty for one month, you lose $3,000, which is about 8% of the year's rent, and you still pay the mortgage, taxes and insurance that month.

    A 2-family at $1,800 a unit is $43,200 a year. One unit empty for the same month loses $1,800, about 4% of the year, and the other unit still pays. Jimmy said the same thing in words, and the numbers are how I'd compare them on a spreadsheet.

    Whichever way you go, keep that lost rent in your own tracking. It isn't a deduction, it's just income you didn't get. I'd also hold a reserve account sized to cover a full vacant month plus one surprise repair, and run each property's income and expenses separately so you can see which one is actually carrying the other.

    Accounting Properties LLC
    View Page
    CFO LLC
    View Page
  • Shawn McenteerBusiness Member
    Realtor · Boonton Township, NJ · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2d

    hi @Ekrem Bermek 2 family is ideal for North Jersey however single family can work when leveraging creative rental strategies. Student housing and MTR tend to attract the highest ROI with single family. I don't see $3k in rent being an issue for a single family. I get over $3k for all my multi family units. The concern you'll run into with single family will be price, unless you are willing to do sizable renovation you will be going up against traditional buyers. Single family gets very competive.

    House Hacking New Jersey561 Reviews
    • Rental Property Investor · Boonton Township, NJ · Member since 2017 · 19 posts · 4 votes
      19h

      Thanks Shawn - Are you seeing single family acquisition more competitive than 2 -family in Boonton/surrounding areas? I'm definitely open/expecting to do sizeable renovation for a single family BRRRR. For your multi-family units, are you getting $3k for each unit? I just got a lease signed for 2bd/1ba for $2,100 in Boonton. It would be difficult for me to get $3k for this apartment or any of my other units.

  • Arman AhmedPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus Cleveland Dayton, OH · Member since 2024 · 2k+ posts · 975 votes
    2d
    Quote from @Ekrem Bermek:

    Hello!

    I'm looking for my next rental in my market (northern NJ). I already have a 2-family home and would love another one. However, a single family (1 family) home fits my budget much more comfortably while a 2-family would be a stretch but still possible for me. There is also a larger inventory of 1- family homes in my area compared to 2-family.

    I've never invested in a single-family home. What are some considerations for a 1-family home vs. 2- family? Would the tenant be responsible for more costs and maintenance in a single? 100% vacancy when a tenant moves out?

    Also, rents in my area for a single family would have to be over $3k/month to make the deal work. I feel like this high of a rent would be harder to rent out compared to getting an apartment rented? Less of a tenant pool?

    Thanks!

    Hey Ekrem, I’d look at the numbers more than just the property type. A single-family home can be easier to manage, but you’re taking on 100% vacancy when it’s empty. A two-family gives you another income stream to help offset that risk. I’d also keep an open mind about investing out of state. The Midwest has some attractive rental opportunities, and having a reliable local team makes a big difference when managing from a distance.

  • Gregory AcsPro Member
    Lender · MD · Member since 2025 · 286 posts · 102 votes
    2d

    One advantage of a two-family is that you still have rental income coming in if one unit becomes vacant, while a single-family means losing all rental income between tenants. On the other hand, single-family rentals can sometimes have longer-term tenants and fewer shared maintenance responsibilities. I'd compare both options based on net cash flow after vacancy, repairs, taxes, and insurance rather than just the monthly rent. Financing can also look different depending on the property type and projected rental income. What price range are you considering for each option?

    • Rental Property Investor · Boonton Township, NJ · Member since 2017 · 19 posts · 4 votes
      19h

      Thanks @Gregory Acs my budget for my next deal would be $500k (includes acquisition and repair costs). This budget for a 2-family in my area would get tight but for a 1-family it should be adequate.

  • Mechanicsburg, PA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    17h

    @Ekrem Bermek I've had both plus more than 2 tenant buildings. I've bought and sold over 1,000 properties for my own inventory. I prefer single family houses to rent. Some of the things I like are:

    At Apartments, I usually end up paying water, sewer, trash and storm water. I don't pay Heat or Electric for any tenant. I have to pay for lawn care and snow removal. It has been my experience that apart tenants, stay for shorter terms and are a little more rough of the properties.

    At houses tenants pay water, sewer, trash, and storm water. And they mow the lawn and shovel the snow, and they stay a long time. One current tenant has been there 26 years, and I've had other tenants stay more than 30 years. In my experience, longer tenancy means fewer vacant time, fewer repairs and expenses, and a better bottom line. My Buy Box is single family detached house with 3 bedrooms, 2+ baths, 2 car garage (everybody has cars but most store their stuff in the garage, and the more stuff they have the longer they stay because its harder to move all their stuff) and built since year 2000. And in an area with good schools, low crime, and a residential area with mostly owner occupants.

    I've said this before. A prospect asked if I'd permit a piano, I said sure. Because the more big heavy things they bring, the longer they stay. While doing a minor repair at a rental, I saw the 30 year tenant had lottery ticket and the prize was huge like $500 million. I asked if you win, what are going to do with all that money. I expected something like buy an island in Fugi. He said If I win, I going to buy this place. I said if you win I'll sell this place to you.

    • Rental Property Investor · Boonton Township, NJ · Member since 2017 · 19 posts · 4 votes
      17h

      @David Krulac

      @David Krulac

      Thanks for the response. Agreed with you on all the points you made! I love how you encourage your tenants to make deep roots at your property. Makes them harder to move and will keep the tenants much longer than small apartments.

  • Mechanicsburg, PA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    16h

    @Ekrem Bermek I had one 30 year tenant, who I asked if they ever considered moving. They said the only way they're moving out horizontal. Another tenant was there for nearly 3 years and called and asked if they were going to renew their lease. They said they were going to renew; and "oh by the way we installed new wall to wall carpet in the bedrooms, I hope you don't mind." I told them I didn't mind. Another time the same tenant called to say that the hot water wasn't working. It was an oil hot water boiler with a domestic coil for hot water for the baths and kitchen. The repair service said that the domestic coil was not repairable and the part was no longer available. he said the heating component of the boiler was fine and would continue to work, but could make domestic hot water. There was no natural gas in the area, so I said I would install a new electric hot water heater. The tenant said they did not like that idea as electric hot water heaters are too expensive to operate, high electric bills. His alternative was an oil hot water heater, since there was already an oil storage tank and the oil boiler. The only problem for me was oil hot water heater are about $2,000 versus an electric hot water heater at $700. The resolution was the oil service company, which also supplied the oil (paid by tenant) offered a payment plan to the tenant and financed the oil hot water to the tenant. Win, Win, Win for tenant, for me, for the oil company.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.