Turnover is the real cost in LTR, MTR and STR. Here's how I compare them

Turnover is the real cost in LTR, MTR and STR. Here's how I compare them

John RacinePro Member
Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes

A lot of threads here this week come back to the same problem in different forms. A tenant skipped out, a deposit didn't cover the damage, a unit sat empty, or the cash flow came in thinner than the spreadsheet said. I've run long-term, mid-term and short-term rentals. For me, the biggest difference between the three isn't monthly rent vs. nightly rate. It's how often the unit turns over, and who pays for each turn.

Long-term: few turns, but the empty days add up.
I owned long-term rentals in Orlando for several years before I moved into mid-term and short-term. With a 12-month lease you might turn a unit once a year or less, and that's the big appeal. When it does turn, all of it is on you. My turns there usually cost under $1,000 in make-ready, which isn't bad. What hurt more was the time: it took over a week to get a unit back on the market, and that's a week with no rent coming in. People budget for the paint and repairs and forget to budget for the empty days. I suspect a lot of the "is cash flow really this hard" posts are really turnover posts.

Short-term: constant turns, but the guest pays for the clean.
STRs turn over all the time. That sounds like the worst of the three, but on my listings the cleaning fee is a pass-through: the guest pays it, and it covers the clean. So a normal turn isn't eating my margin. The abnormal turns are where the cost is. I had one guest leave the bedding in a condition where it couldn't be saved, and the sheets went straight in the trash. With that many turns, an occasional bad one is guaranteed, so I treat linen and supply replacement as a normal cost, not a surprise.

Mid-term: in between, and extensions make it better.
This is why most of my units now run as a mid-term/short-term hybrid. The calendar is set for 30+ day stays with 30–60 day minimums, and short stays only fill gaps of a few days to two weeks. That alone means far fewer turns than a straight STR. The other piece is keeping a 60-day window open after each mid-term stay so the guest can extend. One construction crew extended four times and stayed over 90 days. Every extension is a turn that never happened.

How I'd use this if you're weighing strategies

  • Count turns per year, not just monthly income. Then put a real cost on each turn, including the empty days.

  • Ask who pays for the turn. In an LTR it's you. In an STR the cleaning can be passed through to the guest. On my mid-term stays I do a mid-stay clean every 30 days and a deep clean at checkout. Both are built into the price, and the deep clean is built into the checkout turn time, so the calendar already blocks the days it takes.

  • Look at what would keep stays long. If nothing near the property creates 1–3 month demand, an "MTR" will turn like an STR without the STR rates.

For those of you who've run more than one strategy: what does one turnover actually cost you, and has that changed which strategy you favor?

3Reply
1,428 views

Most Popular Reply

Diana KhanPro Member
Attorney · 10451 Mill Run Cir #755 Owings Mills, MD 21117 · Member since 2024 · 837 posts · 307 votes
5d
Quote from @John Racine:

A lot of threads here this week come back to the same problem in different forms. A tenant skipped out, a deposit didn't cover the damage, a unit sat empty, or the cash flow came in thinner than the spreadsheet said. I've run long-term, mid-term and short-term rentals. For me, the biggest difference between the three isn't monthly rent vs. nightly rate. It's how often the unit turns over, and who pays for each turn.

Long-term: few turns, but the empty days add up.
I owned long-term rentals in Orlando for several years before I moved into mid-term and short-term. With a 12-month lease you might turn a unit once a year or less, and that's the big appeal. When it does turn, all of it is on you. My turns there usually cost under $1,000 in make-ready, which isn't bad. What hurt more was the time: it took over a week to get a unit back on the market, and that's a week with no rent coming in. People budget for the paint and repairs and forget to budget for the empty days. I suspect a lot of the "is cash flow really this hard" posts are really turnover posts.

Short-term: constant turns, but the guest pays for the clean.
STRs turn over all the time. That sounds like the worst of the three, but on my listings the cleaning fee is a pass-through: the guest pays it, and it covers the clean. So a normal turn isn't eating my margin. The abnormal turns are where the cost is. I had one guest leave the bedding in a condition where it couldn't be saved, and the sheets went straight in the trash. With that many turns, an occasional bad one is guaranteed, so I treat linen and supply replacement as a normal cost, not a surprise.

Mid-term: in between, and extensions make it better.
This is why most of my units now run as a mid-term/short-term hybrid. The calendar is set for 30+ day stays with 30–60 day minimums, and short stays only fill gaps of a few days to two weeks. That alone means far fewer turns than a straight STR. The other piece is keeping a 60-day window open after each mid-term stay so the guest can extend. One construction crew extended four times and stayed over 90 days. Every extension is a turn that never happened.

How I'd use this if you're weighing strategies

  • Count turns per year, not just monthly income. Then put a real cost on each turn, including the empty days.

  • Ask who pays for the turn. In an LTR it's you. In an STR the cleaning can be passed through to the guest. On my mid-term stays I do a mid-stay clean every 30 days and a deep clean at checkout. Both are built into the price, and the deep clean is built into the checkout turn time, so the calendar already blocks the days it takes.

  • Look at what would keep stays long. If nothing near the property creates 1–3 month demand, an "MTR" will turn like an STR without the STR rates.

For those of you who've run more than one strategy: what does one turnover actually cost you, and has that changed which strategy you favor?

@John Racine, I agree that turnover costs can really change how profitable a rental is. Beyond cleaning and vacant days, I'd also consider the cost of dealing with property damage or disputes when someone moves out. Those expenses can add up quickly, especially when they're unexpected.

In my experience working with previous clients as a real estate attorney in Maryland, I've seen how important clear lease terms and property condition records can be for landlords. For example, having photos and documentation from move in and move out can make it easier to address damage concerns and security deposit disputes when they come up.

I appreciate you breaking down the differences between these rental strategies, @John Racine! It's a helpful perspective, and it connects closely to the landlord tenant matters I work with. Happy to stay connected!

See this reply in the discussion

25 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Diana KhanPro Member
    Attorney · 10451 Mill Run Cir #755 Owings Mills, MD 21117 · Member since 2024 · 837 posts · 307 votes
    5d
    Quote from @John Racine:

    A lot of threads here this week come back to the same problem in different forms. A tenant skipped out, a deposit didn't cover the damage, a unit sat empty, or the cash flow came in thinner than the spreadsheet said. I've run long-term, mid-term and short-term rentals. For me, the biggest difference between the three isn't monthly rent vs. nightly rate. It's how often the unit turns over, and who pays for each turn.

    Long-term: few turns, but the empty days add up.
    I owned long-term rentals in Orlando for several years before I moved into mid-term and short-term. With a 12-month lease you might turn a unit once a year or less, and that's the big appeal. When it does turn, all of it is on you. My turns there usually cost under $1,000 in make-ready, which isn't bad. What hurt more was the time: it took over a week to get a unit back on the market, and that's a week with no rent coming in. People budget for the paint and repairs and forget to budget for the empty days. I suspect a lot of the "is cash flow really this hard" posts are really turnover posts.

    Short-term: constant turns, but the guest pays for the clean.
    STRs turn over all the time. That sounds like the worst of the three, but on my listings the cleaning fee is a pass-through: the guest pays it, and it covers the clean. So a normal turn isn't eating my margin. The abnormal turns are where the cost is. I had one guest leave the bedding in a condition where it couldn't be saved, and the sheets went straight in the trash. With that many turns, an occasional bad one is guaranteed, so I treat linen and supply replacement as a normal cost, not a surprise.

    Mid-term: in between, and extensions make it better.
    This is why most of my units now run as a mid-term/short-term hybrid. The calendar is set for 30+ day stays with 30–60 day minimums, and short stays only fill gaps of a few days to two weeks. That alone means far fewer turns than a straight STR. The other piece is keeping a 60-day window open after each mid-term stay so the guest can extend. One construction crew extended four times and stayed over 90 days. Every extension is a turn that never happened.

    How I'd use this if you're weighing strategies

    • Count turns per year, not just monthly income. Then put a real cost on each turn, including the empty days.

    • Ask who pays for the turn. In an LTR it's you. In an STR the cleaning can be passed through to the guest. On my mid-term stays I do a mid-stay clean every 30 days and a deep clean at checkout. Both are built into the price, and the deep clean is built into the checkout turn time, so the calendar already blocks the days it takes.

    • Look at what would keep stays long. If nothing near the property creates 1–3 month demand, an "MTR" will turn like an STR without the STR rates.

    For those of you who've run more than one strategy: what does one turnover actually cost you, and has that changed which strategy you favor?

    @John Racine, I agree that turnover costs can really change how profitable a rental is. Beyond cleaning and vacant days, I'd also consider the cost of dealing with property damage or disputes when someone moves out. Those expenses can add up quickly, especially when they're unexpected.

    In my experience working with previous clients as a real estate attorney in Maryland, I've seen how important clear lease terms and property condition records can be for landlords. For example, having photos and documentation from move in and move out can make it easier to address damage concerns and security deposit disputes when they come up.

    I appreciate you breaking down the differences between these rental strategies, @John Racine! It's a helpful perspective, and it connects closely to the landlord tenant matters I work with. Happy to stay connected!

    • John RacinePro Member
      OP
      Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
      5d

      Thanks so much @Diana Khan 😃

  • Member since 2023 · 194 posts · 80 votes
    5d

    John, this is exactly the math we run. We operate 236 doors in Memphis, mostly single-family, and turnover and vacancy cost us more than repairs — so we price the turn, not just the repair.

    Our rent-ready turnovers run on a 21-day scheduling system. The day a move-out is known, the clock starts: inspection, photos, scope, and the contractor is already lined up. We find and test contractors months before something breaks, in small paid steps, so we are not scrambling when a unit is empty. Every empty day is rent we never get back, and a slow turn is usually a scheduling problem, not a repair problem.

    On your question: one turnover costs us the lost rent for the empty days plus the make-ready, and the make-ready is the smaller number. Keeping stays long starts before move-in — screening for verified repeatable income and consistency between the story and the paperwork, not just a credit score.

    What part of your turn takes the longest — the clean, the repair, or finding the next tenant?

  • Michael K GallagherBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus OH · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5d

    very interesting perspective thanks for putting this together. I'd be curious if there is any data even anecdotally how included the cleaning fee in the rate impacts vacancy vs having the pass through charge? or is that fairly common and customary for people using these types of rentals?

  • John RacinePro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
    5d

    @Rosina Persaud, on my long-term rentals it was the repairs. The clean was quick and finding the next tenant wasn't the bottleneck, but the repairs are what kept a unit off the market for over a week. On mid-term the clean isn't the slow part, because the deep clean is already blocked on the calendar. The slow part is lining up the next 30+ day guest. That's why I keep the extension window open and let short stays fill the gap so the unit doesn't sit empty.

    Your 21-day clock is smart. Starting it the day you know about the move-out is the step most small landlords skip.

    @Michael K Gallagher, I do both, depending on the clean. The turnover cleaning fee is a pass-through, and that's pretty common on both STR and MTR. The mid-stay cleans are different. On my mid-term stays there's a clean every 30 days, and I build it into the monthly rate instead of charging it as a separate fee.

    I'd expect length of stay to be the big factor in how much the fee matters. On a 1–2 night booking the cleaning fee can be a large share of the total, so a high one can cost you short bookings. On a 30-day stay it's a small slice of the month. Airbnb also shows guests the total price up front now, so the fee ends up in the number they compare either way.

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 595 posts · 173 votes
    5d

    You're right to budget the empty days and not just the paint, and that same gap shows up again when you go to finance. On a long-term rental, the DSCR programs I see usually qualify off the lease or the appraiser's market rent, so a week of vacancy between tenants doesn't make it into the loan math. It still comes out of your real coverage, which is why a deal that clears the lender's ratio can feel thin month to month. Short-term works the other way. When there's a full year of booking history, many lenders that take STR income work from trailing twelve months of actuals, so every slow turn and blocked night is already inside the income they count. On a short-term rental the gaps between guests cost you twice, once in cash and once in what the lender will credit.

  • John RacinePro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
    5d

    @Noah Wright, good point. It's the part of turnover most people never connect to financing. If the lender is working from the trailing twelve months, it makes sense that a slow turn costs you twice on an STR.

    It's also why it pays to shop around for a DSCR lender when you finance a short-term rental. Some will underwrite off AirDNA projections, and others have much stricter requirements on what income they'll count. They can come up with very different numbers on the same property, so it's worth knowing which kind you're talking to before you apply.

  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 774 votes
    3d

    John, I only run long-term rentals, so turnover is the number I watch closest. I run 236 single-family properties in Memphis, mostly Section 8, and one turnover costs me the lost rent for the empty days plus the make-ready. At Section 8 rent of $1,395-$1,950 for a 3BR+, every empty week is real money, and it comes straight out of the year.

    That is why I favor stays that last. I buy 3BR or larger in the same 9 Memphis ZIPs, and I rehab them so a tenant can stay: a 2/1 to 3/1 or a 3/1 to 4/2, a full bath where there was a half bath, and a house that is ready to live in, not just ready to photograph. A house that turns every year will not hit the 1% rule or refinance at 70-80% LTV on DSCR, no matter how good the rent looks on paper.

    I do not run STR or MTR. I cannot make the turnover math work on houses I buy under $100K with an ARV of $180K-$265K. For me, the cheapest turnover is the one that never happens.

  • John RacinePro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
    3d

    @James Jones, congrats on running it that way. That's how I approached my long-term rentals in Orlando too: fix the house up so it's ready to live in, and a good tenant has every reason to stay. The longer they stayed, the better those rentals did.

    It's definitely not the same with STR and MTR, where turnover comes with the model. That's a big part of why I lean toward mid-term. There are a lot fewer turnovers than with a straight STR, and the overall revenue still comes out higher than a long-term lease would bring in.

    Out of curiosity, with the way you set up those 3BR+ houses, how long does an average tenancy run for you?

  • Member since 2017 · 131 posts · 73 votes
    3d

    Renting by the room is a fourth column worth adding to your comparison, because it turns over more often than long-term but each turn is tiny.

    When one person leaves a house of five, the other four are still paying. You are turning one bedroom, not the whole unit, so the empty-day cost is one room's rent: a $675 room is about $22 a day empty, against the whole house's rent sitting idle in a long-term turn.

    The make-ready is small too. We have the cleaner do the bedroom on a day they are already at the house, about $30 a room, and the room is clean and ready in about two days. The new person gets their own door code, so there is no rekey.

    The part that is easy to underprice is the shared spaces. They never turn, so they slowly wear down. We put a set-day clean of the kitchen, baths and living room into the rent rather than waiting for a move-out to find out what they look like.

    The trade is more turns and more screening. If the house is near a hospital, a university or a big employer, rooms fill from people already in town, and the extensions you describe happen on their own.

  • John RacinePro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
    3d

    @Harrison C. thanks for adding this. I'm hearing more and more about renting by the room lately, and the way you laid out the empty-day math makes it easy to see why. Losing $22 a day on one room is a very different problem from a whole house sitting empty.

    A few questions, since it's newer to me:

    - Are your houses listed on PadSplit, or do you run them yourself?

    - How long does a typical resident stay with you?

    - Do you furnish the bedrooms, or just the shared spaces?

    Your point about shared spaces wearing down makes sense to me. It's the same reason I do a clean every 30 days on my mid-term stays.

  • Member since 2017 · 131 posts · 73 votes
    3d

    John, we run them ourselves, not through PadSplit. Doing it ourselves means we do the screening, set the house rules and keep the whole rent instead of sharing a cut of every payment.

    Stays are shorter than a long-term lease. Across the residents who have moved out so far, the middle stay is about four months and the average a little under five. A lot of people who rent a room are interns or in town on a contract, so a short stay is part of the plan rather than a surprise, and some extend once they are settled.

    On furniture, the shared spaces should always be furnished, because a couch, a table and a working kitchen are what make it a home people want to stay in. Bedrooms depend on who you are renting to. Short stays like interns and travel workers expect a bed and a dresser waiting for them; people planning to stay a year often prefer to bring their own.

    Your 30-day clean on mid-term stays is the same idea. Once it is on the calendar, nobody has to ask for it and nobody argues about it.

  • John RacinePro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
    3d

    @Harrison C. thanks for the detail. A median stay of about four months is mid-term territory. Interns and people in town on a contract are the same group I see on my 30+ day stays. They just rent a room instead of the whole unit. Running it yourself and keeping the full rent makes sense once your screening and house rules are dialed in.

    The furniture point matches what I see too. A guest on a 1–3 month stay expects to walk in with a suitcase and have everything ready.

    One more question: when a room opens up, where do most of your new residents come from? Your own listings, referrals from current residents, or local employers and schools?

  • Member since 2017 · 131 posts · 73 votes
    3d

    John, a big one for us is a Facebook group we run for interns coming to work at a large employer near our houses. Each new class asks in there for housing before they arrive, so the people looking for a room are already gathered in one place. Our own listings page is where everyone goes to apply from there.

    Two things that would carry straight over to your mid-term units. Ask residents for their move-out date as early as you can, so the room is listed 30 days ahead instead of the day it empties. And hold on to the people who applied and missed out on a room. They already know the house and the price, so they are the easiest people to fill the next opening with.

    Do your 30+ day guests mostly come through Furnished Finder, or direct from the employers and hospitals near you?

  • John RacinePro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
    2d

    @Harrison C. mostly Airbnb. It's close to 90% of my bookings, and that includes the 30+ day stays. Work crews are the biggest group I see, and they're searching for a monthly stay, which is why "30 day+" goes right in my headline.

    Furnished Finder brings in fewer bookings than people expect. I use it more to gauge how much mid-term demand a market really has. My first booking there in almost eight months was a 90-day stay this October. I haven't built a direct pipeline with local employers yet, and your intern group is a good picture of what one could look like. For me the equivalent would be the person who books housing for a crew on every new job.

    Both of your tips carry over. Asking for the move-out date early is my 60-day extension window from the other direction: I find out whether a guest is staying before I have to market the dates. And someone who inquires about dates that are already booked is a warm lead for the next opening.

  • Simon W.Business Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Lehigh Valley PA & New York City · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 697 votes
    2d

    To answer John's question about what one turnover costs, the books are where I'd start, because most owners can't pull that number. I'd give turnover its own expense category, cleaning, paint, patching, lock changes, and track it per property. That's generally deductible as repairs in the year you pay it, while something like new flooring is usually a capital item you'd depreciate, so keep those on a separate line.

    Then add the part that never shows up as an expense. Say make-ready is $900 and the unit sits 10 days at $1,400 rent. The lost rent is about $467, so that turn really costs around $1,370, but only the $900 is on the P&L. Empty days just show up as missing income, so you have to track days vacant on the side.

    On the STR side, I'd record the cleaning fee as income and the cleaner's bill as an expense instead of netting them. Netted, your revenue looks smaller and your cost per turn disappears, which makes comparing against Harrison's by-the-room numbers hard.

    Accounting Properties LLC
    View Page
    CFO LLC
    View Page
  • Member since 2026 · 97 posts · 32 votes
    2d

    John, this is the comparison I wish more owners would run before choosing a strategy, because the rent hides the real cost. On our short-term stays, one turnover runs us the clean, the linen, the restock, and the hours spent checking the place and messaging guests, and the empty nights between bookings are the part people forget to price. On longer stays, turns are rare, but a bad one hurts more because the make-ready is bigger and the vacancy stretches longer. What helped us most was giving turnover its own line in the books, with cleaning, repairs, and lost rent tracked separately per property, so we could see which units were profitable and which ones just looked busy. A simple turnover checklist with photos at every step cut the back-and-forth with cleaners and caught small damage early. Count the turns, price them honestly, and the strategy choice gets much clearer.

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 595 posts · 173 votes
    2d

    Going after the person who books housing for each crew is the right next move, and your 30 day+ headline shows you already know exactly who your guest is. Set up the paper trail before the first direct deal. When a lender sizes an STR DSCR loan off your actual income, it usually wants that income documented, and Airbnb payout statements do that job for you. A crew booking paid by company check or sent to your personal account is real money that's much harder to count. With about 90% of your bookings on Airbnb, almost all of your income has a statement behind it today. Keep the direct side the same way, with a short written agreement for each booking and payment into the property's own account. How many months of booking history does this property have now?

    • John RacinePro Member
      OP
      Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
      2d

      @Simon W. your example shows exactly what I was getting at. The P&L says the turn cost $900, but once you count the 10 empty days it was closer to $1,370. Tracking days vacant on the side is the only way that number ever shows up.

      Agreed on not netting the cleaning fee on the STR side, too. Since mine is a pass-through, it's tempting to treat it as a wash and never record it, but then the cost per turn disappears from the books.

      @Noah Wright it runs the gamut. Every property has a different history depending on when it came online. The newest has a couple of months, and the longest is over a year. When I start booking crews direct, a short written agreement for each stay with payment going into the property's own account is how I'd set it up, so those stays are as easy to document as the Airbnb ones.

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 595 posts · 173 votes
    1d

    That setup is right, and putting it in place before the first crew stay is what makes it hold up later. One detail matters once you have several properties: give each one its own account, not one shared operating account. When an STR DSCR lender sizes a loan on one property, it wants that property's income, and if two places pay into the same account an underwriter can't tell which one earned what. Match each agreement to one deposit for the full stay too, so the roughly 10% of bookings that won't come with an Airbnb statement still lines up line for line. On the one with over a year of history, what does it gross a month? That's what tells you whether its own numbers carry a DSCR payment today.

  • John RacinePro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
    1d

    @Noah Wright agreed on one account per property, and it's easy to set up. My units are held in an LLC and I bank with Relay. Each property gets its own account, and I record revenue and expenses by property, so it's clear which one earned what.

    On the units I co-host, Airbnb's split payout sends the owner's share straight to the owner, so I never hold their money. Since we're only co-hosting right now, we don't need a trust account yet. That changes once we move into full property management.

    I'll keep the per-property numbers off the forum. Your point holds either way: if I refinance one for a specific purpose, its own statements have to carry the payment.

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 595 posts · 173 votes
    1d

    That's the setup that makes per-property turnover costs and income readable to a lender, and keeping the numbers off the forum is fair. The split payout has one side effect for the owners you co-host. Their deposits only show their share, so if one of them refinances into a DSCR loan, their bank statements show revenue after your cut. That's why they should keep the full Airbnb earnings report for each property, since it shows the gross. This gets harder once you move to full management and pay owners out of a trust account, because one lump payout per owner is hard to tie to a single property. On the one you'd refinance, is it run as a short-term or mid-term rental? That decides whether most lenders size it off booking history or market rent.

    • John RacinePro Member
      OP
      Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
      21h

      Noah, good point on keeping the full Airbnb earnings report so the gross shows up, not just the owner's share. I don't have one lined up for a refi right now. I was answering it as a what-if. If I did, it would most likely be a mid-term unit, since that's where most of my portfolio sits. From what you're saying, a lender would probably size that one off market rent rather than booking history, which is good to know before anyone counts on the furnished income.

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 595 posts · 173 votes
    15h

    You read it right, and testing the what-if now, before any furnished income gets baked into a plan, saves a nasty surprise at appraisal. The catch on a mid-term cash-out is where that market rent comes from. The appraiser's rent schedule usually compares your unit to unfurnished 12-month leases, so the furnished premium mostly drops out of the DSCR math even when your deposits run higher. If the gap is big, some lenders will run the unit through their STR program instead and size it off a year of documented income, which is where your per-property accounts earn their keep. A DSCR calculator run twice, once on unfurnished rent and once on what the unit actually collects, shows what that gap is worth in cash-out. On a typical mid-term unit of yours, how far above unfurnished long-term rent does it run?

  • John RacinePro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 276 posts · 141 votes
    9h

    Noah, there isn't one number. It's very dynamic. It changes with property type (a townhome versus a single-family), location, the class of the property (A, B, C) and the amenities each one offers. Depending on those factors, I've seen mid-term run anywhere from 30% to over 100% above long-term rent. Across my portfolio, mid-term has consistently brought in more than long-term would, even after utilities and the other owner expenses. That's why I price each unit on its own, between its long-term rent as the floor and what it could gross as a short-term rental as the ceiling.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.