Out-of-state investor: Am I the weirdo for wanting my PM to follow the PMA?

Out-of-state investor: Am I the weirdo for wanting my PM to follow the PMA?

Investor · Spokane, WA · Member since 2024 · 22 posts · 12 votes

Hey BP,

Out-of-state investor here looking for a quick reality check from seasoned remote landlords and PMs.

My wife and I really try to treat our property managers like partners - the last thing we want is to micromanage or insert ourselves into the nuanced business of property management. Lately, though, with one PM in particular, we keep running into friction over what feel like basic ground rules:

  • Ignoring approval limits: Our PMA requires written approval over certain thresholds. They recently dispatched and billed an 'over-the-limit' HVAC repair with zero heads-up or emergency notice.

  • Not enforcing the lease they wrote: They just signed a new tenant to a lease that puts lawn care and pest control on the resident. When I asked to drop our paid lawn vendor for that side, they pushed back saying "99% of our multi-family owners pay for lawn care"—and suggested I buy the tenant a shed for a mower if I actually wanted them to do it.

  • Zero visibility & slow comms: We don't know a work order exists until it hits our monthly statement. It takes days to get an email response, and—I just checked our history—they have never actually answered the phone or returned a call since June.

I get that managing small multi-family properties is messy and reactive. Be honest with me: Am I the weirdo for expecting the PMA and the executed lease to actually be followed?

I know plenty of folks will say this is just an assumed risk of out-of-state investing, and I don't disagree—but frankly, it's 2026. The tools exist for at least the communication side of this relationship to work better.

For those of you managing remotely—or running a PM shop—how do you handle this? Have you successfully "reset" expectations with a drifting PM, or are these red flags that mean it’s time to start shopping for a new manager?

Appreciate any candid advice!

1Reply
752 views

Most Popular Reply

James JonesPro Member
Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 774 votes
6d

No, you are not the weirdo. The agreement is the deal, and a property manager who rewrites the lease, ignores a written approval limit, and will not return a call since June is not a partner. I run 236 doors in Memphis with an in-house team at Memphis Passive handling leasing, maintenance, and collections, and the same rule applies inside our own shop: what is written down is what happens, and every change gets documented. A $250 surprise bill is not about $250. It is the sign that the next one will be bigger and you will find out later. Give it to them in writing, once, with a clear deadline. If the lease and the approval limit are not followed after that, replace the manager. Your numbers only work if the team running them follows the plan.

See this reply in the discussion

29 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 774 votes
    6d

    No, you are not the weirdo. The agreement is the deal, and a property manager who rewrites the lease, ignores a written approval limit, and will not return a call since June is not a partner. I run 236 doors in Memphis with an in-house team at Memphis Passive handling leasing, maintenance, and collections, and the same rule applies inside our own shop: what is written down is what happens, and every change gets documented. A $250 surprise bill is not about $250. It is the sign that the next one will be bigger and you will find out later. Give it to them in writing, once, with a clear deadline. If the lease and the approval limit are not followed after that, replace the manager. Your numbers only work if the team running them follows the plan.

    • Investor · Spokane, WA · Member since 2024 · 22 posts · 12 votes
      6d

      Thank you James. Your right, it is not the actual cost associated with a repair that is my central concern, it is the failure to follow our written agreement and the subsequent lack of communication that concerns me. Thank you for your wisdom and the straightforward manner in which you framed it.

  • Member since 2026 · 20 posts · 1 vote
    6d

    Travis, no, expecting the agreement and the signed lease to be followed is the baseline, not micromanaging. A reset usually works best in writing: list the specific items (the approval limit that was exceeded, the lease clause on lawn and pest, the response times), say what you need going forward, such as a call or email before any spend over the limit and a copy of each work order when it opens, and give a date to confirm. Also check your PMA for the cure period and termination terms now, so you know your options if nothing changes. How they respond to a clear written request tells you a lot: a fix with a process behind it is a good sign, while excuses or silence are the red flags that point to shopping for a new manager.

    Disclosure: I work with Guest Haus Company, which helps owners with listing, pricing, and guest communications.

  • Member since 2026 · 46 posts · 15 votes
    6d

    Hi Travis, no, expecting the written agreement and the signed lease to be followed is not micromanaging. For an out-of-state owner, those documents are the main way to know what should happen when no one can check in person.

    One helpful step is to ask for a simple system that makes compliance easy to check. Experienced landlords often ask for a copy of each work order when it is opened, not only when it appears on the monthly statement, with the amount, the vendor, and whether approval was required. That way, an approval limit is tested before the work is done, rather than discovered after the invoice arrives.

    The same approach helps with the lease. If the signed lease says one thing about lawn care or pest control and the manager's practice is different, ask for the discrepancy to be put in writing, with the lease clause cited, and for any change to be made as a formal amendment rather than by habit. That protects both sides and avoids confusion at renewal.

    Finally, agree on a short monthly check: work orders opened, amounts over the approval limit, and any lease terms that were not followed. If that record stays empty for a few months, the system is working.

    • Investor · Spokane, WA · Member since 2024 · 22 posts · 12 votes
      6d

      Hi John, thank you for the insight. It should be simple, right? I know this particular PM uses both AppFolio and Property Meld and I can't for the life of me figure out why I can't get an automated notice or something. I've never seen the PM side of those applications before, but I'd imagine its nearly as simple as checking a box and putting our email address(es) in. I'd think that simple communication automations of this nature are one of a PMs greatest efficiency tools. I like your idea of a short monthly 'health check' - I'll have to work on building that into our process. Thanks again.

  • Monroe, Orange County · Member since 2026 · 25 posts · 7 votes
    6d

    Not weird at all. The PMA is the only thing that defines what you're paying for, so holding them to it is the job, not micromanaging.

    What helps keep it from turning personal: pull the 4-5 items that matter most (approval limit for repairs, how fast they notify you of late rent, inspection schedule, when owner draws go out, what's in the monthly statement) and turn them into a one-page checklist. Each month, check the statement against it and send one short email listing anything that was missed, with the PMA section number.

    If the same items keep getting missed after two or three of those emails, that's your answer on whether to switch. A good PM will appreciate knowing exactly what you care about.

  • Leo SteinBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 343 posts · 84 votes
    6d

    Travis, you're not the weirdo. The PMA and the signed lease are the deal, and what you describe is a pattern, not a one-off. Before you shop for a new manager, I'd try one documented reset.

    Send a short written note that lists each issue with the PMA section it touches: the approval limit that was skipped, the lease terms that weren't enforced, and the missed calls. Ask for three things in writing: a named contact with a response time (say, one business day), work order visibility before invoices post, and a rule that anything over the limit needs your written okay except true emergencies. Give them 30 days.

    Then watch what happens. A good manager fixes it fast and thanks you for the clarity. If you get excuses or more silence, read the termination clause and notice period in your agreement now, so you know your exit costs before you need them. Also keep copies of the invoices that broke the limit.

    Happy to compare notes by message.

    Real Property Management Optimal 4.926 Reviews
    • Investor · Spokane, WA · Member since 2024 · 22 posts · 12 votes
      6d

      Hi Leo. Thank you for this wisdom. I'll try the documented reset, none of us are perfect after all, sometimes we all need a little 'realignment.' I suppose what matters is how they respond. Thank you again.

    • Leo SteinBusiness Member
      Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 343 posts · 84 votes
      6d

      Thanks, Travis. A documented reset sounds like a fair next step, especially since you see this as a process gap and not a reason to assume bad intent. I’d keep the request narrow: cite the approval clause, ask for work-order visibility and a clear emergency exception, then agree on a contact and response window. If the software can send an alert when a work order opens, that could help; even without it, a short written update should be part of the workflow. Not legal advice.

      Real Property Management Optimal 4.926 Reviews
  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    6d

    You're right it's not easy managing rentals in general.

    That doesn't excuse bad behavior though.

    • Ignoring approval limits: Our PMA requires written approval over certain thresholds. They recently dispatched and billed an 'over-the-limit' HVAC repair with zero heads-up or emergency notice.

      • It can be difficult to immediately alert an owner about an emergency repair, but there's no excuse to NOT update an owner at all.

    • Not enforcing the lease they wrote: They just signed a new tenant to a lease that puts lawn care and pest control on the resident. When I asked to drop our paid lawn vendor for that side, they pushed back saying "99% of our multi-family owners pay for lawn care"—and suggested I buy the tenant a shed for a mower if I actually wanted them to do it.

      • Going to attribute this to an "honest" error. We do NOT make our tenants in 2+ unit properties responsible for lawn maintenance - even is side-by-side units. Besides nowhere to store their lawnmower, it leads to uneven maintenance between tenants. The PMC should just admit this mistake, but don't expect them to eat the cutting bill.

    • Zero visibility & slow comms: We don't know a work order exists until it hits our monthly statement. It takes days to get an email response, and—I just checked our history—they have never actually answered the phone or returned a call since June.

      • FYI we hear this OFTEN from owners interviewing us to find a new PMC, we don't understand why (1) PMCs think this is acceptable (2) Owners tolerate it!
        We used to have our management software set to alert owners as soon as a WO was created. We turned that off years ago because owners were contacting us with questions before we even had a chance to figure out what was going on. It is our standard procedure though, to publish a WO to an owner as soon as possible. The human element of this means there will be mistakes, but they do NOT occur often.

      • Going to guess you also do not regularly receive a detailed invoice to support the WO charges? Also no Before & After pics?

    Failing on two out of 3 of the above issues is enough to give them written notice you will not tolerate and to start looking for a new PMC as a backup if they do not improve.

    • Leo SteinBusiness Member
      Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 343 posts · 84 votes
      6d

      Thanks for laying out the operator side, Drew. Your distinction between an emergency that makes advance notice difficult and the need to update the owner afterward is useful. I can also see why automatic alerts can create noise before the PM has context. Publishing the work order once the facts are known, with the invoice and before-and-after photos when available, gives the owner visibility without making them guess. I appreciate the candid perspective.

      Real Property Management Optimal 4.926 Reviews
  • Pittsburgh, Allegheny County · Member since 2026 · 92 posts · 36 votes
    6d

    Travis, you're not the weirdo; an approval limit only means something if they ask before going over it. I'd send one written email that lists each issue next to the PMA section it falls under, then ask for three specific fixes: work orders in an owner portal or emailed when they're opened, a heads-up before anything over the limit, and either enforcing the lawn and pest terms in the lease they wrote or a lease addendum that changes them. Give it 30 days, and use that time to reread the termination clause and quietly interview one or two other managers, so if nothing changes you can move without scrambling.

    • Leo SteinBusiness Member
      Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 343 posts · 84 votes
      6d

      Dan, the checklist by PMA section is especially practical, and I agree the owner portal or a notice when a work order opens can make the approval limit visible before the invoice. I’d also keep the lease terms and any changes aligned in writing, so the resident and owner are not left with different expectations. A 30-day reset gives both sides a clear way to see whether communication and follow-through improve. Not legal advice.

      Real Property Management Optimal 4.926 Reviews
  • Real Estate Broker · Northeast PA · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6d

    Sounds like you got very good advice from the previous posters!
    The current manager broke rules, and broke faith. The operative word here to move forward is "NEXT!" Move on to better management, and good luck.

  • Alim AbrahimBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Oklahoma City Metro · Member since 2026 · 20 posts · 5 votes
    6d

    Travis, if you’re the weirdo, it should go both ways. Ask your manager the same question: would they settle for 80% of their fee, since they’re only following about 80% of the PMA? I doubt they’d call that reasonable either.

    The agreement is the job description. Approval limits, the lease they wrote, returning calls: those aren’t extras, they’re what the fee pays for. A written reset is the right first step, and if they push back on following their own documents, you have your answer.

    For what it’s worth, the owners of our operation here in OKC after having owned property all around the country for a couple of decades, eventually fired the PMs that were underperforming and built their own management company, just so they could build the culture and protect owners’ assets the way they felt owners deserve.

    You’re asking for exactly what that’s supposed to look like.

    Bankers Invest
    View Page
  • Real Estate Agent · Memphis · Member since 2026 · 632 posts · 363 votes
    6d

    You're not being unreasonable. There's a difference between micromanaging a PM and expecting them to follow the agreement you both signed. The HVAC repair might have been urgent, but they should still be able to explain why approval wasn't obtained. And the lawn care issue should've been addressed before the lease was signed, not after.

    I'd give them one opportunity to get things back on track with clear expectations around approvals and communication. But if they're consistently ignoring the PMA and you can't even get a returned phone call, that's a pretty good reason to start interviewing other managers.

  • Investor · Spokane, WA · Member since 2024 · 22 posts · 12 votes
    5d

    Thank you all! I sincerely appreciate everybody's wisdom and insights on this matter. I will proceed with a written notice which plainly lists the concerns while citing the PMA, present a path to remediation, and list expectations (PMA-based) moving forward. Again, I thank each of you for your response.

  • Property Manager · Melbourne, FL · Member since 2019 · 571 posts · 197 votes
    5d

    Since you're proceeding with the reset, I'd ask them to walk one sample work order through the proposed process with you: reported, assessed, awaiting approval, scheduled and completed. At each step, identify what you'll see and who is responsible for the next action. Include who covers that person when they're away. It gives both sides a concrete test of the communication fix before another real repair arrives, and helps distinguish a software setting problem from a task that nobody actually owns.

  • Anitha B.Pro Member
    Member since 2024 · 23 posts · 4 votes
    5d

    As an out of state landlord with a PM I have put up with for over 3 years I am just about getting ready to move on. I have learned much and most importantly things don't get better only worse so I would start shopping around and cut your losses. check you termination clause while a tenant is in place. I do also agree with some of the comments above but no need to play defense. Out of state landlords are PMs easy clientbase especially new landlords who are learning the ropes of the business yet they take advantage and in the process lose the cash cow...

  • Colleen F.Pro Member
    Investor · Narragansett, RI · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    4d

    As for PM expectations, I don't think you are unreasonable on the issues. I would suggest that you have them modify the lease for multi-families regarding yard care and common areas. Unless you have a very clear division on outdoor areas enforcing yard maintenance is difficult and often unexpected by the tenant. You would need to provide some storage for lawn tools and it probably isn't a successful strategy.

  • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    4d

    Travis, you're not the weirdo here. Approval limits and a written lease are the whole point of having a PMA, and a manager who has not returned a call since June is telling you something about how the next year will go.

    One thing I'd add to the advice above: before you decide to replace them, pull out the PMA and read the default and termination sections. Most agreements have a notice-and-cure clause, so a dated email that cites the exact approval-limit section and the HVAC invoice starts that clock and builds a paper trail. It also tells you what the exit costs, since some agreements charge a termination or re-leasing fee, and it's far better to know that before you send the letter.

    If you do move on, line things up first: get copies of the leases, the security deposit ledger and vendor invoices, confirm who holds the deposits, and interview the replacement before you give notice so the tenants never go without a contact.

    Happy to connect and compare notes on remote management.

  • Member since 2026 · 24 posts · 8 votes
    3d

    You’re not the weirdo. A written approval limit only works if the PM has a step that stops the job being sent out above it. Owners I’ve seen get this fixed ask for two things in writing: a same-day email for any work order over the limit, and the vendor’s invoice attached to the statement line. Did your PM say why the HVAC call skipped approval, or was it called an emergency after the fact?

    • Investor · Spokane, WA · Member since 2024 · 22 posts · 12 votes
      13h

      Hi Rukhaam. I was finally able to get in touch with the PM and I was told that 'that the approval slipped between the cracks' and that it would not happen again. The did admit that failing to obtain an approval was a mistake - It was not called an emergency. I recapped the phone call in a summary email for documentation purposes.

  • Rental Property Investor · Greenville, SC · Member since 2024 · 27 posts · 14 votes
    2d

    You're not the weirdo. One thing that helps is asking for the work order history in writing every month, with the date it was reported, the vendor, the invoice, and who approved it. If anything over your approval limit shows up without your sign off, you have it in black and white and can point to the exact clause in the PMA. A good manager will be fine with that, and one who pushes back is telling you something.

  • Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 203 posts · 75 votes
    2d

    @travisa155 Travis, you're not the weirdo. The management agreement and the signed lease are the job description, not optional guidelines. (Disclosure: I'm a Realtor with Swiss Realty Group and assist at Swiss Property Management Group in Columbus.)
    I'd put a short reset in writing: the approval limit that was missed, the lawn and pest clauses in the new lease, and a rule that work orders come to you when they're opened, not only on the monthly statement. Give a date to confirm they'll follow that.
    If they still won't return calls, or they keep spending over the limit, that's enough to start interviewing a replacement. Before you terminate, get the tenant files, signed leases, keys, the deposit ledger and a trust-account statement, and send each tenant written notice of who to pay and who to call for repairs.
    The lawn issue is a good test. If the lease they wrote puts it on the tenant, they should enforce that lease, not talk you into keeping a vendor.

  • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 296 posts · 80 votes
    1d

    Hey @Travis Cooke,

    You're definitely not the weirdo. The approval limit and the lease are the two documents that are supposed to make remote ownership work, so when both get ignored in the same month, it makes sense that the trust starts to slip.

    One thing that's become much easier recently is checking the statement against the agreement itself. AI can read the PMA, the lease and each month's statement together and flag any work order over your approval limit, any charge the lease puts on the tenant, and any repair that showed up without notice. It turns a vague feeling that something's off into a short list, with the exact clause next to each item.

    Before the reset conversation, it could help to run that check on the last six months of statements, so you walk in with every exception in one place rather than the HVAC charge on its own.

    Best of luck with the reset,
    Lee

  • Investor · Member since 2026 · 92 posts · 19 votes
    17h

    You're not the weirdo — the agreement is the job description, and you're just asking them to follow it.

    I'd start with the notifications, because you can test that this week. Ask your PM to add you as a recipient in AppFolio / Property Meld for work-order created, any estimate over your approval limit, and work-order completed — not just portal access you have to go check. Then run one small job through and confirm you actually get each alert. If that doesn't work, it's a process problem, not a software one.

    And get a named backup in writing: who to call when your PM doesn't pick up, and when they have to call back. No callback since June is the tell — without a backup and a callback rule, a checklist won't save it.

    • Investor · Spokane, WA · Member since 2024 · 22 posts · 12 votes
      13h

      Thanks Willson. I was able to obtain access to Property Meld and setup notifications, so we'll see how it works. Admittedly, I'm not all that optimistic as looking through the 'Meld History' just shows a list of vague entries, i.e. "faucet leaking" with no description, resolution notes, attachments, etc. We'll see. Thanks for the advice.

  • Investor · Spokane, WA · Member since 2024 · 22 posts · 12 votes
    13h

    I want to thank the whole group again for your comments and thoughts - I always find value in discussing these sorts of topics with the veterans and I sincerely appreciate everybody's wisdom. I suppose at the end of the day, in addition to communicating with the PM and reminding them of their PMA responsibilities, I'll need to continue to improve our own systems so that this does not occur over and over.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.