maintenance requests keep coming

maintenance requests keep coming

Investor · Bend, OR · Member since 2026 · 29 posts · 18 votes

This is my first experience as a landlord and my first tenant. Just three months into the tenancy, the maintenance requests keep coming; loose door hinges, blinds issues, smoke detector issues, and now reports of no heat, a disposal that won’t run, and an ice maker that isn’t working.

What makes this frustrating is that the home was built in 2022. I expected maintenance, but several issues this early have caught me off guard.

I’m still waiting on diagnoses and estimates (smoke detector, no heat, disposal and ice maker), so I’m not assuming tenant misuse. I do wonder how much could have been caught during the move-in checks.

Have other landlords experienced a similar cluster with a newer home?

How do you distinguish routine maintenance from gaps in property preparation by PM, and keep service-call costs under control?

1Reply
1,140 views

Most Popular Reply

Member since 2017 · 131 posts · 73 votes
1w

Built in 2022 may actually help you here. A lot of builders give a one-year workmanship and two-year systems warranty, so the heat and the smoke detectors could still be the builder's problem, not yours. Dig out the closing papers or call the builder before paying anyone for a diagnosis. The fridge and the disposal may still be under their own manufacturer warranty as well.

Before sending anyone out, a two-minute call with the tenant clears a surprising number of these:

No heat: thermostat batteries, the furnace power switch (looks like a light switch near the unit) and a clogged filter cause most first-winter calls.

Disposal: there is a reset button on the bottom of the unit, and a hex socket underneath to free a jam.

Ice maker: the water valve behind the fridge, or the shut-off arm is up.

Smoke detectors: a chirp is usually a low backup battery; a false alarm is often one interconnected unit near the kitchen or bathroom setting off the rest.

Going forward I would put a short "check these first" list in the move-in packet (breaker, reset button, filter, thermostat), give your PM a written dollar limit for repairs, and batch the small items into one visit like Noah said. Three months into a new build this is mostly settling in, and it usually quiets down after the first year.

See this reply in the discussion

25 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1w

    I think it is a rent-ready sales ploy to downplay the common maintenance issues that come with owning a home. As a landlord you will find the tenant will call you for things that you would ordinarily just do yourself as a homeowner. It waxes and wanes.

  • Real Estate Broker · Sacramento, CA · Member since 2021 · 563 posts · 431 votes
    1w

    Yes, totally normal for a 2022 build to throw a cluster like that in the first 90 days, most of it is small stuff settling in, not tenant misuse. Ask your PM for the move-in checkllist and photos, then compare each item to it. If it was working at move-in, it is routine maintenance. My rule is one trip, one fix list, I batch the small items so I am not paying a separate service call for a hinge. I am a licensed broker in Sacramento managing 100+ Airbnbs, so I see this pattern a lot. Hope this helps, DM me if you want a second look at the checklist.

  • Member since 2017 · 131 posts · 73 votes
    1w

    Built in 2022 may actually help you here. A lot of builders give a one-year workmanship and two-year systems warranty, so the heat and the smoke detectors could still be the builder's problem, not yours. Dig out the closing papers or call the builder before paying anyone for a diagnosis. The fridge and the disposal may still be under their own manufacturer warranty as well.

    Before sending anyone out, a two-minute call with the tenant clears a surprising number of these:

    No heat: thermostat batteries, the furnace power switch (looks like a light switch near the unit) and a clogged filter cause most first-winter calls.

    Disposal: there is a reset button on the bottom of the unit, and a hex socket underneath to free a jam.

    Ice maker: the water valve behind the fridge, or the shut-off arm is up.

    Smoke detectors: a chirp is usually a low backup battery; a false alarm is often one interconnected unit near the kitchen or bathroom setting off the rest.

    Going forward I would put a short "check these first" list in the move-in packet (breaker, reset button, filter, thermostat), give your PM a written dollar limit for repairs, and batch the small items into one visit like Noah said. Three months into a new build this is mostly settling in, and it usually quiets down after the first year.

  • Theresa HarrisPro Member
    Member since 2019 · 15k+ posts · 11k+ votes
    1w

    Is this a place you just bought (ie what did the property inspection report say) or is it a home you are familiar with and a new tenant? Hire a handyman and get them to go in and deal with the issues. As Harrison said, smoke alarm is easy, furnace check filter (tenants are horrible about doing that). If you have a PM, they should have done a walk through and noticed some of these things (eg smoke alarm chirping), but may not have noticed others (ice maker) as problems only show up when you go to use them.

    the home is 4 years old, so should be in good shape.

  • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 292 posts · 80 votes
    1w

    Hi @Vick Alumi,

    A cluster like this in the first few months is more common than it feels, even in a newer home. Builder-grade parts, a brand new tenant who reports everything, and a house that's still settling all tend to show up at once.

    To your second question, I'd start a simple log for this house today: each request, the date, what the tech found, the cost, and whether a proper move-in check should have caught it. A loose hinge or blinds is routine. A smoke detector fault or no heat three months in is worth raising with your PM, because those should have been tested before the tenant got the keys.

    Since the home was built in 2022, I'd also check whether the furnace, disposal or fridge are still under the builder's or manufacturer's warranty before paying for those service calls. After a few months, the log will tell you whether you're looking at normal wear or gaps in how the house was prepared.

    Wishing you a quieter winter,
    Lee

  • Lauren CutchenBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · The Woodlands, TX · Member since 2019 · 244 posts · 92 votes
    1w

    @Vick Alumi the first few months with a new tenant are always the noisiest, and it usually calms down once they see you actually respond. Here in the Houston area the heat barely gets used until the first cold snap, so that's when we find out about thermostats and filters every year, even in newer homes. I'd have your PM troubleshoot by phone first, batch the small stuff into one visit, and set a written dollar limit so you're not paying a trip charge per hinge.

  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    1w

    What was your prep process prior to moving in a tenant? What was your move in process with the tenant? If either/neither of these were thorough, there's your answer. Why are you "waiting" for diagnoses and estimates on such minor (except possibly the no heat) issues? What is your plan for a serious plumbing issue?

  • Leo SteinBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 343 posts · 83 votes
    1w

    Newer builds really do throw a cluster of small stuff in the first year, so don't beat yourself up. Most of it is settling and builder grade parts. Next time I'd walk the unit with a written move-in checklist and have the tenant sign off with dated photos, so you know what was working on day one. For the no heat call, have the tenant check the thermostat batteries, the furnace switch and the filter before you pay for a service visit. For cost control, set a dollar limit you'll approve without a call and keep one reliable handyman for the small jobs.

    Real Property Management Optimal 525 Reviews
  • Realtor · Columbus, Franklin County · Member since 2026 · 201 posts · 75 votes
    1w

    @vicka5 Vick, a cluster like this in the first few months is common, and it usually settles down. A few ways to keep costs in check:

    • Check the builder warranty (Harrison's point) and the appliance manufacturer warranties before paying for diagnosis. A 2022 fridge or disposal may still be covered.

    • Ask the PM for the move-in inspection report with photos and compare each item. If it worked at move-in, it's normal maintenance; if it was already broken, that's a make-ready gap to discuss.

    • Ask the PM to batch non-urgent items into one vendor trip. Trip charges add up fast. No-heat is the exception and should be handled right away.

    • Put a written approval limit in place and ask for photos and an invoice on every work order.

    • Before the next tenant, ask for a make-ready checklist that tests every appliance, detector and the HVAC, signed off with photos. What did the no-heat call turn out to be?

  • Investor · Bend, OR · Member since 2026 · 29 posts · 18 votes
    6d

    Thank you, everyone, for the helpful suggestions and perspective.

    This is my first experience as a landlord and my first tenant, so I’m still learning what to expect.

    It’s reassuring to hear that these early maintenance calls aren’t unusual.

    I’ll follow up with my PM on the move-in checklist, warranties, and combining nonurgent repairs into fewer visits.

    I appreciate everyone sharing their experience.

    Vick

  • Investor · San Francisco · Member since 2026 · 73 posts · 36 votes
    6d

    A cluster like that in a 2022 build is frustrating, but it is more common than it looks. The first year or two after construction is when cheap builder-grade parts start failing: disposals, ice makers, and smoke detectors are all usual suspects, and a loose hinge or blinds are just wear items that show up early. The question is not whether things break, it is whether your PM caught the obvious ones at move-in. Ask for the move-in inspection report and photos, then compare it against what has come in. If the heat, disposal, and ice maker were already failing, that is a prep gap, not bad luck. For cost control, triage in writing. Anything affecting heat, safety, or water gets same-day attention. Everything else gets batched into one visit where possible, because a separate trip charge for each small fix is where the money goes. Keep a dated log per property with photos and invoices, and after a few months you will see whether this was a one-time cluster or a pattern.

  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6d

    The tax side here is good news Vick, almost everything on that list is deductible this year. Door hinges, blinds, smoke detectors, and getting the heat working are all repairs that go straight on Schedule E. The disposal and the ice maker are the ones to watch. Fixing them is a repair, but replacing an appliance is technically a capital item depreciated over 5 years. If you make the de minimis safe harbor election on your return, anything $2,500 or under per item or invoice can be expensed instead. The heat works the same way: repairing a component is deductible, but replacing the whole system has to be capitalized.

    Two things to keep on file while this is fresh. First, make sure the PM’s invoices spell out exactly what was done. A line that just says “service call” doesn’t tell your CPA whether it was a repair or an improvement. Second, on a 2022 build some of this may still be under the builder’s warranty, so track anything the warranty, the PM, or the tenant ends up paying for. You can’t deduct costs someone else reimbursed, and money the tenant pays toward damage counts as rental income.

    Happy to connect!

    INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®4.9242 Reviews
    TaxMD® | Tax Planning Software
  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 774 votes
    6d

    Vick, a cluster like that in the first few months is more common than it feels, even in a newer house. The question I would ask is the same one you asked: did the make-ready miss something? On my deals, the $40,000 rehab before leasing is the maintenance plan, so a house should not throw a cluster like that in the first 90 days unless something was not tested. Ask your property manager for the move-in inspection with photos and check each item against it. If it worked at move-in and broke after, that is maintenance. If it never worked, that is a prep gap, and you want it fixed before the next tenant. At 236 doors, my in-house team handles maintenance and collections, and I still want a written approval limit and a photo and invoice on every work order. Keep the rent math honest: the rent has to cover repairs and CapEx, or the house does not work.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    6d

    It's difficult to catch EVERYTHING on RentReady walk-thrus.

    • Two biggest concerns are how were the smoke detectors and garbage disposal missed?

    So, VERY common for tenants to find issues once they move in and start living in a property.

    What matters most is responding to them quickly and managing their expectations.

  • Property Manager · Katy, TX · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6d

    Could be one of two things - poor make ready or a picky tenant.

    Yes, I've seen this many times when the owner/investor tried to cut corners on the make ready.

    A picky tenant can be a good thing when they want to point out the issues because they want a quality property, but it can be a bad thing when the tenant is just trying to be a pain so they can ask for a rent discount...

  • Member since 2026 · 11 posts · 4 votes
    5d

    Vick, one correction and one Oregon point. The builder warranty is probably done: a house built in 2022 is past the usual one-year workmanship and two-year systems coverage. Manufacturer warranties often run longer, though. Many furnaces carry 10 years on parts if they were registered, so pull the model and serial off the furnace and check the maker’s site before you pay for parts. Labor usually isn’t covered.

    On the smoke detector, Oregon puts testing and battery replacement on the tenant once they’ve moved in, so a chirping alarm shouldn’t turn into a paid service call. Ask your PM to tell the tenant that in writing, and to check with you before sending a vendor for anything under a set dollar amount.

  • Property Manager · Melbourne, FL · Member since 2019 · 571 posts · 197 votes
    4d

    I'd keep 'not documented at move-in' separate from 'known to be working at move-in.' A missing test record doesn't prove the PM missed a fault, and a photo of an appliance doesn't prove it was tested. Ask each technician to note the actual failure and likely cause, then compare that with the handover record before assigning responsibility. Meanwhile, the heat and detector concerns need prompt attention; the warranty and responsibility discussion can run alongside the repair rather than hold it up.

    • Investor · Bend, OR · Member since 2026 · 29 posts · 18 votes
      4d

      Thanks, Matthew. That’s a helpful distinction.

      I’ll ask for the technicians’ findings and likely causes before drawing conclusions about responsibility.

      My PM has vendors assigned, and I agree the heat and detector issues need prompt attention while those details are sorted out.

      Vick

  • Member since 2026 · 46 posts · 15 votes
    4d

    Hi Vick — a cluster like this in the first three months is frustrating, and landlord guides commonly note it is more common than it feels, even in a newer home, because daily living tests systems a walk-through does not. The practical split experienced landlords recommend is urgency first, cause second: heat and smoke detectors get prompt attention, while disposal and ice-maker issues can be grouped into one vendor visit where possible, so trip charges do not multiply.

    For the record-keeping side, start one simple log for this property today: date reported, item, photo, technician diagnosis, likely cause, cost, and whether a warranty or the move-in checklist covered it. That log makes the next conversation with the property manager concrete, and it also helps at tax time, since repair invoices need a clear description and date to be filed correctly.

    Before paying for parts, check builder and appliance warranties, and ask for the move-in test record for each item. If an item was tested and working at move-in, that points one way; if it was never tested, that points another. Either way, fixing safety items first and documenting the rest usually keeps both the tenancy and the books calmer.

  • Real Estate Consultant · Member since 2026 · 1 post · 0 votes
    2d

    Good advice above on warranties and the move in record. Two things I'd add on keeping service call costs down:

    1. Troubleshoot before you dispatch. A lot of these calls end without a tech. Disposal: have the tenant press the red reset button on the bottom of the unit, or turn the hex key slot underneath to free it. Ice maker: check that the water valve behind the fridge is open. No heat: thermostat batteries, the filter, and whether the furnace switch got flipped off. A chirping smoke detector is usually just the battery. Ask your PM whether they run a quick checklist like this with the tenant before booking a vendor. If they don't, that's one of the easiest costs to cut.

    2. Ask that every invoice notes the cause: normal wear, defect, or tenant damage. After a few months you'll know whether you have a house problem, a tenant problem, or a process problem, which is the question you're really asking.

  • Property Manager · Miami, FL · Member since 2026 · 2 posts · 0 votes
    2d

    Had a lot of this on a newer place in Miami the first summer. Honestly I think it's one of the more philosophical parts of property management.

    There's two ways to do everything. One is totally by the book, iron fist on the law, your processes and your documentation. The other is the reality that the tenant is probably the most important business partner you have in this simple rental business. They're the customer and they bring the money that keeps the whole thing going. So you end up on a bit of a tightrope between the principled decision and what's best for the business.

    What I've found is if the tenant is happy, and you don't let them take too much advantage of you, it usually nets out better. I'll work with them a little and then show them where the boundaries are.

    Sometimes I'll remind them the rent is where it is partly because some of these things are typically on the tenant, and if it was all on the landlord everybody would have to charge more. That little economics lesson usually calms things down and it stops feeling like landlord versus tenant and more like business partners working together. It goes best when both sides are happy and the rent gets paid.

    There's no perfect answer. It's kind of an art, and for me the only way to learn it was trial and error, just not letting the errors get bad enough to sink you.

  • Investor · Bend, OR · Member since 2026 · 29 posts · 18 votes
    15h

    Thanks, everyone, for the helpful suggestions!

    I’ll put them into practice.

    Still learning as a first-time landlord.

    Vick

  • Investor · Remotely · Member since 2026 · 31 posts · 17 votes
    15h

    Congrats on your first tenant, Vick, and it's smart that you're waiting on diagnoses before assuming tenant misuse.

    New builds often show a cluster like this in the first year, since appliances and fixtures get used for the first time and small install issues come to light. A simple way to tell the difference is a log with one row per request, with the date, the tenant's description, the vendor's diagnosis, and the cost, so you can see which ones trace back to setup and which are normal wear.

    I'd also do a full walkthrough with a checklist and dated photos before the next turnover, covering smoke detectors, heat, and every appliance, so you can see what was working at move-in. Has your property manager given you a written move-in report from before the tenant arrived?

  • Investor · Member since 2026 · 92 posts · 18 votes
    13h

    Hi Vick, that cluster in the first three months is frustrating, and it's pretty common when a move-in walkthrough looks at things instead of running them.

    I'd split it into two piles. No heat and the smoke detector are same-day items, especially in Bend in November, so I wouldn't let those sit in the same queue as hinges and blinds. The rest can wait for one visit and one fix list, instead of four separate diagnostic trips.

    Two things worth asking your PM for in writing: the dated move-in inspection with photos, and whether each item was actually tested under load — heat run, disposal run, ice maker making ice, detector tested — or just looked at. And ask to see the diagnosis notes before you approve a repair, so you can tell a one-off from a pattern. A simple log of item, date, and what was found helps a lot the second time something comes up.

    Hope the heat gets sorted quickly.

  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    4h

    Seriously folks, what are you reading? The OP stated the unit was new in 2022...only the tenant was "new". Aside from the "no heat" call, the other items are micky mouse issues that should have been addressed prior to offering for rent. The OP's PM apparently placed the tenant, so somebody did not properly inspect the unit prior to move in.

    "Loose door hinges, blinds issues, smoke detector issues, and now reports of no heat, a disposal that won’t run, and an ice maker that isn’t working...waiting on diagnoses and estimates (smoke detector, no heat, disposal and ice maker)."

    For all of those that feel this is "common" for either a new property or a new tenant, I must heartily disagree.

    Of course we don't know specifics of any of these items, so lets take them one by one.

    Loose door hinges. Screws likely stripped out, probably "fixed" with longer drywall screws instead of proper plug and re-drill.

    Blinds. 4 year old originals? Really cheap, or obviously physically damaged. Or wrong size.

    Smoke detector. OK, sometimes the battery fails after the workers are gone, even a new battery sometimes. So it Chirps. No mystery, new battery or replacement hardwired unit if that type.

    Disposal won't run. No excuse for at move in, and this includes if foreign object is rattling around in it because the cleaners or someone wiped/knocked something into it. If after move in it stopped working, instruct tenant to push reset and use the disposer wrench that should be hanging in the cabinet to free it if jammed to save themselves the $150 plumbing charge.

    Ice maker not working. Was it plumbed in to begin with? Did anyone lift the shutoff lever that is common on most?

    No heat. Obviously depending on local temps this may be urgent. Did anyone...OP, PM, check operation, or have a pro actually inspect it prior to the season which is a pretty basic step? If not, then yes you may well need an estimate, as you may be replacing the whole unit, but this should have been determined months ago on acquisition.

    Why would time and effort be wasted do diagnose and provide estimates for these minor issues? Is the alternative to not address any of them? Does the PM not have vetted vendors and handypersons for these issues?

    @Vick Alumi this is not normal. Based on your comments through this thread, I am assuming you purchased a vacant unit, hired a PM, and they placed the tenant. If that is the case, one or both of you did not adequately inspect and prep the unit for tenant use/abuse. Did you ask the PM before signing, what their policies and procedures were, or what routine repair costs would be for basic items? Do they use outside vendors or in-house staff? How many units, and for how long, has the PM been managing? They must have solid systems or you will be over-analyzing every "new" issue that comes along. For an example and greater detail, my new book, available on Amazon, Nuts and Bolts Rental Management Secrets might be of interest to you. Best of luck with your investments.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.