Real Estate Broker · Chicago and Kansas City · Member since 2016 · 117 posts · 107 votes
My first property was a house hack. I lived in one unit, and a renter helped pay my mortgage. That one building is how I got started.
I want to hear from people who have done it here in Chicago, in a 2, 3 or 4 flat.
In your first year, how much of your monthly payment did the rent from the other units cover? A third? Half? More? And what surprised you most about living in your own building?
If you are thinking about buying your first building: what is the one number you want to see before you feel ready?
I don't house hack — I buy single-family rentals in Memphis — but the number to check before you buy is the same: rent against the full monthly payment, not just the mortgage.
Run it plain. If rent from the other units doesn't cover at least the mortgage, taxes, insurance, and a real allowance for maintenance and vacancy, you're paying to live there and hoping appreciation bails you out. I use the 1% rule as a first filter — monthly rent should be around 1% of the price — and on a refi I want DSCR at 70-80% LTV to work on the rent alone.
In my market, a 3BR+ single-family at under $100K with Section 8 rent of $1,395-$1,950 clears that test. For a 2-4 flat, do the same math unit by unit. If the other units can't carry the building in year one, don't count on year two to fix it.
Great question, Dan! My first house hack was in 2019. The mortgage was about $2,200, and the back unit rented for $800, so it covered a little over a third of the payment. It wasn’t life changing in year one, but it got me in the door. Seven years later, that same property rents for $2,400 (the unit we lived in) plus $1,600. The real win showed up after we moved out.
Now we live in a triplex where the mortgage is $4,400, and the other two units bring in $2,000 and $1,700. That covers about 80%+ of the payment.
What surprised me most was how much rent growth does the heavy lifting over time. Before buying, the number I'd want first timers to know is the full payment, including taxes and insurance, minus the rent a lender will actually count. That's typically 75% of market rent. Additionally, it's important to work with a lender that understands house hacks and can make sure it goes as smoothly as possible for the buyer. There's FHA self sufficiency test and several other rules that a great lender should be aware of ahead of a contract.
Love this thread. We’ve worked with a lot of owners who started exactly this way, and in the Chicago area the pattern is pretty consistent. In a 2-flat, the other unit usually covers somewhere around half the payment. In a 3 or 4 flat, it can get close to covering the whole thing, which is when it really starts to feel like a business.
What surprises people most isn’t the money, it’s living next to your tenant. They know where you are, so the knock on the door at 9pm for a running toilet happens. The owners who enjoy it set boundaries from day one: requests in writing, a set way to contact them, and a lease that treats the tenant like any other tenant, not a neighbor doing you a favor.
The other surprise is costs. Shared boilers and meters mean you might be paying heat for the whole building, and Cook County taxes can jump after a sale reassessment.
The number I’d want to see before buying: the full payment with realistic taxes after the purchase, minus market rent from the other units, and then ask yourself honestly if you could cover it for a few months with a unit vacant. If the answer is yes, you’re ready.
Hey @Dan Nelson - I worried less about the rent covering a set percent of the payment and more about paying LESS than you be if you were renting in that same neighborhood.
I always looked at 2 units in areas I actually wanted to live in, like Logan Square and Bucktown. My priority was to make sure my overall cost was lower than a rental there.