Good question, Mykah. The detail I always write down is the seller's own words about their timeline and what they need to happen next. I am still learning, but I have found the follow-up lands better when I can repeat back what they told me instead of starting over. I also note what they owe on the house and what they are hoping for on price, so I am not guessing later. Thanks for raising it.
Who else has to sign. A seller can be motivated, priced right and on your timeline, and the deal still dies because a spouse, a sibling on an inherited deed or an ex still on title was never on the call. Ask early whether anyone else is on the deed or part of the decision, write the names down, and get them on the next call.
If it's tenant occupied like your example, note the current rent and whether a lease is running. That rent tells you early whether the house can carry a rental loan, and a lease in place usually transfers with the sale, so the buyer inherits that tenant and those terms.
The tenant detail is a good habit. The notes get you the callback, the names get you the signature.
"I'm ready to retire" is the answer. What they're actually tired of is the motivation: the late-night calls, chasing tenants who don't pay, the manager they can't replace. The first comes out on call one. The second usually shows up on call two or three, if you're actually listening instead of pitching.
I write that part down word for word, because that's what the offer has to solve. Price is rarely the only thing on the table.
Do you keep the motivation separate from the timeline in your notes, or lump them together?
Kevin, good question. I keep them separate. The timeline gets its own line, and the reason gets its own line in the seller's own words. When I call back I can see fast which one changed. If the timeline moved but the reason did not, the call is different than if the reason moved. Keeping them apart keeps my notes honest.