Lease-to-own from the landlord's side: what my Orlando lease options taught me

Lease-to-own from the landlord's side: what my Orlando lease options taught me

John RacinePro Member
Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 303 posts · 157 votes

There's been a lot of seller-finance and subject-to talk here lately, so I wanted to add a creative strategy that doesn't get much airtime from the landlord's side: lease options.

Before I ever ran a mid-term or short-term rental, some of my first rental income in Orlando came from lease-to-own deals. I got into them through a mortgage broker I knew. When he had a borrower he couldn't get approved, he'd bring that buyer in and the home became a lease-to-own instead. Later I bought a 3-bed/2.5-bath home and sold it on a lease option myself.

Why I liked them

For a landlord, the appeal is real. The buyer handled the repairs, so I collected rent and that was about it. No maintenance calls, no late-night emergencies.

Where it went wrong

On the 3/2.5, the monthly payment was set slightly above market rent because of the option. That premium looked like cash flow. It wasn't. That tenant-buyer turned out to be running what looked like a bad-check scheme, and I had to evict. When I put the house on a regular lease, I couldn't get anywhere near that rate. Rent went back to market, and I was fortunate to break even.

What I'd check before doing one today

  1. Underwrite to market rent, not the option payment. If the deal only works with the premium, it doesn't work.

  2. Plan for the buyer not buying. Three of my tenant-buyers did close. The one on the 3/2.5 didn't, and that's the one that taught me the most. Make sure the numbers still hold if you end up a regular landlord again.

  3. Screen like it's a regular lease. A buyer who can't get a mortgage today might have a good reason, or might not. Find out which before you sign. I also don't accept personal checks for move-in funds anymore.

  4. Know your exit before you need it. Mine went through the same eviction process as a regular tenant. In Florida that took about 25 days, so I took roughly a month's rent hit. Don't assume that's true everywhere. Depending on your state and how the agreement is written, a tenant-buyer may not be treated like a plain tenant.

  5. Have it papered properly. Keep the lease and the option clear and separate, and have an attorney who does these regularly draft or review it.

For those of you doing seller finance or lease options right now: do you underwrite the deal as if the buyer never closes, or do you count on the option premium?

3Reply
590 views

Most Popular Reply

Shiloh LundahlPro Member
Rental Property Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
2d

@Zachary Ellis it’s not a good idea to structure lease option that way. Because if you do, the tenant has equitable interest in the house and now you have a court case. Don’t have any of the option fee or the rent go as credit towards the purchase price.

See this reply in the discussion

16 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Chris ColtonPro Member
    Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 259 posts · 97 votes
    3d

    John, thank you for sharing what the Orlando deals taught you. I am still learning this side of the business, and the part that stays with me is your line about underwriting to market rent. I look at it the same way. If the deal only works when the buyer closes, I am counting on something I do not control. I want the rent to carry it on its own, and I want the lease and the option written down clearly so everyone knows where they stand. The paper is what protects the person on both sides. Appreciate you posting this.

    • John RacinePro Member
      OP
      Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 303 posts · 157 votes
      3d

      Thanks, Chris. You nailed it: the paper protects both sides. The option premium on my 3/2.5 looked like cash flow right up until it wasn't, so now if a deal only works because the buyer closes, I pass. Are you looking at lease options as a way to buy, or to sell something you own?

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 646 posts · 185 votes
    3d

    Yes, and if the house carries a DSCR loan, the lender has mostly made that call for you. Lenders generally size the loan off the lesser of the lease rent and the appraiser's market rent, so an option premium gets capped at market before it ever counts. Sharing the 3/2.5 is the generous part of your post, since most people only write up the ones that closed.

    What I'd add is where the option fee goes. Spent as income, it disappears into the mortgage. Held as a reserve, it pays for the eviction, the vacant months and whatever the tenant-buyer let slide. A tenant who handles repairs on a house they end up not buying usually stops handling them well before they leave. On the 3/2.5, did you credit the option fee toward the purchase price or keep it as the turnover reserve?

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    3d

    I believe over 60% of lease options do NOT close.

    Google it!

  • John RacinePro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 303 posts · 157 votes
    2d

    Noah, that one had traditional financing, so DSCR wasn't something I had to work with back then. Great info for anyone doing a lease option on a DSCR loan, though. And it was a non-refundable option fee, never meant to be credited toward the purchase price, so it went into cash flow.

    Drew, that number doesn't surprise me. Three of mine closed and one didn't, but I'd never plan around those odds. If the deal only works when the buyer closes, it doesn't work.

  • Rental Property Investor · Tallahassee, FL · Member since 2026 · 8 posts · 0 votes
    2d

    I underwrite it like the buyer never closes. The deal has to cash flow at market rent, with normal vacancy and repairs, before the option enters the math.

    Then the option money is a cushion, not income. Say market rent is $1,900 and the lease-option payment is $2,100. If that extra $200 a month gets credited toward the price, it comes back off your sale price at closing. It's the buyer's money parked with you, not cash flow.

    Same with the upfront option fee. I hold it against the exact risk you hit: a failed buyer, an eviction, a turnover. I don't count it as profit until the option expires or closes.

    If a deal only pencils with the premium, it's a rental that doesn't work with a nicer story. Agree on having a Florida attorney draft the lease and the option as separate docs.

  • Shiloh LundahlPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    2d

    @Zachary Ellis it’s not a good idea to structure lease option that way. Because if you do, the tenant has equitable interest in the house and now you have a court case. Don’t have any of the option fee or the rent go as credit towards the purchase price.

  • Shiloh LundahlPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Gilbert, AZ · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    2d

    @John Racine I live in Arizona and I have done well over 100 lease options. I would say about 30% of the people that I have brought into the properties have exercised their option. I have now switched up my process to connect them with a loan officer at the very beginning of the process in order for the loan officer to give them a path to help get them ready to purchase the property. I give my tenant buyers three years to exercise the option. And I never accept a personal check as an option fee.

    I’m not sure why you didn’t bring in another lease option tenant and continue to get the higher rent rather than turning it into a regular rental. I currently have about 60 buy and hold single-family homes and probably 90% of them are on lease options. It’s one of the best strategies for single-family homes that few people know or talk about.

    If you’re ever interested in learning more about it, check out BIggerPockets episode 287. It talks a lot about Lease Options.

  • John RacinePro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 303 posts · 157 votes
    2d

    Shiloh, over 100 lease options is a real sample size, and 30% exercising lines up with what Drew posted. Connecting tenant-buyers with a loan officer at the very start is a smart change. It gives them an actual path to closing instead of hoping they figure it out in three years.

    On why I didn't put another tenant-buyer in right away: I tried. It was very early in my investing career, just before the crash, when prices were skyrocketing, and I wasn't having much luck finding one. So I put a long-term tenant in to keep it covered. After that tenant, I did find another lease-option buyer, and that one actually purchased. So the house did end up selling the way I'd planned. It just took a detour.

    And agreed on the fee. Mine was non-refundable and never credited toward the price, so there was no equitable-interest argument to deal with when it went sideways. No personal checks for option fees is a rule I learned the hard way too.

  • Chris ColtonPro Member
    Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 259 posts · 97 votes
    2d

    John, thank you for coming back with the detail on the fee. Keeping it non refundable and never credited toward the price, and keeping the lease and the option as separate papers, is what stood out to me. That is the part that keeps the paper clear if a buyer does not close. I am still learning this side of it. When you hold the fee, do you keep it in its own place until the option ends or closes?

  • Jim BlackburnBusiness Member
    Lender · Florida Based (48 states Puerto Rico) · Member since 2017 · 344 posts · 130 votes
    2d

    John, good thread. One angle nobody has covered yet is what happens on the tenant-buyer's side when they go to get a mortgage, because it affects how you structure the option.

    On conventional and FHA loans, lenders typically count only the part of the monthly payment that's above market rent as a rent credit toward the down payment, and only if it's documented: the signed lease and option agreement, proof of every payment from the buyer's bank account (cancelled checks or statements, not cash or money orders), and a market-rent figure, usually from the appraiser. So a premium that was never written down as a credit, or was paid in ways the buyer can't document, usually won't help them qualify.

    That ties into Shiloh's point about equitable interest. Crediting rent can make the buyer easier to finance, but it raises the legal questions he mentioned, so it's worth deciding up front with your attorney which way you want it.

    A side benefit: requiring payments from the buyer's own bank account also gives you a paper trail early, which would have flagged the bad-check problem sooner.

    Do your lease-option buyers usually talk to a lender at move-in, or closer to the exercise date?

    — Jim Blackburn, NMLS #1072866

    Stairway Mortgage, a Division of NEXA Mortgage LLC598 Reviews
  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 646 posts · 185 votes
    2d

    The detour is the normal shape of a lease option, and you handled it right by keeping the house rented instead of holding out for the premium. What most landlords miss is that the exercise rate follows the market. A tenant-buyer exercises when the house is worth more than the option price and their lender will finance it, so a price fixed before a run-up usually gets exercised and one fixed before a drop mostly doesn't. Shiloh's 30% means about 7 of every 10 houses come back to you as plain rentals. The appraisal at exercise can also stop a sale. If it comes in under the option price, the buyer's loan shrinks and the sale stalls unless you lower the price. Do you set the option price at signing, or tie it to an appraisal when they exercise?

  • John RacinePro Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 303 posts · 157 votes
    2d

    Chris, no, it wasn't held separately. Since the fee was non-refundable and never credited toward the price, it went into cash flow like the rent did.

    Jim, thanks for adding the buyer's side. To answer your question, my tenant-buyers didn't talk to a lender until they got close to the exercise date.

    Noah, the option price was fixed at signing. That fits your point about the market. My deals were done before the crash while prices were climbing, so a price locked in up front looked better every year, and three of mine closed.

  • Charleston, SC · Member since 2026 · 35 posts · 12 votes
    2d
    Quote from @John Racine:

    There's been a lot of seller-finance and subject-to talk here lately, so I wanted to add a creative strategy that doesn't get much airtime from the landlord's side: lease options.

    Before I ever ran a mid-term or short-term rental, some of my first rental income in Orlando came from lease-to-own deals. I got into them through a mortgage broker I knew. When he had a borrower he couldn't get approved, he'd bring that buyer in and the home became a lease-to-own instead. Later I bought a 3-bed/2.5-bath home and sold it on a lease option myself.

    Why I liked them

    For a landlord, the appeal is real. The buyer handled the repairs, so I collected rent and that was about it. No maintenance calls, no late-night emergencies.

    Where it went wrong

    On the 3/2.5, the monthly payment was set slightly above market rent because of the option. That premium looked like cash flow. It wasn't. That tenant-buyer turned out to be running what looked like a bad-check scheme, and I had to evict. When I put the house on a regular lease, I couldn't get anywhere near that rate. Rent went back to market, and I was fortunate to break even.

    What I'd check before doing one today

    1. Underwrite to market rent, not the option payment. If the deal only works with the premium, it doesn't work.

    2. Plan for the buyer not buying. Three of my tenant-buyers did close. The one on the 3/2.5 didn't, and that's the one that taught me the most. Make sure the numbers still hold if you end up a regular landlord again.

    3. Screen like it's a regular lease. A buyer who can't get a mortgage today might have a good reason, or might not. Find out which before you sign. I also don't accept personal checks for move-in funds anymore.

    4. Know your exit before you need it. Mine went through the same eviction process as a regular tenant. In Florida that took about 25 days, so I took roughly a month's rent hit. Don't assume that's true everywhere. Depending on your state and how the agreement is written, a tenant-buyer may not be treated like a plain tenant.

    5. Have it papered properly. Keep the lease and the option clear and separate, and have an attorney who does these regularly draft or review it.

    For those of you doing seller finance or lease options right now: do you underwrite the deal as if the buyer never closes, or do you count on the option premium?

    All great points @John Racine Lease to own can be tricky. Many people cannot qualify for a traditional mortgage for a reason. Yes, there are people out there who do not qualify for a mortgage for a specific reason (divorce, medical, bad luck). I guess all I am saying is do your due diligence and ask the correct questions.

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 646 posts · 185 votes
    1d

    Underwrite a lease option as if the buyer never closes, and treat a close as a bonus. Fixing the price at signing is the simplest way to run one, and a price that steps up each year is a common alternative. A step only helps if the higher number still appraises at exercise and fits what the tenant-buyer's lender will finance. Push it past that and the step-up just lowers your close rate. Same logic if the house ends up a plain rental you want to refinance: a DSCR lender will usually size the loan off market rent, not an option premium. How far above market rent was the payment on the three deals that closed?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.