Accountant · Williamstown, NJ · Member since 2025 · 357 posts · 185 votes
Depreciation is one of the biggest tax benefits of owning rental property, but it's not just about claiming a deduction every year. You also need to understand how it affects your property's adjusted basis and what happens when you eventually sell.
Don't just let the numbers roll over year after year without reviewing them.
Do you review your depreciation schedule every year, or do you simply rely on whatever your tax software carries forward?
I don't trust the carryforward alone. Once a year, before the CPA packet goes out, I pull last year's depreciation schedule and match it to my books per property: purchase basis split between building and land, then each improvement from this year as its own line with the date it went into service. Anything I booked as a repair that was really a roof or new flooring gets flagged for my CPA to decide.
Review it every year, especially after a change in preparer or software, since that’s when history most often gets lost. The issue we see most is depreciation that was never taken at all. Basis is reduced by depreciation “allowed or allowable,” so the missed years still get recaptured at sale even though the owner never got the deduction. The fix is a Form 3115 catch-up rather than amended returns, and it’s much better done before a sale than after.
Other common problems include improvements added to the schedule without writing off the component that was replaced, assets still depreciating after they were sold or scrapped, and land never separated from the building. New Jersey adds an extra layer, since the state doesn’t follow federal bonus depreciation. Any property with bonus or a cost seg needs its own state schedule, or the state basis and the gain at sale won’t match.
I don't trust the carryforward alone. Once a year, before the CPA packet goes out, I pull last year's depreciation schedule and match it to my books per property: purchase basis split between building and land, then each improvement from this year as its own line with the date it went into service. Anything I booked as a repair that was really a roof or new flooring gets flagged for my CPA to decide.
Good point, William. From the lending side, I see investors spend a lot of time reviewing the numbers before they buy. That same discipline pays off while they own the property. I’d make the depreciation schedule part of the annual review with a CPA, especially after a major renovation. It’s a much easier conversation when the records are fresh and you have time to plan for an eventual sale.