AirDNA’s Top Cash-on-Cash Short-Term Rental Markets for 2026

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Agent · Boston, MA · Member since 2025 · 131 posts · 37 votes
5d

@Rati Meskhishvili — exactly. That's the right way to test it: run the real expense stack against the headline number instead of taking the ranking at face value. Broken Bow is a good example — strong demand, but once you load in management, cleaning on short stays, tax, insurance and reserves, the cash-on-cash compresses fast. Same lesson I keep coming back to in Revere: underwrite the operator's version, not the listing's version. Appreciate you running the numbers.

See this reply in the discussion

5 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Agent · Boston, MA · Member since 2025 · 131 posts · 37 votes
    6d

    Good list, and the caveats in the article matter as much as the rankings. I operate a short-term rental in Revere and hold 17+ units across Massachusetts with my company, TWM Residential, and the gap between AirDNA's numbers and real operations is where most STR deals die.

    Three things I check before trusting any cash-on-cash figure: first, expenses. Thirty percent is light for a true STR — cleaning and turnover, furnishing reserves, platform fees, and vacancy add up fast, and they hit hardest in the shoulder season.

    Second, insurance and local rules. Get a real quote and confirm the STR rules in writing before you go hard; in some markets either one can erase the return.

    Third, demand drivers. A market with steady weekday demand beats a pretty vacation town that sits empty Tuesday to Thursday.

    Rankings are a good starting point. Underwrite like an operator, not a spreadsheet, and the winners hold up. Happy to compare notes with other STR operators here.

  • Tbilisi, Georgia (country) · Member since 2026 · 36 posts · 8 votes
    5d

    @Inder Singh I agree that 30% is light. I tried the Broken Bow line with the costs I'd expect there instead: 20% management cost, cleaning on 2-3 night stays, property tax of around 0.9%, insurance, utilities for a hot tub cabin, maintenance and capex.

    On AirDNA's own averages (USD 770k home, USD 72.8k revenue) that comes to roughly 3/4th of revenue, so the 6.6% drops to about 2% with cash, about 4% if you manage it yourself. With a mortgage at today's rates - it becomes negative.

    That lines up with the Broken Bow listings I ran a couple of weeks ago, none of which cash flowed at the asking price. Still a useful list for where to start looking, just not for what you'll earn.

    (I used AI tools to help run the numbers)

  • Real Estate Agent · Boston, MA · Member since 2025 · 131 posts · 37 votes
    5d

    @Rati Meskhishvili — exactly. That's the right way to test it: run the real expense stack against the headline number instead of taking the ranking at face value. Broken Bow is a good example — strong demand, but once you load in management, cleaning on short stays, tax, insurance and reserves, the cash-on-cash compresses fast. Same lesson I keep coming back to in Revere: underwrite the operator's version, not the listing's version. Appreciate you running the numbers.

  • Melissa HaworthBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · The Panhandle | The Emerald Coast | Panama City Beach | Destin · Member since 2017 · 303 posts · 114 votes
    2d

    Agree with Inder and Rati about running the real expense stack. I work with STR buyers on the Florida Panhandle (Destin, 30A, PCB) and the stuff that gets left off the headline numbers down here is HOA dues, special assessments on the older condo buildings now that the reserve rules got stricter, insurance, and the bed tax. You're collecting state sales tax plus the county tourist tax on every booking, so budget for that and for the time to file it every month. Beach markets can still work, you just want the real numbers on the specific building before you get attached to the gross revenue.

    • Tbilisi, Georgia (country) · Member since 2026 · 36 posts · 8 votes
      2d

      @Melissa Haworth Good point on the condo side! None of that shows up in AirDNA numbers. If possible, could you please share roughly how big the special assessments are? And, is it mostly a one-off hit per unit, or are the monthly HOA dues going up for good too?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.