How are you guys verifying rehab budgets before funding?

How are you guys verifying rehab budgets before funding?

Springfield, Sangamon County · Member since 2026 · 3 posts · 4 votes

Jered here, real estate broker and veteran in Springfield, IL. Wanted to share something I've been working on and get some honest feedback, especially from lenders.

I kept seeing the same thing happen on rehab deals. A loan gets funded off a one page contractor bid or the borrower's own estimate, then the walls come open and the budget is suddenly way off. Now everybody's fighting over draws halfway through the job and the lender's money is sitting in a half finished house.

So I started writing a line item renovation scope before the deal funds. I walk the property and go room by room and system by system, and every item gets a quantity and a cost. The walk takes about an hour and the report is back the next day.

What really sold me on it was a fire loss property. Smoke and water hide a lot of damage and a quick bid would have missed half of it. Having everything written out gave the lender something they could actually underwrite. Since then two six figure rehab deals have been funded off these scopes.

The way I see it, the lender gets a real number to lend against instead of trusting one contractor. Draws are easier because there's a baseline to check progress against. The borrower finds the surprises before closing instead of after demo. And contractors are all bidding the same work, so you can actually compare quotes.

For the lenders on here, what are you doing right now before you fund? Your own inspector, the contractor's bid, something else? And for the rehabbers, has a bad scope ever burned you on a draw?

Curious how others around Central Illinois are handling it.

4Reply
515 views

Most Popular Reply

Lender · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2026 · 30 posts · 19 votes
1d

@Jered Dennis From the lender side, a line-item scope is the right starting point, but it's usually one of three things we look at before funding, not the whole answer:

1. Independent cost review. On larger rehabs most private and bank lenders have their own inspector or a third-party construction consultant check the scope against the plans and local costs. A good scope makes that review faster, but the lender still wants someone with no stake in the deal to sign off.

2. Contingency, and whose money goes in first. We typically want 10-15% contingency on cosmetic work and more on fire, water or structural jobs. The bigger question is whether the borrower's equity goes in first. If the lender's holdback funds the early work and the borrower's cash is last in, an overrun lands on the lender.

3. Borrower track record. A first-time flipper with a perfect scope is still a bigger risk than an experienced operator with a rough one, so experience drives leverage and how tight the draw schedule is.

On draws, the things that protect the money beyond photos: an inspection before each release, draws paid on percent complete by line item rather than on invoices, lien waivers from the GC and major subs with each draw, and a title date-down before later draws so no mechanic's liens slipped in.

To Vladimirs's question, most lenders want a written change order approved before the extra work starts, with the overrun paid from contingency or new borrower cash, not pushed into the next draw.

See this reply in the discussion

12 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 206 posts · 46 votes
    1d

    @Jered Dennis, after funding, I would group the same lines into stages with a price each, and close each stage with dated photos. Extra work found at demo gets its own line with photo and price before anyone starts.

    When the walls open and the scope changes, do your lenders re-approve the changed line, or does it wait until the next draw?

  • Investor · Cuyahoga Falls, OH · Member since 2026 · 29 posts · 6 votes
    1d

    Thank you for asking this so honestly, Jered.

    The move you made, writing a line-item scope room by room, is the one that protects everybody in the deal.

    What I have learned to pay attention to is getting that scope priced line by line before the funding, not after.

    When a contractor has walked the property and every room is priced out, the lender, the rehabber, and the draw schedule are all working from the same numbers.

    That is when the draws stop becoming fights, because everyone already agreed on what each step costs.

    When the numbers and the story match from the start, the funding side tends to go a lot smoother, because the whole chain can trust what is in front of them.

  • Chicago, Cook County · Member since 2026 · 52 posts · 23 votes
    1d

    The worry is always the walls.

    A line item scope helps, but

    only if it says what it

    couldn't see.

    - List the hidden items as

    allowances: subfloor, drains,

    wiring behind plaster.

    - Write down what was not

    opened or tested.

    - Tie each draw to a finished

    stage with dated photos.

    - Price change orders before

    the work starts, not after.

    I've watched a $20K rehab

    turn into $60K, so I'm a big

    fan of writing the unknowns

    down up front.

    Kyle

  • Lender · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2026 · 30 posts · 19 votes
    1d

    @Jered Dennis From the lender side, a line-item scope is the right starting point, but it's usually one of three things we look at before funding, not the whole answer:

    1. Independent cost review. On larger rehabs most private and bank lenders have their own inspector or a third-party construction consultant check the scope against the plans and local costs. A good scope makes that review faster, but the lender still wants someone with no stake in the deal to sign off.

    2. Contingency, and whose money goes in first. We typically want 10-15% contingency on cosmetic work and more on fire, water or structural jobs. The bigger question is whether the borrower's equity goes in first. If the lender's holdback funds the early work and the borrower's cash is last in, an overrun lands on the lender.

    3. Borrower track record. A first-time flipper with a perfect scope is still a bigger risk than an experienced operator with a rough one, so experience drives leverage and how tight the draw schedule is.

    On draws, the things that protect the money beyond photos: an inspection before each release, draws paid on percent complete by line item rather than on invoices, lien waivers from the GC and major subs with each draw, and a title date-down before later draws so no mechanic's liens slipped in.

    To Vladimirs's question, most lenders want a written change order approved before the extra work starts, with the overrun paid from contingency or new borrower cash, not pushed into the next draw.

    • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 206 posts · 46 votes
      16h

      @Rickey Shneyder, thank you, that answers it. A signed change order before the work also saves a lot of friendships between the owner and the GC 🙂

      The hard moment is usually a Friday afternoon, when the wall is open and the crew is standing there. How fast does a change order like that come back from you?

    • Lender · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2026 · 30 posts · 19 votes
      6h

      @Vladimirs Veiss it depends on the lender's shop more than anything. With a good private lender, a change order that stays inside contingency and can be confirmed with photos or a quick inspector call usually comes back in 24-48 hours. Anything that raises the loan amount or goes past contingency goes back to credit, and that can take several days to a week.

      The way to handle the Friday-afternoon wall is to set it up at closing:

      • Agree on a threshold in the loan docs, for example small changes under a set dollar amount or percent of the budget, where the GC can proceed with a signed owner change order and photos and the lender just gets notice within a day.

      • Get the name of the actual draw/change-order contact and their turnaround time before you close, not when the crew is standing there.

      • Keep some borrower cash on hand so an urgent fix can start out of pocket and get reimbursed from contingency on the next draw if the lender approves it.

      Lenders mostly get upset about surprises, not change orders.

  • Real Estate Consultant · Massapequa Park, NY · Member since 2026 · 14 posts · 3 votes
    1d

    Good question, Jered. What I see in the estimate reviews I do is that the budget only holds up when it is tied to a written scope, line by line, with the draw schedule matched to that same scope. When the borrower has one lump price and the draw schedule is a separate lump sum, there is no way to check what a draw is actually paying for. A simple check that helps is to ask each bidder to list what is included and what is not included for each line, and to confirm allowances in writing before funding. Then a draw request can be checked against finished work on that line, not just a percent complete claim.

  • Lender · Tampa, FL · Member since 2018 · 34 posts · 6 votes
    20h

    A line-item scope is the right idea, and it's close to what we ask for but depends on the deal. Before we fund a rehab loan we want a line-item budget by room or trade, the contractor's bid with license and insurance, and our own site visit or third-party inspection to confirm the scope matches the house. That budget becomes the draw schedule, so each draw gets inspected against the same lines before money goes out. Smaller renos not so tight, but larger luxury new builds would follow this template.

    Where scopes usually fail isn't the kitchen, it's what's behind the walls: electrical, plumbing, subfloor and roof decking. A scope that calls those out with an allowance, plus a 10% contingency, is the one we trust. Fire loss is a good example, since smoke damage hides in framing and ductwork.

    Question for you: do you re-walk the property at each draw, or only before closing? Lenders value the draw-time check the most.

    • Real Estate Consultant · Massapequa Park, NY · Member since 2026 · 14 posts · 3 votes
      8h

      Good question, Jeff. In the reviews I do, the draw-time check is the one that matters most, because that is when the money is about to move. Before funding I check the scope and budget on paper. At each draw, the work on that line should be looked at in person or with dated photos before the draw is approved, so the payment matches finished work and not a percent complete claim. A quick check at each draw also catches the behind the walls items early, while they are still open and cheaper to fix.

  • Springfield, Sangamon County · Member since 2026 · 3 posts · 4 votes
    20h

    I appreciate all the responses. This is a great community. Thanks all!

  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    14h

    Line-item scopes like that solve a tax problem too, not just a lending one. For anyone keeping the property as a rental, a single lump-sum rehab number usually ends up depreciated over 27.5 years as one big improvement. A room-by-room breakdown lets the appliances, carpet, and similar items be pulled out as 5-year property, and the landscaping and driveway as 15-year property, both eligible for bonus depreciation in year one. It also shows which items were genuine repairs that can be expensed and which were improvements that have to be capitalized.

    The “before” documentation matters too. A scope written before purchase records the property’s condition at acquisition. That’s the evidence a CPA or cost seg firm needs to support how the price gets allocated, and to show which old components were removed if the property was already rented. For flippers, everything goes into the cost of the house either way, but a clean line-item record still makes the year-end numbers much easier to support.

    Feel free to DM me, I’d be happy to share a few resources that might help.

    INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®4.9244 Reviews
    TaxMD® | Tax Planning Software
  • Investor · Cuyahoga Falls, OH · Member since 2026 · 29 posts · 6 votes
    13h

    Thank you, Jered, and thank you to everyone who added to this.

    The scope review and draw protection points are the ones I keep coming back to, because they are what keep a budget honest once the work starts.

    Wishing you a clean funding process on this one.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.