Do You Choose the Property First or the Financing Strategy?

Do You Choose the Property First or the Financing Strategy?

Real Estate Broker · Frankfort, KY · Member since 2019 · 221 posts · 61 votes

When evaluating a real estate opportunity, investors often focus on the property's location, price, potential income, and projected returns.

But financing can influence the entire investment strategy.

A rental acquisition, fix-and-flip, and new construction project each have different funding needs, timelines, and risks.

How do you approach this when evaluating a new opportunity?

Do you identify the financing options first, or do you find a property and then determine which financing structure makes the most sense?

2Reply
303 views

Most Popular Reply

Jason WrayPro Member
Banker · Nationwide · Member since 2020 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
1d

Linda,

That's the Best question for any home buyer or investor! Coming from a 20 Year Veteran Banker the answer is simple. The "Finance" must come first and it has to be strategic and compliment the investors rental strategy.

It also has to be set up in advance to know if and when the investor will renovate and refinance to reduce their BRRR time frame. So many investor jump to HML Hard money lending, or Non/QM without running the numbers.

DSCR, comes with a PPP Prepayment penalty ususlly 3-5 years in this current market to capture a rate in the high Sevens. If not your in the 8's and even worse you pay for an appraisal just to find out the rents "Do Not" DSCR ratio 1 to 1.

I wish more brokers and loan officers would be more involved in the front end. Instead of just rushing to pull credit and order an appraisal chasing a paycheck.

It pays to use a more Seasoned Banker & Realtor as well AIRDNA, or other sites to really understand the rent market instead just taking their agents or AI rent advice.

Good news to all Agents and Investors, 2027 will bring New programs for both Primary and Investment Purchase and Refinance. Meaning Lower down payments and Higher LTV cash outs and Rate and term refinances!

See this reply in the discussion

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Jason WrayPro Member
    Banker · Nationwide · Member since 2020 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1d

    Linda,

    That's the Best question for any home buyer or investor! Coming from a 20 Year Veteran Banker the answer is simple. The "Finance" must come first and it has to be strategic and compliment the investors rental strategy.

    It also has to be set up in advance to know if and when the investor will renovate and refinance to reduce their BRRR time frame. So many investor jump to HML Hard money lending, or Non/QM without running the numbers.

    DSCR, comes with a PPP Prepayment penalty ususlly 3-5 years in this current market to capture a rate in the high Sevens. If not your in the 8's and even worse you pay for an appraisal just to find out the rents "Do Not" DSCR ratio 1 to 1.

    I wish more brokers and loan officers would be more involved in the front end. Instead of just rushing to pull credit and order an appraisal chasing a paycheck.

    It pays to use a more Seasoned Banker & Realtor as well AIRDNA, or other sites to really understand the rent market instead just taking their agents or AI rent advice.

    Good news to all Agents and Investors, 2027 will bring New programs for both Primary and Investment Purchase and Refinance. Meaning Lower down payments and Higher LTV cash outs and Rate and term refinances!

  • Specialist · NJ · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 663 votes
    14h

    The absolute bottom line number is the project cost/ARV. And the better you are at assessing project cost and ARV the better you will be at predicting margin.

    What % of the ARV do you have to be invested to reach the ARV. That is the question. The lower that percentage the more wiggle room you have on exit.

    How do you finance these situations matters much less than finding them. You'll find some financing. There's one thing there's no shortage of and that is money. Private, Hard, Institutional, Conventional, Personal. That is a nice problem to have. You have this system for identifying and then a team to execute these low % ARV projects and all you need is the money. Nice problem.

    If the only financing you have is a HML, then you are limited to their program. You have to buy what works for them. And I can tell you, these low % ARV projects do not. The purchase price is either too low, or the buy is a ll cash, sight unseen buy with no appraisal. Both scenarios they hate. But I can't tell you how many times I saw a 20k property that needed 80k but would be worth 200k when done. A HML lender would never, ever do that deal. But those are there.

    I bought two duplexes, a triplex, and a 5/2 SFH this year. But I'm so leery of the rehab process that I sold them all as is for anywhere from a 50% - 100% markup. I have one that just closed where I bought for 20k and sold for 60k. House was almost pristine inside, got lucky. 200% return.

    So my advice would be make the financing a problem. It becomes a problem when you've built the system that brings in opportunity and you can't take advantage of. At worst you find a partner to start. You curate the opportunities and manage the projects, someone else brings the money. You'd rather have the cost of debt taken out of the equation if at all possible because in RE deals, sometimes there is no way of know how long they will take close to close.

  • Chris ColtonPro Member
    Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 254 posts · 97 votes
    14h

    Hi Linda, I am still learning, but I look at it a little differently. I start with the monthly payment. I ask what the payment would be in real life, with taxes and insurance and the other costs, and then I ask if the rent can cover that payment. If the payment does not work, a lower price does not fix it for me. The way a deal is paid for can change that payment, so I try to understand that part before I get excited about a house. What part of the payment do you check first when you look at a rental?

  • Real Estate Coach · Sacramento Area · Member since 2026 · 64 posts · 39 votes
    14h

    For me it's property first, then structure.

    I find the deal, talk to the owner, and figure out what they actually need. Sometimes that's a bank loan. Sometimes the owner is open to carrying a note. With seller financing, a $500K storage facility might need $25K to $75K down.

    You won't know which structure fits until you know the property and the seller.

    Linda, how often do you see sellers in your market open to carrying paper?

  • Lender · Vernon, CT · Member since 2026 · 40 posts · 8 votes
    10h

    I've always been coached to:

    1.) Figure out how much money you could currently put into a deal.
    2.) Find buyers or tenants (get an idea of what your target is for sale price or rents)
    3.) Figure out the rough numbers that could get you there. (Purchase price, renovation amounts, ARVs, number of units, taxes, insurance, interest rates, holding costs, closing costs, downpayments, etc).
    4.) Look at the market to see if there are properties that can be purchased in the right range for that to work.
    5.) Talk to a lender or broker to go through your plan, and make sure it works in concept with the right house.
    6.) Figure out exact how much money you would need to invest to make deals like that work.

    7.) Make sure that is an amount of money you could put into a deal.
    8.) Start looking for an individual property and start making offers.

    I believe it starts with "What can I afford?"

    If I've got $5, it doesn't matter how good the BRRRR deal is. The $5 limits me more than finding a property.

  • Lender · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2026 · 30 posts · 19 votes
    10h

    Linda, from the lending side, I'd say you need to know how you'll finance it before you get too far into a property, but you still choose the structure after you know the property. What I'd want an investor to know before they start looking:

    • The leverage they can get for each type of deal. Roughly 75-80% on a stabilized rental, 85-90% of purchase on a fix-and-flip for an experienced borrower, and much less on land or ground-up construction.

    • How much cash they need to close and hold in reserves. That limits them more than the rate does.

    • What's in the way of each loan: seasoning on a cash-out refi, minimum DSCR, and whether value comes from the appraisal or the rents.

    Once there's a property, its condition, income and timeline pick the loan. A vacant house that needs a rehab won't qualify for a DSCR loan on day one, no matter how strong the borrower is. The mistakes I see most come from making an offer first and then forcing a loan structure that doesn't fit the property. Do you see more deals fall apart on the financing or on the appraisal?

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    9h

    Property first always. Then pick the strategy that works best...if one works at all. If you can't find a strategy that works for that property, then pass on that property.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.