Flipper/Rehabber · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2009 · 132 posts · 39 votes
I'm looking at an Indianapolis four-bedroom, one-bath house with a garage as a BRRRR example. It's 1,217 square feet, built in 1963 on a slab, and needs a roof, HVAC and cosmetics.
The asking price is $80,000. Using a $60,000 renovation budget puts the purchase and rehab at $140,000, before closing costs, holding costs and any separate fees.
The sold comps I pulled averaged around $168,000 which are actually smaller and three bedrooms, with the highest at $179,000. I'm evaluating $175,000 as a potential finished value with the fourth bedroom, more square footage and fully remodeled nicer finishes. My market rent estimate is $1,600 a month, with a Zillow rent estimate supporting that number. These are estimates for a property I'm evaluating.
That would put the estimated finished value about $35,000 above the purchase and rehab budget, before the other costs. The idea would be to renovate, rent, refinance to recover much of the initial capital, and repeat.
For investors buying from out of state, what would you want verified before relying on these numbers? How would you account for closing costs, holding costs, reserves and lender requirements when estimating how much cash would remain invested after refinancing?
Ryan, being the first to say it—trying to make a $175k ARV work when you're already at $140k before closing, holding, and hard money points is tightrope walking! Once you add $15k–$18k in soft/holding costs, a 75% cash-out refi (~$131k) leaves way too much cash trapped in the deal especially since a 4-bed/1-bath on a slab usually struggles to hit top-of-market comps.
When we pull off-market data in Indy, isolating deep-equity distress (15–40%+ below live sub-market medians) before it hits retail asking prices is usually the only way to keep that post-rehab refi buffer safe.
Quick question: are you underwriting this off an MLS listing, or looking at direct off-market deal flow in Indy right now?
Ryan, good set of numbers to stress test. Building on what's already here, a few things I'd verify from out of state.
Appraisal risk first. Your best sold comp is $179K and your subject is a slab-on-grade 1963 house, so an appraiser may not give full credit for the extra bedroom. I'd underwrite at the average comp rather than $175K and see if the deal still works.
Second, the refi terms. Many lenders want around six months of seasoning before a cash-out, though some programs are shorter, so get the lender's actual rules in writing before you buy. At 75% LTV on $168K you'd borrow about $126K against $140K plus closing, holding and reserves, which means you leave cash in the deal.
Third, the property. On a 1963 slab I'd want a sewer scope and a look at plumbing under the slab, plus roof and HVAC bids from contractors you've vetted. And get a property manager's rent opinion, not just a Zillow estimate.
Ryan, the part I'd stress test is the refinance, since your whole plan hangs on it. A cash-out refi on a rental is sized off the appraised value, and lenders usually lend a percentage of that, so at your $140K in and a $175K finished value you'd likely pull back less than you're hoping once you count closing costs and holding costs. Your own sold comps average well below $175K, so I'd run the refi at the comp number, not the remodel number, and see if you still get most of your cash out.
For how much cash to leave in a deal, I like to know the answer before I buy: if the appraisal comes in at the low end, can I live with what's stuck in it, and does the rent still cover the payment on a DSCR loan at that value? Also check seasoning and prepay terms on whatever short-term money you use for the buy and rehab.
My branch does DSCR, fix and flip and hard money in-house, so I can look at a deal like this with you before you commit. Give me a call, my number's in my signature below.
I'd be careful with the $175K ARV. That's the number I'd want to prove before buying, not the number I'd use to make the deal work. I'd verify the comps, get a realistic rehab estimate from someone who has actually walked the property, and get the refinance terms upfront. The $35K spread can disappear pretty quickly once you add closing costs, holding costs, financing and the possibility of a lower appraisal. With a BRRRR, I'd want enough margin that the deal still works if the rehab runs over budget or the appraisal comes in light. Otherwise, you're not really recycling your capital; you're hoping everything goes right.
The $35,000 cushion is thinner than it looks, because $175,000 sits near the top of comps that averaged $168,000 and were smaller three bedrooms. Working backward from the refinance before you buy is the right instinct, so run it at $168,000. Cash left in the deal is your all in cost minus the new loan, and that loan is usually a percentage of the appraisal, not of what you spent. Out of state, I'd verify a roof and HVAC bid from a contractor who isn't also selling you the deal, a rent number from leased comps or a manager rather than Zillow, and whether an appraiser will credit a fourth bedroom with only one bath. Then add taxes, insurance on a 1963 house, and the holding months until it's rented. Is the purchase and rehab coming from cash or a short term loan?
I'd verify comps. Have an agent run them and share. Also gather 2-3 bids. Make sure they are itemized not a verbal number. I would also have someone there to check up on the rehab as it progresses. Honestly focusing on a team that can help with each part is crucial. BRRR is great but you can lose $$ quickly.
@Ryan Moeller Before relying on $175K, I'd want sold comps that actually have 4 bedrooms and similar square footage, not 3-bed comps adjusted up, since an appraiser may not give full credit for the added bedroom. From out of state I'd verify: 1) line-item bids for the roof and HVAC instead of a lump $60K, and on a 1963 slab house, a sewer scope and a look at the plumbing under the slab; 2) leased rent comps for a 4-bed/1-bath specifically, because one bath can cap rent against 4/2 comps; 3) your refi lender's max cash-out LTV, seasoning period, and whether they cap the loan at your cost basis early on. Then work out cash left in: purchase + rehab + closing on both ends + 4-6 months of holding + a 10-15% contingency, minus the new loan. At 75% of a more conservative $165K, that's about $123,750, roughly $16K below your $140K before any of those costs. If you're comfortable leaving that in, the deal doesn't depend on a best-case appraisal. What LTV and seasoning is your lender quoting?
Ryan, the refi math has been covered really well here already, so I'll stick to the Indy-specific stuff I'd check if a client sent me this one.
Where in the city is it? Values here can change block by block, so a $168k average can hide a pretty wide spread. I'd want comps from the same pocket, renovated, and sold recently. If there just aren't any renovated 4 beds nearby, that's kind of your answer on the $175k.
Taxes are the one I see out of state buyers miss the most. Don't use the tax bill on the listing if the last owner had a homestead. As a rental you're under the 2% cap, not 1%, and the assessment can go up after a big permitted rehab. Run your refi and DSCR numbers with the higher figure, not today's bill.
Budget time for permits on the roof and HVAC and make sure your contractor is licensed for where the house actually is. Beech Grove, Speedway, Lawrence and Southport have their own building offices, so "Indy rules" don't automatically apply there. If it's in the City of Indianapolis, you'll also need to get it on the city's landlord registry before you lease it.
On rent, $1,600 might be fine but I wouldn't lean on Zillow for it. Have a local PM or agent pull what 4 beds actually leased for nearby, because that one bath will hold it back compared to the 4/2s.
What zip is it in? I can tell you what I've been seeing over there.
Ryan, I'm a DSCR lender, so I'll take the refi side.
The new loan is a percentage of the appraised value, so run it at the comps, $168k, not $175k. At [75%] cash-out that's about $126k against your $140k. You're $14k short before any costs. Add both closings and six months of carrying, and $25k–$30k left in the deal is realistic.
Two things to ask any lender up front. First, how long before they use the appraised value instead of your cost? Mine is no seasoning. Second, can reserves come out of the cash-out? If the purchase and rehab are on a short-term loan, check its prepay too.
The rent side holds up. $1,600 against a $126k loan, with taxes at Indiana's 2% rental cap and normal insurance, is a DSCR around 1.25.
If you want real numbers before you buy, send me your email in a private message and I'll put a proposal together for the refi.
I'm looking at an Indianapolis four-bedroom, one-bath house with a garage as a BRRRR example. It's 1,217 square feet, built in 1963 on a slab, and needs a roof, HVAC and cosmetics.
The asking price is $80,000. Using a $60,000 renovation budget puts the purchase and rehab at $140,000, before closing costs, holding costs and any separate fees.
The sold comps I pulled averaged around $168,000 which are actually smaller and three bedrooms, with the highest at $179,000. I'm evaluating $175,000 as a potential finished value with the fourth bedroom, more square footage and fully remodeled nicer finishes. My market rent estimate is $1,600 a month, with a Zillow rent estimate supporting that number. These are estimates for a property I'm evaluating.
That would put the estimated finished value about $35,000 above the purchase and rehab budget, before the other costs. The idea would be to renovate, rent, refinance to recover much of the initial capital, and repeat.
For investors buying from out of state, what would you want verified before relying on these numbers? How would you account for closing costs, holding costs, reserves and lender requirements when estimating how much cash would remain invested after refinancing?
@Ryan Moeller, you've already received some great advice about the numbers, especially the refinance and renovation costs. One thing I'd also pay attention to is protecting yourself through the purchase and contractor agreements. Since you're buying from out of state, I'd want to make sure you have enough time for inspections and that any additional renovation work needs your approval before the costs increase.
In my experience working with previous clients as a real estate attorney and broker in Maryland, I've seen how important clear agreements are when renovating investment properties. For example, if a contractor discovers additional repairs after starting the work, having a written process for approving changes can help prevent unexpected charges and disagreements.
I appreciate you sharing the numbers, @Ryan Moeller! Real estate transactions and contractor agreements are closely related to my work, so I enjoy discussions like this. I hope the project works out for you, and I'm happy to stay connected!
Run the refi at 70 to 75% of a conservative ARV. At the $168K comp average, 75% is about $126K, which leaves roughly $14K plus closing costs in on a $140K all-in. Before buying I'd verify the DSCR on that loan (rent versus PITI, ideally 1.2+), what local rents actually support, the lender's seasoning rule (some cash out off the new value right away with documented rehab, others make you wait 6 months), and that the comps truly match. A 4/1 on a slab can appraise below 3/2 comps. What's your rent estimate?