Real Estate Agent · Cincinnati, OH · Member since 2014 · 170 posts · 102 votes
My wife and I were just approved for a $100,000 open line of credit on our home; we house-hack a 4-family near Over the Rhine in Cincinnati, Ohio. This quad is our only hold right now, our goal is to own enough rental property to sustain our family and our future business goals. Also, I already have my real estate license.
So my question is: What would YOU do if you had $97,000 available between 5% and 6% and you wanted to build a rental portfolio? Please assume that you're already owner-occupying a cashflow-positive multi, and feel free to delve into whatever investing arenas you think will help us buy and hold for the long term. Whatever your thoughts are, I'd love to read them and learn from them!
If you can find properties in Cincinnati for $100,000 that cash flow $1,000 each after making a mortgage payment on $90k, send them all my way and I'll pay double that for them. In Cincinnati, your rent on a $100,000 property is mostly going to be right around $1,000/month... Not sure that I've ever heard of a market that exists where that math actually lives in the wild.
@Slocomb Reed I would buy 10 $100k houses with 10% down on each, each cash flowing $1,000+/month. $144,000 gross cash flow in year 1. Season the tenants, then refinance to something long term and do it again.
If so, and your timeline is fairly long, I would focus on forced appreciation opportunities. Things like low occupancy multis that need work to turn them around, or sfr's that are distressed. Fix them up with the 100k, then turn around and refi them to get your credit free again and repeat. The goal is not to keep your 100k tied up for longer than a couple years at a time at the max. 6 months or less at the min.
If you want to discuss this in depth I would be happy to grab a cup of coffee sometime.
@Jason Hirko Just curious, how is buying an investment property with 10% down possible nowadays? Usually banks are going to want to see reserves on each property and 20% is pretty standard for down payment.
@Samantha Klein it sounds like @Jason Hirko is talking about buying with hard money, then refinancing with a bank after the units/tenants are seasoned.
@Samantha Klein@Slocomb Reed Hard money is definitely an option, but so is private money. It sounds to me if you are able to get a $100k unsecured line of credit, you are likely a great borrower, and there's a lot of portfolio lenders around that could do what I suggested for less - heck, I know community banks that would take on a commercial loan for this and give you a 15 year amortization and a 5 year balloon
Hey @Slocomb Reed !! You've got yourself a good situation there!!
Personally, I'd try and replicate what you've already done. Find another quad/duplex somewhere, move in, and rehab it..
(side note, since you'd be using HELCO loan, you'll want to make sure that the amount of money you put in to the new rental makes a better return than the rate your paying on the HELCO, does that make sense?? ex, if your loan is at say, 4% and you invest $50k in a new prop. You'll want to be sure that you're making atleast a 5% return on the $50k)
You need to refinance to get your money back out of this first 4 plex. Then pay cash for another Cash Flow Property, then refi that one, and continue to do this over and over.
If you split it up for 10 - 10% down payments, it loses its power because you can't re-use it. Also, now you're trying to get NOO units 10 at a time, for only 10% down. Very hard to do.
If you keep it together, and refi one unit at a time, you're only applying for one loan at a time. I you need a partner for the loans (Credit Partner), so be it. This way, by continuing to get ALL of you money back out at each refi, you never spend any money...just use it...over and over.
Never Spend you money...use it to infinity. Just put it into a deal, and quickly get it all back...with friends.
@Joe Villeneuve after the seasoning period, there are plenty of lenders will refinance based on the appraised value, allowing you to pull 100% of your funds back out.
If you can find properties in Cincinnati for $100,000 that cash flow $1,000 each after making a mortgage payment on $90k, send them all my way and I'll pay double that for them. In Cincinnati, your rent on a $100,000 property is mostly going to be right around $1,000/month... Not sure that I've ever heard of a market that exists where that math actually lives in the wild.
@Joe Villeneuve after the seasoning period, there are plenty of lenders will refinance based on the appraised value, allowing you to pull 100% of your funds back out.
That's right. Putting in 10% at a time is much slower. There is a much faster way than what has been discussed so far, but it would be hard to explain on this platform
If you can find properties in Cincinnati for $100,000 that cash flow $1,000 each after making a mortgage payment on $90k, send them all my way and I'll pay double that for them. In Cincinnati, your rent on a $100,000 property is mostly going to be right around $1,000/month... Not sure that I've ever heard of a market that exists where that math actually lives in the wild.
If you can find properties in Cincinnati for $100,000 that cash flow $1,000 each after making a mortgage payment on $90k, send them all my way and I'll pay double that for them. In Cincinnati, your rent on a $100,000 property is mostly going to be right around $1,000/month... Not sure that I've ever heard of a market that exists where that math actually lives in the wild.
Gross, not net.
You're right. I missed where you said gross. I believe you mean $120k instead of $144k (1,000 x 12 months x 10 houses). I think that it's important to note that this scenario probably leaves about $100-$150/month in net cash flow -- or $12,000 to $18,000 for the year. Not terrible, but 12-18% ROI for all that management might be a tough pill to swallow. To refi 100% of their money out, they'd have to be value add plays vs. market purchases so they'd also need to consider their time to manage 10 rehabs in a year after starting at 0. I have lots of people come to me that want to scale from 0 to 10 and it's never been a pretty outcome.
I might suggest rehabbing a house or 2 this year to get contractors and processes worked out and then buying a few value add rentals. Alternatively, there are people like me that have the ability to put their money to work lending to other rehabbers and the lender makes 15% interest on their money without having to manage any projects.
Ideally I think I want to buy, rehab, rent, and refinance my next deal deal without having to use any money other than this $100k open line. You can buy and rehab to rent in Cincinnati for under 100k in a variety of neighborhoods, so that shouldn't be too big of an issue.
Do y'all see any value in getting a BRRRR deal under my belt before reaching out to hard and/or private money lenders? Is it worth the wait to make myself a more attractive loan option, or would the wait not be worthwhile?
Ideally I think I want to buy, rehab, rent, and refinance my next deal deal without having to use any money other than this $100k open line. You can buy and rehab to rent in Cincinnati for under 100k in a variety of neighborhoods, so that shouldn't be too big of an issue.
Do y'all see any value in getting a BRRRR deal under my belt before reaching out to hard and/or private money lenders? Is it worth the wait to make myself a more attractive loan option, or would the wait not be worthwhile?
If it was me I would prefer to start using whatever lending ASAP and only reaching into a smaller portion of the 100k line. That way you can move faster if you want to.
That makes sense, but I won't be able to get money anywhere else for 5.2% with no fees. Using the HELOC will be the cheapest way to go, and I don't see myself jumping into multiple deals until I've fully completed my first real rehab.
Wow, so many options. Which one to pick? Probably that one that brings more ROI and higher cash flow. Am I right? And which one is that one? Maybe you should put together a mix, Slocomb Reed. Or start with the arena that you feel more comfortable with.
Here is a suggestion/offer. i am in the the middle of closing on a property in Scottsdale Az. I have a fee to meet of $850.00 that wasn't anticipated. I will offer you $1700 ( to be returned in 20 days out of the proceeds from the closing) for the use of $850 paid directly to the entity (not myself) to help me complete this closing ASAP. I know the amount is small. and the return high, but it is a BIG PICTURE issue. i have come too far on this deal to either, wholesale the deal, or walk away at this stage. PLEASE RESPOND -
Not sure of the prices in your area; but I would contact your network and fellow investors. Team up and purchase some commercial properties. A 25+ unit apartment building 8+ cap rate. Good luck!
I would pretend I didn't have that money, learn to buy with out the vast majority of it and then I would know the answer as to what I would do with it. I always recommend that people learn to buy and make it in this business with out access to a lot of money. Having money as a tool for someone starting can be very risky as it can blind people. I am not saying that is in fact the case with the OP but there is a lot of value to be had when cutting your teeth on a shoe string budget.
@Slocomb Reed, you earlier asked about getting a few deals under your belt before going to a HML/PL. I can't speak for any other lenders, but I'll say that lack of experience isn't a huge issue for me when you have the available capital to cover your portion of the loan (payments, rehab funds not included in the loan, etc.). We do a pretty good job here of walking people through the process AND finding them deals that match their ability. I wouldn't feel good about putting you in your first deal that needed a ton of work. I'd be looking for something that was much more cosmetic that you could get done quickly.