First home first investment

First home first investment

Member since 2021 · 4 posts · 3 votes

hey all
I'm living in NYC, 
I want to go into real estate, not sure yet if I would want to do house hacking or cash flow investment, or both.
I have over 250k cash ready to invest, would want to hear from the professionals about which way and path I should choose, should I try to invest in my area (NYC isn't cheap) or should I start out of state?
I'm not very risk-tolerant.
would love to talk to someone who is in the business for a while and wants to help.
Best

3Reply
87 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Agent · Evergreen, CO · Member since 2015 · 126 posts · 73 votes
4y

@Joseph Z. First of all, congratulations on starting your real estate investment journey! 

I agree with @Luka Milicevic and @Jim Pellerin and others...You need to first determine what you want. i.e. What is your goal? And it can't be as broad as to make money. It needs to be specific. I've been a real estate investor for over 17 years and my goal(s) have definitely changed over time. But I always have a goal that I am shooting for. 

I am also a real estate agent in Colorado and I see this a lot with my investor clients. They say they want an investment property but they don't know what they want. They just know they like the idea of it, but don't know what else to do or where to start. So this aspect is where I add value in helping them uncover their goal(s). But without a goal, it's hard for anyone to answer your question and provide solid value. 


The cliff notes approach to this is to start by asking yourself, what am I looking to achieve? And then to continue asking yourself questions until you get down to something very specific. e.g. Keep asking yourself "What would I need to do/make true to achieve that result?". Let's say the answer to that initial question is monthly cash flow. So how much cash flow do you need to make per property or per door to feel it's a good investment for your situation? Is that desired cashflow specific to a particular property value or value range? Or are you also looking for a certain cash on cash return? If so what type of cash on cash return? Because of course you could pay cash for a property and of course it will/should cashflow if you pay cash, but is that the best use of your money? That's your call, but many like to use leverage so they can accumulate more. So what's the balance of cash on cash to cashflow that you are looking to achieve? Is there a price range you feel most comfortable in? You mentioned you are not very risk tolerant. So maybe you want a property that isn't that expense because to you it feels less risking. 

So you see one example, many questions (of which the above isn't all of them and is just one individual scenario that could branch in many different ways), but I hope you get the point. 


But when you know the answer to that question, you then have a focus. You then have something to go and hunt for. And you have something for others to hunt for. e.g. If you tell a realtor, I'm looking in a max $500,000 price range. I only want a long term rental. I'm going to use a property manager. I want a minimum of at least 10% cash on cash. And or a minimum of 10% cash on cash but if the property is a cheaper property I want to at least cash flow $200+ per door. That's something tangible. That's something that someone can help you find. 

The answer could vary again based on different scenarios. The answer could be a single family home that you rent. It could be a small multifamily that you rent or that you live in one side and rent out the other(s). Or it could be a property that you house hack. (Of course if you have a preference here that helps narrow things even further.) But having a goal(s) at least gives a specific enough request to which someone can help find solutions. 

Make sense?

Hope that helps. Happy to chat more. Hey, you're on here so that's a start. Starting and taking action is step one. So congratulations on that!

See this reply in the discussion

19 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Agent · Kansas City · Member since 2018 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4y

    I would try house hacking if you can. Whether it's a multi family or a single family. You could also look OOS. You could look in the Midwest or similar cities, there you would find deals 100-200K. Personally I think a house hack would give you experience and get you started. In a high appreciating market like NY you'll have great long term growth. 

  • Real Estate Consultant · USA · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 751 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Joseph Z.:

    hey all
    I'm living in NYC, 
    I want to go into real estate, not sure yet if I would want to do house hacking or cash flow investment, or both.
    I have over 250k cash ready to invest, would want to hear from the professionals about which way and path I should choose, should I try to invest in my area (NYC isn't cheap) or should I start out of state?
    I'm not very risk-tolerant.
    would love to talk to someone who is in the business for a while and wants to help.
    Best

    It depends on your goals. Do you want to make an income today or are you ok waiting for your investment to appreciate over 10 years or so.
  • Member since 2021 · 4 posts · 3 votes
    4y

    I don’t need the money for an income today, but would love to have positive cash flow and just wait for appreciation in 10 year’s, because who knows what will happen in nyc in 10 years.
    Quote from @Jim Pellerin:
    Quote from @Joseph Z.:

    hey all
    I'm living in NYC, 
    I want to go into real estate, not sure yet if I would want to do house hacking or cash flow investment, or both.
    I have over 250k cash ready to invest, would want to hear from the professionals about which way and path I should choose, should I try to invest in my area (NYC isn't cheap) or should I start out of state?
    I'm not very risk-tolerant.
    would love to talk to someone who is in the business for a while and wants to help.
    Best

    It depends on your goals. Do you want to make an income today or are you ok waiting for your investment to appreciate over 10 years or so.

  • Real Estate Agent · Nashville, TN · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    4y

    @Joseph Z.

    If you ask 100 investors on the forums how they would invest 250k, you would get 101 different answers.

    What I would do is think about what you want first. That will determine your investing goals and what you want to do with your money. 

    If you are risk averse and want to stay in your local market then I'd recommend house hacking or a live in flip.

    Out of state, I'd look for solid markets where you can buy properties cash for 250k. Most important aspect of out of state investing is finding reliable boots on the ground. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Evergreen, CO · Member since 2015 · 126 posts · 73 votes
    4y

    @Joseph Z. First of all, congratulations on starting your real estate investment journey! 

    I agree with @Luka Milicevic and @Jim Pellerin and others...You need to first determine what you want. i.e. What is your goal? And it can't be as broad as to make money. It needs to be specific. I've been a real estate investor for over 17 years and my goal(s) have definitely changed over time. But I always have a goal that I am shooting for. 

    I am also a real estate agent in Colorado and I see this a lot with my investor clients. They say they want an investment property but they don't know what they want. They just know they like the idea of it, but don't know what else to do or where to start. So this aspect is where I add value in helping them uncover their goal(s). But without a goal, it's hard for anyone to answer your question and provide solid value. 


    The cliff notes approach to this is to start by asking yourself, what am I looking to achieve? And then to continue asking yourself questions until you get down to something very specific. e.g. Keep asking yourself "What would I need to do/make true to achieve that result?". Let's say the answer to that initial question is monthly cash flow. So how much cash flow do you need to make per property or per door to feel it's a good investment for your situation? Is that desired cashflow specific to a particular property value or value range? Or are you also looking for a certain cash on cash return? If so what type of cash on cash return? Because of course you could pay cash for a property and of course it will/should cashflow if you pay cash, but is that the best use of your money? That's your call, but many like to use leverage so they can accumulate more. So what's the balance of cash on cash to cashflow that you are looking to achieve? Is there a price range you feel most comfortable in? You mentioned you are not very risk tolerant. So maybe you want a property that isn't that expense because to you it feels less risking. 

    So you see one example, many questions (of which the above isn't all of them and is just one individual scenario that could branch in many different ways), but I hope you get the point. 


    But when you know the answer to that question, you then have a focus. You then have something to go and hunt for. And you have something for others to hunt for. e.g. If you tell a realtor, I'm looking in a max $500,000 price range. I only want a long term rental. I'm going to use a property manager. I want a minimum of at least 10% cash on cash. And or a minimum of 10% cash on cash but if the property is a cheaper property I want to at least cash flow $200+ per door. That's something tangible. That's something that someone can help you find. 

    The answer could vary again based on different scenarios. The answer could be a single family home that you rent. It could be a small multifamily that you rent or that you live in one side and rent out the other(s). Or it could be a property that you house hack. (Of course if you have a preference here that helps narrow things even further.) But having a goal(s) at least gives a specific enough request to which someone can help find solutions. 

    Make sense?

    Hope that helps. Happy to chat more. Hey, you're on here so that's a start. Starting and taking action is step one. So congratulations on that!

  • Bay area, CA · Member since 2021 · 383 posts · 306 votes
    4y

    Congratulations on having that much cash which puts you in a position to ask this question! 

    Now speaking of your question, I say, better to ask how to achieve what you want, instead of asking what can be done with the money. Luka summarized this in an excellent one-line! 

    Never forget, there are tons of people online offering great turnkey investments, passive investments, etc. So what to do with money or what to do in real estate is an easy problem, however, what you want or what will make you fulfilled in a few years or what you won't regret doing/trying is the right question to ask.

    Anyhow, enough of me being philosophical, now to your question:

    If you are not very risk-tolerant, I say cash-flowy turn-key properties, recently repaired and fixed is the way to go to make good passive income. Reach out to me if you have more questions.

  • Lender · NJ NY PA CT GA FL, Puerto Rico · Member since 2015 · 213 posts · 111 votes
    4y

    @Joseph Z. what is your end goal? If you are looking to become a landlord familiarize yourself about landlord-tenant laws in your state and compare those to the neighboring state. In my experience working with investors they lean towards landlord friendlier states when it comes to property management

  • Investor · Germany · Member since 2021 · 23 posts · 33 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Joseph Z.:

    hey all
    I'm living in NYC, 
    I want to go into real estate, not sure yet if I would want to do house hacking or cash flow investment, or both.
    I have over 250k cash ready to invest, would want to hear from the professionals about which way and path I should choose, should I try to invest in my area (NYC isn't cheap) or should I start out of state?
    I'm not very risk-tolerant.
    would love to talk to someone who is in the business for a while and wants to help.
    Best

     Hey Joseph,

    Thank you for asking this question. It definitely appears that we are in a similar situation of having the money, but struggling where to start. I have been dedicating massive time to finding the answer to this question. Unfortunately, I don't have much valuable input to add, but @Michael Glunk's answer spoke volumes and made me realize that I too need to figure out exactly what my end goals are and what help specifically I am asking for. 

    This is why I love BiggerPockets, I learn so much from the questions that everyone else asks.

    Great luck on your journey!

  • Specialist · Southlake, TX · Member since 2021 · 213 posts · 157 votes
    4y

    How much free time do you have to invest? If you are a busy person, there are passive ways to get into the world of real estate. I would suggest taking a look at the turnkey real estate model. You would actually own the asset, so you receive the benefits of appreciation, residents paying down your mortgage to build equity and tax benefits. I would work with a team that has years of experience to minimize the risk of your investment. I'd be happy to connect if you have questions. @Joseph Z.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    4y

    @Joseph Z.

    If I had to start all over again, I'd look to acquire a 2-4 unit property with an FHA low-down payment mortgage.

    Getting it under market value would be a bonus.

    So, would using an FHA 203k renovation loan, which would allow me to buy something unqualified for a standard mortgage, which would weed out a lot of competition and push the price lower.

    Hopefully, I would increase the value of the property in 1-2 years and be able to refi out of the FHA mortgage. I'd also learn a lot about maintenance and managing tenants.

    Then, with my hands-on experience, I could decide if I wanted to repeat the process or target 5+ units - which my experience would help with lenders.

    Good luck with whatever you decide to do!

  • Member since 2021 · 4 posts · 3 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Michael Glunk:

    @Joseph Z. First of all, congratulations on starting your real estate investment journey! 

    I agree with @Luka Milicevic and @Jim Pellerin and others...You need to first determine what you want. i.e. What is your goal? And it can't be as broad as to make money. It needs to be specific. I've been a real estate investor for over 17 years and my goal(s) have definitely changed over time. But I always have a goal that I am shooting for. 

    I am also a real estate agent in Colorado and I see this a lot with my investor clients. They say they want an investment property but they don't know what they want. They just know they like the idea of it, but don't know what else to do or where to start. So this aspect is where I add value in helping them uncover their goal(s). But without a goal, it's hard for anyone to answer your question and provide solid value. 


    The cliff notes approach to this is to start by asking yourself, what am I looking to achieve? And then to continue asking yourself questions until you get down to something very specific. e.g. Keep asking yourself "What would I need to do/make true to achieve that result?". Let's say the answer to that initial question is monthly cash flow. So how much cash flow do you need to make per property or per door to feel it's a good investment for your situation? Is that desired cashflow specific to a particular property value or value range? Or are you also looking for a certain cash on cash return? If so what type of cash on cash return? Because of course you could pay cash for a property and of course it will/should cashflow if you pay cash, but is that the best use of your money? That's your call, but many like to use leverage so they can accumulate more. So what's the balance of cash on cash to cashflow that you are looking to achieve? Is there a price range you feel most comfortable in? You mentioned you are not very risk tolerant. So maybe you want a property that isn't that expense because to you it feels less risking. 

    So you see one example, many questions (of which the above isn't all of them and is just one individual scenario that could branch in many different ways), but I hope you get the point. 


    But when you know the answer to that question, you then have a focus. You then have something to go and hunt for. And you have something for others to hunt for. e.g. If you tell a realtor, I'm looking in a max $500,000 price range. I only want a long term rental. I'm going to use a property manager. I want a minimum of at least 10% cash on cash. And or a minimum of 10% cash on cash but if the property is a cheaper property I want to at least cash flow $200+ per door. That's something tangible. That's something that someone can help you find. 

    The answer could vary again based on different scenarios. The answer could be a single family home that you rent. It could be a small multifamily that you rent or that you live in one side and rent out the other(s). Or it could be a property that you house hack. (Of course if you have a preference here that helps narrow things even further.) But having a goal(s) at least gives a specific enough request to which someone can help find solutions. 

    Make sense?

    Hope that helps. Happy to chat more. Hey, you're on here so that's a start. Starting and taking action is step one. So congratulations on that!

    thanks for this reply there's a lot of knowledge in it.

    I want to start with one property as a solid investment have positive cash flow and learn the business of REI while having my own property, and then figure out what I want to do next.
    I saw some answering me here that I should invest in passive income, that's not my goal, my goal is to learn more about REI while doing it small scale and then grew with the experience, i have time to learn as i'm not a very busy person.

  • Wale LawalBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Houston | Dallas | Austin, TX · Member since 2018 · 5k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    4y

    @Joseph Z.

    Get in touch with a local Investor-Agent as they can help shorten your learning curve and save you a lot of headaches as they tend to understand the market better.

    Investing long distance requires specific attention to various factors like understanding the local market, cap rates, rents and other critical information.

    Do market analysis on current rents, potential rents, appreciation, etc.

    You need a team of local professionals like property managers, contractors, agents etc.

    Dos and Don'ts
    Buy in an area with some similarities to the area where you live, such as climate, demographics, or property age so that you have some idea of what you're dealing with.

    Don't buy a high-risk property. Buy in a primarily owner-occupied neighborhood to attract tenants who are a lower economic risk. A high-quality property will typically have less maintenance and upkeep, he notes. "These properties also rent more quickly, as they usually have modern layouts and an adequate count of bedrooms and bathrooms."

    Finally, as mentioned earlier, it's crucial to build a great network of professionals to help you and to occasionally visit your property yourself.

    All the best!

  • Real Estate Agent · Member since 2019 · 569 posts · 257 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Joseph Z.:

    hey all
    I'm living in NYC, 
    I want to go into real estate, not sure yet if I would want to do house hacking or cash flow investment, or both.
    I have over 250k cash ready to invest, would want to hear from the professionals about which way and path I should choose, should I try to invest in my area (NYC isn't cheap) or should I start out of state?
    I'm not very risk-tolerant.
    would love to talk to someone who is in the business for a while and wants to help.
    Best


     Are you looking for long term growth or short term capital revenue to grow quickly? I prefer Florida over new York solely for their tax rules, less crime and chances of shut downs are unlikely if we run into another pandemic. You could buy more properties out of state and statically beach air bnb are the #1 choices for renters that go vacation an area. 

  • Member since 2021 · 4 posts · 3 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Ricardo Hidalgo:
    Quote from @Joseph Z.:

    hey all
    I'm living in NYC, 
    I want to go into real estate, not sure yet if I would want to do house hacking or cash flow investment, or both.
    I have over 250k cash ready to invest, would want to hear from the professionals about which way and path I should choose, should I try to invest in my area (NYC isn't cheap) or should I start out of state?
    I'm not very risk-tolerant.
    would love to talk to someone who is in the business for a while and wants to help.
    Best


     Are you looking for long term growth or short term capital revenue to grow quickly? I prefer Florida over new York solely for their tax rules, less crime and chances of shut downs are unlikely if we run into another pandemic. You could buy more properties out of state and statically beach air bnb are the #1 choices for renters that go vacation an area. 


     i think FL is too high right now, i wany a long term growth, i don't need the money right now.

  • Real Estate Agent · Member since 2019 · 569 posts · 257 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Joseph Z.:
    Quote from @Ricardo Hidalgo:
    Quote from @Joseph Z.:

    hey all
    I'm living in NYC, 
    I want to go into real estate, not sure yet if I would want to do house hacking or cash flow investment, or both.
    I have over 250k cash ready to invest, would want to hear from the professionals about which way and path I should choose, should I try to invest in my area (NYC isn't cheap) or should I start out of state?
    I'm not very risk-tolerant.
    would love to talk to someone who is in the business for a while and wants to help.
    Best


     Are you looking for long term growth or short term capital revenue to grow quickly? I prefer Florida over new York solely for their tax rules, less crime and chances of shut downs are unlikely if we run into another pandemic. You could buy more properties out of state and statically beach air bnb are the #1 choices for renters that go vacation an area. 


     i think FL is too high right now, i wany a long term growth, i don't need the money right now.


     Look into the panhandle of Florida and the infrastructure being invested by the state. I think it will change your mind. We have more land the properties in some markets. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Centreville, VA · Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 799 votes
    4y

    Hi Joseph, I started with out of state turnkey investing back in 2020 and needed 20k in down payments to buy SFH that were cash flowing. I would love to chat with you and add value if I can

  • Real Estate Broker · New York, NY · Member since 2020 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4y

    Hey @Joseph Z. - lots of different advice in this forum. My name is Mohammed, I'm a realtor and investor based in NYC. 

    If you're not risk-tolerant, I don't recommend investing out of state. Sure, real estate investing is 'passive' but it still involves using your time and mental headspace to solve issues that pop up with any rented out property. My advice would be to look into properties that are within a few hours drive of NYC if you're wanting most bang for your buck (Albany has good returns). 

    You have a solid downpayment amount and could use that for a multifamily in NYC itself to househack and appreciate in value. There are multiple ways you can get into real estate, and the answer isn't going to be on BiggerPockets - you have to do your research and decide which route is the best for you. 

    Drop me a DM if you're serious, happy to chat and point you in the right direction, thanks. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Albany, NY · Member since 2017 · 309 posts · 149 votes
    4y

    Hi @Joseph Z. I am a realtor in the Albany, NY area. I would love to share some info with you about our market up here. I'll send you a DM

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH · Member since 2013 · 31k+ posts · 20k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Joseph Z.:

    hey all
    I'm living in NYC, 
    I want to go into real estate, not sure yet if I would want to do house hacking or cash flow investment, or both.
    I have over 250k cash ready to invest, would want to hear from the professionals about which way and path I should choose, should I try to invest in my area (NYC isn't cheap) or should I start out of state?
    I'm not very risk-tolerant.
    would love to talk to someone who is in the business for a while and wants to help.
    Best

     If you do go out of state, you'll want to follow this punch list. I like to give that out to new out of state investors whenever I can. Out of state investing is a tough nut to crack. If you do it well, it's awesome, but it's very easy to get tripped up on. If you follow the punch list below, you'll greatly limit your risks.

    • Don't buy in the roughest neighborhood in the urban core. Pick a solid B-Class suburban area.
    • Always hire a 3rd party property inspector to give you an unbiased feel for the home. The reports are 40-90 pages long and go through the entire house in great detail.
    • Get an appraisal. If your using financing the bank requires this. This is good. The bank isn't going to let you blow their money. They have more skin in the game then you do.
    • Make sure you get clear title. If using a lender this is a non issue. They will make you do this. It's those maniacs that buy homes cash via quit claim deed off of craigslist that really get screwed.
    • Make sure your property manager is a licensed real estate brokerage.
    • Google Clayton Morris and/or Morris Invest for a cautionary tale of what not to do when buying turnkey real estate
    • Understand you can not eliminate all risk, only mitigate it. If you are risk averse, real estate, (especially out of state) is not for you.
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.