To many Decisions! Continue Investing in a Higher Priced Market?

To many Decisions! Continue Investing in a Higher Priced Market?

Investor · New York & Vermont · Member since 2022 · 10 posts · 4 votes

Good Morning Bigger Pockets Community! 

I believe the old saying when it rains it pours is true, but not always a bad thing. Sometimes its a storm of options that you receive after your certain you have chosen the right path. Here's the situation and I would definitely appreciate any feedback you have!


Currently we own one rental property townhouse in the Capital Region of New York, soon after purchase (Less then 6 Months) we were contacted by the owner of the other half of the two townhouse structure asking if we wanted to purchase it at the same price as the one we had already bought (the person owned both halves originally). Graciously we agreed and drafted a letter of intent which is currently on file and bound by a $1k Deposit. The total purchase price is $269,000 of a Two Bedroom-Two Bath with a full basement identical to the one we already own. Rent in the area for like units is in the neighborhood of between $2,000-$2,500 If we are to purchase the other half of the building I believe there are numerous options we could implement to make the building cashflow. For starters; 


-I would like to attempt to merge the lots together since the building shares a wall and attempt to reclassify it as a multifamily rather then two stand alone single families, if possible. Hoping to both identify the property as a single entity and to drop some of the taxes.  

-In addition to merging (or separate from merging the properties) we plan to finish the basement of both properties into One Bedroom-One Bath apartments. This should increase the value and cashflow with the ability to sustain an additional tenant, the area is already zoned for Multi-Family use.


There other option I am weighing which is slightly less favorable due to the connections we have already made and the image of faulting on a Letter of Intent this early in our investing career is to cancel the agreement and invest the money into a different market which exists in Vermont. There are numerous incentives to buy properties and grants available for properties needing repair due to the current housing scarcity in the state. Between Zillow and Mailed out flyers we have been in contact with numerous single and multifamily properties for less then $100,000 renting in the range of $1250-$1500 as long as it has a cleared Occupancy statement from the City. 

Therefore we are on the having the argument of Cashflow vs. Equity, New York will yield more equity and will eventually return additional funds for investment over time, but Vermont will be able to Cashflow sooner with the ability to increase equity through repair, but it may be several years before it reaches the value of the New York property if ever. Currently I am hoping to be able to purchase the New York property and still be able to enter the Vermont market later in the year, but I do not want to over leverage or miss an opportunity. Any feedback would be a huge help and honestly just typing this out helped a fair amount!

Thank you in advance,

-Ryan B.  

0Reply
46 views

Most Popular Reply

Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
Moderator
Real Estate Broker · Cody, WY · Member since 2010 · 28k+ posts · 41k+ votes
4y
Quote from @Ryan Blanchard:

Have you spoken with Planning and Zoning to confirm you can convert each unit into a duplex?

I don't think you'll add any value by combining the two lots into one. People usually do the opposite: buy four townhomes as one purchase, then sell them off individually for a profit.

The DIY Landlord Book4.7245 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

12 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Cody, WY · Member since 2010 · 28k+ posts · 41k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Ryan Blanchard:

    Have you spoken with Planning and Zoning to confirm you can convert each unit into a duplex?

    I don't think you'll add any value by combining the two lots into one. People usually do the opposite: buy four townhomes as one purchase, then sell them off individually for a profit.

    The DIY Landlord Book4.7245 Reviews
  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    4y

    Two questions on the NY property:

    1 - Will it cash flow at purchase?  Based on what you've written, I'm guessing "no".
    2 - Assuming the answer to Q #1 is "no", what happens if the NY property stabilizes, and doesn't appreciate the way you are speculating?

    ...OK, I have a 3rd question,

    3 - Why did you put any deposit money down on your LOI if the seller came to you first?...unless that $1k you put up guarantees the LOI wasn't written in invisible ink.

  • Investor · New York & Vermont · Member since 2022 · 10 posts · 4 votes
    4y

    @Nathan Gesner Thank you for the reply! I have reached out to the Zoning and Permitting office and have received confirmation to convert the first half which we already own into a Duplex. The other half would be an exact copy of the first since they are mirrored units. Which I realize doesn't guarantee acceptance, I am hoping that it means we have a higher likelihood of the plans going through. I agree that its atypical, but I am hoping to hold the properties for an extended period and want to minimize regional expenses like separate taxes on the properties. Seems like this would not be as beneficial though as I first estimated. 

  • Investor · New York & Vermont · Member since 2022 · 10 posts · 4 votes
    4y

    @Joe Villeneuve Thank you for the reply! Currently the property is leased with a tenant that would breakeven based on the amount we are currently paying on the first half of the property and the pre-approval already received. This tenant has been in place for 5 years and is paying under market average. Therefore as long as the property pays for itself and has a consistent rental history I am not worried in regards to immediate cashflow. To answer question 2, I am attempting to keep away from speculating increases in value on the New York properties, because I do think we would be purchasing on the top side of this market currently. If the New York Property stabilizes then we will continue to use the rental income to sustain the property and attempt to plan the next move. The LOI guarantee was more of mutual stipulation to keep the house from going onto the open market. The owner owns several houses and between inexperience in conducting deals and the hopes of attempting to acquire more from them I made a questionable move, but it will be taken from the final sales price once we proceed towards closing.

  • I​nvestor & Agent · Tulsa, OK · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4y

    Man, those Vermont numbers sound amazing. I don’t have an eloquent breakdown at the moment but if the numbers you stated are true, I’d lean towards that market, personally, if I was in your shoes. 

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Ryan Blanchard:

    @Joe Villeneuve Thank you for the reply! Currently the property is leased with a tenant that would breakeven based on the amount we are currently paying on the first half of the property and the pre-approval already received. This tenant has been in place for 5 years and is paying under market average. Therefore as long as the property pays for itself and has a consistent rental history I am not worried in regards to immediate cashflow. To answer question 2, I am attempting to keep away from speculating increases in value on the New York properties, because I do think we would be purchasing on the top side of this market currently. If the New York Property stabilizes then we will continue to use the rental income to sustain the property and attempt to plan the next move. The LOI guarantee was more of mutual stipulation to keep the house from going onto the open market. The owner owns several houses and between inexperience in conducting deals and the hopes of attempting to acquire more from them I made a questionable move, but it will be taken from the final sales price once we proceed towards closing.

    The NY property sounds like a dud.  No CF and speculation on equity increases.  By the way, breaking even is negative CF waiting to happen.  How much cash would you have in the deal if you went ahead with it?
    CF has one role when you buy a property...to recover your cost ASAP.  My goal is within 5 years.  If you have no, or negative CF, that means you lost money because you have no way of recovering your cost...and equity doesn't count in cost recovery.  Equity doesn't really exist until you turn it into cash.  It's an imaginary number, a very important one, but still a virtual number.  Equity is your real profit, when you access it through the sale of the property. 
    Ask yourself this question:  If you think it's OK to accept "breakeven" or negative CF on properties with the hope of appreciation adding equity to it down the road, how many of these properties can you own before you go broke?  Also, a NCF property stealing CF from a PCF one, doesn't solve the problem.  Would you work a second job, and pay your employer to do that, then justify it because you make enough on your main job to cover it?
  • Investor · New York & Vermont · Member since 2022 · 10 posts · 4 votes
    4y

    @Nate Sanow Agreed, the Vermont Market is nice on money conversation in some of there more densely populated areas, but the cost of repair and age of homes makes it a hard sell. I appreciate the reply!

  • Investor · New York & Vermont · Member since 2022 · 10 posts · 4 votes
    4y

    @Joe Villeneuve You make an incredible point, I am not intending to borrow from the already owned property, but I see your point in that there's going to be a greater period to recoup if that's ever possible. Would you consider attempting to pickup the property through a formal listing? I.e. dissolve the LOI and attempt to purchase through traditional method once it hits the housing market. I appreciate the additional point of view, I would be in around $25k at time of purchase, I am definitely rethinking this move though based on the points you make. Great analogy by the way! definitely helpful in showing the difference.

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    4y

    I don't see how you would have a better financial situation if your waited...probably even worse.  I see this NY property as a dud, with no redeeming value at all.  Look at it this way, if you put $25k in cash (your cost) into this deal, and have no way of getting that money back, meaning your "spent" it, how much profit did you lose by not having it available to "use" (meaning you get it back) over and over again, on profitable properties?

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Nathan Gesner:
    Quote from @Ryan Blanchard:

    Have you spoken with Planning and Zoning to confirm you can convert each unit into a duplex?

    I don't think you'll add any value by combining the two lots into one. People usually do the opposite: buy four townhomes as one purchase, then sell them off individually for a profit.

    Right.  Splitting is usually the preferred way...not combining.  This is like turning a 3 bedroom house into a 2 bedroom.  Sure, one of the bedrooms is larger, but 3 bedrooms are always more valuable.
  • Member since 2022 · 3 posts · 1 vote
    4y

    Hey Ryan, 

    Something I would like to add to what joe is saying is if you’re breaking even on the rent which I’m going to assume you mean it’s covering the mortgage and just that correct?. So say the mortgage is 2k a month it’s bringing in exactly 2k ish. Well if that’s the case from my understand and if I’m mistaken someone please correct me but the only tax break you get on that “loss” is interest not principal payments for the mortgage, so all the income that’s going towards your principal payment is still being taxed as your income. So you are not breaking even unless that’s already factored in to what you collect in rent.

    Also cash flow is king my friend, if you’re not cash flowing on anything and have no extra equity to draw from “ which a bank won’t give you a refi without cash flow anyways” how will you build your real estate portfolio?

    Something I’ve learned to keep in mind is to treat my property cash flow like an annuity or mutual fund because if you do you will always be able to hold that property almost no matter what happens..  So If I can not make 6-20+% a year on my cash input part of the invest after expenses I’d rather not touch it. It has to make money to cover repairs and pay me… and incase that confuses someone by what I’m saying, what I mean is if I put $20,000 in an investment between down payment and fees I’d want to see Atleast $1,200 - $4,000 in pure profit after mortgage, management, expenses etc etc .. They are out there, I have one currently that makes 20% it’s total purchase price a year in rent. And another that should be doing about 20 - 30% profit after a small Reno I did to up the rent, I’ll know for sure when I get some tenants in it later this month. I had 3 but just sold one due to me wanting to get into bigger property’s.

    Hope this helps! 

  • Investor · New York & Vermont · Member since 2022 · 10 posts · 4 votes
    4y

    Update*  Thank you for all of the honest and informative feedback everyone! We have decided to dissolve the deal for the home in New York and start focusing on better properties in the VT Market that have a potential for immediate return on investment. Rather then trying to predict equity gain, all of the feedback is appreciated and without a doubt helped to get us to what we consider the right decision. 

    Thank you,

    -Ryan B.
     

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.