Wholesale. Fix n Flip, or Buy & Hold... What Would You Do?

Wholesale. Fix n Flip, or Buy & Hold... What Would You Do?

Investor · Valdosta, GA · Member since 2015 · 187 posts · 112 votes

Hi! I'm a newbie investor and just spoke with my first lead from a yellow letter campaign.

The property is a 3bd/2ba brick house, 2035 sq ft including the attached 2 car garage. It has a 3 acre yard but sits on 24 acres altogether. The seller - who lives in the Florida Keys - is protector of her father's estate; he has dementia.

Seller had the trees on the undeveloped 21 acres appraised and a local lumber company offered $30K for them. She included that info as she described the property's features, which include a stocked fishing pond on the land and plenty game for hunting.

She also detailed repairs that the house would need, which I've roughly estimated to be around $43K. I used to work at Lowe's so I remember the cost of several materials & appliances. The rest is conservative estimates for labor.

I'll be following up with the seller this week. During our first conversation, she told me that there's mold in the crawlspace under the house. She said she'd ordered a test kit to see if it was black mold or not. We're waiting on those results because it will make a big difference if the house has black mold.

The $43K repair estimate does NOT include black mold removal if the test comes back positive for black mold.

She said she had the property appraised as-is at $252K. I'm thinking it's value is more around $215K based on average home values per sq. ft in my small town & similar properties sold recently. I haven't gotten any precise comps from a realtor yet.

My main question with this post is what would you do with this property: wholesale, fix n flip, or buy & hold?

My second question is, how do I approach a property attached to such a large plot of land? It has a 3 acre lawn and another surrounding 21 acres (currently used for hunting and fishing). Would you try to get it all under contract or just the house & 3 acre lawn? 

Any and all input is welcome. :)

0Reply
42 views

Most Popular Reply

Interior Decorator · Costa Mesa, CA · Member since 2015 · 76 posts · 35 votes
11y

Hi Nikki,

It all depends on how you are financially.  Usually when you fix and flip or wholesale a property is because the investor is trying to build up capital in order to buy and hold.  

It looks like you did your homework on the property, and you answered your own question that you feel it may be a great long term investment.  If the property generates possitive cash flow after (1) mortgate, (2) property taxes, (3) vacancy's, (4) insurance, (5) repair costs, (6) water & gas bill, and (7) any other unforseen cost, then I would buy and hold.

When I mention repair cost, I am talking major future repairs suchas, roof replacement, driveways etc.

It is a good investment if you can generate at least $100 a month after all your fixed costs.

Hope that answers your question.

Melissa

See this reply in the discussion

4 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Texas/Colorado · Member since 2014 · 72 posts · 36 votes
    11y

    @Nikki Robinson 

    I am a new investor as well so my advice comes far more from life experience than re experice. Two question...first, what price is she looking for? Second, what do you think the fixed up value of the house will be? The rule of thumb is buy the property at 70% of after repaire value so let's say the after repair value is $295k. That would equal an ARV of $206k ($295k x 70%) minus repair cost of $43k = $163,500 but you still have to minus holding cost (varies but let's say $7k) and selling cost (17,700 - 6% realtor fee) = $139,500. You still need to subtract closing cost but I am not sure what those look like I'm GA. The value of the trees doesn't matter unless you plan on cutting them down. The question is can you get the property for less than $139,500? I am guessing no since the owner is having appraisals done on the property. I would guess she is looking for too dollar. I would offer her $130k and let her know that number will need to be reduced if black mold is discovered. Hope this helps. Let me know I how it goes and good luck.

  • Interior Decorator · Costa Mesa, CA · Member since 2015 · 76 posts · 35 votes
    11y
    Originally posted by @Carey Edmund:

    @Nikki Robinson 

    I am a new investor as well so my advice comes far more from life experience than re experice. Two question...first, what price is she looking for? Second, what do you think the fixed up value of the house will be? The rule of thumb is buy the property at 70% of after repaire value so let's say the after repair value is $295k. That would equal an ARV of $206k ($295k x 70%) minus repair cost of $43k = $163,500 but you still have to minus holding cost (varies but let's say $7k) and selling cost (17,700 - 6% realtor fee) = $139,500. You still need to subtract closing cost but I am not sure what those look like I'm GA. The value of the trees doesn't matter unless you plan on cutting them down. The question is can you get the property for less than $139,500? I am guessing no since the owner is having appraisals done on the property. I would guess she is looking for too dollar. I would offer her $130k and let her know that number will need to be reduced if black mold is discovered. Hope this helps. Let me know I how it goes and good luck.

  • Investor · Valdosta, GA · Member since 2015 · 187 posts · 112 votes
    11y

    @Carey Edmund @Melissa W. 

    Thanks for responding, although I didn't get the kind of answer(s) I was hoping for. I understand how the wholesale deal analysis process works. I was more so hoping to see what other investors thought about the type of property I described. I know some people stick to wholesales only, while others diversify. Under ideal conditions, I wanted to know whether investors would wholesale, flip or hold onto a property like this - with such a large plot of land, rural area with hunting & fishing on site, the sturdy brick exterior many buyers seek & all.

    As for the numbers, I think the seller is hoping to get close to her stated appraisal value ($252K) but I plan to explain to her that it's out of the question since I am an investor after all (which I stated in the yellow letter). She told me a realtor friend of hers said the property would be hard to sell because of the rural location and the constant sounds of gunfire (hunting). That's why she never listed the property with an agent. But she responded very quickly to the letter and thanked me several times for sending it. That's what leads me to believe she's more motivated to sell than she's trying to appear.

    She pays $300/mo for lawn upkeep (which she let go during these past few winter months) and there's the costs of maintaining a private well and septic tank and stocking the pond on the property. She mentioned all of that right before telling me that there's no income coming into her father's estate. So those expenses are all coming right out of her pocket.

    That's all on top of delinquent property taxes. That's the list I'm mailing out to.

    Also, the whole house needs new carpet, new appliances, a chimney repair, a few electrical switch replacements and new drywall on one side of the kitchen. The shed in the back also needs to be repaired/removed and replaced.

    With all the improvements, I'm estimating the house value to be around $275K (conservatively).

    As I mentioned before, I believe her appraisal value is inflated, based on the avg. house value per square foot in this city and based on recently sold houses with similar features. Also based on the tax assessor's valuation of the house.

    I think the house's value right now is really somewhere around $215K.

    Either way (wholesale, fix n flip or buy & hold), I wouldn't want to go over $140K to get it under contract.

    Starting with a $130K offer (pending the mold test results) sounds good.

  • Interior Decorator · Costa Mesa, CA · Member since 2015 · 76 posts · 35 votes
    11y

    Hi Nikki,

    It all depends on how you are financially.  Usually when you fix and flip or wholesale a property is because the investor is trying to build up capital in order to buy and hold.  

    It looks like you did your homework on the property, and you answered your own question that you feel it may be a great long term investment.  If the property generates possitive cash flow after (1) mortgate, (2) property taxes, (3) vacancy's, (4) insurance, (5) repair costs, (6) water & gas bill, and (7) any other unforseen cost, then I would buy and hold.

    When I mention repair cost, I am talking major future repairs suchas, roof replacement, driveways etc.

    It is a good investment if you can generate at least $100 a month after all your fixed costs.

    Hope that answers your question.

    Melissa

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.