San Diego, CA · Member since 2017 · 38 posts · 11 votes
I live in San Diego, CA and have been looking for options locally but the numbers aren't adding up to my planned budget. I have been looking out of state at cheaper multifamily homes and those seem to bring the cash flow I am looking for. If you were starting out would you try to invest out of state, and if so what are some things to look for?
@Brandon Vannier I have been investing out of state for close to 15 years (full disclosure I do it for a living and assist others). I live in OC CA now, SF Bay before, and in Europe before that. I started investing in 2002 While living in Europe (talk about "out-of-state" :-) )
The way I go about it - first myself: What's my budget
Will I be using cash, cash + a mortgage, etc.
I'd list down my top/main concerns
Second, I like to look at metros that are:
1.5MM and up population
Growing metros in jobs and population
Multiple industries present in the metro (diversification)
Rent-purchase price +/- 1%/per month (a $150k house should rent between $1350 to $1500/ mo)
Once I find that metro start looking at houses BUT first make sure I know how to fully evaluate and financially analyze property.
@Brandon Vannier I have been investing out of state for close to 15 years (full disclosure I do it for a living and assist others). I live in OC CA now, SF Bay before, and in Europe before that. I started investing in 2002 While living in Europe (talk about "out-of-state" :-) )
The way I go about it - first myself: What's my budget
Will I be using cash, cash + a mortgage, etc.
I'd list down my top/main concerns
Second, I like to look at metros that are:
1.5MM and up population
Growing metros in jobs and population
Multiple industries present in the metro (diversification)
Rent-purchase price +/- 1%/per month (a $150k house should rent between $1350 to $1500/ mo)
Once I find that metro start looking at houses BUT first make sure I know how to fully evaluate and financially analyze property.
@Brandon Vannier there are many threads on this topic, so with a little searching you can find a wide array of information. I posted a quick down and dirty post to get new investors started, but there is more to be aware of. Check out the post below.
Dani Beit-Or which areas do you invest in? Which ones met your criteria?
Do you fly down for purchases? How challenging is it to run rehabs remotely?
Do you flip or buy and hold?
Sorry for all the questions. I've been thinking about this as well.
Thanks,
Scott
Yes - I invest out of state. Here's what I would look for...
1) A property manager with their own repair crew
2) An "investor friendly" location - I wouldn't invest in states like Massachusetts or Washington that are not investor friendly. I would not invest in states like New Mexico that have a gross receipts tax. I would be cautious about investing in states that have various provisions where you have to jump through hoops to do business (i.e. set up a separate savings account for cleaning deposits).
3) Look out for jurisdictions that have "point of sale" requirements like certain areas of Missouri, Certain areas in Ohio, etc.
Absolutely! As long as you do your due diligence to learn how to evaluate potential properties, identify cities to invest with, identify personnel to handle your property (you can go with a good turn-key company or assemble your own team), learn the basic differences in tax laws for the cities you're considering, identify landlord friendly vs tenant friendly cities, etc. There are a million and one ways to invest in RE; with due diligence and education on the subject any one of them can work for you.
I recommend starting local prior to trying out of state. Most out of state investors are putting a lot of trust in other people.
If you decide to invest out of state Make sure you have a good team that you can trust.
We were fairly experienced when we tried investing out of state. Our first purchase was a duplex in gulf shores on the beach. It was beautiful. The location that is unavailable virtually everywhere in the US. We used STR with property management. Things were as projected for a while. Then the property tax started to rise much faster than the rents would support. Our cash flow was reducing. Then hurricane #1. Our unit survived but would need a lot of repairs. Many units did not survive and current regulations would not allow them to be rebuilt on the beach. We had huge issues getting work done. We had to go there and manage the repairs ourselves as every contractor had too much work. The owners there where were getting the work before absentee owners. Our property just became more desirable as more than 50% needed to be rebuilt with setback from the beach. Now our insurance and property tax rose more than the rents but at least our units had significant paper appreciation. We could exit with a profit if we wanted but we chose not to.
Then hurricane #2. Again our units survived. Again we could not get work completed from afar and had to go there to manage the work. Again insurance rose. However the market depreciated. 2 hurricanes was too much and many owners including ourselves were done. We sold for far below taxed appraised value.
We currently own one out of state property that we will sell likely at next tenant turn over.
Out of state can be challenging. Teams transition. Property management companies change either due to sell or adapting. Building a strong team is step #1 but effort must be exerted maintaining a strong team.
So we currently only invest local and our projected ROI on local property has been far better than our out of state properties (All out of state except one have actual ROI as we have exited the investments).
HI all I live in Ontario so everythign I do is out of state infact out of country..doing your homework is essintial and laning in a spot that the numbers work... once you have a spot gettign a great team on the grond is essintial.. I have had no issues at all and I invest in Ohio and Missorie where the numbers are great... more then willing to share what I have learnt
California REI are commonly investing for Cash Flow out of state due to the high cost in California, and the low cost in other states (like here in MI) for the exact same property. You flip for enough profit from one CA property that covers all cash costs in a MI property. Can't help but CF. Problems start due to CA REI's:
1 - Lack of MI Market knowledge
2 - Lack of Power Team in MI
3 - Distance
4 - Management
5 - ...and more.
This is why I stopped going with the traditional Turn Key model with my CA (and other OoS) Partners. I found that simply turning properties over to them wasn't a good move for all parties involved. Now, I only turn over "part of" the property, and stay on board as managing partner. This solves all the above issues with OoS investing, and solidifies the OoS REI mindset as to the quality of the deal. They know if I'm still a part of it, and I retain the management responsibilities, the property must be good...and they can breath much easier.
"which areas do you invest in? Which ones met your criteria?" These days for rentals: Nashville, Indy, Tampa, Houston, DFW and OKC
"Do you fly down for purchases? How challenging is it to run rehabs remotely?" In close to 15 years I have never needed to fly out to take care of an issue. All was solved over phone/emails/Skype. I do suggest to at least fly out there once before you buy to see the area, houses, and mainly meet the team. I have learned that 85% of the investors we work with and guide (many from the Redmond, Bellevue area BTW) don't fly at all. I personally do fly but not mainly not to look at houses but meet w/ our local teams to help them develop better and find opportunities to provide better investment for our investors.
For the rentals we buy houses that need some make-ready. Meaning simple repairs tasks and not a full reno. All the property managers we have lined up locally will handle those make-ready w/o a problem.
"Do you flip or buy and hold?"
Both. About 60% of our activity is rentals and the rest is flips. For flips we do have local contractors and project managers that are able to do a full reno job. We have about 15 flips going right no in Tampa, Chicago and Indianapolis. The smallest reno job is about $30k and largest s about $265k
Finding the right teams and having strong systems, processes and checkpoints is what enables us to work in a large scale and in multiple metros.
We are also interested in investing out of state, we have primarily looked in vacation areas and we haven't actually pulled the trigger yet. We have invested in our metropolitan area as well as other cities in our state as we live in a highly desirable area with a lot of competition.
Finding a good property management company is critical to out-of-town investing. I do agree that an in-house maintenance crew makes getting small repairs done quickly, however, we have also found the repairs tend to be of a poor quality or lazy choices are made... especially when they know you can't easily come and check up on them.
I too live in San Diego. My first OOS investment was in Florida in 2003. It made sense as I am originally from there and have tons of family and people on the ground. I left Florida in 2006 due to the huge increases in insurance from Hurricanes. I 1031'ed that property into a house in the Dallas, TX area.
While there are benefits in having property close by, I can't get the numbers to work locally either. Those that are in SoCal that "CAN" seem to have the time to spend hunting the deals full time. I am currently on Active Duty and do NOT have hours a day to spend going to auctions. Or the the huge cash reserves to buy these places cash. I am interested in what others have to say on "finding deals". Either way...You MUST trust the people working in your behalf. Just because you trust them doesn't mean that you don't follow up/stay on top of them.
@Dani Beit-Or What qualifier do you use to either "Keep" or "Flip" a property? How did you find and screen your team in Tampa? (I am from that area and if the numbers made sense, I would invest there again.)
I won't...been there, done that.... never again...
Even if you are lucky, and end of making $300 a door, how is that going to fund your San Diego living???
It is like trying to find a job in Malaysia and try to save for a retirement in US....
@Dani Beit-Or How hard has it been to find tenants after these flips? I will most likely be looking to buy an older property that needs a little in repairs to get rent worthy then hold for a bit.
I would...if you were confident in the following:
1. Property manager
2. Property
3. Location
And all aspects of such. Aka, one must know what they have, where they have it, and who is making sure it works.
I have not done it for 5+ multi family. Here is the latest multi family 2017 forecast by Marcus Millicap. Half are OOS.
Good luck!
Multifamily Investment Forecast
National Report, 2017
National Multifamily Index (NMI)
Several markets with favorable supply-and-demand balances and momentum in hiring made large moves to ascend to the top spots in the 2017 National Multifamily Index (NMI).
Los Angeles advanced 11 places in the Index from one year ago to take the highest position in 2017 behind a forecast for further tightening in vacancy and minimal supply growth. Robust job growth propelled the seven-rung rise of Seattle-Tacoma (#2) and Boston (#3) also executed an advance of seven places on its strong job market.
Minneapolis-St. Paul (#4) is the highest-ranked Midwest metro this year. San Francisco (#7) and San Jose (#8) were downgraded from the top of last year's NMI as their growth cycles mature, and New York City also declined to the last spot in the top 10.
Keeping or flipping is entirely different filter/glasses. A keeper would be something that matched my size, age,area, schools, price, rent, cashflow, and ROI pre-set criteria. The rentals we buy need no to minimal repairs.
In a flip we're looking for the improvement margins. How much can we sell a house after much needed renovations and what would we pay for it to get those margins/ROI.
There is no secret sauce for finding team. It requires time, experience, conversations and vetting. It is easier to line up teams when you have the power of a network w/ many buying investors, that's for sure.
When we flip we don't loom for a tenant but for a homeowner. We have done so many and in different areas. Sometimes we had a buyer the same weekend we listed it and sometimes it took several months. That's one of the things I have found to be the bigger unknown in a flip.
@Dani Beit-Or: SO TRUE! "It is easier to line up teams when you have the power of a network w/ many buying investors".... I was recently having a conversation with another investor. We talked about how to find people to take you seriously when you don't have the volume of full time investors.
The convo concluded that....You can't. Really unless you find a mentor that will let you do deals "with" them. It will be hard to find those that will take you seriously as an "investor" and not as just another "sucker". Thanks again for your reply Dani!
Do you use a "network" of other investors? I have seen a few out there but they all come across like pyramid scams or an advertisement for the next most expensive conference.
I too live in San Diego. My first OOS investment was in Florida in 2003. It made sense as I am originally from there and have tons of family and people on the ground. I left Florida in 2006 due to the huge increases in insurance from Hurricanes. I 1031'ed that property into a house in the Dallas, TX area.
While there are benefits in having property close by, I can't get the numbers to work locally either. Those that are in SoCal that "CAN" seem to have the time to spend hunting the deals full time. I am currently on Active Duty and do NOT have hours a day to spend going to auctions. Or the the huge cash reserves to buy these places cash. I am interested in what others have to say on "finding deals". Either way...You MUST trust the people working in your behalf. Just because you trust them doesn't mean that you don't follow up/stay on top of them....)
You could have purchased just about any property off the MLS iN San Diego 2 to 5 years ago and if you financed it you would have had a very good ROI. So virtually every property was a deal. The hard part is not finding the properties that will produce a good ROI but realizing that the properties will produce a good ROI.