First Investment Property (SFH w/ questions!)

First Investment Property (SFH w/ questions!)

Investor · Toledo, OH · Member since 2020 · 88 posts · 101 votes

Me: $85k in 401k, $18k cash, $5k liquid investments (Robinhood). Credit score 780. Owe 100k on primary. Started the refi last week and will need $7k ish cash at time of close. ($3.5k or so is escrow which will be refunded.)

Property: Great schools, highly desirable suburb in Northwest Ohio. About 10 minutes from a new Cancer Clinic + a 68 acre development property that is being built currently. While the "city" is staying flat in terms of property values the suburbs have been appreciating. 

Property is a 3/1. This is an area that has almost no rentals so comps are tough. Comps in nearby suburbs have rented for $1,350 but might be high right now due to a "hot" market. Figure $1,100-$1,200 conservatively. 

The home is in pre-foreclosure and is a bit tied up; the mortgage is held by one individual but both he and the ex girlfriend are on the deed. She has not signed the deed over. We (myself and seller) believe that she would be willing to but might need a little coaxing (ie: throw her some cash.) 

The owner who's name is on the mortgage (and 1/2 the title) is willing to transfer the mortgage to me / sell me the property for what he owes. He believes its about $112k. Houses on the street have appraised for around $140k before the market went cuckoo this summer. Identical floor plan home down the street sold for $170k within 5 days of listing. It needs some work + appliances. Walk-thru later this week. 

My questions:

1.) All the podcasts talk about taking out a FHA / Conventional loan, but from what I can tell you cannot rent the property if you go this route. If I assume his mortgage I'm assuming its FHA, which means I wouldn't be able to rent the property. Can someone explain?

2.) The bank may be willing to accept a short sale; however, I would need financing. Since I'm already in the process of a refi on my primary, can I even do this? That is, with both happening simultaneously where might I get hung up?

3.) If this is not a traditional "owner occupied" property, what can I expect to pay in terms of interest on the loan? (I'm running my numbers at 5.2% just to run extremely conservative - but IS it conservative? Or is that more realistic?)

0Reply
59 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Marin County California · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
6y

There are banks that lend on investment properties at somewhat higher interest rates so that you can forego the residency concerns.  I would contact a local mortgage broker who can lay out the different scenarios for you.  You may want to post a referral request in the local Toledo Ohio section of this forum.

See this reply in the discussion

10 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Tyler GibsonBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Orlando, FL · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    @Christopher Abele If you end up assuming the mortgage you should be able to rent it. How long has the current owner had it? FHA requires the borrower to live there for the first 2 years and conventional requires that you live there a year. So if that has already been satisfied and you are assuming the mortgage then you should have no problem.

    On a different point why would you pay him what he owes and take on the mortgage? if you give him $112k and assume the mortgage you are essentially paying $224k for the property. I would offer him less much less. If he is falling behind then you are doing him a favor by saving his credit. If he wants to walk with cash and clean credit then $25k or so would be where I would want to be. If you assume the mortgage then I would look at transferring the property title into a land trust. 

    you can get financing still right now as long as your debt to income is good and credit is good. If you are self-employed it is harder to get financing but you can. Investment loans right now are 20-25% down and interest rates are high 3's low 4's. 

  • Investor · Toledo, OH · Member since 2020 · 88 posts · 101 votes
    6y

    @Tyler Gibson my apologies as that part might not have been clear. 

    The owner is willing to walk from the property. He would "sell me the title for what he owes" and "I assume the mortgage" are one in the same. He is willing to transfer the property to me for what he owes on it, either through transfer of the existing mortgage (which requires bank approval) or I take out a loan and pay off his existing loan. 

    Basically he's willing to hand over the equity he has in the property in exchange for not having his credit destroyed and a foreclosure on record. 

    IF I'm taking over the mortgage and the deed is transferred (quit claim) then the owner has not lived there since purchase. I'm not quite sure how that would all play out on a FHA loan.

  • Tyler GibsonBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Orlando, FL · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    @Shawn G. you have any thoughts on this? 

    @Christopher Abele ok that makes more sense. I was interpreting the scenario incorrectly. If you were to assume the mortgage then yes you would need bank approval but you should get a warranty deed instead of a quitclaim. Also, would the seller do subject to? This would not require the bank to be involved but the mortgage would stay in the seller's name. If he wants the mortgage out of his name it might be easier to get a loan and just buy it outright for the payoff cost if it appraises correctly. 

  • Investor · Toledo, OH · Member since 2020 · 88 posts · 101 votes
    6y

    At the end of the day, he wants to be able to walk from the responsibility of the mortgage.

    Remember, its him and the ex on the deed. He needs to get her off of it first and foremost. That's going to require a third party (me) to come in and say, "I'll give you 'x' to sign it over." That adds an added layer of complication but, at the end of the day, if he's foreclosed on she gets nothing. (She's on the title but not on the mortgage... hence, I don't think he'll want to do seller financing.)

    If I take out a conventional loan for the balance owed, then I'm also paying closing costs on top of repairs. This might be okay because the ARV would still be well under the loan value. Ultimately I think I need to speak with a lender about the options if I take out a loan for the balance; specifically, whether I can rent the property or if I need to live in it for a year.

  • Investor · Marin County California · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    There are banks that lend on investment properties at somewhat higher interest rates so that you can forego the residency concerns.  I would contact a local mortgage broker who can lay out the different scenarios for you.  You may want to post a referral request in the local Toledo Ohio section of this forum.

  • Rental Property Investor · Brooke Park Drive · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    @Stone Jin can probably help he invests in the suburbs

  • Rental Property Investor · Chandler AZ and Sylvania, OH · Member since 2009 · 708 posts · 561 votes
    6y

    @Account Closed thanks for the shout out... kind of :)

    @Christopher Abele

    There is a lot to dissect.  Is the house in a suburb if so which one (we own in South Toledo, Maumee, Sylvania)?  There are sections of Toledo where rentals are scarce.  At 112K plus money for rehab does it cashflow at $1100-$1200?  

    To answer some of your questions.  I'm assuming the seller doesn't have to walk away from the mortgage.  If he just wants to subject to the property then that would be better.  Just pay off the ex and take possession of the home and pay your friends mortgage until you figure out the rest.  You need to find a sales contract and a title agency that knows this type of transaction.

    If seller no longer wants the mortgage. Then I would take out a loan from your 401K for whatever the max allowable is currently. 18K doesn't go very far if you need down payment and rehab. I would talk to a hard money lender or find private money to purchase the property and then rehab. This is basically a BRRR at this point. Run your math.

  • Investor · Toledo, OH · Member since 2020 · 88 posts · 101 votes
    6y

    @Stone Jin - Yes, suburb. Waterville to be exact. 

    I'm meeting with seller tomorrow. He wants done with "it." In this case, I'm presuming "it" to be both mortgage and property. Listening to the owner, his ex (and her family) set him up for failure... He bought the house from them without knowing what he was doing. (Hey, its a nice house, it cost x per month, sign here.) As REIs, we're problem solvers... in his case, the problem includes trust issues, so closure is a good thing. 

    This isn't really one of those "needs a gut" rehab. It needs general maintenance that's been neglected. Porch, storm doors, carpet ripped up, hardwood floors refinished, baseboards, paint, landscaping and appliances (apparently the ex took them with her.) I budgeted $15k loosely based on what I know at this point; that's not firm by any stretch. 


    At $1100 it cashflows but just barely, so its going to be dependent on the numbers I've selected as a complete novice for things like vacancy. Simple math should tell you what it cash flows from there at either $1,200 or $1,350. I mention the $1,350 number based on 3 bed comps of similar size in Maumee, the closest I can find. 

  • Retirement Accounts Attorney · Southfield, MI · Member since 2017 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Stone Jin:

    @Account Closed thanks for the shout out... kind of :)

    @Christopher Abele

    There is a lot to dissect.  Is the house in a suburb if so which one (we own in South Toledo, Maumee, Sylvania)?  There are sections of Toledo where rentals are scarce.  At 112K plus money for rehab does it cashflow at $1100-$1200?  

    To answer some of your questions.  I'm assuming the seller doesn't have to walk away from the mortgage.  If he just wants to subject to the property then that would be better.  Just pay off the ex and take possession of the home and pay your friends mortgage until you figure out the rest.  You need to find a sales contract and a title agency that knows this type of transaction.

    If seller no longer wants the mortgage. Then I would take out a loan from your 401K for whatever the max allowable is currently. 18K doesn't go very far if you need down payment and rehab. I would talk to a hard money lender or find private money to purchase the property and then rehab. This is basically a BRRR at this point. Run your math.

    Here are the general considerations regarding 401k loans.

    401k Participant Loans

    • If your 401k plan allows for 401k participant loans, the maximum loan amount is equal to 50% of the balance up to $50k. The repayment terms for a 401k participant loan are equal monthly/quarterly payments of principal and interest (typically prime plus 1%) over a 5 year term (longer if used to acquire your principal residence).
    • Please note that if you take a full $50,000 and then pay back the loan, you can't take another $50,000 until 12 months after the first loan was fully paid back.
    • Per the loan offset rules that went into effect with the 2018 Tax and Job Act: if you leave your job and the loan is current at the time you leave your job but then the loan goes into default because you left your job, you will have until your tax return deadline (including any timely filed extension) to make the loan current by depositing the outstanding balance into an IRA (and thereby avoid the taxes and penalties that would otherwise apply).



    Please keep in mind the multiple loan rules:

    Under those rules, the sum of the balances of a participant's outstanding 401k loans under a single 401k plan (using the highest outstanding balance of each loan over the last 12 months) can't exceed 50% or $50,000 whichever is less. Thus, if you took a $50,000 loan and paid it back within 6 months, you would need to wait another 6 months before you could take another $50,000 loan.

  • Rental Property Investor · Chandler AZ and Sylvania, OH · Member since 2009 · 708 posts · 561 votes
    6y

    @Christopher Abele I monitor Anthony Wayne school district and have seen basic rentals go from 1400-1600.  If you are going to update the property, you can probably get at the high end of that range with some nice flooring/paint/appliance/fixtures for a 3/1.  The one thing I would say with some level of confidence is that don't price your rent too low.  There are higher quality renters out there.  

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.