First time Investor and home buyer. Looking at Raleigh, Durham

First time Investor and home buyer. Looking at Raleigh, Durham

Member since 2018 · 1 post · 1 vote

I have saved some money over time and i started looking for my first purchase in san diego. It's to expensive and i feel like i would get tied down for a while with the mortgage. Condos Appreciate maybe 4-8% a year. I Found Raleigh and durham area and seems like its been growing and prices are still super low compared to san diego of course.. Im guessing i could buy rent and hold that property for 1 or 2 years and then use the brrr to get another property.. and so on. in san diego i would just sit with a high mortgage and low savings...

my question is :

Would it be a good idea for me to dive in and buy a long distance investment property in the area? What should I learn before diving in and starting this journey. I have been aware of the brrr for a few years now but have never actually done it.

I have read the brr book it was a few years ago. i'm starting from page one again.

    1Reply
    30 views

    Most Popular Reply

    Dan H.Pro Member
    Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    5y

    The idea behind BRRRR is to extract all of your investment to be able to reuse it. I would classify such a BRRRR as highly successful, and maybe ambitious for the first time BRRRR investor, but the goal is to extract all of your investment. Assuming you can qualify for the loans, what is the rationale for not doing the BRRRR local if you can extract all of your investment?

    Here are some thoughts:

    1. A local BRRRR is likely to be lower risk than a long distance BRRRR.
    2. Managing a local property will be lower risk than managing a long distance property.
    3. Expensive markets have low cap rates.  Cheap markets have high cap rates.  The cap rates are set by a fairly efficient free market.  What this implies is that low cap rate markets are expected to be lower risk and/or product higher long-term returns than high cap rate markets.  Conversely low cap rate markets typically have better short term return, but either are perceived to be higher risk or lower long-term return.  Another way to state this is that markets are typically priced appropriately when all factors are considered.
    4. I recommend all newbie RE investors start local.  For you that implies San Diego.  For the investor living in Detroit that means Detroit.  It is due to the above reasons.
    5. The more expensive the property the higher the equity obtained from the BRRRR. For example, if you purchase an RE at $400K, you need it to have a $500K ARV (at 80% LTV) to extract all of your investment (excluding closing costs). You have just created $100K in equity in a single BRRRR. Note if all the numbers are 50% of the San Diego costs, the BRRRR would have resulted in only $50K in equity.
    6. Historically, the appreciation or San Diego has been forgiving for BRRRR that may have been less successful than planned. As of last year, every one of our properties purchased prior to last year has had all of investment extracted. Note, we typically are unable to extract all of our investment on our initial refi, but the appreciation has resulted in continued equity build up in excess of the principle paydown. We took advantage of the low interest rates to extract out excess equity.
    7. Historically San Diego has been one of the best markets in the US for long-term buy n hold real estate.  You live in a market that has historically produced outstanding returns yet you are looking at another market.

    Good luck

    See this reply in the discussion

    10 Replies

    Jump to latestLatest
    • Jonathan GreeneBusiness Member
      Real Estate Consultant · Madison, NJ · Member since 2016 · 6k+ posts · 7k+ votes
      5y

      Get in touch with @Abiy Birhanu. He lives in NJ and is flipping a house in Durham right now. He may be able to assist.

    • Dan H.Pro Member
      Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
      5y

      The idea behind BRRRR is to extract all of your investment to be able to reuse it. I would classify such a BRRRR as highly successful, and maybe ambitious for the first time BRRRR investor, but the goal is to extract all of your investment. Assuming you can qualify for the loans, what is the rationale for not doing the BRRRR local if you can extract all of your investment?

      Here are some thoughts:

      1. A local BRRRR is likely to be lower risk than a long distance BRRRR.
      2. Managing a local property will be lower risk than managing a long distance property.
      3. Expensive markets have low cap rates.  Cheap markets have high cap rates.  The cap rates are set by a fairly efficient free market.  What this implies is that low cap rate markets are expected to be lower risk and/or product higher long-term returns than high cap rate markets.  Conversely low cap rate markets typically have better short term return, but either are perceived to be higher risk or lower long-term return.  Another way to state this is that markets are typically priced appropriately when all factors are considered.
      4. I recommend all newbie RE investors start local.  For you that implies San Diego.  For the investor living in Detroit that means Detroit.  It is due to the above reasons.
      5. The more expensive the property the higher the equity obtained from the BRRRR. For example, if you purchase an RE at $400K, you need it to have a $500K ARV (at 80% LTV) to extract all of your investment (excluding closing costs). You have just created $100K in equity in a single BRRRR. Note if all the numbers are 50% of the San Diego costs, the BRRRR would have resulted in only $50K in equity.
      6. Historically, the appreciation or San Diego has been forgiving for BRRRR that may have been less successful than planned. As of last year, every one of our properties purchased prior to last year has had all of investment extracted. Note, we typically are unable to extract all of our investment on our initial refi, but the appreciation has resulted in continued equity build up in excess of the principle paydown. We took advantage of the low interest rates to extract out excess equity.
      7. Historically San Diego has been one of the best markets in the US for long-term buy n hold real estate.  You live in a market that has historically produced outstanding returns yet you are looking at another market.

      Good luck

    • Real Estate Agent · San Diego, CA · Member since 2016 · 308 posts · 173 votes
      5y

      @Emmanuel Mendez

      Call me biased but I'd recommend really considering investing locally for your first deal. San Diego's appreciating market will allow you to jump to your next owner occupied home faster than you think. The increasing rental market has and will continue to follow our appreciating housing market. 

      Wait to invest OOS until after you're already reaping the many benefits of an owner occupied home. Little money out of pocket to get started and you're not throwing money away to rent. Principal pay down, appreciation (compounding), & tax savings will add quickly to your net worth. You should also see a great return on your money coming in w/ a little down payment. 

      Lastly, after 2 years you'll have up to $250K ($500K married) capital gains exclusion if you choose to sell for any reason. 

    • Residential Real Estate Broker · San Diego, CA · Member since 2015 · 44 posts · 27 votes
      5y

      Hi Emmanuel,

      I think @DanHeuschele is on target with his comments as always.

      @MaxwellVentura made similar great points.

      Based on my 20 years of being in San Diego real estate full time and investing:

      1. Managing a local property is lower risk than managing a long-distance property. 

      2. Expensive markets have low cap rates. Cheap markets have high cap rates. Markets are typically priced appropriately when all factors are considered. Prime areas of San Diego have low cap rates. If you drive many miles inland north/east, cap rates will go up. But so will risk, as the local demographics and economies are less stable.

      3. I agree all new RE investors should start local – much lower risk. 

      4. Historically San Diego has been one of the best markets in the US for long-term buy and hold real estate investment. Despite Covid, we just had a banner real estate year (appreciation) in San Diego, and are expected to have a repeat performance in 2021.

      I work with people selling property and often see them taking multiple six figures in equity with them from the sale. We have low risk and a corresponding lower cash flow in San Diego. And you may have to look a little harder - but opportunities abound for very solid total return on investment.

      Good luck!

    • Flipper/Rehabber · San Diego, CA · Member since 2016 · 26 posts · 86 votes
      5y

      @Account Closed you should chime in here. 

    • Specialist · Charlotte North Carolina · Member since 2020 · 112 posts · 66 votes
      5y

      @Emmanuel Mendes 

      As someone who was in a similar situation and has experience in CRE sales and management in San Diego, I understand your struggle with investing in your backyard vs out of state. The average home price in San Diego is 700k let say you pick up a condo for around 400k and don't self-manage. You have an HOA which is an uncontrolled cost, high property tax, and give 8-10 percent of gross rent to your pm. And along with the other reoccurring expenses with the property all, it would take is an appliance breaking down, a bad tenant, or a large repair and there goes that year's cashflow.

      You will see large appreciation but will be stuck with the property for a longer period of time. And while the appreciation is great you have to remember you will still see the same percentage return on your property but it will be 12% on 300k vs 700k.  

      It really comes down to what your plans are and the risk tolerance. Are you willing to put in the upfront work of studying the local market, building out a team, and relationships with people in another city? If you are I have some contacts in the area I can connect you with. 

      I was living in San Diego and moved to Charlotte NC so I can leverage my experience and have a more business-friendly climate that will let me make the most of my bottom dollar. Which is a big challenge for first-time investors. If you just want to pick up one property and set it and forget it and not worry about the monthly income coming in then I would suggest staying in a market you understand. If you want to acquire more properties in a shorter amount of time, willing to put in the work. And build a large portfolio in a state that is landlord and business-friendly then go for it. 

    • Specialist · Charlotte North Carolina · Member since 2020 · 112 posts · 66 votes
      5y

      Also, cap rates and GRMs should not be what you are looking for in SFR's. They only apply to larger multifamily properties with multiple income streams and tenants. And while the CA market is great for the appreciation I think it's plain for everyone to see that the market is gear towards larger experienced investors with a good amount of capital to start with. Look at how the rent control is gear toward older properties and has a sunset clause that doesn't affect the large new projects major companies build.

      If a newer mom and pop investor acquires a property that has unforeseen issues or runs into problem tenants you're going to be facing problems that are much more expensive and difficult to solve and will set you back in your overall goals for your portfolio. 

      I still get confused looks or laughs from local investors when I explain some of the hoops you have to jump through back in CA vs NC. 

      I can send you some information on what you should look for in your first investment property and what red flags that people miss and learn the hard way. I've managed 700 units at one point from class A to C properties going all the way to the imperial beach to oceanside. 

      My favorite is when you get a turnkey multifamily with all new tenants that have security deposits that are 2-3x the market rental amount and payments are not timely or you always have problems at the property. Oh, yea, and have fun trying to get them out in a timely manner and replacing them with a new responsible tenant. 

    • Dan H.Pro Member
      Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
      5y
      Originally posted by @Account Closed:

      @Emmanuel Mendes 

      As someone who was in a similar situation and has experience in CRE sales and management in San Diego, I understand your struggle with investing in your backyard vs out of state. The average home price in San Diego is 700k let say you pick up a condo for around 400k and don't self-manage. You have an HOA which is an uncontrolled cost, high property tax, and give 8-10 percent of gross rent to your pm. And along with the other reoccurring expenses with the property all, it would take is an appliance breaking down, a bad tenant, or a large repair and there goes that year's cashflow.

      You will see large appreciation but will be stuck with the property for a longer period of time. And while the appreciation is great you have to remember you will still see the same percentage return on your property but it will be 12% on 300k vs 700k.  

      It really comes down to what your plans are and the risk tolerance. Are you willing to put in the upfront work of studying the local market, building out a team, and relationships with people in another city? If you are I have some contacts in the area I can connect you with. 

      I was living in San Diego and moved to Charlotte NC so I can leverage my experience and have a more business-friendly climate that will let me make the most of my bottom dollar. Which is a big challenge for first-time investors. If you just want to pick up one property and set it and forget it and not worry about the monthly income coming in then I would suggest staying in a market you understand. If you want to acquire more properties in a shorter amount of time, willing to put in the work. And build a large portfolio in a state that is landlord and business-friendly then go for it. 

       There is some truths in your 2 posts but a lot of misinformation. 

      Let's start with the appreciation being the same. Why do you think San Diego RE prices are so much higher than Raleigh or Durham? According to neighborhoodscout San Diego has 160% appreciation since 2000 (a 10 out of 10). Raleigh is 85% (7 of 10 and just over half of San Diego's appreciation). Durham is virtually the same as Raleigh at 86%. So the San Diego appreciation rate has historically been virtually double Durham and Raleigh. this implies 13% on $300k or 25% on $700k but let's do it with more realistic scenario of 80% non OWner Occupied 80% LTV. $60k to produce $7.8k, or $120k to $30k. I know what I would choose.

      Property tax is 1.24% in Durham (I will assume Raleigh is similar).  Average effective property tax in Ca is 0.77%, but the high appreciation cities pull that number down so San Diego likely has a lower rate than 0.77%.  It is highly likely San Diego property tax rate is 0.5% of property value lower than Durham.  

      final item, San Diego has one of the lower missed payment and eviction rates in the country.  North Carolina in 2016-2017 (last year I can find data and one of the highest eviction rates in the nation) had an eviction filing rate of 12.2% (https://www.ncjustice.org/publ...). The state seems to have been significantly worse than Raleigh 5.16% or Durham 3.79% eviction rates (https://evictionlab.org/rankin...).  San Diego historically is below 1%.  In fact, I never remember it exceeding 1% and we have been doing this quite a while including through the Great Recession.  

      I am not sure if your posts intentionally misled.  I provided source for my counter points.  Neighborhoodscout allows anyone (free) to see appreciation rate for this century.  If you want more details, membership is necessary.  Tax rates and eviction rates are easy to find via search engine.  

    • Specialist · Charlotte North Carolina · Member since 2020 · 112 posts · 66 votes
      5y

      The whole point of going into the NC market is because of the growth economically and population-wise. The future economic outlook along with the population growth, explains why investors and businesses are coming to the state. If you look at the past 5 years for the state, you can see the drastic change. The investment properties are not just appreciation plays, and you are leaving out the fact that they cash flow heavily and have a lower barrier to entry suited to newer investors or those looking to add multiple units to their portfolio. Just going by LTV and appreciation is not the whole picture. Year over year for the past trailing five years, they are similar in appreciation and looking toward the future; this will only increase exponentially.

      You are leaving out the additional bonds and other props that drive the current SD tax rate to 1.22982 https://www.sdttc.com/content/ttc/en.html# .

      Info for NC taxes https://www.ncacc.org/193/Property-Tax-Rate

      Also, you are not comparing apples to apples when it comes to eviction rates. Of course, the SD rate will be lower as eviction will always be the last option in that market. The time it takes for notices and prepping the eviction case takes a very long time and will be an uphill battle unless the tenant has seriously messed up (let alone the cost of a lawyer if needed). In reality how many people are giving cash for keys and have missed payments on their rentals and try to get the tenant to vacate the property. People either take the cash for keys or leave the property and write off their security deposit. How many of those occurrences are reported? I would not take the time to go and report that I lost 3k on rent and had a tenant leave the property with the trash left on the inside.

      In NC a 30-day eviction is considered standard and one of the first options on the table. Not the last so the comparison does not work.

    • Dan H.Pro Member
      Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
      5y
      Originally posted by @Account Closed:

      The whole point of going into the NC market is because of the growth economically and population-wise. The future economic outlook along with the population growth, explains why investors and businesses are coming to the state. If you look at the past 5 years for the state, you can see the drastic change. The investment properties are not just appreciation plays, and you are leaving out the fact that they cash flow heavily and have a lower barrier to entry suited to newer investors or those looking to add multiple units to their portfolio. Just going by LTV and appreciation is not the whole picture. Year over year for the past trailing five years, they are similar in appreciation and looking toward the future; this will only increase exponentially.

      You are leaving out the additional bonds and other props that drive the current SD tax rate to 1.22982 https://www.sdttc.com/content/ttc/en.html# .

      Info for NC taxes https://www.ncacc.org/193/Property-Tax-Rate

      Also, you are not comparing apples to apples when it comes to eviction rates. Of course, the SD rate will be lower as eviction will always be the last option in that market. The time it takes for notices and prepping the eviction case takes a very long time and will be an uphill battle unless the tenant has seriously messed up (let alone the cost of a lawyer if needed). In reality how many people are giving cash for keys and have missed payments on their rentals and try to get the tenant to vacate the property. People either take the cash for keys or leave the property and write off their security deposit. How many of those occurrences are reported? I would not take the time to go and report that I lost 3k on rent and had a tenant leave the property with the trash left on the inside.

      In NC a 30-day eviction is considered standard and one of the first options on the table. Not the last so the comparison does not work.

       Your tax rate (and the rate in the link you provided) is not including prop 13.  The average property tax paid in Ca is 0.77% (Google it).  This 0.77% includes local and state bonds.  The high price markets pull this down so average rate in San Diego is likely lower than 0.77%.  The city of San Diego also includes trash service in the property taxes.

      I did not leave out the cash flow, but I was only addressing your mis-statements but seeing you bring it up do you know what the cash flow is on a property purchased in 2000 in San Diego?   Case Shiller has total return for San Diego as 3rd highest in the nation for this century.  It is not solely due to the outstanding property appreciation.  It is due to the cash flow.  A rental market with higher rent appreciation rate will always out cash flow a rental market with lower rent appreciation rate over the long term.   It is simple math.  
       
      I do agree that the low eviction rate is helped by the cumbersome process.  But that does not explain that the missed payment rate is near lowest in the nation.  The reason for both is more due to the housing shortage/low vacancy rate than cumbersome evictions.  We do not accept any tenant that has ever been evicted or has a rent blemish on their credit report.  We have never not collected rent.  My family’s first rental was in the 1970s.  We once had a tenant ask for cash for keys.  We reminded them of the housing shortage and that a rent blemish would make it difficult for them to rent a decent place in San Diego.  They paid.  I am on record locally and on this forum as anti cash for keys.  We will never do it and most of the local LL I know are of a similar mindset.  

      Those that do cash for keys 

      • Reward/encourage undesired behavior
      • Make it difficult for LL who are properly screening tenants from being able to detect a problem tenant. 
      • Increase the odds for all LL to get a tenant that has been rewarded for being a bad tenant and is likely to repeat the behavior they were rewarded for.  

      I suspect Raleigh and Durham are fine markets.   Their entry point is lower, their initial cash flow is likely greater.  I believe RE prices reflect perceived risk and reward over the long term and San Diego’s high price is based on more than 60 years of outstanding long term reward.  In summary, I believe the efficient RE market prices in all variables (initial cash flow, short term and long term rent and property appreciation, payment risk, eviction risk, rental policies, etc.).

      I believe newbies should start local whether that is Raleigh, Durham, Detroit, Cleveland, or San Diego.  After they have a few properties, they are educated enough to potentially justify pursuing other markets.  

    Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.