College Towns: Are we approaching a buying opportunity

College Towns: Are we approaching a buying opportunity

Gregory SchwartzBusiness Member
Rental Property Investor · College Station, TX · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes

For those of you that buy and hold in college towns do you see this fall as...

A. The same old housing market, all the students will be back. Sunshine and rainbows for everyone

B. Buying opportunity. This is the Thursday before Black Friday. Everything is about to be on sale!!

C. College's are never going to bounce back, online education is the way of the future. Sell now and run!

This applies to towns like; College Station, Clemson, Boulder, Anne Arbor, Madison, Chapel Hill, State College, Gainesville, Blacksburg, Charlottesville, Tallahasse, Morgantown, Athens, Tuscaloosa, and the many other towns dominated by student population. 

3Reply
113 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Agent · Clemson, SC · Member since 2015 · 56 posts · 35 votes
6y

I'm in the Clemson market. It was rough trying to get leases from March-Mid May. A lot of large communities were in panic mode and offering huge concessions because leasing came to a screeching stop. Students were hesitant to sign leases due to the uncertainty of on campus classes in the fall. Activity has picked back up, and most places are nearing their normal pre-leased occupancy levels. Depending on the type of property, I think that demand is still present. I know Clemson has notified faculty that they need to be prepared to pivot to online/hybrid classes at any point during the semester. I think if that happens then we might see an uptick in delinquency and THAT could be the thing that tips the scale in favor of buyers. 

See this reply in the discussion

45 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Cambridge, UK · Member since 2020 · 203 posts · 95 votes
    6y

    Hybrid A-B. Some landlords might dump their properties because of fear others won't could be a good buying opportunity but everything will be back to normal after a vaccine (12-18 months, optimistically).

  • Peter TverdovBusiness Member
    Developer · New Brunswick, NJ · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    Rutgers University in New Jersey checking in here. I own a management company that manages nearly 400 students and the school (foolishly IMO) already announced a fall semester that will be online.

    So epicenter of the pandemic, classes online and....

    It has not been horrible. We collected about 97-98% of rents since March. One group packed up and left in the middle of the night, so the owner will have their day in court when they re-open.

    We are getting a few people asking for rent breaks for fall but no one leaving. We have also had people looking for places to live (these kids don't want to be with Mom and Dad while doing online learning).

    The bigger risk is incoming freshman. Those numbers will get hit hard and that might affect off campus rental demand but that's so far away I'm not worrying about it. 

  • Investor · Jacksonville Beach, FL · Member since 2017 · 12 posts · 13 votes
    6y

    We are hoping to move back to Athens and househack (biggest regret is not doing that when we were in college, even looked around 2012ish), so I'm hoping B lol. But so far, everything is flying off the market with multiple offers the first day. If anyone is local and has connections, I'd love to chat!! 

  • Joseph CacciapagliaBusiness Member
    Lender · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    C. I decided to get out of student housing a few years ago, even though I got my start in College Station, TX. There is a looming dip in college aged students, and the push to online education is real. COVID just sped up this process in my opinion. I'm sure some college towns will do great, but many will suffer. 

    One thing I don't hear many people talking about is that there will be a winner take all effect when things move online. In a mostly online world, Harvard could double their enrollment much easier than they could with brick and mortar classes. Those students will have to come from somewhere. I wouldn't expect all the higher end schools to do this, because they want to keep some prestige, but if a large portion of the top schools do, then a lot of the lower end schools could really suffer.

    One thing that I don't think enough people realize is that prices are determined by the marginal buyer. This means that you don't need a huge dip in demand for prices to fall. This applies to both rental rates and property prices. If there are only 5% less students in a given college town over the next year, that could be enough create a race to the bottom for rents. I don't know exactly what number it takes to create that effect, but I don't think it's as high as many people assume.

    Joseph Cacciapaglia powered by Morty
  • Investor · SC NC, VA · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 756 votes
    6y

    The online college education is not new so I don’t know why anyone sees it as a threat.  I took undergrad online classes in 1997, 23 years ago.  I also did online classes in 2000 at GWU, 2004 at Suffolk, and 2005 at Indiana.  Have colleges suffered through declining enrollment?  Has vacancies increased in Washington, Boston, and Bloomington in the last 15 years, no.

  • Tim JacobPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Baltimore, MD · Member since 2016 · 520 posts · 379 votes
    6y
    I have 1 in Baltimore City and have seen no decline. It will be a partial dip that will come back. The university makes money from the students when they live on campus and use campus facilities thus they will want to keep things in person. I still feel far more safe in the student rental market than in the low to mid income family market. There is just a lot of doom and gloom right now.
  • David BarnettPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Cambridge, MA · Member since 2016 · 634 posts · 415 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Mark H. Porter:

    The online college education is not new so I don’t know why anyone sees it as a threat.  I took undergrad online classes in 1997, 23 years ago.  I also did online classes in 2000 at GWU, 2004 at Suffolk, and 2005 at Indiana.  Have colleges suffered through declining enrollment?  Has vacancies increased in Washington, Boston, and Bloomington in the last 15 years, no.

    Although I agree that online education isn't new, COVID is increasing the need to do virtual learning, at least in the near term.  I think we're looking at a different time where there might be more of a shift to more permanent e-learning.  For areas that are reliant on student housing, it could create a big vacuum.  I generally don't watch the news, generally don't put any stock in what they say, and was drawn to a story about rent prices dropping in Boston with a lot of the universities going to e-learning for the fall.  Can landlords in the Boston area afford 4.5 months of potential vacancy if they can't fill their unit in the Fall?  Will students move and/or work on finding an apartment in the cold/snow?  It could be very interesting to see how it all plays out.

  • Rental Property Investor · Plattsburgh, NY · Member since 2020 · 16 posts · 8 votes
    6y

    I’m not sure any of these choices apply.  What some people are forgetting is that there’s so much more to the college experience than just showing up on campus and sitting through a class.  A lot of kids go to college for much more than just sitting in the classroom.  Sports, the social aspect, getting out of mom and dads house, the list goes on.  Non of which can happen with online classes.  Not to mention there’s some things that really can’t realistically be successfully taught online.  Sure some kids will choose online learning, but those are the same kids that are already doing it.  As @Mark H. Porter said, online classes aren’t a new thing.  I’ve spoke with all of my student tenants and not one of them is in favor of distance learning.  We had 100% rent collected for spring semester and are 100% leased for fall/spring this coming school year.  Most of my kids can’t wait to get back to school and want to move in early actually.  Sure things are going to be different for awhile as is everything and maybe it’s still too early to judge but I just don’t see brick and mortar schools going anywhere.  

  • Real Estate Agent · Lexington, KY · Member since 2020 · 13 posts · 6 votes
    6y

    @Jeremy Hart i will clarify. There is good podcast called “borrowed Future” put on by the Ramsey crew.

    We are over 1.5 trillion dollars in student loan debt. The government has federally backed student loans since 1965 making lending 100k to a 17-19 year old (whom can’t buy beer, tobacco, or vote) a low risk loan. It is worse predatory lending then we have seen with the mortgage companies pre- 2008. Some statistics: 1 in every 4 student loans are very late or in default. Every 28 seconds a student loan goes into default. 1 in every 15 student with student loans over 50k have thought about committing suicide bc of their loans. A cabinet member of president johnson (the one who federally funded the loans) has said that they have created a monster. Colleges continue to raise prices because they know students will always be able to be approved for student loans. The process to get one takes about 2-3 minutes (freaking crazy). Finally, the schools are not required to educate or even tell the student the interest rate and many just sign the document that’s presented to them. It’s a very sad, unregulated loan process that we the tax payers will always ensure is paid. That’s the scam he’s referring too.

  • Rental Property Investor · Streetman, TX · Member since 2018 · 528 posts · 495 votes
    6y

    @Gregory Schwartz

    I vote D. Covid is driving a major change in higher education. We will see more people moving to online learning. My future son-in-law is a great example. He is finishing his BS degree 300 miles away from campus. He has plans on doing his graduate degree totally online. The old paradigm of large numbers of student on campus is changing.

    On top of that you need to consider the oversupply of resort style off-campus housing. I have been watching the Baylor and A&M markets. There has been a huge build up of new high end housing. Even before Covid these properties were struggling to keep full. With Covid it will be even worse. Short term Fall 2020 is going to be really tough.

    Last year I bid on several properties near Baylor. Margins were razor thin. One property had lost money two of the last three years. At the sales price I would have been negative as well. That was pre-Covid-19, I can’t imagine how it is today. You might say that there will be potential of in-fill from non-students. The PM I spoke with said there was very little mixing. Basically if you are not rented by the start of Fall classes it will sit empty for the entire year.

    I’m very Bearish on student housing.

  • Real Estate Broker · Portland, OR · Member since 2019 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Gregory Schwartz:

    For those of you that buy and hold in college towns do you see this fall as...

    A. The same old housing market, all the students will be back. Sunshine and rainbows for everyone

    B. Buying opportunity. This is the Thursday before Black Friday. Everything is about to be on sale!!

    C. College's are never going to bounce back, online education is the way of the future. Sell now and run!

    D. Student housing is getting over-built.

    I guess I'd pick C. since D. is temporary.  First, I broker apts and have done ONE student housing deal in 20 years, so not an expert by any stretch.

    In PDX, a lot of the weak-sisters like the for-profit liberal arts colleges are having a real tough time.  

    It's becoming somewhat apparent that all that student debt that gets passed out in exchange for a fill-in-the-blanks studies degree will put you in for 20 years of servitude due to debt payments.

    I don't think college is going away, but I don't know about growth since coding jobs pay well and don't need a degree (I'm an engineer so am NOT slamming the worth of a degree).  Same can be said for trades like welders, electricians, etc.

    Anyways, I think there'll be some depression in student housing enough to make it a reasonable buy, however, you'll be looking at some over-saturation for a while also.

  • Rental Property Investor · Hawthorne, CA · Member since 2018 · 655 posts · 900 votes
    6y

    @Nicholas Urcuioli

    In Bloomington (IU) homes are flying off the shelf. I think the campus housing question is location Specific.

  • Nicholas U.Pro Member
    Member since 2020 · 65 posts · 44 votes
    6y

    @Damaso Bautista 100% agree.  As long as you know the area you are getting into you are good.  A duplex came on the market very late yesterday and already has an accepted offer in my area.  Homes are still flying off the shelf here but to me it is making sure value is still good and long term potential.  In certain areas I will be happy to buy in others closer to campus I am not.  

    To many questions long term for me to justify cost and risk.  

  • Cliff H.Pro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Nashua, NH · Member since 2014 · 610 posts · 486 votes
    6y

    Take one look at a major metro area on a Friday night here in the northeast and you’ll see exactly what’s coming: students are out drinking, eating, and invincible without masks. None of this concerns the average 20something that insurance rates and credit cards for generations have told us have little ability to plan ahead. 

    Schools can’t afford to go 100% online, too much of most university’s income is locked in on campus housing. They don’t want kids gone, but it’s a liability the lawyers tell them they have to plan around. So they create their 47 page plans that no one reads, cut on campus housing for 50% to see what happens, and students come back and ignore everything the schools tell them.

    Are college rental investors really worried about 4-5 months of vacancy? This is one of the highest margin sectors in the industry, if you’re not banking 6-12 months of reserves maybe you’re doing it wrong? 

  • Accountant · Baltimore, MD · Member since 2016 · 74 posts · 29 votes
    6y

    Weighing in as a parent of a 2020 grad and a rising sophomore. Both in Mid-Atlantic area, one mid-sized state flagship in a college town, the other a smallish liberal arts school in a major city. 

    First, I get so tired of reading how a college education is a waste of time and money. Certainly, it can be for those who only want to party and get a useless degree and lousy grades. But my grad has a computer engineering/science degree, and is fully launched with an excellent job and a small student loan. I have no loans for him and he is living with friends in a large city, paying all of his own bills. The sophomore is majoring in comp sci/chem (yes, you can get a useful degree at a liberal arts college!) and I anticipate the same outcome in three years. Years of savings through up markets and down combined with their hard work in high school that earned big scholarships enabled this outcome. No McMansions or luxury cars. It is possible to go to an expensive school and not come out with huge debts.

    I don't see the elite schools in a hurry to water down their brands. Their endowments are enormous, they turn away multiple fully-qualified students for every one that they accept, and parents who can afford it will continue to write checks whatever the cost. Maybe there will be an uptick in gap years for the next year or two, but there is a waiting-list candidate to fill every one of those seats. Schools that are lower-tier are going to be the ones that will need to think about their model and how to keep the revenue flowing.

    As for online learning - I can say for sure that neither of my kids them enjoyed their online learning experience this spring and would not be interested in obtaining a four-year online degree sitting in their bedroom at home. My older son lived in his off-campus house after the school shut down, so he could at least see a few friends and continue to live independently. My younger son had to come home and has spent months seeing almost no one but his father and I. He has taken two online classes this summer to get ahead and does not enjoy it. Given the choice to take a year off or continue in an environment with masks and limited interaction, he is returning to school. We already have a plan for him to move into off-campus housing if the dorms close again so at least he has the independent living aspect of this year.

    Regarding the future of college housing - I follow the FB parents groups for both schools. When everyone was sent home, the state school parents were outraged that they weren't going to get rent forgiveness, and the on-campus students who got refunds were considered the lucky ones. Fast-forward four months and the tide has turned. Many students are going to live in their on-campus housing whether classes are in-person or online. Some parents are actively seeking off-campus housing instead of dorm housing. Because of course, college is more than just classes. It's social, it's clubs, it's learning how to live independently. It's not four years of sitting in your bedroom at your parent's house. We know students who are looking at long-term AirBnB rentals since their dorms will be closed for at least the fall semester.

    So I don't have a vote from the options available. I don't think it's all doom and gloom, but I also don't think it's all sunshine and roses. The under-endowed schools that participated in the nuclear arms races of the 90's and 00's with lazy rivers and luxury rentals may be paying the piper soon due to the smaller Gen-Y population, skyrocketing prices and the effects of COVID. Investors there could get hammered if schools close. But IMO, upper-tier schools are not going away. As in all real estate... location, location, location.

  • Patrick LiskaPro Member
    Investor · Verona, NJ · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 832 votes
    6y

    I own a few student rentals, as everything hit towards end of the school semester, none of my student rentals were rented out for the next year. within the past month I am happy to say I have one unit vacant, all the sudden students wanted to be back at school. the college is opening up and they have and always had online learning. I think what you will see is when things get better with Covid, the schools will slowly drop certain online lessons to bring the kids back to the schools, they have to in order to survive. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Plattsburgh, NY · Member since 2020 · 16 posts · 8 votes
    6y

    @Tracey G. thank you for weighing in as a parent.  That is the exact same opinion I’m hearing from all my students and also their parents.  Not to mention that the majority of off campus housing, at least in my market is thousands less than living on campus. So even the kids that are concerned about their loans and saving money tend to go off campus for that reason also.  College housing imo has always been about location and I believe that will continue to be the case even with smaller scale schools.  The benefits of a college degree go so far beyond the actual classes and that will never be able to be replaced online. Not to mention the quality of the degree won’t be able to be matched imo either.  
    Also, anyone that has some units in a prime location next to a university that is fearful of the market and wants out, please send it my way.  I’m always looking.  

  • Gregory SchwartzBusiness Member
    OP
    Rental Property Investor · College Station, TX · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Tracey G. well put. I completely agree. 

    Just like all other niches within real estate investing it depends on the individual market. UCLA, TX A&M, Harvard, and Easter Carolina Univ are all going to have vastly different results. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Charlottesville, VA · Member since 2016 · 48 posts · 39 votes
    6y

    I've liquidated or my poorly performing assets to have resources for the upcoming slump.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.