New investor in Milwaukee area. In need of help.

New investor in Milwaukee area. In need of help.

Rental Property Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2019 · 11 posts · 4 votes

Hello Everyone,

This is my first time posting. I wanted to feel out this whole BiggerPockets group so I’ve been stalking all of you silently lol. With that being said, I figured there’s no time better than now to ask for some help/guidance. I’ve been plagued by Paralysis by Analysis and when I finally do pull the trigger on a rental property I strike out hard. I’m starting from behind now and need some help pulling myself out of the mud.

I’m looking to buy and hold properties bc like most of you I have Millionaire dreams. Unfortunately my nightmares are taking over my motivation. Ik this isn’t a get rich quick life so I’m here for the long haul but a motivational pick me up is due.

My interest is the Milwaukee area bc of the untapped potential I seen. Please feel free to yell, scream, or politely explain some of the ways you’ve been able to find success around these parts or others.

Best,

Wes

0Reply
76 views

Investor-friendly agents in Milwaukee, WI

See the agents BiggerPockets members work with in Milwaukee, WI.

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2019 · 55 posts · 26 votes
6y

@Kendal West I invest in the Milwaukee area. I would suggest purchasing a "rental ready" property that needs minimal work. Also look into the City owned properties, but you will have to complete the Landlord Training class before placing a bid on those. There are good deals out in Milwaukee, be patient.

See this reply in the discussion

27 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Jonathan GreeneBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Madison, NJ · Member since 2016 · 6k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    6y

    Why have you lost the deals you bid on? What do you think your weakest point right now is? Do you have a trusted agent who understands investors? How many homes have you seen in person? Really, until you have seen at least 25 houses, you haven't even started so don't think you are missing out. You want to be 100 percent on your first deal. You can be scared, but you have to know the deal is a good one. If you are suffering from Analysis Paralysis, it's often not about the deals, but about your confidence. Sometimes, making friends with other young investors at REI events is all you need to feel better.

  • Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2017 · 138 posts · 69 votes
    6y

    Hi @Kendal West - congrats on your first post.  I agree with the things @Jonathan Greene mentioned above from the fear/nightmare perspective.

    As for the analysis paralysis I'd say this - there is so much to know about REI and so much great information available here and elsewhere that it can be easy to fall into that. My advice would be to narrow your focus. Don't analyze a SFR, then a 4 unit, then a 20 unit, etc. Don't try to compare 50 different markets to each other either. Pick one zip code, or one neighborhood and a specific type of property and focus on that for a while. Eventually, you'll may very well branch out to other areas or property types, but for me, having a super narrow focus (SFR with at least 3BR and 1000sq ft in the 53222 zip code) was extremely helpful in getting me to take action on my first property. Once you get comfortable with that, you can move on to the next one which might be a little different, but much easier now that the ball is rolling. Just my 2 cents.

  • Rental Property Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2019 · 11 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    @Jonathan Greene I’ve seen well over 50 properties and have put in offers on 10 or more. I got two accepted offers and both fell through bc the bank wouldn’t finance the properties bc of the work orders. My agent is trustworthy and does whats I think is needed. I don’t want to blame anyone for my failures. I just know I’m doing something wrong and can’t quite put my finger on it.

  • Rental Property Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2019 · 11 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    @Pete Woelfel Thanks a lot for your 2 cents lol. I think I’ve read another one of your post that had the same knowledge behind it. I’ve stuck with that on my last few attempts and it work pretty well. I have seen my focus narrow and gotten past a lot of the BS.

  • Rod HanksBusiness Member
    Insurance Agent · Dallas, TX · Member since 2013 · 743 posts · 462 votes
    6y

    50 properties 10 offers 2 contracts? Wow you are going to burn that agent out really quick. I would suggest instead of looking at all of those properties, analyze them first and only go see the ones that fit your criteria to verify repairs and comps. What a lot of investors do is shoot out tons of low ball offers and only go and look at the ones that counter back at a reasonable price. Good Luck and don't give up!

    Rod Hanks Insurance4.9165 Reviews
  • Rental Property Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2019 · 11 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    @Rod Hanks I agree. That’s what I’ve done with them all. I’ve been at this for over a year.

  • Real Estate Agent · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2020 · 77 posts · 102 votes
    6y

    @Kendal West Hi Kendal,

    Good for you for reaching out for help and also good for you for putting in the legwork you clearly have.

    It sounds like there are a few things going on:

    1. Understand your lender: The properties you are offering on are out of synch with the current bank financing criteria. There are lots of avenues for funding but if you are starting out with the conventional residential products do some deeper research on what lender criteria are at the moment - understand their pain points. These criteria fluctuate with general market conditions and with area so getting clear on their parameters would put you in a stronger position when you offer.

    2. Financial parameters: I would also suggest that you widen your financial scope a bit. When you are first starting out you will be terrified of getting it wrong ( because you're..er..human) you will be wanting to get the best deal but if that means you're offering too low then you won't get in the game at all. Good deals exist within a range and this range will widen and narrow according to market and neighbourhood phases so if your financial model is outside the current market conditions you will be out of synch. 

    3. Narrowing your radius: I agree with @Pete Woelfel that knowing your neighbourhood and your property type is essential but I would suggest you monitor three areas not just one, this will widen your funnel and if your risk tolerance is low as it sounds like it is from the offer acceptance rate you are getting then you may need to have more properties that fit your criteria.

    If you are looking to flip you may be looking for too high a profit margin in your area( within the constraints of your lender profile) and if you are looking to buy and hold or BRRR you may need to switch lender, increase your pool or get a little more flexible with your numbers.

    Hope this helps.

    Best,

    Jed

  • Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    Welcome to BP neighbor!

    If you plan on being a landlord, Milwaukee offers a free landlord training class and it's really good.

    I would not say Milwaukee's potential is untapped. The best deals never make it to the open market. But that's not much different from anywhere else in the country really.

    I'm a penny investor. I buy the crap houses and fix them myself. I enjoy it. I'm working towards buying and building them for other investors. For now, I'm still just fixing them for myself.

    I dunno. You have financing. Maybe buy a duplex or 4-plex and move in? Learn how to be a landlord first, and learn how a building works along the way. Most of the super successful investors don't swing hammers like me. Then again, we all have our ideas about what success is.

    Maybe you will be the next Boulder Guy right??? lol

    Good luck!

  • Rental Property Investor · Oak Creek, WI · Member since 2017 · 26 posts · 7 votes
    6y

    Have you narrowed your scope? 


    Try searching groups on FB (brew city rei, landlords of mke, etc)

    Are you pre-approved with your lender so you can act quickly?

    I’d gladly offer a second set of eyes on a showing or analysis if you’d like. 

  • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    6y

    @Kendal West you are doing what most new investors do and you start with the property. Turn that around and start with your financial model: what is the price tag on the property, what is the condition, what is the rehab budget, what will the rents be, what will the financing look like and what is the cash flow etc. 

    You basically lay it all out without an actual property. What you will find most likly on your first atempt, that you have just drawn up a unicorn (does not exist in the real world). So you will have to tweak your model until it is realistic. This may take you a few iterations. Your agent and your lender can then help verify, that would you are planning on doing will actually work.

    From there on it is much easier, because you have solved the entire puzzle with only on piece left to plu in: the address of the property. But you already know everything about it, so it's easy to find.

    I have been doing this for over ten years and this is still how I find and buy my own properties.

    PS: your agent is a saint! 

  • Rental Property Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2019 · 11 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    @Merritt S. We share the “Jack of all trades” traits lol. I plan on getting my hands dirty and mind wrecked. I feel that I have to do that before letting a Managment/ contracting team assist. That way I’m not getting taken for extras lol. I’m looking at duplexes for my first property to assist with what I call self contained chaos lol. As for the untapped potential of Milwaukee I should’ve been more clear #sarcasm. Well anyway thanks for the advice. I’ll definitely be putting it in my bag of tips and tricks.

  • Rental Property Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2019 · 11 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    @Dustin Young I think I have all of my ducks in a row. I made sure financing was done first before I started looking bc we all know banks play too much lol. As for narrowing my scope. I think I’ve learned a lot from A LOT of different people. Maybe I need to narrow the amount of other people’s advice part. If you’re up for a challenge maybe I can run a few ideas by you to get more in-depth? PM me if you’re available.

  • Rental Property Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2019 · 11 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    @Marcus Auerbach lol I just showed this to my Agent... He laughed and then looked at me with a serious death stare. Don’t worry I compensate him with free meals and other extras for his time. I’m not one of those investors lol I’m looking to build a dream team bc I know I can’t do it on my own. Plus sharing is caring, it can be fun.

    I have two methods of financing (business loan or VA home loan) Ik the VA is much easier but I didn't know the business side so I've been going with that as my primary to learn the ropes. I use all of the BP tools to set up my options and they work. I'm just not getting to home plate. Either way I appreciate the the advice and motivation it truly goes a long way.

  • Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Kendal West:

    @Merritt S. We share the “Jack of all trades” traits lol. I plan on getting my hands dirty and mind wrecked. I feel that I have to do that before letting a Managment/ contracting team assist. That way I’m not getting taken for extras lol. I’m looking at duplexes for my first property to assist with what I call self contained chaos lol. As for the untapped potential of Milwaukee I should’ve been more clear #sarcasm. Well anyway thanks for the advice. I’ll definitely be putting it in my bag of tips and tricks.

     Being a jack of all trades is great. However you will need to be an expert in most trades to rehab the clunker houses. You also need that to be able to bid on properties with the right calculations in all cases. Be safe and learn to understand when it is smartest to hire a pro. I think the "house hack", meaning living in the property you invest in is ideal, so long as you don't mind living in the chaos/construction - that's not for everybody - I would be doing that except my wife says nope. The trick there is to only fix what you ought to - that's a deadly mistake almost everyone makes to some degree so, never stop considering it - I can't stress that point enough.

    My advice to you is to buy a duplex in the best physical condition you can afford, in the best neighborhood you can afford, for starters. Once you have some experience, then maybe take on a clunker. Make sure the bones are good - the foundation is critical. If a house has a finished basement (meaning the foundation is hidden in one or all areas) don't buy it for any price (let the investors who are also basement contractors have those). Stuff that is easy to overlook are bad drainage from the house, too many trees, bad concrete outside - that stuff will murder you. I've found old garages are more of a liability than a good investment in the lower rent areas unless you get lucky and get one that isn't falling over - it will cost more to bring them back to life or replace them than it will ever bring back in rent and therefore, the best choice is to remove them and spend the money on a new parking slab - obviously a property that already has that done is a plus (people use them as storage lockers too, then leave it all for you to clean when they skip out later). For the most part, you are looking for a house with good bones, and all the annoying, expensive and necessary stuff is as updated as possible. That means the last things to worry about are paint and "nice" features (though not to say they are not important), and the first things to worry about are foundations, wirings, plumbing, windows, roofs, concrete, structural issues, over-grown yards, etc. You want a house that is as functional and major-repair-free as possible, in a world where pretty much all the houses will need some degree of repairs. The thing is, those houses get bought fast - lol - which is why I end up fixing clunkers.

    Be safe.

  • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    6y

    @Kendal West a VA loan is propbably not an ideal choice, as it requires the seller to do and pay for a termite inspection (I know; we don't have termites, tell that to the VA). VA and FHA are the least desireable for Sellers. I would focus on your business loan. Make sure you understand the lenders requirements on property condition and then map out your financial model.

    How much will the property cost.

    Type of home, size in SF and bed/bath rooms. 

    Condition and reapirs acceptable.

    Budget for repairs.

    Rents.

    Cash flow.

    Once you have that nailed down and you look at inventory through that lense you will see that 99% of the listings do not meet all of your criteria. No need to see them. Focus on the ones that meet your definition.

  • Rental Property Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2019 · 11 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    @Marcus Auerbach thanks a lot for the advice. I’ll definitely take it to my drawing board.

  • Rental Property Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2019 · 11 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    @Merritt S. I understand. I worked in construction for a few years. My father in law is a cert. election, my father a mechanic and all of my brothers are in the trades as well. I have all of the experience I feel needed to get the job done with “clunkers” I guess my inexperience in having a property is taking away from the advice I actually need. I’m looking for info like best banks in the area. I have a excellent credit score and cash. I don’t know if I should be worried about a personal credit score or building business credit. Either way you’ve been helpful and I appreciate it. I have a few people in my inbox now. I’ll give them a try. Maybe a more in-depth collaboration can give me a jolt of energy. Thanks again. I hope I get a chance to pick your brain later on.

  • Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Kendal West:

    @Merritt S. I understand. I worked in construction for a few years. My father in law is a cert. election, my father a mechanic and all of my brothers are in the trades as well. I have all of the experience I feel needed to get the job done with “clunkers” I guess my inexperience in having a property is taking away from the advice I actually need. I’m looking for info like best banks in the area. I have a excellent credit score and cash. I don’t know if I should be worried about a personal credit score or building business credit. Either way you’ve been helpful and I appreciate it. I have a few people in my inbox now. I’ll give them a try. Maybe a more in-depth collaboration can give me a jolt of energy. Thanks again. I hope I get a chance to pick your brain later on.

     LOL. Yea, you got one thing right. Your inexperience in having a property is definitely taking away from the advice you really need. You are all over the board.

    So, my advice is to take mine. You are not even close to ready to handle a clunker. A "couple years in construction" and a few "buddies" to cheer you on is not enough. You are going to lose your *** financially and maybe some body parts too with all that. The most valuable thing you have attained is your good credit and financial success so far. Work that angle and buy the best property you can to start, one that needs little or nothing in repairs if you can. You have no idea what you're getting into my friend. You don't even have a business so why are you thinking about business credit??? If you ruin your personal credit and don't have cash, you're dead in the water. And, don't forget this little tidbit either, the most successful investors are not DIY carpenters like me.

    Be safe. Protect your body. Protect your finances. Don't be Tigger (from Winnie The Poo). Take that credit and go buy the best duplex you can for the best price you can get. Learn to be a landlord. Learn how taxes work. See if you can actually make any money. THEN decide if you have what it takes to be a builder, because that's what you are if you buy and fix a clunker. I'll leave you with this - crap rehabs don't sell for the amount the crap rehabber thinks they are going to get - that's advice from an appraiser of 14 years.

    Step one is go out and get pre-approved for a personal loan. Nothing wrong with shopping lenders either. Step two is going out and purchasing a property. I hope you take my advice and steer-clear from a fixer.

  • Rental Property Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2019 · 11 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    @Merritt S. I have an LLC and have been making moves on it. But you wouldn't know that through a few messages on this forum. You are getting your information about me and what I want to do and came to this forum originally from a few sentences. I get the idea you think I haven't done my homework on anything. You can't get a full overview of everything I have going on from the snap shot comments on this forum but I get the feeling your condescending tone is based on your judgment of my brief comments. It's ok I guess that's what I get for opening up myself to the public experts via social media. It's a good thing I don't take it negatively or have the feelings behind it all lol. Have a good day sir. I wish you great success.

  • Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Kendal West:

    @Merritt S. I have an LLC and have been making moves on it. But you wouldn't know that through a few messages on this forum. You are getting your information about me and what I want to do and came to this forum originally from a few sentences. I get the idea you think I haven't done my homework on anything. You can't get a full overview of everything I have going on from the snap shot comments on this forum but I get the feeling your condescending tone is based on your judgment of my brief comments. It's ok I guess that's what I get for opening up myself to the public experts via social media. It's a good thing I don't take it negatively or have the feelings behind it all lol. Have a good day sir. I wish you great success.



    "Please feel free to yell, scream, or politely explain some of the ways you’ve been able to find success around these parts or others."

    Those are your words from your first post.

    You would not be the first, nor the last, to take what I say on this forum as a condescending troll. That perception however, is mistaken. I promise you I take no pleasure in being mean to people for the sake of being mean. I also promise you I care more about other people than most other people. What you will get from me is a straight-forward approach. I prefer to strike at the heart of the matter, if I am smart enough to identify what that is. Some people find that difficult to deal with. I consider those people hyper-sensitive and weak - probably the first to die in the Zombie apocalypse. I pretty much avoid people like that as much as possible, and get annoyed when I'm stuck coddling and catering to them, which for the most part only happens with family members I am stuck spending time with, or the occasional client I wished I had not taken work from. What can I say, I prefer to live in the truth and not on Fantasy Island like the rest of America. For those reasons, I am a terrible salesman.

    If you spent a "couple years" in the trades, maybe you picked up on a certain fact. The meanest thing one worker can do to the other is ignore them or mislead them. While on the other hand, the worker who takes the time and makes the effort to help the next guy learn something is truly kind. I dunno...maybe you never picked up on that. Maybe you we're told to go sit in the truck too many times after expressing you knew it all and didn't like people telling you what you ought to do - lol. Maybe you went home and cursed the old grumpy guy that was trying to show you something.

    I feel bad you feel bad so I'll say it one more time. You are not ready to rehab a house AND be an investor right out of the gate. Not one of the clunkers Milwaukee is full of. Maybe one of the better houses in the suburbs, maybe, and we're talking maybe a bit of paint and some flooring or something, not a full-blown, fix 100 years of deferred maintenance and straight-up neglect. This is because building a house and investing in housing are two separate and very complicated disciplines on their own, by themselves, independently. NOBODY comes out of the gate knowing how to do both well, nobody. Yet, MANY people try to do just that. Probably because they are too stubborn and full of can-do attitude to listen to anyone who came before them who tried the same thing, and instead read some book titled, "Real Estate. You can do it too." - lol. You will find countless success stories contradicting what I just said on this forum. You will find a couple that confirm it. The thing is my friend, people love to bask and boast in their success, but hide from the world when they fail. Just not politically correct to be negative these days now is it???

    You have credit. That's an extremely valuable asset. Your best move is to buy a house in the best physical condition you can when you start out. Why? Because even that house will have plenty of things that need to get fixed along the way - trust me. While you are leaning all the ins and outs of being a landlord (like marketing, leasing, contracts, dealing with tenants, evictions, taxes, etc), you can also learn the market more (like neighborhoods, property values, correlations between physical condition and value, etc) and improve your home construction knowledge (too much to list on this one). Didn't you also say you we're prepared to go into this for the long haul? Well my friend, that's what it takes. The get rich quick people are fewer than advertised.

    But hey, call me a troll again and I'll give you the silence you ask for in a heartbeat.

  • Rental Property Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2019 · 11 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    @Merritt S. Lol you’re awesome. Thanks man

  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2019 · 55 posts · 26 votes
    6y

    @Kendal West I invest in the Milwaukee area. I would suggest purchasing a "rental ready" property that needs minimal work. Also look into the City owned properties, but you will have to complete the Landlord Training class before placing a bid on those. There are good deals out in Milwaukee, be patient.

  • Real Estate Syndicator · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 907 votes
    6y

    I also invest in the Milwaukee market!  I think you are taking the right approach by being conservative.  Continue to make offers based on your conservative underwriting models and you'll get one eventually.  Better to wait for the right deal than overpay.  Lots of people overpaying for deals this past year.

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2016 · 153 posts · 84 votes
    6y

    @Marcus Auerbach love your advice about building the model of what you want to buy. The hurdle I think our friend needs to get over will be pulling the trigger once he finds a good fit. I think it’s a discipline thing. You’ve done the research, you’ve found the property that makes sense with your model, now you need to buy it. Some might call it a leap of faith but it’s an preparation meeting opportunity. You have to trust your self. First one is the scariest. Come to terms with the fact that not everything will go perfectly, but it is unlikely to be a disaster either. You’ll have some challenges and you’ll grow by overcoming them. Best experience is still from jumping in and getting your hands dirty. So go build the model of what you want to buy, find it, and MAKE OFFERS. Zero properties are purchased when zero offers are made. Make offers and you’ll pick up your first rental eventually.

  • Investor · Tucson, AZ · Member since 2017 · 394 posts · 178 votes
    6y

    @Kendal West I think you are offering on properties that you may not be ready for yet and you may not understand all the costs involved.  Your lender is not obviously not comfortable lending on these type of properties that require a lot of work.  So you have two options:

    1. Find a property that requires minimal rehab and pay more for it.

    2. Find a lender that will lend on fixer-uppers. These will be  non-conventional lenders and will mean higher interest and possibly shorter duration.  

    I agree with @Account Closed.  You should start with a property in better condition until you get your feet wet. Once you have one or two under your belt, then proceed to the more difficult rehabs.  As you are probably seeing, these properties are harder to get because you need cash or a quick close.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.