Real Estate Agent · Palm Springs, CA · Member since 2026 · 5 posts · 1 vote
Hi everyone! Quick question for the investors here 👋
I used to focus mostly on flips, but lately I’ve been looking at new construction communities in Palm Springs / Coachella Valley and I’m seeing something interesting.
Most new builds have negative cash flow as long-term rentals right now, BUT the upside is buying early and potentially getting strong appreciation once the whole community is fully completed (12–24 months).
I’m curious — does anyone here invest like this on purpose?
Buy early → rent even if it’s negative → sell later for equity growth?
Also — anyone using 1031 exchange money for new construction?
Selling an older rental, buying a brand-new build (less maintenance), renting, and exiting later after appreciation?
You’re essentially describing an appreciation-first, developer-tailwind strategy, and yes, some investors do this intentionally, but it needs very clear guardrails. It can work when, the negative carry is modest and fully underwritten, you’re buying meaningfully below future stabilized retail, and demand drivers (jobs, lifestyle, supply constraints) support exit liquidity once the community matures. Many 1031 buyers use this approach specifically for lower maintenance and predictable capex, but the risk is tying up capital in a long, appreciation-dependent hold.
You’re essentially describing an appreciation-first, developer-tailwind strategy, and yes, some investors do this intentionally, but it needs very clear guardrails. It can work when, the negative carry is modest and fully underwritten, you’re buying meaningfully below future stabilized retail, and demand drivers (jobs, lifestyle, supply constraints) support exit liquidity once the community matures. Many 1031 buyers use this approach specifically for lower maintenance and predictable capex, but the risk is tying up capital in a long, appreciation-dependent hold.
I have been working in the build to rent space for the last two years. I have changed to investing only in New Construction for that time. In the number of areas that i have been working in I am finding cash flow in the properties. This is mainly because of the incentives that some of the builders are able to give. I am able to find rates in the 3s and free PM on most all of my investments.
With that being said, there had been an equity play with this as well. In the past year that has gone away but it is only a matter of time before we are back. In today's market I would not advise NOT to buy only for appreciation. It could be awhile before we see things come back. I still invest for solid cash flow. There are many strategies out there that will provide this.
Your last question is true as well. I work with many investors, and have done myself, who are looking to get rid of the continuous unknown of maintenance fees and get into a new property that needs no capital improvement for over 10 years. I believe that this is a solid investment strategy for growing wealth. This can be used as a continuous move to keep things growing.
@Victoria Bonhomme, there are a lot of investors out there who use new construction to reduce the risk of capital expense. And as importantly, new construction is easier to work with as your replacement property because you can time the completion of a particular property to match your 1031 dates. No one ever likes negative cash flow. But there are a lot of folks (it's typically more of a tool for the higher-income folk who don't need cash flow) doing it. Remember, cash flow is only one component of what makes a property profitable. Work with the IRR calculations to compare your property with negative cash flow versus a property you can find with positive cash flow. And see how appreciation, depreciation, and amortization of the loan
I wouldn’t. Appreciation isn’t guaranteed so I want the likelihood of both appreciation and cash flow. This could be area specific but around here not only are new builds priced at a premium, think new car, but like a condo situation if in a neighborhood there can be excess supply especially hard to complete if they are still building new when yours is a few years old. I suspect this strategy is largely suited to green investors who incorrectly think if it’s new there won’t be maintenance.
Hi everyone! Quick question for the investors here 👋
I used to focus mostly on flips, but lately I’ve been looking at new construction communities in Palm Springs / Coachella Valley and I’m seeing something interesting.
Most new builds have negative cash flow as long-term rentals right now, BUT the upside is buying early and potentially getting strong appreciation once the whole community is fully completed (12–24 months).
I’m curious — does anyone here invest like this on purpose?
Buy early → rent even if it’s negative → sell later for equity growth?
Also — anyone using 1031 exchange money for new construction?
Selling an older rental, buying a brand-new build (less maintenance), renting, and exiting later after appreciation?
I wouldn't buy anything negative cash flow, but have bought new construction. It would depend on your market but what I have seen is new construction was going up every phase but now has leveled off or decreased. I would not expect near term appreciation just because the neighborhood has finished.
New construction yes, negative cash flow no. Plenty of opportunities out there to find a better new construction deal and walk into equity & cash flow. That day one equity is the same as appreciation and serves as your buffer, instead of counting on a future value and eating negative cash flow.
What I would invest in depends on my goals. New builds mean lower maintenance costs for the first few years, but financial independence requires a different approach.
For long-term financial independence, rental income must be:
Inflation-beating - rents grow faster than inflation (depends on the city where you invest)
Reliable - continues during recessions (depends on the tenant segment’s job and behavior)
Lifelong - lasts as long as you need it (depends on both)
Success isn't about buying any property—it's about buying in a city where rents outpace inflation, and attracting tenants who stay long-term, pay rent consistently on time, and have recession-proof jobs.
To find the right tenant segment for your goals, interview property managers. Then buy properties similar to what those tenants currently rent. Your personal taste doesn't matter—only what attracts reliable tenants.
Bottom line: Property type doesn't matter. What matters is buying properties that attract the right tenants in the right city.