I've been debating this for so long and I just can't decide what's best. I live in Greater Vancouver, Canada.. Would it be best to invest in a non-appreciating duplex that cashflows well (in Saskatoon or Edmonton- compare to midwest for US folks) or a non-cashflowing detached home in the coastal region of Vancouver area (think Seattle!) where there is tons of appreciation but NO cashflow. We would have to supplement the rent for a few years, but these properties are million dollar homes with great value. I'm so torn. what would you do? We have a decent amount to put in for a down payment (200k) but would stay with the 20% downpayment if going with a cheaper property (400-600k). We want to maximize our money to go as far as possible. Help please!! thank you so much for any responses!!!
I am embarrassed how complicated others are making this, it's actually very simple.
If the choice is as stated, ALWAYS 100% of the time go with APPRECIATION.
Appreciation CREATES cash-flow. But cash-flow does NOT create appreciation.
Actually, most often, properties with cash-flow and low or no appreciation create EXPENSES, like cap-x realization, and thus destroy there cash-flow so one is left with neither. A great example of this is the MFH market today, without appreciation there stuck in a bad way for a long time, until appreciation comes back into that picture.
Think of it this way:
Appreciation without cash-flow is a SEED. Nurture it, it will grow and blossom into a nice money tree.
Cash-flow without appreciation is an old-old tree who's done it's growing and what's left, yeah, rotting and dying. No thanks.
Neither. If you don't have both, don't buy it.
lol then no one should buy in Plymouth MI or almost anywhere in the midwest for that matter. Would love to see the appreciation those markets bring you.
You are going to be so far in the negative buying in Vancouver plus add the property purchase tax. You could look nearby in parts of Vancouver Island, but those prices have also gone up a lot. BC is very tenant friendly, AB isn't. BC has caps on rent increases, AB doesn't. I'd look to AB, Lethbridge has lower prices and places that should cash flow. I have a few places there and have a PM who manages them.
I'd avoid condos as you have strata fees and I'd rather that money go to paying the mortgage, then going into someone else's pocket.
Neither. If you don't have both, don't buy it.
lol then no one should buy in Plymouth MI or almost anywhere in the midwest for that matter. Would love to see the appreciation those markets bring you.
Buy good houses in good neighborhoods. If there a little OTM today, that's fine if you can weather it. The rental raises + quality of tenants will be way better off. If you can't weather $200/mo in OTM cash flow then don't play in real estate.
If you're relatively small, buy less houses in higher quality areas. Less physical risk, less tenant risk, way higher exposure to market upside. I know the idea of owning 10 houses is lovely, but buying 3 better one's is way more worth it.
Anyone buying to collect a menial $100/mo and making that the deciding factor is truly coming out on the bottom.
Neither. If you don't have both, don't buy it.
lol then no one should buy in Plymouth MI or almost anywhere in the midwest for that matter. Would love to see the appreciation those markets bring you.
Which cities in the midwest are appreciating anywhere near as fast as SF, LA, etc? Theres some level of appreciation just about everywhere. But 3% is waaaaaay different than 5-6%. Good luck cash flowing in year 1 in prime areas of those cities, barring a massive rehab. But by year 5 it’s a different story and then you’re off to the races.
Neither. If you don't have both, don't buy it.
lol then no one should buy in Plymouth MI or almost anywhere in the midwest for that matter. Would love to see the appreciation those markets bring you.
Which cities in the midwest are appreciating anywhere near as fast as SF, LA, etc? Theres some level of appreciation just about everywhere. But 3% is waaaaaay different than 5-6%. Good luck cash flowing in year 1 in prime areas of those cities, barring a massive rehab. But by year 5 it’s a different story and then you’re off to the races.
I've been debating this for so long and I just can't decide what's best. I live in Greater Vancouver, Canada.. Would it be best to invest in a non-appreciating duplex that cashflows well (in Saskatoon or Edmonton- compare to midwest for US folks) or a non-cashflowing detached home in the coastal region of Vancouver area (think Seattle!) where there is tons of appreciation but NO cashflow. We would have to supplement the rent for a few years, but these properties are million dollar homes with great value. I'm so torn. what would you do? We have a decent amount to put in for a down payment (200k) but would stay with the 20% downpayment if going with a cheaper property (400-600k). We want to maximize our money to go as far as possible. Help please!! thank you so much for any responses!!!
Cash flow is king. If you cash flow, then you can withstand a downturn in the market. If not, then what happens when the market tanks (2007/08)? You are losing money every month and also lost money in the downturn. IMO People buying for appreciation are the ones who lose everything in the bad market. It's easy to survive a good market, but what happens in the bad market?
I've been debating this for so long and I just can't decide what's best. I live in Greater Vancouver, Canada.. Would it be best to invest in a non-appreciating duplex that cashflows well (in Saskatoon or Edmonton- compare to midwest for US folks) or a non-cashflowing detached home in the coastal region of Vancouver area (think Seattle!) where there is tons of appreciation but NO cashflow. We would have to supplement the rent for a few years, but these properties are million dollar homes with great value. I'm so torn. what would you do? We have a decent amount to put in for a down payment (200k) but would stay with the 20% downpayment if going with a cheaper property (400-600k). We want to maximize our money to go as far as possible. Help please!! thank you so much for any responses!!!
Cash flow is king. If you cash flow, then you can withstand a downturn in the market. If not, then what happens when the market tanks (2007/08)? You are losing money every month and also lost money in the downturn.
If asset price going down due to market volatility, simple, you don't sell. This is similar like holding stock index , if market going down, what would you ? you don't sell it unless it's margin call.
In real estate market since there's 30 margin call, everything is predictable, as long as you can pay the mortgage you are all set.
Problem mostly happened due to personal issue, for example, if one is having 8000k monthly mortgage , RE price going down, and folks get lay off.
but even then, in reality, in real estate market post 2008, even if market tanks, it's shortlived, the downturn post 2008 only occured for six months, very easy to mitigage as long as one doesn't over-leverage and two, having backup plan.
Neither. If you don't have both, don't buy it.
lol then no one should buy in Plymouth MI or almost anywhere in the midwest for that matter. Would love to see the appreciation those markets bring you.
Which cities in the midwest are appreciating anywhere near as fast as SF, LA, etc? Theres some level of appreciation just about everywhere. But 3% is waaaaaay different than 5-6%. Good luck cash flowing in year 1 in prime areas of those cities, barring a massive rehab. But by year 5 it’s a different story and then you’re off to the races.
although rate appreciation is different, but the baseline comparison tend to favor the higher price due to how our 30YFRM is calculated. For example, a 5% appreciation from 100k house in Ohio is very different than 4.8% appreciation that's starting from 800k house in Hawaii, the absolute number is way way different.
And since 30YFRM is structured for the same payment as 30Y, in theory, the longest maturity debt favors those who owned property that has the highest appreciation, end result would be different because the payment rate is different.
There's also theory of buying power, if one is living in CA for example, as pharmacist, one could make $150k salary easily and could afford $800k mortgage. Appreciation rate per year is 5.75% average in year.
Now, same guy, due to phamarcist salary strucure in Ohio (or North Dakota), has same job profile, but could only make $80k salary, so his buying power is capped at $300k mortgage, appreciation rate per year is 4% average in year.
Both would have different investment profile although the starting career could be the same.
Now, the appreciation is created solely by housing demand/supply. There's almost no other factor. This is why also, in higher appreciation city, the appreciation doesn't really collapse although nationwide real estate market is tanked. This is how to explain recently why Nortcal CA market perform the best this year compare to example, Austin.
Neither. If you don't have both, don't buy it.
lol then no one should buy in Plymouth MI or almost anywhere in the midwest for that matter. Would love to see the appreciation those markets bring you.
Which cities in the midwest are appreciating anywhere near as fast as SF, LA, etc? Theres some level of appreciation just about everywhere. But 3% is waaaaaay different than 5-6%. Good luck cash flowing in year 1 in prime areas of those cities, barring a massive rehab. But by year 5 it’s a different story and then you’re off to the races.
although rate appreciation is different, but the baseline comparison tend to favor the higher price due to how our 30YFRM is calculated. For example, a 5% appreciation from 100k house in Ohio is very different than 4.8% appreciation that's starting from 800k house in Hawaii, the absolute number is way way different.
And since 30YFRM is structured for the same payment as 30Y, in theory, the longest maturity debt favors those who owned property that has the highest appreciation, end result would be different because the payment rate is different.
There's also theory of buying power, if one is living in CA for example, as pharmacist, one could make $150k salary easily and could afford $800k mortgage. Appreciation rate per year is 5.75% average in year.
Now, same guy, due to phamarcist salary strucure in Ohio (or North Dakota), has same job profile, but could only make $80k salary, so his buying power is capped at $300k mortgage, appreciation rate per year is 4% average in year.
Both would have different investment profile although the starting career could be the same.
Now, the appreciation is created solely by housing demand/supply. There's almost no other factor. This is why also, in higher appreciation city, the appreciation doesn't really collapse although nationwide real estate market is tanked. This is how to explain recently why Nortcal CA market perform the best this year compare to example, Austin.
Neither. If you don't have both, don't buy it.
lol then no one should buy in Plymouth MI or almost anywhere in the midwest for that matter. Would love to see the appreciation those markets bring you.
Which cities in the midwest are appreciating anywhere near as fast as SF, LA, etc? Theres some level of appreciation just about everywhere. But 3% is waaaaaay different than 5-6%. Good luck cash flowing in year 1 in prime areas of those cities, barring a massive rehab. But by year 5 it’s a different story and then you’re off to the races.
although rate appreciation is different, but the baseline comparison tend to favor the higher price due to how our 30YFRM is calculated. For example, a 5% appreciation from 100k house in Ohio is very different than 4.8% appreciation that's starting from 800k house in Hawaii, the absolute number is way way different.
And since 30YFRM is structured for the same payment as 30Y, in theory, the longest maturity debt favors those who owned property that has the highest appreciation, end result would be different because the payment rate is different.
There's also theory of buying power, if one is living in CA for example, as pharmacist, one could make $150k salary easily and could afford $800k mortgage. Appreciation rate per year is 5.75% average in year.
Now, same guy, due to phamarcist salary strucure in Ohio (or North Dakota), has same job profile, but could only make $80k salary, so his buying power is capped at $300k mortgage, appreciation rate per year is 4% average in year.
Both would have different investment profile although the starting career could be the same.
Now, the appreciation is created solely by housing demand/supply. There's almost no other factor. This is why also, in higher appreciation city, the appreciation doesn't really collapse although nationwide real estate market is tanked. This is how to explain recently why Nortcal CA market perform the best this year compare to example, Austin.
I calculated of those Joe with real time practive. After ten years, the net money appreciation after capital gain is 4x with DSCR 1.1 ; and 3.5x with DSCR 0.95; assuming appreciation is 5.75%.
It's still okay after all.
it's important to evaluate your investment options based on your personal financial goals and risk tolerance.
If you're looking for a long-term investment strategy and prioritize cash flow, then investing in a non-appreciating duplex in Saskatoon or Edmonton might be a good option for you. These properties will provide a steady stream of income, allowing you to reinvest that money into additional properties or other investments.
On the other hand, if you're more interested in short-term gains and appreciation potential, then investing in a non-cashflowing detached home in the coastal region of Vancouver might be more appealing. However, you need to consider the risk of having to supplement the rent for a few years
I've been debating this for so long and I just can't decide what's best. I live in Greater Vancouver, Canada.. Would it be best to invest in a non-appreciating duplex that cashflows well (in Saskatoon or Edmonton- compare to midwest for US folks) or a non-cashflowing detached home in the coastal region of Vancouver area (think Seattle!) where there is tons of appreciation but NO cashflow. We would have to supplement the rent for a few years, but these properties are million dollar homes with great value. I'm so torn. what would you do? We have a decent amount to put in for a down payment (200k) but would stay with the 20% downpayment if going with a cheaper property (400-600k). We want to maximize our money to go as far as possible. Help please!! thank you so much for any responses!!!
Cash flow is king. If you cash flow, then you can withstand a downturn in the market. If not, then what happens when the market tanks (2007/08)? You are losing money every month and also lost money in the downturn.
If asset price going down due to market volatility, simple, you don't sell. This is similar like holding stock index , if market going down, what would you ? you don't sell it unless it's margin call.
In real estate market since there's 30 margin call, everything is predictable, as long as you can pay the mortgage you are all set.
Problem mostly happened due to personal issue, for example, if one is having 8000k monthly mortgage , RE price going down, and folks get lay off.
but even then, in reality, in real estate market post 2008, even if market tanks, it's shortlived, the downturn post 2008 only occured for six months, very easy to mitigage as long as one doesn't over-leverage and two, having backup plan.
Couple of differences between Canada and the US from your two posts-we didn't have the housing crash that happened in the US about 15 years ago. Also in Canada, we can get a 25 (or 30) year mortgage, but it is renewed every 1-5 years and our payments change because it is renewed at a different interest rate.
Neither. If you don't have both, don't buy it.
lol then no one should buy in Plymouth MI or almost anywhere in the midwest for that matter. Would love to see the appreciation those markets bring you.
Which cities in the midwest are appreciating anywhere near as fast as SF, LA, etc? Theres some level of appreciation just about everywhere. But 3% is waaaaaay different than 5-6%. Good luck cash flowing in year 1 in prime areas of those cities, barring a massive rehab. But by year 5 it’s a different story and then you’re off to the races.
although rate appreciation is different, but the baseline comparison tend to favor the higher price due to how our 30YFRM is calculated. For example, a 5% appreciation from 100k house in Ohio is very different than 4.8% appreciation that's starting from 800k house in Hawaii, the absolute number is way way different.
And since 30YFRM is structured for the same payment as 30Y, in theory, the longest maturity debt favors those who owned property that has the highest appreciation, end result would be different because the payment rate is different.
There's also theory of buying power, if one is living in CA for example, as pharmacist, one could make $150k salary easily and could afford $800k mortgage. Appreciation rate per year is 5.75% average in year.
Now, same guy, due to phamarcist salary strucure in Ohio (or North Dakota), has same job profile, but could only make $80k salary, so his buying power is capped at $300k mortgage, appreciation rate per year is 4% average in year.
Both would have different investment profile although the starting career could be the same.
Now, the appreciation is created solely by housing demand/supply. There's almost no other factor. This is why also, in higher appreciation city, the appreciation doesn't really collapse although nationwide real estate market is tanked. This is how to explain recently why Nortcal CA market perform the best this year compare to example, Austin.
I calculated of those Joe with real time practive. After ten years, the net money appreciation after capital gain is 4x with DSCR 1.1 ; and 3.5x with DSCR 0.95; assuming appreciation is 5.75%.
It's still okay after all.
I've been debating this for so long and I just can't decide what's best. I live in Greater Vancouver, Canada.. Would it be best to invest in a non-appreciating duplex that cashflows well (in Saskatoon or Edmonton- compare to midwest for US folks) or a non-cashflowing detached home in the coastal region of Vancouver area (think Seattle!) where there is tons of appreciation but NO cashflow. We would have to supplement the rent for a few years, but these properties are million dollar homes with great value. I'm so torn. what would you do? We have a decent amount to put in for a down payment (200k) but would stay with the 20% downpayment if going with a cheaper property (400-600k). We want to maximize our money to go as far as possible. Help please!! thank you so much for any responses!!!
Hi Suzanne, I'd say it depends on your real estate goals - are you able to sustain your living expenses with your w2 job and don't need cash flow? or are you planning on using real estate to supporting your lifestyle and living expenses? It depends on your goals and what you're looking to accomplish with real estate investing!
With that being said, I really like Columbus Ohio - there's so many catalysts for why people should invest here. Specifically, there's job growth (Intel, Honda, Amazon, Nationwide, etc) and the population is growing (unlike Cleveland or Cincy). I really see Columbus Ohio as an extremely safe bet for the next 10-20 years. Plus, there's still so many positive cash flowing and 1% deals here in Columbus Ohio. Just a few weeks ago, I helped a client close on a deal getting them 20% cash on cash return. As a local investor and agent here, let me know if you have any questions or want to connect!
There is no rule that says you can't have both.
If you invest in an affordable market where population is increasing, you should be able to get both cash-flow and appreciation.
Can you find a "cash flow" property that needs work, do a renovation and then gain both an equity return on your renovation and cash flow from you renting it?
but even then, in reality, in real estate market post 2008, even if market tanks, it's shortlived, the downturn post 2008 only occured for six months, very easy to mitigage as long as one doesn't over-leverage and two, having backup plan.
Couple of differences between Canada and the US from your two posts-we didn't have the housing crash that happened in the US about 15 years ago. Also in Canada, we can get a 25 (or 30) year mortgage, but it is renewed every 1-5 years and our payments change because it is renewed at a different interest rate.
that's normal everywhere in the world, where you have 5Y ARM.
Because of this, the risk between lender and borrower are pretty much equal in Canada, while in US it gives unbeatable advantage to US borrower.
Why not both? If the property has high appreciation rate and long-term rental cash flow doesn’t look good then try medium-term and short-term rental. I’m sure one of those will make it cash flow. At the end of the day, the cash flow will keep the property afloat but appreciation is what’s gonna build your equity. That’s what’s gonna make you rich.
Cashflow is a safer route to go, Appreciation obviously has higher potential, so it depends where your finances stand, beyond the down payment. If you can risk low/no/negative cash flows early on in a high appreciation market, it could be worthwhile. Another huge factor is your timeline. Short term the goal should always be cash flow, but if you have 10+ years on the horizon, appreciation could make more sense.
With creative layout, we can achieve a balance between appreciation and cash flow.
For example, split level houses, we can rent upstairs to one family, and downstairs to a second family.
This allows us to still buy in appreciating neighborhoods and cities, while still get a decent cash flow.
Equity comes, equity goes, but the cash will always flow! - Pace Morby
Buy for cashflow! When you buy for cashflow you will be able to survive any market cycle.
When people say buy for cash flow, you can survive market downturn. You do realize if we ever have a deep recession, your renter can't pay rent? Any market down turn wil impact you whether you're a cash flow only or an appreciation guy.
Buy good houses in good areas where there's favorable landlord laws, growing population, and economies are strong. Houses are priced relative to quality of selection. If you haven't realized that, you're no investor you're bait.
@V.G Jason how so very helpful of you.
When people say buy for cash flow, you can survive market downturn. You do realize if we ever have a deep recession, your renter can't pay rent? Any market down turn wil impact you whether you're a cash flow only or an appreciation guy.
Buy good houses in good areas where there's favorable landlord laws, growing population, and economies are strong. Houses are priced relative to quality of selection. If you haven't realized that, you're no investor you're bait.
Odds are Section 8 will still pay in a recession, not an excuse to buy in a shotty deals, but still a good hedge in good markets. Hell, if the recession is deep enough, section 8 may be the only option left for renters lol