Property tax surprise (yay)

Property tax surprise (yay)

Member since 2024 · 74 posts · 26 votes

I usually underwrite property taxes based on the actual estimation of the value of the property.

I actually thought I was being conservative, as most properties I research in my area have tax assessments at about 30% lower than their actual value.

However...

I bought a new construction property in January of this year at full price (with some moderate rate buydown/buying cost coverage concessions from the seller). The property appraisal came in right on the mark of my underwriting's value estimation at $350,000. To my surpise, the county tax appraisal came in at $444,000 back in in May. Unfortunately, I was abroad when that piece of mail came in, and by the time I got back, it was too late to protest (although I did try).

The county said they'd do an "informal review" and I'd get an update before the final tax notice on October 1st.

Well, I never heard back and just got slapped with a $3,500 tax bill.

I'm a little pissed off to say the least. I'm hoping that my protest will pull through next year if I get it in the right timeframe, and I have since created a system to review porperty tax assessments during the protest period. So here's to hoping.

I'm trying to understand the county's perspective here. Why would they slap this new construction neighborhood with such an enormous assessment? I mean it's not a small amount higher than the actual appraisal, it's a whopping $100,000 more.. What am I missing here?

0Reply
1,058 views

Most Popular Reply

Matthew MorrowBusiness Member
Investor · PA - NY - NJ · Member since 2019 · 986 posts · 360 votes
1mo

@Jonathan Warner That stings, especially on new construction where assessors can come in aggressive. A lot of people underwrite taxes off purchase price and still get surprised. Putting the appeal window on your calendar going forward will save you real money. Did they give any reason for landing about $100K over the appraisal, or just "neighborhood comps"?

CORE Team | Realty ONE Group Supreme4.950 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

13 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Matthew MorrowBusiness Member
    Investor · PA - NY - NJ · Member since 2019 · 986 posts · 360 votes
    1mo

    @Jonathan Warner That stings, especially on new construction where assessors can come in aggressive. A lot of people underwrite taxes off purchase price and still get surprised. Putting the appeal window on your calendar going forward will save you real money. Did they give any reason for landing about $100K over the appraisal, or just "neighborhood comps"?

    CORE Team | Realty ONE Group Supreme4.950 Reviews
    • Member since 2024 · 74 posts · 26 votes
      1mo

      They mentioned that their tax appraisal methods are to determine the "tax value" of the home, not the "market value". I'm not even realyl sure what that means other than "It's whatever we say it is because we choose whatever method we want to choose regarding tac value". I called the county assessor's office and took notes on their methods. They use a tier system. Tier 1 is 1900-1969. Tier 2 is 1969-2000. Tier 3 is 2000-2026. Of course new construction falls in the higher tier. There also factors like neighborhood quality, build quaility etc, external structure, improvements, etc. I really thought that it was on a simple formula. assumptions was take the assessed value and apply them milage rate, but there seems to be a lot more to than that. All the other homes in the neighborhood were assessed similarly. Of course I have a lot of market evidence that the assessment was complete BS, but I have to wait until next year to protest. Huge pain in the ***.

  • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    1mo

    1) Did you pay $350k? (You say you underwrote 30% under Sales’s price. But I assume you wouldn’t buy a property for $450k if it only appraised for $350k?) Or did you pay $444k and now they are assessing it at $44kk? (I’d have been pissed about the $350k appraisal and walked.)

    2) OTH if you only paid $350k you should have a pretty good set of facts to contest it and get a $1,200 discount next year.

    3) Does your county have a property tax estimator? Did you look at any neighboring new builds to see their property tax assessed value?

    4) The assessed value “usually” has nothing to do with the real value, and sometimes not even the taxed value. About 10-15 years ago almost all counties got sick of having to hold property tax protest meetings. So they dropped the values 20-30% and raised tax rates 18-28%. Everyone saw a tiny tax decrease and were ecstatic. But it collected the same rent with no protests. So the tax man was more ecstatic.

    5) Lastly. If you can’t figure it out you’ll need a local expert with that county. They all have unique things. In NV property taxes aren’t reassessed at sale, they simply climb a maximum of 3% for homes and 8% for above certain thresholds. So you can have a $600k new build with $6k taxes, a 10 year old identical home at $4k, and an ancient 30 year old home might be $2,400. And that’s ignoring Sid’s/lids. Good luck with your protest if you paid $350k. Either way study your county website.

    • Member since 2024 · 74 posts · 26 votes
      1mo
      1. I paid 343k, appraisal came back at $350k, I think the actual value of the house is more like $320k considering the rate buydown concessions I recieved at closing.

      2. I believe I do.

      3. They use very complicated methods. I outlined them in my recent reply to Matthew above.

      4. That's a fascincating bit of psychology f*ckery xD

      5. I called the county assessor's office and took notes on their methods. They use a tier system. Tier 1 is 1900-1969. Tier 2 is 1969-2000. Tier 3 is 2000-2026. Of course new construction falls in the higher tier. There also factors like neighborhood quality, build quaility etc, external structure, improvements, etc. I really thought that it was on a simple formula. assumptions was take the assessed value and apply them milage rate, but there seems to be a lot more to than that. All the other homes in the neighborhood were assessed similarly. Of course I have a lot of market evidence that the assessment was complete BS, but I have to wait until next year to protest.

      Thanks for the reply. I'll be protesting gun ablazing next year xD.

  • Simon W.Business Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Lehigh Valley PA & New York City · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 698 votes
    1mo

    New construction assessments catch a lot of people. Underwriting off "30% under market" works until the county decides your house is the comp.

    Next time I'd pull the assessor's estimate or neighboring new-build tax bills before you remove contingencies, and I'd put the protest deadline on the calendar the week you close. Missing that window is expensive in a way a rate buydown never offsets.

    For the books, update the tax escrow or the monthly reserve as soon as the new bill is final. If you're still setting aside money off the old estimate, you'll feel fine until the true-up hits — and that true-up looks a lot like a surprise CapEx bill.

    Accounting Properties LLC
    View Page
    CFO LLC
    View Page
  • Investor · San Francisco · Member since 2026 · 77 posts · 37 votes
    1mo

    Counties do not assess at your purchase price. They assess at what their mass appraisal model says the property is worth, and for new construction that model leans on replacement cost and comparable new sales, not the number on your closing statement. Builder-reported values and early sales in the development can push the model higher than what you paid.

    Three things I would do. First, check your appeal window immediately. Most counties give 30 to 60 days from the notice, and you file with actual comparable sales, not just an argument about your purchase price. Second, verify the property record card: square footage, bed and bath count, and finish level errors are common on new construction and make easy wins. Third, confirm you are not missing an exemption, though the homestead exemption will not apply to a rental.

    For underwriting, I now assume a new-construction assessment comes in at or above purchase price. Conservative on the buy side beats a surprise tax bill every time.

    • Member since 2024 · 74 posts · 26 votes
      1mo

      That's helpful, thank you. I'll be cross-referencing the property card with the actual property details on all of my properties moving forward.

  • Lender · Franklin, TN · Member since 2026 · 158 posts · 43 votes
    1mo

    One more thing if your loan is escrowed: the servicer will run an escrow analysis off that new bill and your payment jumps to cover both the shortage and the higher tax going forward. Most will let you pay the shortage as a lump sum so the monthly increase is smaller. And if the protest wins next year, ask for a fresh analysis right away so you aren't overpaying for 12 months.

  • Divin KanyamaBusiness Member
    Accountant · Seattle, WA · Member since 2025 · 704 posts · 303 votes
    1mo

    That is understandably frustrating, @Jonathan Warner. The county’s assessed value and a lender’s appraisal are produced for different purposes, so they do not always match. With new construction, the assessor may rely on a mass-appraisal model, builder sales across the development, recorded permits, land value, and standardized replacement-cost assumptions rather than the concessions and property-specific adjustments reflected in the purchase appraisal. The first assessment after completion can also be especially uneven if the county’s data is incomplete or incorrect.

    It would be worth requesting the full property record card and the comparable sales or cost data used to reach $444,000. Check the square footage, lot size, bedrooms, bathrooms, finished areas, upgrades, and completion status for errors, and confirm whether the bill includes any prior-year adjustment or supplemental assessment. For the next appeal, submit the closing statement, independent appraisal, photos, builder price list, and comparable sales, and focus on the property’s value as of the county’s required valuation date. A local property-tax consultant or attorney may also be worthwhile if the potential savings justify the fee.

  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    3w

    Jonathan, I can see why that would be frustrating, especially when your private appraisal came in right around the value you underwrote and the county assessment came in nearly $100K higher.

    One thing I'd separate is the property tax appeal from the income tax side. Your county assessment affects the property's carrying cost and therefore your actual rental cash flow, while your tax basis and depreciation are a separate calculation.

    For future acquisitions, I’d probably build a little more cushion into the property-tax assumption, especially with newer construction, rather than relying on the current assessment of nearby older properties. The assessment methodology can produce a very different number once a new property enters the system.

    If your appeal is successful, I'd also update the property's underwriting afterward and look at how much the lower assessment actually changes your annual cash flow and long-term return.

    It sounds like you’ve already built a good system for monitoring assessments. That’s probably one of the better habits to have when you're building a rental portfolio.

    Happy to connect!

    INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®4.9244 Reviews
    TaxMD® | Tax Planning Software
  • Los Angeles · Member since 2026 · 6 posts · 0 votes
    1w

    Same boat here, just in California.

    My condo in LA is assessed at $679,005 but sat on the market at $430K without selling. I filed what's called a Prop 8 decline-in-value — basically you show the county recent comparable sales proving the market value is below their number.

    I had HiHolt handle the filing for me since I didn't want to deal with the forms, but the evidence part is the same either way. Still waiting on the result. Where I am you can file again every year, so missing one protest window doesn't lock you out — worth checking your county's dates for next year and going in with the appraisal and comps ready.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.