I have not built an ADU in Arizona, so I will not invent a cost number for you. But I add rentable space for a living — 2/1 to 3/1 and 3/1 to 4/2 conversions in Memphis — and the test I run there is the one I would run on your ADU.
What makes it worth it to me: the added rent has to justify the all-in build cost the same way a purchase does. I screen with the 1% rule. If the ADU rents for $1,000 a month, I want to be all-in near $100K, not $180K.
And value is not what it costs. It is what an appraiser credits at refinance, because I refinance DSCR at 70-80% LTV. If the appraisal ignores the unit, the value add is a story, not equity. Get real bids in Phoenix, then run both tests.
I have not built an ADU in Arizona, so I will not invent a cost number for you. But I add rentable space for a living — 2/1 to 3/1 and 3/1 to 4/2 conversions in Memphis — and the test I run there is the one I would run on your ADU.
What makes it worth it to me: the added rent has to justify the all-in build cost the same way a purchase does. I screen with the 1% rule. If the ADU rents for $1,000 a month, I want to be all-in near $100K, not $180K.
And value is not what it costs. It is what an appraiser credits at refinance, because I refinance DSCR at 70-80% LTV. If the appraisal ignores the unit, the value add is a story, not equity. Get real bids in Phoenix, then run both tests.
Braeden, I'm with Renters Choice Homes. From the management side, I'd compare rents for similar detached units rather than use the main house's rent per square foot. Access, parking, laundry, privacy and utility arrangements all matter. I'd also consider whether the ADU changes the main home's rent, plus vacancy, turnover and maintenance. Which city and unit size are you considering, and would the main home also be rented?
James and Brandon covered the rent and appraisal side, so I'll add how the build cost behaves on the books, since it decides your real return.
Everything that gets the ADU ready to rent is generally capitalized into one basis: construction, permits, design, impact fees, and utility hookups. Keep a separate ledger for it so those costs don't get mixed into the main house's repairs. Say it all comes to $150,000 and rents for $1,500 a month. That's $18,000 a year, and after roughly 30% for vacancy, taxes, insurance, and upkeep you're at about $12,600, or 8.4% on cost. Depreciation over 27.5 years is about $5,450 a year, so taxable income is closer to $7,150.
If you live in the main house, split shared costs like utilities, the roof, and landscaping between personal and rental, and put a separate meter on the ADU if you can. It keeps the P&L clean.
So the worth-it test I'd run is yield on all-in cost after real expenses, not the sticker build price.
I'd separate this into feasibility, cash flow, and resale value before relying on a statewide cost estimate. First confirm zoning, lot coverage, setbacks, parking, utility connections, sewer capacity, fire access, plans, and permit fees for the specific parcel. Then obtain a written construction budget with a contingency and compare realistic long-term rent against the total project cost, financing expense, vacancy, maintenance, taxes, and insurance. An ADU may improve value, but the appraisal usually depends on comparable properties and local buyer demand—it isn't automatically a dollar-for-dollar return on construction costs. If financing is involved, compare cash, home-equity, renovation, and construction options early because their draw procedures and documentation can differ. I'd only proceed if the project still works with conservative rent, a higher final cost, and a longer construction schedule.
One thing I'd add is a quick call to your insurance agent before you build, since a second unit on the lot can change the policy and they may ask about the age of the roof, electrical and plumbing on the main house too. That surprise can matter as much as the build cost.
Hi! If you’re in the Phoenix area, BiggerPockets is hosting a small in-person meetup and bootcamp for investors looking to scale, December 5–7 (capped at 100 people).