The $12k Mistake I’ll Never Make Again

The $12k Mistake I’ll Never Make Again

Matthew MorrowBusiness Member
Investor · PA - NY - NJ · Member since 2019 · 975 posts · 354 votes

Early in my investing career, I was chasing a deal a little too aggressively. I found a semi-stabilized two-unit right down the street from where I lived. It checked the boxes: below-market rents, an attractive price, and a place that presented well despite its age.

I had also recently finished my home inspector certification, which gave me a little more confidence than I should have had.

We walked through, I wrote an offer, and we got a deal. I checked the electrical and plumbing and sent the drone up to look at the roof. But I missed something I’ll never forget: the sewer lateral.

One day, a tenant reported water backing up in the basement. I figured it was a simple clog. We tried a snake, couldn’t clear it, and called our plumber.

What happened next bruised my ego and emptied my repair budget.

The buried sewer piping was old cast iron. The house trap before the connection to the public sewer had rotted out, and sewage was going into the ground instead of reaching the sewer.

Here’s the part I hadn’t given enough thought to: on this property, our responsibility extended all the way to the public connection—not just to the edge of the house or the property line. Those boundaries are worth confirming with the local utility, especially when the connection is out under the street.

Thankfully, we had a great relationship with our plumber, and they handled it that day. But it took an emergency excavation and replacement of the failed trap.

Five hours later, I was out $12,000.

A roughly $300 sewer scope before closing could have flagged the problem and given me a chance to negotiate repairs or a credit. Instead, I owned the whole bill.

The lesson wasn’t just “get a sewer scope.” It was to stop confusing confidence with diligence. Below-market rents and a good purchase price don’t tell you what’s happening underground.

I still use this example because I knew enough to feel comfortable, but not enough to recognize what I hadn’t checked. Trust, but verify—especially the expensive things you can’t see.

What’s a missed inspection item or assumption that ended up costing you real money?

CORE Team | Realty ONE Group Supreme549 Reviews
1Reply
521 views

6 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 752 votes
    1w

    That $12k is exactly why I never trust a walkthrough alone. I scope the sewer on every house I buy, before I close, no exceptions. A lateral is not a maybe, it is a real number, and if I cannot see it, I price it like it is bad.

    Same rule on the rest of the rehab. I do not guess from photos. I walk the house and I price it from my own actuals, room by room, at 236 doors. If a line item is unknown, I put a real number on it and I put it in the all-in.

    Your ARV was fine. The miss was the all-in. If that $12k had been in the numbers on day one, the deal either still works or you pass it fast. That is the whole point of underwriting before you get attached to a deal.

    Did you add the scope to your pre-close checklist now?

  • Pittsburgh, Allegheny County · Member since 2026 · 92 posts · 36 votes
    6d

    Thanks for putting a real number on it, that's what gets people to book the scope. Around Pittsburgh, a number of municipalities require a sewer lateral inspection or dye test before a sale, and as-is purchases like sheriff sale houses usually never get looked at before closing. One more step I'd add: ask the municipality or sewer authority whether there are open repair orders on the lateral, since those can stick with the property after the sale. A camera scope usually runs a few hundred dollars, which is cheap next to an emergency dig under the street.

    • Matthew MorrowBusiness Member
      OP
      Investor · PA - NY - NJ · Member since 2019 · 975 posts · 354 votes
      6d

      Dan, that's a great add. The lateral piece is easy to miss, especially on as-is or sheriff sale deals where nobody is forcing the test. A quick call to the sewer authority about open repair orders is a cheap step that can save a lot of pain later. Adding that one to my list.

      CORE Team | Realty ONE Group Supreme549 Reviews
  • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6d

    Thank you for sharing this. My 6th property had tree roots that grew through the waste pipe in front yard and flooded 1st floor with sewage within days of my first tenant moving in. I missed a few key issues in that purchase that looking back were due to an inflated sense of ego. It was in a stellar neighborhood and ended up being a solid investment but humbling and more costly than I anticipated over the first couple of years. I have justified it in my mind as tuition costs and hopefully learned from my mistakes.

    • Matthew MorrowBusiness Member
      OP
      Investor · PA - NY - NJ · Member since 2019 · 975 posts · 354 votes
      1d

      @Jules Aton roots in the waste line with a tenant already in is a rough way to learn that one. I had the same kind of overconfidence after I finished my home inspector certification, and it cost me $12k on a two-unit when I skipped the sewer scope. Calling it tuition is fair if the property still works after you pay it. I scope every deal now, because that is the part I can actually change going forward.

      CORE Team | Realty ONE Group Supreme549 Reviews
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.