Can lender refuse escrow removal when there is no reason for it?

Can lender refuse escrow removal when there is no reason for it?

Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2021 · 36 posts · 16 votes

I have a conventional 30 yr mortgage for 3 years. I have always paid on time and recently canceled PMI so there is no PMI right now. I have a LTV <0.8. The lender said the investor (in my loan) has refused to remove my escrow account. But, there is no reason why lender insists on that when I have above parameters. The lender does not provide any reason as to why lender refuses it or what factor prevents them from doing so. I am in TX. I wrote a complaint on CFPB. What are my options?

0Reply
131 views

Most Popular Reply

Chris SeveneyBusiness Member
Moderator
Investor · VA · Member since 2015 · 21k+ posts · 19k+ votes
1y
Quote from @Turgut Oz:

I have a conventional 30 yr mortgage for 3 years. I have always paid on time and recently canceled PMI so there is no PMI right now. I have a LTV <0.8. The lender said the investor (in my loan) has refused to remove my escrow account. But, there is no reason why lender insists on that when I have above parameters. The lender does not provide any reason as to why lender refuses it or what factor prevents them from doing so. I am in TX. I wrote a complaint on CFPB. What are my options?


PMI and Escrow are two totally different things. Most loan documents require the property to be escrowed for taxes and insurance as that protects the lender to make sure they are being paid. The default rates on taxes and insurance I would bet are 10 fold compared to loans who have escrow because people live paycheck to paycheck and then when a big bill comes due they cannot pay it.

I would guess your loan documents require it

BTW why are you putting up a big fuss on having the servicer hold taxes and insurance escrow?

7e investments4.34 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

20 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Chris SeveneyBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Investor · VA · Member since 2015 · 21k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Turgut Oz:

    I have a conventional 30 yr mortgage for 3 years. I have always paid on time and recently canceled PMI so there is no PMI right now. I have a LTV <0.8. The lender said the investor (in my loan) has refused to remove my escrow account. But, there is no reason why lender insists on that when I have above parameters. The lender does not provide any reason as to why lender refuses it or what factor prevents them from doing so. I am in TX. I wrote a complaint on CFPB. What are my options?


    PMI and Escrow are two totally different things. Most loan documents require the property to be escrowed for taxes and insurance as that protects the lender to make sure they are being paid. The default rates on taxes and insurance I would bet are 10 fold compared to loans who have escrow because people live paycheck to paycheck and then when a big bill comes due they cannot pay it.

    I would guess your loan documents require it

    BTW why are you putting up a big fuss on having the servicer hold taxes and insurance escrow?

    7e investments4.34 Reviews
    • Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2021 · 36 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Chris Seveney:
      Quote from @Turgut Oz:

      I have a conventional 30 yr mortgage for 3 years. I have always paid on time and recently canceled PMI so there is no PMI right now. I have a LTV <0.8. The lender said the investor (in my loan) has refused to remove my escrow account. But, there is no reason why lender insists on that when I have above parameters. The lender does not provide any reason as to why lender refuses it or what factor prevents them from doing so. I am in TX. I wrote a complaint on CFPB. What are my options?


      PMI and Escrow are two totally different things. Most loan documents require the property to be escrowed for taxes and insurance as that protects the lender to make sure they are being paid. The default rates on taxes and insurance I would bet are 10 fold compared to loans who have escrow because people live paycheck to paycheck and then when a big bill comes due they cannot pay it.

      I would guess your loan documents require it

      BTW why are you putting up a big fuss on having the servicer hold taxes and insurance escrow?

      Is that a real question? Let me ask you this. Why would I not want to keep my own funds in my own control and use it how I want? 

    • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2018 · 829 posts · 811 votes
      1y

      while I agree impounds are good for lenders to reduce defaults, they are horrible for responsible borrowers. If I have 6 figures of taxes and insurance escrowed at 0% interest I am losing $20k+ of interest income.... and even worse opportunity cost is even more. 

    • Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2021 · 36 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Allan C.:

      while I agree impounds are good for lenders to reduce defaults, they are horrible for responsible borrowers. If I have 6 figures of taxes and insurance escrowed at 0% interest I am losing $20k+ of interest income.... and even worse opportunity cost is even more. 


       That is WHY they fight to retain it so hard...

  • Jay HurstBusiness Member
    Lender · Dallas, TX · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Turgut Oz:

    I have a conventional 30 yr mortgage for 3 years. I have always paid on time and recently canceled PMI so there is no PMI right now. I have a LTV <0.8. The lender said the investor (in my loan) has refused to remove my escrow account. But, there is no reason why lender insists on that when I have above parameters. The lender does not provide any reason as to why lender refuses it or what factor prevents them from doing so. I am in TX. I wrote a complaint on CFPB. What are my options?


     The servicer is not required by any law to remove an escrow account that has already been set up. As Chris points out, it is to their advantage for you to have an escrow account for both the reason he points out but also a higher servicing fee from Fannie/Freddie in a high tax/insurance state like Texas.  Some servicers will do it, some for free, some for a fee, but they are not required to do it.

    Hurst Real Estate, INC4.986 Reviews
  • Houston, TX · Member since 2015 · 261 posts · 170 votes
    1y

    That's unfortunate to hear that they will not work with you even as you are up to date and not late on payments. I have a loan with Chase and they removed the escrow after about 2 years at my request with no fuss. I too would rather keep that money and pay it later

    • Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2021 · 36 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Gustavo Delgado:

      That's unfortunate to hear that they will not work with you even as you are up to date and not late on payments. I have a loan with Chase and they removed the escrow after about 2 years at my request with no fuss. I too would rather keep that money and pay it later


       Yes, that is what I do with all my loans and deploy those funds elsewhere until payment time comes in. 

  • Member since 2023 · 348 posts · 190 votes
    1y

    Totally understand your frustration, and it’s great to hear you’ve been so consistent with your payments and maintaining a strong equity position.

    From a lender's standpoint, even when a borrower meets general eligibility criteria (like a strong payment history and low LTV), the ability to remove an escrow account isn't always at the lender's discretion alone. In many cases, it depends on who owns the loan—such as Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, or a private investor. Each has its own servicing guidelines that the lender or servicer must follow, and sometimes those guidelines restrict escrow waivers regardless of borrower performance.

    Since you're in Texas, it's also worth noting that certain state-specific regulations or risk factors related to property taxes and insurance premiums can come into play, and some investors see escrow as a way to protect the asset and ensure those payments are made on time.

    • Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2021 · 36 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Katie Smith:

      Totally understand your frustration, and it’s great to hear you’ve been so consistent with your payments and maintaining a strong equity position.

      From a lender's standpoint, even when a borrower meets general eligibility criteria (like a strong payment history and low LTV), the ability to remove an escrow account isn't always at the lender's discretion alone. In many cases, it depends on who owns the loan—such as Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, or a private investor. Each has its own servicing guidelines that the lender or servicer must follow, and sometimes those guidelines restrict escrow waivers regardless of borrower performance.

      Since you're in Texas, it's also worth noting that certain state-specific regulations or risk factors related to property taxes and insurance premiums can come into play, and some investors see escrow as a way to protect the asset and ensure those payments are made on time.


       Thanks for the response. I wish they provided better answers so I'd know what exactly they are concerned with. 

  • Michael MagnoBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Wadsworth, OH · Member since 2017 · 234 posts · 168 votes
    1y

    I believe this is going to be specific to your particular mortgage documents, and how the lender wrote the mortgage. 

  • Erik EstradaBusiness Member
    Lender · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2022 · 7k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Turgut Oz:

    I have a conventional 30 yr mortgage for 3 years. I have always paid on time and recently canceled PMI so there is no PMI right now. I have a LTV <0.8. The lender said the investor (in my loan) has refused to remove my escrow account. But, there is no reason why lender insists on that when I have above parameters. The lender does not provide any reason as to why lender refuses it or what factor prevents them from doing so. I am in TX. I wrote a complaint on CFPB. What are my options?


     Did you check the loan documents that you signed when you took out the loan? 

    LuxePrivate Investments LLC 571 Reviews
  • Member since 2024 · 65 posts · 63 votes
    1y

    Personally I think it’s one of the largest injustices done to the American homeowner. Imagine the amount of purchasing power taken out of the economy at any given time so insurance companies and banks can lower risk for themselves.  Granted it all gets paid (or should get paid) in the end but I’d rather have control of my cash vs paying it in escrow.  I’ve always thought this is an overlooked issue that banks and insurance companies have gotten away with.

    • Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2021 · 36 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @Stetson Oates:

      Personally I think it’s one of the largest injustices done to the American homeowner. Imagine the amount of purchasing power taken out of the economy at any given time so insurance companies and banks can lower risk for themselves.  Granted it all gets paid (or should get paid) in the end but I’d rather have control of my cash vs paying it in escrow.  I’ve always thought this is an overlooked issue that banks and insurance companies have gotten away with.


       Totally agree. They want to keep it for the same reasons, we, homeowners want to keep it. I am ok with this until certain equity but it seems like they want to hold on to it forever!

  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    1y

    Most people would be in doomsday scenario if escrow were removed, because a significant portion of buyers would not be disciplined enough to set aside the funds themselves for payment and would then be in tax or insurance default. Your partner (the bank) knows this, which is why they're not crazy about the idea.

    That said, I agree with you about removing escrow if you're the type that knows what you are doing and always keeps sufficient reserves (I don't really get the redeploying the capital other than keeping it somewhere safe and liquid, since you'll need it every year like clockwork). I hate escrow for 3 personal reasons:

    1. I have had two different instances in the past where my lender failed to pay property tax and insurance. In both cases I had to pay out of pocket until it was resolved. Both were eventually resolved but at great time & aggravation to me.

    2. I do not trust the record keeping of lenders. I had a loan once sold 3 times in 2 years, and the last buyer suddenly insisted I had a $25 late fee on my account for some mystery late payment from years earlier from one of the previous note holders. When I inquired which lender & which payment (I keep records on everything), they couldn't identify it, only told me that I'd keep getting the notice it was on my account until I paid it. Coda: I told them they could kick rocks unless they identified what payment & lender it was, and that they could send me letters until I was dead and I'd sooner set $25 on fire in the middle of the lawn first. After 2 years of sending the monthly letter (they probably spent more on letters than $25), I suddenly got a letter one day that because of my excellent payment record they were granting me a courtesy convenience waiver of the fee.

    3. I like paying my insurance and taxes depending on when I need deductions. Sometimes I pay just before the end of the year, other times I will pay just the minimum on insurance and/or taxes before our 2/28 deadline depending on where I am with write-offs. I don't get that luxury with escrow. 

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
    • Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2021 · 36 posts · 16 votes
      1y
      Quote from @JD Martin:

      Most people would be in doomsday scenario if escrow were removed, because a significant portion of buyers would not be disciplined enough to set aside the funds themselves for payment and would then be in tax or insurance default. Your partner (the bank) knows this, which is why they're not crazy about the idea.

      That said, I agree with you about removing escrow if you're the type that knows what you are doing and always keeps sufficient reserves (I don't really get the redeploying the capital other than keeping it somewhere safe and liquid, since you'll need it every year like clockwork). I hate escrow for 3 personal reasons:

      1. I have had two different instances in the past where my lender failed to pay property tax and insurance. In both cases I had to pay out of pocket until it was resolved. Both were eventually resolved but at great time & aggravation to me.

      2. I do not trust the record keeping of lenders. I had a loan once sold 3 times in 2 years, and the last buyer suddenly insisted I had a $25 late fee on my account for some mystery late payment from years earlier from one of the previous note holders. When I inquired which lender & which payment (I keep records on everything), they couldn't identify it, only told me that I'd keep getting the notice it was on my account until I paid it. Coda: I told them they could kick rocks unless they identified what payment & lender it was, and that they could send me letters until I was dead and I'd sooner set $25 on fire in the middle of the lawn first. After 2 years of sending the monthly letter (they probably spent more on letters than $25), I suddenly got a letter one day that because of my excellent payment record they were granting me a courtesy convenience waiver of the fee.

      3. I like paying my insurance and taxes depending on when I need deductions. Sometimes I pay just before the end of the year, other times I will pay just the minimum on insurance and/or taxes before our 2/28 deadline depending on where I am with write-offs. I don't get that luxury with escrow. 

      A similar thing happened to me as well. I spent hours with their customer service (most are off-shore by the way) to get the accounting done right. I think there has been a lot of companies popping up recent years calling themselves "XYZ Capital" and get into the industry without proper support for their customers. That is a another problem though. 
  • Lender · Charleston, SC · Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    For a lot of lenders, there is a pricing adjustment when a loan is originated to waive escrows. As other have said, escrows/impounds for taxes and insurance materially decrease the risk in the loan. Many people are undisciplined and will spend this money if it's not escrowed and then will be unable to pay taxes and insurance when due. This leaves the lender/servicer to advance the funds needed or puts the collateral at risk if not paid.

    You're asking the lender to bear more risk for your benefit. This typically comes with a cost, and usually that cost is the pricing adjustment, although some will waive escrows later for a fee. You don't get a gold star for paying your loan on time; this is the baseline expectation and is what you agreed to do when you took the money. 

    Ultimately, the source of truth for whether you can have escrow cancelled will be your loan documents. If there is a provision for this in the terms, then pursue it. If not, then you don't have a leg to stand on and filing a CFPB complaint will do nothing. 

  • Member since 2025 · 250 posts · 101 votes
    1y

    @Turgut Oz If your LTV is solid and payments are on time, sounds off. CFPB is a smart step. Maybe time to shop refi options with more flexible terms?

  • Real Estate Broker · Coppell, TX · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    1y

    I think CFPB is dissolved or soon will be.  DOGE effect.

    There was a brief period of time where strong borrowers and even some weak borrowers were allowed to waive escrows.  It didn't work out all that well for lenders.  If you can't pay monthly, then how are you going to pay this big chunk when they become due.  This caused a lot of foreclosures, because the borrowers just couldn't pay.  Then the whiplash happened and even responsible and well positioned borrowers were forced to escrow again.    For a short time some lenders decided they didn't want to be responsible for escrow and I don't think that lasted very long.  My lender on my personal home mortgage was one of those.  I didn't have a choice.   I still pay my own taxes and insurance. 

    So you can ask, but don't sweat the small stuff.  You're not going to get wealthy playing small games like fighting escrow and writing to CFPB.  Fight for things like bonus depreciation or lower deficits that would help lower interest rates for investors, or more opportunity zones, or something that will really move the needle for you.  Fight rental inspections, or rogue JPs who don't follow eviction law or 100 other issues that will make a difference.

  • Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2021 · 36 posts · 16 votes
    1y

    A little late on this post but I will add this anyway for future readers to benefit from this discussion. CFPB actually worked and I was able to remove that escrow although it required a bit fighting. I removed it from three properties in total this year so I can invest those thousands of dollars elsewhere and make profit off of my own money and still pay my dues when its time comes (property tax etc).

    I highly recommend everyone doing the same if they have similar concerns.

    • Jay HurstBusiness Member
      Lender · Dallas, TX · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      1y
      Quote from @Turgut Oz:

      A little late on this post but I will add this anyway for future readers to benefit from this discussion. CFPB actually worked and I was able to remove that escrow although it required a bit fighting. I removed it from three properties in total this year so I can invest those thousands of dollars elsewhere and make profit off of my own money and still pay my dues when its time comes (property tax etc).

      I highly recommend everyone doing the same if they have similar concerns.


      Glad you got it done. Love to hear what the CFPB had to with it?  

      Hurst Real Estate, INC4.986 Reviews
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.