Here is my
situation. I am NYC based with a solid W2 job in tech and I own one out of
state rental property. As I am sure you could guess I pay an insane amount in
taxes every year. I am looking for ways to reduce my tax bill outside of
traditional strategies for a w-2 employee (Max 401k, HAS, etc). I do really
like my job and don't plan on being a full time entrepreneur
Would love to
connect. I have explored ideas like starting an LLC, doing a cost segregation
on my property, short term rental loophole, etc.
@William White, you can use real estate related losses to shelter your W-2 income.
The big obstacle here is Section 469 tax law which says two things super relevant to your situation. One that you can't use passive losses to shelter your nonpassive income... Two that the general rule for real estate is it's considered passive.
Thus, the two obvious tactics to consider:
1. Talk your spouse into becoming a real estate professional so real estate rentals aren't for you automatically passive. (You guys will still need to materially participate.)
2. Invest in something like an STR that ironically, isn't considered real estate which means all you need to do is materially participate. (That can be done with a few hours a year if carefully structured.)
Here is my
situation. I am NYC based with a solid W2 job in tech and I own one out of
state rental property. As I am sure you could guess I pay an insane amount in
taxes every year. I am looking for ways to reduce my tax bill outside of
traditional strategies for a w-2 employee (Max 401k, HAS, etc). I do really
like my job and don't plan on being a full time entrepreneur
Would love to
connect. I have explored ideas like starting an LLC, doing a cost segregation
on my property, short term rental loophole, etc.
LLC does nothing for taxes, its a disregarded entity and passes right back through you.
Other options are to invest in syndications that take larger depreciation such as some oil and gas or Multifamily offerings. Just realize you are just deferring taxes not reducing your liability.
you're not going yo meaningfully reduce your W2 tax burden, so better that you focus your energy on increasing your income.
let's hypothetically say you can find $50k/yr losses to offset W2 income. that ultimately becomes $25k/yr net savings, which isn't insignificant, but it's likely not going to be worth the effort. you'll need a fair amount of capital or effort to generate $50k/yr losses, and its better to focus ther effort/capital on somerthing that's aligned with your investment strategy anr interests.
You're on the right track. To lower your tax bill beyond 401k and HSA, focus on real estate strategies. Cost segregation on your rental can front-load depreciation, which creates big paper losses. If you convert it to a short-term rental and materially participate, you might be able to use those losses to offset W2 income (that's the STR loophole).
An LLC doesn't lower taxes by itself, but if you start a side business (consulting, property management, etc.), you could open up more deductions and possibly reduce self-employment tax with an S-Corp.
Best move now? Work with a CPA who really understands real estate. That’ll help you unlock more of what you’re already doing.
Here is my
situation. I am NYC based with a solid W2 job in tech and I own one out of
state rental property. As I am sure you could guess I pay an insane amount in
taxes every year. I am looking for ways to reduce my tax bill outside of
traditional strategies for a w-2 employee (Max 401k, HAS, etc). I do really
like my job and don't plan on being a full time entrepreneur
Would love to
connect. I have explored ideas like starting an LLC, doing a cost segregation
on my property, short term rental loophole, etc.
Hi Will, how much income is this property generating over expenses? Are you taking full advantage of the write-offs available, such as interest, property taxes, insurance, repairs/maintenance, etc.? If you are fully offsetting you're income though expenses and carrying over any losses, you are in a good spot I'd say.
A cost segregation may not have an impact right now only because excess passive activity losses will be carried over either way if your deductions are already fully offsetting your income (it would suspend the losses, so it would be more useful potentially in the future).
For the short term rental, you would have to meet the material participation and average rental period tests. Most rental owners with a full time W2 job usually do not meet the material participation test (but not impossible!).
However, one option you may qualify for is the $25k active participation write-off. This would allow you to offset some of your passive rental losses against your ordinary income (like W-2 income, etc), but it does get phased out as you earn more money, so its not a guarantee.
Also, as for forming an LLC, it would be treated as a disregarded entity, which means the rental property would not have a separate tax return and would still be filed on your personal tax return. It would give you greater risk protection if that is something that you were interested in, but otherwise filing on Sch E is sufficient for now.
Here is my
situation. I am NYC based with a solid W2 job in tech and I own one out of
state rental property. As I am sure you could guess I pay an insane amount in
taxes every year. I am looking for ways to reduce my tax bill outside of
traditional strategies for a w-2 employee (Max 401k, HAS, etc). I do really
like my job and don't plan on being a full time entrepreneur
Would love to
connect. I have explored ideas like starting an LLC, doing a cost segregation
on my property, short term rental loophole, etc.
Starting an LLC is not a tax-saving strategy—it's primarily an asset protection strategy that helps limit personal liability but generally does not change how your income is taxed.
Starting an LLC is not a tax-saving strategy—it's primarily an asset protection strategy that helps limit personal liability but generally does not change how your income is taxed.
@William White, you can use real estate related losses to shelter your W-2 income.
The big obstacle here is Section 469 tax law which says two things super relevant to your situation. One that you can't use passive losses to shelter your nonpassive income... Two that the general rule for real estate is it's considered passive.
Thus, the two obvious tactics to consider:
1. Talk your spouse into becoming a real estate professional so real estate rentals aren't for you automatically passive. (You guys will still need to materially participate.)
2. Invest in something like an STR that ironically, isn't considered real estate which means all you need to do is materially participate. (That can be done with a few hours a year if carefully structured.)
@William White As a NYC W-2 tech employee with an out-of-state rental, your best tax-saving options beyond 401(k)/HSA are:
Short-Term Rental (STR) Loophole: If average stays are ≤7 days and you materially participate (e.g., 100+ hours, more than anyone else), you can offset W-2 income using rental losses, no REP status needed.
Cost Segregation and Bonus Depreciation: Accelerate depreciation (80% bonus in 2024) to generate large paper losses. Combine with STR loophole to offset W-2 income.
LLC: Offers legal protection, but no tax benefits unless you're flipping or managing rentals as a business.
Family Tax Strategy: Hire your kids for real rental work, pay them tax-free (up to $13,850), and fund Roth IRAs or cover college costs.
Real Estate Professional (REP): Difficult with a full-time job, but if your spouse qualifies, all rental losses can offset W-2 income.
These strategies can unlock major tax savings when structured and documented correctly.
This post does not create a CPA-Client relationship. The information contained in this post is not to be relied upon. Readers should seek professional advice.
If your income is on the higher side, the best next step isn’t just trying piecemeal strategies here and there—it’s sitting down with a tax professional for a full tax plan. That way, you’ll get a detailed understanding of your specific situation and they can show you which strategies actually apply to you (and which ones don’t). You’ll get much better, personalized advice than what you’ll find from general tips online.
You can definitely use real estate losses to offset W-2 income, but the main hurdle is Section 469 of the tax code. This rule says you can’t use passive real estate losses to offset non-passive income like wages, and by default real estate is considered passive.
There are a couple of ways around this. One option is qualifying as a real estate professional, or having your spouse qualify, so that your real estate activity isn’t automatically passive. You would still need to materially participate, but it opens the door to using those losses. Another option is investing in short-term rentals, which aren’t treated the same way under the rules. As long as you materially participate, the losses from short-term rentals can be used against W-2 income. In some cases, it only takes a few hours of active involvement each year if it’s structured properly.