Asset protection...does it even matter?

Asset protection...does it even matter?

West Bend, WI · Member since 2016 · 18 posts · 13 votes

My question is mostly out of curiosity. Does anyone on here have any example of you or anyone else being sued and losing the entire asset, business or worse?

I hear so much about asset protection and it just gets me thinking, I've never heard of anyone being sued and losing everything or losing the asset. I own a couple rentals in a LLC with million dollar+ liability coverage, the likelihood that I would be sued and loose excess of that seems highly unlikely. Seems to me that if something major does come up the insurance will pick it up, and if not you will likely be held liable personally anyway for some reason or another.

3Reply
156 views

Most Popular Reply

Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
Moderator
Real Estate Broker · Cody, WY · Member since 2010 · 28k+ posts · 41k+ votes
8y

I think asset protection is over-hyped. I know people with 50+ rentals all owned in their personal name. They've never been sued, they've never lost an asset, and they certainly didn't lose everything. I manage rentals for over 150 different owners and not one of them has ever been sued. I can't even think of a single person on BP that's lost an asset.

Can it happen? Sure. Your kid could also be kidnapped walking home from school. In fact, it's probably more likely. Even more likely is that you'll die in a car accident within one mile of your home but I bet that doesn't stop you from driving every day. 

The best thing you can do to protect your assets is to operate within the law. Treat people honestly and fairly. They can still try to sue you but justice will almost always prevail if you are truly honest.

I personally intend to set up an LLC and place my properties there just to separate them from my personal assets, but I'm not rushing to do it and I don't lose sleep over it.

The DIY Landlord Book4.7245 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

61 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Vendor · Kansas City, MO · Member since 2014 · 22 posts · 6 votes
    8y
    My two cents. Asset protection matters when you have assets to protect. In this world there are people with assets and those without. If you mistake yourself as one without it may just be a matter of time that it will become a self fulfilling prophesy.
  • Member since 2016 · 13k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    8y

    @Jay Hinrichs

    "free and clear at the end of the day is were you want to be.."

    As a investor free and clear real estate is not investing, it is hoarding. I prefer to make my money earn it's keep. When I stopped pulling equity to grow my real estate portfolio I diverted that cash/equity to investments out side real estate. As a investor cash sitting as dead equity saving 4% on a mortgage is not earning it's keep.

    High leveraged property is not at risk if the cash is invested elsewhere as a reserve. If investors feel the need to hoard cash as dead equity for fear the sky is going to fall it's time for them to get out of the game. Sell and put th emoney in a safety deposit box

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Thomas S.:

    @Jay Hinrichs

    "free and clear at the end of the day is were you want to be.."

    As a investor free and clear real estate is not investing, it is hoarding. I prefer to make my money earn it's keep. When I stopped pulling equity to grow my real estate portfolio I diverted that cash/equity to investments out side real estate. As a investor cash sitting as dead equity saving 4% on a mortgage is not earning it's keep.

    High leveraged property is not at risk if the cash is invested elsewhere as a reserve. If investors feel the need to hoard cash as dead equity for fear the sky is going to fall it's time for them to get out of the game. Sell and put th emoney in a safety deposit box

    don't think the risk of debt to the max is worth the delta .. we all have our things..  but free and clear rentals are a nice place to be.. don't care what anyone says.... just ask all those from 07 to 2011 who lost their rental properties because of max debt and tenants fleeing... not much you can do when your 100% vacant and that way for a long time.. Most investors as you know with max debt many times do not have enough liquidity to carry their portfolio for any length of time.   

  • tallahassee, FL · Member since 2017 · 4 posts · 1 vote
    8y

    Lots of exemptions w/ insurance policies. GL will try and find any loophole they can to not actually pay out on a claim (e.g. owner's negligence); leaving you holding the bag.

  • Contractor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2014 · 123 posts · 115 votes
    8y

    They are your assets. If you want to leave them exposed to save a few bucks, that's your call. To me, protecting what I build to the best of my ability is important to me. Setting up an LLC in several states costs $100, which is a low price to pay for protection. I set all mine up myself. I'm not an attorney and I did not stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night, but it's pretty straightforward. I am with @Jay Hinrichs. Paying everything down and having no vig to cover is what I am working towards. I don't think you are wrong or stupid if you have a different view. Everybody has their own approach, and many people have been successful using many different approaches.

  • Jerry W.Pro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Thermopolis, WY · Member since 2012 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    8y

    There are so many really good and true statements here that I love, like @Jay Hinrichs long post. It is dead on correct. There truly are some ways to avoid liability. There are some very good posts with very bad advice buried in them as well. First off the only way to truly avoid liability on your assets is to not have them be your assets. All this hype about them not being able to get money or property out of intervivos trust is incorrect, you cannot make a trust to yourself that you control and keep it away from creditors. It is stupid in some cases. Now an irrevocable trust can keep assets away from creditors but you must turn over control permanently to someone else. How many folks are willing to do that? Are you willing to have no say in what houses are bought? Or how much contractors get paid or what tenants get placed? Not me. Lawsuits do happen, many are not justified, they are getting worse every day, still you are much more likely to have a natural disaster then a lawsuit. A flood, a tornado, or hurricane, a fire, landslide, windstorm, hailstorm, blizzard, major economic recession, etc. LLCs do work, at least in my state. it is dam hard to pierce an LLC in Wyoming. One of the best ways to pierce the veil and get to the person behind the LLC or corporation is siphon off the assets with fake or fraudulent mortgages. Do you really think they won't look up who got the mortgage? If there was not money exchanged or if the money went into the pocket of the LLC owner it is one of the best ways to get sued personally. You create more liability by doing the fake mortgage than you prevent. Folks say no the mortgage isn't fake or fraudulent. OK so why did the LLC suddenly need money? Why isn't that money from the mortgage deposited into the LLC? Think about it. You have a paid off property worth $200K and you get a mortgage for 80% or $160K, where did the $160k go? If your LLC now doesn't have the money to cover a $50K lawsuit it has been intentionally under capitalized. That is a basis to pierce the veil. Much of the advice here is good, but some is dead wrong. The folks giving the advice are kind, intelligent and it is great that they are sharing their knowledge, but they are wrong and if you follow the advice it could cost you a lot. Having different LLCs or entities does break up the potential liability by limiting damages to only those assets in each LLC, IF the activity is liable to the LLC not the person who did the act! Example drive the company car drunk and run over a kid in a crosswalk and all the LLCs wont stop the lawsuit that goes after all your assets. If it is a slip and fall it will stay in one LLC. The proper LLC will in some states keep the damages limited to a charging order. That means they can garnish your payments directed to you by the LLC, but cannot take your place in the LLC because you cannot force a new partner on the other owners. I do not think all states have charging order protection, but again my state does.

  • Multifamily Syndicator · Houston, TX · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8y

    Oh, another reason is simply taking a proactive approach to asset protection by anonymizing yourself during the company formation, so that when there is an initial search performed on your name, not a lot comes back in terms of asset ownership. 

    All in all, it's best to be proactive than reactive, you just never know, as we live in a litigious society!

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    8y

    @Jerry W.  as you know 95% of these folks will never get sued  and 99% will never see the inside of a courtroom..  litigation in real estate is reserved for us guys that do it for a living  LOL.

    the average mom and pop I want to own rentals and retire financially free crowd.  as long as they are not slumlords I totally agree the risk is just not that great..  Kind of like in the event of a water landing in a commercial Jet.. 

    I have north of 10 LLC's personally for all sorts of various activities.. and do probably 250 plus transactions a year.. in the last 10 years I have one actual lawsuit and that was over a contract dispute that has gotten settled.. lots of sabor rattling.. but end of the day you really have to be stubborn to make it all the way in front of a trier of fact.

    And in our market were small claims in 7500 .. you can cover most things there is you really want to sue the b$$st$ard for a 3k wrong doing.. like we see folks post about on BP.

    Other wise I do believe proper insurance is important.. I know in the building of new construction we pay a ton.. and we do need it for builder defects etc.. even then.. we simply fix the problem and don't let things get out of hand..  

    I know we talk about being litigious but sometimes I think its more the FEAR of litigation than the real litigation itself.. 

    Bottom line is though to actually get to courtroom as you know both sides have probably spent at least 50k large on attorney fee's and that usually cuts the wheat from the Chaff... and I love the I am only doing this on principal attitude that tends to go out the window when money is flowing out the window as well.

    AS I state the well to do folks I know Have all sorts of family trust revocable and irrevocable.. and or just in LLC's with proper insurance...

  • Haverhill, MA · Member since 2016 · 27 posts · 2 votes
    8y
    I just recently got demand letter and expecting to get sue for a slip and fall incident. Home insurance policy denies liability, so the attorney decided to use MGL chap 93a( consumer protection act )and the insurance rep says they can’t provide legal representation if lawsuit claims are for 93a statue...I’m now on my own looking for legal rep to response to demand letter. Any help would be appreciated
  • San Antonio, TX · Member since 2009 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    8y

    @Andrew Millard It does happen. But honestly, if you put the right types of tenants in your properties (those who won't sue you!!) and run your business ethically it's less likely to happen. Have never run across this myself or personally known others to go to court over this. Though, I do know a handful of real estate brokers and agents who've had to deal with these issues with disgruntled customers. Hope that helps!! 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.