My question is mostly out of curiosity. Does anyone on here have any example of you or anyone else being sued and losing the entire asset, business or worse?
I hear so much about asset protection and it just gets me thinking, I've never heard of anyone being sued and losing everything or losing the asset. I own a couple rentals in a LLC with million dollar+ liability coverage, the likelihood that I would be sued and loose excess of that seems highly unlikely. Seems to me that if something major does come up the insurance will pick it up, and if not you will likely be held liable personally anyway for some reason or another.
I think asset protection is over-hyped. I know people with 50+ rentals all owned in their personal name. They've never been sued, they've never lost an asset, and they certainly didn't lose everything. I manage rentals for over 150 different owners and not one of them has ever been sued. I can't even think of a single person on BP that's lost an asset.
Can it happen? Sure. Your kid could also be kidnapped walking home from school. In fact, it's probably more likely. Even more likely is that you'll die in a car accident within one mile of your home but I bet that doesn't stop you from driving every day.
The best thing you can do to protect your assets is to operate within the law. Treat people honestly and fairly. They can still try to sue you but justice will almost always prevail if you are truly honest.
I personally intend to set up an LLC and place my properties there just to separate them from my personal assets, but I'm not rushing to do it and I don't lose sleep over it.
I doubt that a whole lot of people are going to come on here and brag about getting their pants sued off. Many of them may not even be in the real estate game any more. Yes there are plenty of examples of people getting sued, but I agree with whoever pointed out that this isn't the place to find them. Asking on BP if anyone has ever been sued and then using the lack of personal responses as evidence that it doesn't actually happen is flawed evidence. No, I have not been sued. No I don't know how many lawsuits I may have avoided because of my asset protection plan because you cannot prove a negative. Yes I know of many stories of people getting sued. And yes, I personally know people that have been sued because of their real estate investing. Just like Thomas knew there wouldn't be any first person responses, I'm sure the folks that are flabbergasted we use business entities as part of our asset protection plan will not come back to BP and warn us of the dangers if they ever get sued for more than their umbrella policy. Or if their insurance company claims they aren't covered for some reason. Like I originally pointed out, just do what's right for you.
Jeff - I did not know this! I learned something new today, thanks for sharing
For those that fear a law suit the best psychological protection is a LLC. Assuming of course that you have faith in it protecting you. Without that faith it does not serve your needs.
It can be pierced under many circumstances, contrary to common belief, and it is virtually impossible for investors to remain anonymous with todays technology and social media. Any forum member on here that uses their real identity has probably jeopardised the security/privacy of a LLC in some way or other.
I am not suggesting that investors in the US not use a LLC, your legal system does promote law suits like lottery tickets, I am suggesting it simply may not serve the full security purpose you may believe it does.
I think there's probably a lot of landlords who've been sued but you're just not hearing about it. Are you going to broadcast that you've been sued?
LLC's are way cheaper than insurance in most states. So why not ?
Doing something wrong has zero to do with getting sued. Too many crazies out there looking for a payday. In fact, you're going to be named just for being remotely associated. And sadly, it's not about the crazy lawsuit anyway - it's about the hopeful settlement that usually happens.
There are 2 types or origins of lawsuits that should be kept in mind. The two always get blended together as one in conversations about liability protection, but are totally different. Took me a long time to finally wrap my head around it.
1) Tenants sues LLC. LLC protects you personally, but the LLC's asset (the building) are up for grabs. A personal umbrella policy won't protect your building from being taken.
2) You get sued personally for something (car accident, crazy neighbor, etc). Your personal assets are up for grabs........your personally owned car, house etc. Yes you're llc protects your building. BUT your membership in an LLC is an asset. They can't get the building, but they can get your portion of the membership in an LLC singed over to them. Specifically the income from that portion. In theory, a personal umbrella should protect your LLC membership. Unless it goes over the $1 - 2mil typical limits.
The question of LLC umbrella insurance vs. personal umbrella insurance is one I recently became aware of. I just submitted paperwork to form an LLC in TX ($300) and spoke with my insurance agent about an umbrella policy. She suggested an umbrella policy for the LLC, rather than a personal umbrella policy. Do people have a preference for an umbrella insurance policy being for an LLC or a personal policy?
Regarding the general issue, the cost of an LLC is so low the only reason I can think of to not have one is if it would cause someone problems with financing (which it won't be for me).
Jeff - I did not know this! I learned something new today, thanks for sharing
This is true, but if your LLC is set up properly there are ways around it that put you back in the driver's seat when the settlement negotiations begin.
It can be pierced under many circumstances, contrary to common belief, and it is virtually impossible for investors to remain anonymous with todays technology and social media. Any forum member on here that uses their real identity has probably jeopardised the security/privacy of a LLC in some way or other.
It is actually exceedingly difficult to pierce a properly established and maintained LLC. To your point, though, probably the vast majority of people do not spend the time and money necessary to either properly establish nor maintain their LLC.
If you have any kind of assets or liability (i.e. doctor, contractor, lawyer, real estate investor, etc.) I believe you should have a personal umbrella policy. Insurance pays to defend you if you are sued and pays out if you are found liable. In the case of the LLC, though, it is overkill. You do need to be adequately insured or it will be ammunition used against you to try and pierce the LLC, but ideally, at least for smaller RE Investors, no single LLC should hold enough assets to warrant an umbrella policy. Only if that is unavoidable would I consider that. For example you have a single multi-million dollar property in the LLC.
"exceedingly difficult" Although possible which is why I view a LLC as basely physiological protection.
The greatest value in a LLC is in having the faith that it will not be pierced. Faith in the protection a LLC offers rather than the LLC itself allows them to sleep better at night.
"exceedingly difficult" Although possible which is why I view a LLC as basely physiological protection.
The greatest value in a LLC is in having the faith that it will not be pierced. Faith in the protection a LLC offers rather than the LLC itself allows them to sleep better at night.
Yeah, but then so is insurance for that matter. Or are you are arguing that insurance is an infallible protection plan?
No not arguing anything is infallible. I do however believe that if your insurance does not protect you then it is probably unlikely a LLC would either.
Maybe putting two diapers on a baby is better protection but I simply do not see it as being necessary, warranted or practical.
Again I believe the value, and there is value, is in having the faith in a LLC that it will protect. If you lack faith in a LLC, in my personal opinion, it serves little actual purpose beyond insurance for the vast majority of investors on this site. I am not stating for all investors. I do believe any investor having employees should have a LLC for other reasons.
Faith: belief that is not based on proof
I have faith my insurance will protect me, I do not have faith that a LLC will provide more protection than adequate insurance coverage..
At this point I think we are pretty much arguing the same point. Except that you believe LLCs and Insurance do the same thing in the same way (two pairs of boots, two pairs of diapers) and I do not. Just because you put a diaper on doesn't mean you can ignore the A&D ointment. They protect in different ways. Regardless, it is probably best to just agree to disagree, lest this become yet another 100 post discussion on this topic where everyone leaves with the exact same stance that they entered with.
Don't forget folks, even if you have 1K to your name, a 2 mil judgement against you will follow you for life. One person locally had a 2 mil judgement against her; pitbull attacked someone.
if this happened this is what chapter 7 BK Is for and you start all over.. Also don't own a pitbull to start with..
LLC insurance land trusts all those can be pierced if someone is going to do it and not stop.. but remember we do have to use logic here.
plantiffs lawyers are only going to work on contingency if there is insurance and or the they REALLY think they can collect. so that means your very wealthy and your assets whatever they are are easily identified. through LLC or what have you.
Most tenants do not have the money for litigation.. end of that story.. and then it falls back to slumlording..
I think the few ways to really insulate your self if your that worried.
1. is a true irrevocable family trust with you as trustee and your kids as the bene to 95% of the assets.
3. start now and put your rentals in a charitable remainder trust.. this could work.
5. just don't own rentals be on the debt side only own notes .. and commercial if possible those have very little risk as they avoid dodd frank issues. and owner occ lender liability issues.
7. Be a true limited partner with top quality operators like syndicators or crowdfunders.. that will limit you to what ever you invested.. although your real risk there is the operator or the project does not go well and you lose money that's much more real than litigation.
Bottom line for 95% of the mom and pop landlords out there landlording done with a modicum of responsibility is just not a litigious thing. your assets are usually encumbered and tenants don't have the money to truly litigate..
In real estate most litigation is over botched contracts or claims of misrepresentations etc.
also generally speaking any money you have in a SDRA type vehicle cannot get touched.. so its good to max those out..
8. Do not allow dead equity to sit in a rental property. This is the honey that will attract lawsuits. Without equity there is very little incentive to file suit.
Unfortunately trying to convince conservative mortgage pay down investors that they are waving a flag and wearing a sign that says in bold letters "come and get me" is a waste of effort.
8. Do not allow dead equity to sit in a rental property. This is the honey that will attract lawsuits. Without equity there is very little incentive to file suit.
Unfortunately trying to convince conservative mortgage pay down investors that they are waving a flag and wearing a sign that says in bold letters "come and get me" is a waste of effort.
not paying off your properties in fear of litigation is bad !!! free and clear at the end of the day is were you want to be..
What is the typical annual cost for each LLC? I'm just trying to do a cost-benefit analysis with some numbers. I own a few rental properties but do not currently have them in an LLC. However, if it's a nominal annual cost to maintain an LLC for each property it would seem like a worthy expense. Can someone please give details to the average annual cost per LLC? Thanks.
Big difference between price and cost.
The price may be nominal. The cost if talking about back-door QCDs on little houses with debt? DOS risk. Title chain clouds. Title insurance and hazard insurance being invalid, etc. Crappy commercial financing moving forward. The cost/risk is very high.
I have yet to see a good risk/benefit ratio to little houses with debt being in LLCs. Commercial assets? You bet. It works for me there on all points mentioned.
8. Do not allow dead equity to sit in a rental property. This is the honey that will attract lawsuits. Without equity there is very little incentive to file suit.
Unfortunately trying to convince conservative mortgage pay down investors that they are waving a flag and wearing a sign that says in bold letters "come and get me" is a waste of effort.
not paying off your properties in fear of litigation is bad !!! free and clear at the end of the day is were you want to be..
Highly agree, Jay.
While having free and clear RE in your own name could be viewed as a target, self-encumbering is super simple. Especially if you have a generic sounding entity on the side to encumber it with. I just did that on a few. Moved some free and clear commercial assets into LLCs, then slapped huge DofTs on them the same day. Costed me $300 in legal and recording to cloak almost two commas worth.
Paying off property is not horrible I assure you. Go get some more tenants and toilets of you want. I was talking to a buddy last week over lunch. He agreed he would need 30-48 more units to net what I save in payments from last year's payoffs alone.
Scour 200 deals to find your new property if you want. Or overpay and landlord for free like most others are doing in the multi space these days. I'd rather reduce my debt service and take a nap until the frenzy ends.
I don't know how "important" asset protection is, but that is just a selling point attorneys and guru's use to scare you in to setting these vehicles up. Personally, I think LLC's and other vehicles are very valuable for a variety for reasons. If I can't sell a house because of seasoning requirements, I can still sell the LLC that owns the house. There are various ways to stack different vehicles to reduce and possibly eliminate tax liability. Land trusts can offer an immense amount of privacy in most states.
We manage properties for over 100 investors worldwide and several hundred investment properties. The Real Property Management Franchise has over 75,000 residential investment properties under management in North America, and asset protection is not something that we overly concern ourselves with. Partially because we implement policies and systems early on to reduce liability and to protect ourselves and our clients. In our particular office, we have never lost a civil suit, although we have had 3 or 4 initiated. We have settled civil suits just to make them go away, but they have been small security deposit disputes of $300 or less. Pretty minor stuff.
I would recommend talking to a business attorney who works very closely with Real Estate businesses. Asset protection is important if you are targeted and it is needed, but I don't think it's something to lose sleep over. Tax liability, mobility in the marketplace, and the ability to build financing options are much more important.
@Andrew Millard Oh landlords get sued. I hear about it here reading BP! As for losing their properties, usually cases are settled out of court. Either way, you'll lose time and money dealing with a lawsuit. Asset protection is important...just in case. But the best thing you can do as a landlord is properly screen your tenants. If you can find low maintenance tenants without the high maintenance mentality, you won't even have to deal with this problem. :)
What is the typical annual cost for each LLC? I'm just trying to do a cost-benefit analysis with some numbers. I own a few rental properties but do not currently have them in an LLC. However, if it's a nominal annual cost to maintain an LLC for each property it would seem like a worthy expense. Can someone please give details to the average annual cost per LLC? Thanks.
Big difference between price and cost.
The price may be nominal. The cost if talking about back-door QCDs on little houses with debt? DOS risk. Title chain clouds. Title insurance and hazard insurance being invalid, etc. Crappy commercial financing moving forward. The cost/risk is very high.
I have yet to see a good risk/benefit ratio to little houses with debt being in LLCs. Commercial assets? You bet. It works for me there on all points mentioned.
Thanks Steve for answering question. Greatly appreciate the response. I have single-family residential homes with existing debt on them, therefore to your point, the risk/benefit ratio may not seem like a worthy expense from a numerical perspective, but from a peace of mind perspective it could worth it.
Reminds me of Michael Gerber in his book The E Myth. He tells the story of Tom Watson, the founder of IBM. Tom Watson credits 3 special reasons for his success. (I'll skip to the third since it's the most relevant for this conversation). The third reason Mr. Watson listed for IBM's success was that once he had a picture of how IBM would look when his dream was in place and how such a company would have to act, he then realized that unless they began to act that way from the very beginning, they would never get there. In other words, if IBM was to become great company one day, it would have to act like a great company long before it ever became one.
With that being said, even though I currently only have single-family residences with moderate equity in them, I do dream of having hundreds of units one day with large amounts of equity in them. Therefore, I will begin the process now of placing them in an LLC. Thanks.
What is the typical annual cost for each LLC? I'm just trying to do a cost-benefit analysis with some numbers. I own a few rental properties but do not currently have them in an LLC. However, if it's a nominal annual cost to maintain an LLC for each property it would seem like a worthy expense. Can someone please give details to the average annual cost per LLC? Thanks.
Big difference between price and cost.
The price may be nominal. The cost if talking about back-door QCDs on little houses with debt? DOS risk. Title chain clouds. Title insurance and hazard insurance being invalid, etc. Crappy commercial financing moving forward. The cost/risk is very high.
I have yet to see a good risk/benefit ratio to little houses with debt being in LLCs. Commercial assets? You bet. It works for me there on all points mentioned.
Thanks Steve for answering question. Greatly appreciate the response. I have single-family residential homes with existing debt on them, therefore to your point, the risk/benefit ratio may not seem like a worthy expense from a numerical perspective, but from a peace of mind perspective it could worth it.
Reminds me of Michael Gerber in his book The E Myth. He tells the story of Tom Watson, the founder of IBM. Tom Watson credits 3 special reasons for his success. (I'll skip to the third since it's the most relevant for this conversation). The third reason Mr. Watson listed for IBM's success was that once he had a picture of how IBM would look when his dream was in place and how such a company would have to act, he then realized that unless they began to act that way from the very beginning, they would never get there. In other words, if IBM was to become great company one day, it would have to act like a great company long before it ever became one.
With that being said, even though I currently only have single-family residences with moderate equity in them, I do dream of having hundreds of units one day with large amounts of equity in them. Therefore, I will begin the process now of placing them in an LLC. Thanks.
I like your mindset!
If you do use QCDs, notify your property insurance to make sure you will still be covered. Ask your title co if your title ins will still be valid and make sure it wont make your title uninsurable for some reason in the future.
This are bigger risks to me than DOS, though thats there, too. Know and mitigate the risks is all I'm saying. Most just ask how much it costs to set up an LLC and pay no mind to the real insurance issues.
What is the typical annual cost for each LLC? I'm just trying to do a cost-benefit analysis with some numbers. I own a few rental properties but do not currently have them in an LLC. However, if it's a nominal annual cost to maintain an LLC for each property it would seem like a worthy expense. Can someone please give details to the average annual cost per LLC? Thanks.
Big difference between price and cost.
The price may be nominal. The cost if talking about back-door QCDs on little houses with debt? DOS risk. Title chain clouds. Title insurance and hazard insurance being invalid, etc. Crappy commercial financing moving forward. The cost/risk is very high.
I have yet to see a good risk/benefit ratio to little houses with debt being in LLCs. Commercial assets? You bet. It works for me there on all points mentioned.
Thanks Steve for answering question. Greatly appreciate the response. I have single-family residential homes with existing debt on them, therefore to your point, the risk/benefit ratio may not seem like a worthy expense from a numerical perspective, but from a peace of mind perspective it could worth it.
Reminds me of Michael Gerber in his book The E Myth. He tells the story of Tom Watson, the founder of IBM. Tom Watson credits 3 special reasons for his success. (I'll skip to the third since it's the most relevant for this conversation). The third reason Mr. Watson listed for IBM's success was that once he had a picture of how IBM would look when his dream was in place and how such a company would have to act, he then realized that unless they began to act that way from the very beginning, they would never get there. In other words, if IBM was to become great company one day, it would have to act like a great company long before it ever became one.
With that being said, even though I currently only have single-family residences with moderate equity in them, I do dream of having hundreds of units one day with large amounts of equity in them. Therefore, I will begin the process now of placing them in an LLC. Thanks.
I like your mindset!
If you do use QCDs, notify your property insurance to make sure you will still be covered. Ask your title co if your title ins will still be valid and make sure it wont make your title uninsurable for some reason in the future.
This are bigger risks to me than DOS, though thats there, too. Know and mitigate the risks is all I'm saying. Most just ask how much it costs to set up an LLC and pay no mind to the real insurance issues.
If your both sides of the QCD further insurance should not be much of an issue where its an issue is folks that rip equity and take title via QCD usually hand written or not done by a title co... those can create un insurable situations especially those using land trusts and are not well known by the title co. Guy PM off of BP a month or so ago and that is exactly what happened took title via QCD into a land trust had the sale ready to close but title co.. would not insure .. and then to make matters worse this guy could not get with the seller / reading between the lines bad blood... so your correct before someone does this checking on end game and exit should be checked out.
Response to @Caleb Heimsoth and others that want some protection and privacy. We have been using land trusts--intervivos revocable trusts, one for each property. OF COURSE one needs insurance, but remember to NOT have all your eggs in the same LLC basket.
The way to structure: IF a suit comes up for a slip/fall on property A, and they win big, the judgment will NOT attach or affect property B through Z. If all your properties are in your own name or in one LLC or Corp, ALL assets attached to that will be affected.
Even if you are sued personally for something outside of real estate (car or boating accident) and you lose BIG beyond insurance, the real estate held in trusts cannot be attached.
Over the last 25+ years, we have been involved in 3 lawsuits. Each one was simply 'legal blackmail', and the insurance company settled a $50,000 claim for about $2,000--nothing out of our pocket. (That one was for a tenant spilling hot oil on her foot while deep frying chicken. People can and do sue for ANYTHING!)