Should You Form a LLC for Each Individual Rental Property?

Should You Form a LLC for Each Individual Rental Property?

Investor · Corpus Christi, TX-Texas · Member since 2015 · 81 posts · 56 votes

My wife and I just bought our second property and were considering forming an LLC for them. I just read something that said some investors opt to form an LLC for each individual property as a shield so that any lawsuit could only be filed against THAT particular property and not risk having all other owned properties included in the suit. Seems a little overkill to me, but it does make sense.

Thoughts on this?

We've owned our first rental for almost 4 years now so it's definitely time to form something!

10Reply
1,674 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · Novato, CA · Member since 2018 · 110 posts · 145 votes
8y

I have an LLC for each of my properties. I agree with @Lance Lvovsky and @George Pauley. Risk vs. Reward.

It's an insurance policy.  

I walked into my lawyer's office expecting to get 1-2 LLCs.

He did a search on my name and within 30 seconds knew about all the properties I owned in that area.  He said, if someone were to get injured on one of my properties (hypothetically) and walked into his office wanting to sue me, he would most likely take that case based on the amount of houses I had and the assets to go after.  It convinced me that I wanted to do what I could to mitigate that risk.

To each their own - there's no right answer.  I'm just sharing my story with you. 

See this reply in the discussion

88 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Round Rock, TX · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 971 votes
    8y

    @Chase Cline My 2¢, your due diligence still required:

    1. You are in TX, and if your properties are in TX also, you definitely should look into Series-LLC as an alternative - then you don't need to worry about this question, as you can place a property in its own children Series-LLC that you can form when needed.

    2. Do you have a lot of equity/cash flow/personal assets to protect? Then an asset protection strategy might be required. Asset protection is a form of insurance - insurance against litigation. My recommendation would be to apply the "2% rule" - the cost of setting up and maintaining your asset protection should be less than 2% of equity you are trying to protect. Let's say, it costs you 1.5K to get your structures in place (holding LLC or Series-LLC, with or without land trusts, with or without separate operations LLC) and 0.5K per year (for maintaining the LLC properly, bookkeeping, lawyer and CPA, etc.) for a total of 2K. You should have 100K or more in equity to protect before it makes sense to spend that money - compare that with how much you spend in annual insurance for the same property/equity.

    3. Directly to your distribution question: you can have one or more per LLC, and that depends on multiple factors:

    • - property class - you might not want to mix A class property with a D class property in the same LLC, due to different tenant level
    • - cash flow - you might want to keep your cash flow cow separate from the ones that barely produce
    • - equity - you might want to keep the one with large equity in its own LLC while you can group the ones with little equity in another LLC (let's say you have one with 50K equity in its own LLC and 3 other each with only 10K in another LLC, till their equity grows to your risk threshold when you move them out in their own LLC).
    • - number of units (in the case of MF)
    • - location of real estate

    The investor has to decide what mix is optimal for their situation.

    4. Insurance is not going to cover you in all scenarios and amounts. Asset protection complements insurance. Ultimately, there is no absolute answer and unique tool/strategy in anything real estate. You need to learn how and when to use all the tools available to you (financing, insurance, management, etc.) and to understand how they fit together in your toolbox, as none will give you everything (e.g, insurance is required and it will cover you for many situations, but not always; asset protection (LLC) is litigation insurance and complements regular insurance, by minimizing the target and making it unappealing).

    5. You should also read these threads: break-portfolio-into-multiple-llcs and separate-llc-vs-one-llc.

    Bonus: my own diagram to help you in the asset protection question.

    "Ignorance is bliss. Knowledge is power, but also a burden. The cure to both - the 4 ions: education, action, progress(ion), not perfection".

  • Rental Property Investor · San Jose, CA · Member since 2015 · 401 posts · 221 votes
    8y
    Maybe it’s cheaper in your state, but in CA, it’s $800 per year to maintain the LLC. Depend on your situation, you can probably just buy insurance.
  • Kansas City, MO · Member since 2013 · 131 posts · 64 votes
    8y
    @Chase Cline I use a series LLC in my state of Missouri and am very happy with it. For me in blends asset protection with operational administration. I put a few properties in each series and don’t create a series for each property. As we grew we learned that would be an administrative headache to have a series for each property. Instead we base it on how much equity we feel is enough in each series. Someone above mentioned they cost $10K to create. Unfortunately that is misInformation, as the formation of a series LLC is only slightly more cumbersome that a regular LLC, and you can get it done for under $1K. Let me know if you’d like to discuss my structure further. Of course I’m not an attorney or cpa so please make sure to follow up with competent professional advice.
  • MBA, CFP®, EA · Columbus, OH · Member since 2018 · 175 posts · 207 votes
    8y
    @Chase Cline it can get confusing with banks accounts, etc. it will make accounting easier but most times I see investors grouping properties under LLC’s. I have grouped several of my own properties under different LLC’s based on location. It just all depends. Don’t get crazy with it.
  • Nate T.Pro Member
    Investor · Tempe, AZ · Member since 2014 · 146 posts · 74 votes
    8y

    You need multiple lines of defense. Insurance is number 1. LLC is number 2. Not creating an LLC because you're unlikely to get sued is the same as not getting hazard insurance because you're unlikely to have a fire. Bad idea.

    But regarding creating a single LLC for each property, that is fine for 5 properties, but with 50 or 100 that would be a nightmare if you have separate bank accounts and books for each one. And the legal fees and accounting fees could be quite onerous.

    There is another option where you only need 2 LLCs. It is referred to as equity stripping. You have one LLC that owns the properties, and a second LLC that loans money on each property. Even though you are the owner of both LLCs, these are still legitimately separate entities and legitimate loans. The loans should be for the full amount of the property value or higher. If you have a bank loan on a property, you can set up a second loan from your lender LLC, to cover the equity above the amount of the bank loan. You can set up the loans so that the interest accrues, so you don't have to track payments.

    Your lender LLC is unlikely to get sued, since it has no "risky" activity. Your property holding LLC is unlikely to get sued, because it has no equity. But if your property holding LLC does get sued, the creditor would have a tough time getting anything out of the LLC. In the case of a judgment, your lender LLC could even foreclose on the property and take the property from the property holding LLC, thereby wiping out the judgment.

  • Rental Property Investor · West Des Moines, IA · Member since 2014 · 17 posts · 7 votes
    8y
    @Tami R. May I ask who you use for your attorney and accountant?
  • Medford, NJ · Member since 2017 · 96 posts · 34 votes
    8y

    Hey everyone, I just wanted to chime in then I'll go back and see what everyone else wrote. All my properties on under one LLC. I'm from NJ and I was advised to do so by someone who was mentoring me through the begging stages of my REI journey. But now I question if it was the best choice. For one, my loan terms aren't as great because I need a commercial mortgage, my insurance premiums are higher each year, I need a lawyer for everything since I'm considered a business. Maybe this was all discussed in previous responses but I'll go back and review. My thought in this stage of the game after I have a little bit of knowledge is, "what is the LLC really protecting?" My assets are owned more by the bank then me. If someone came at me they'd realized I'm so leveraged that it's not worth their lawyers time. I'm actually considering a refi on all my notes under my personal name, this way other big ticket items such as my personal residence, stocks, etc. that are held under my name along with my wife's can't be touched in the unfortunate event something happens rental property related and someone comes after just me. However, I'm in no place to lend legal advice or tax advice but the points I put up are just some things I've been researching so that I am better prepared to make a smart decision. My commercial loans are going to balloon eventually so I may put everything in my name at that time. If I didn't need mortgages though, it would be a no brainier for me, everything would be in an LLC because I would have more to lose.

  • Member since 2018 · 13 posts · 8 votes
    8y

    I am currently in the process of figuring out the exact same thing, what I suggest is do lots of research. Don't set up the LLC's online, you will pay the money and they may not be done correctly which is what I did, I'm in the process of trying to find a good real estate attorney in CA, if anyone knows one? There's a podcast 109 that has lots of information, but honestly, I don't plan to use an attorney out of my state. I have quite a bit of equity living in CA and my rentals are practically paid for.....I spoke to my CPA and he had some input as well, seek legal advice and make sure you get that umbrella policy first from your insurance provider.

  • Nate T.Pro Member
    Investor · Tempe, AZ · Member since 2014 · 146 posts · 74 votes
    8y

    @Steve Boianelli

    When getting bank loans you can get them in your personal name and then change the title to an LLC. That way you have the better loan terms as well as the liability protection. Of course changing the title does violate the due on sale clause, but the likelihood of the loan getting called is minimal. So you can decide whether due-on-sale is a big enough risk to make it worth getting a more expensive commercial loan like you have been, or keeping the property title in your personal name.

    In my experience the insurance premiums are not affected by whether you own in your personal name versus LLC. Of course there's a price difference for owner occupied versus investment property.

  • Shea SpinelliPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Tyler, TX · Member since 2016 · 198 posts · 89 votes
    8y

    We have 15 in one LLC with a DBA.

  • Medford, NJ · Member since 2017 · 96 posts · 34 votes
    8y

    @Nate T.

    I have considered what you suggested regarding transferring title to my LLC after a refi. I am concerned about the due on sale clause. Has anyone out there done this? Transferred from personal to LLC? It seems risky to me to take the chance they'll call the note due. Can anyone touch on that?

    As for insurance premiums, I have one property that sites in the middle of two commercial buildings. My broker couldn't get me my typically personal rate since it was so close to businesses and the homes are in my LLC. I guess I can't complain about that. But in REI it's all about ROI, higher premiums over a few years adds up.

  • Real Estate Agent · College Station, TX · Member since 2017 · 2 posts · 0 votes
    8y

    Series LLC. Best way in my opinion for multiple Properties. The big thing is letting your lender know if you switch it from personal to LLC. Because they can call the loan due in full if you don't notify them. Most Real Estate attorneys can set up a Series LLC for around $1-2K.

  • New to Real Estate · Frisco, TX · Member since 2018 · 13 posts · 5 votes
    8y
    I am just starting my REI journey so I cannot speak from personal experience on what I have done, but I used to practice corporate law and a LLC definitely serves a purpose. One thing I have not seen mentioned (though I might have missed it) is that you have to be careful not to co-mingle personal assets and you must treat the LLC as a truly separate entity. If you don’t, then the LLC could end up being disregarded in a lawsuit and they could still go after personal assets under the claim that you only formed it to try to get asset protection but did not really treat it as a separate entity. So it’s just one of the things to be cognizant of if you decide to use a LLC. As far as separate LLCs for each property, I can see the arguments that it’s the way to go and I can see the arguments that it’s overkill. Each person probably just needs to determine if the added layers of potential protection outweigh the added hassle, bookkeeping, costs, etc. If I was going to use a LLC, I think I would personally be inclined not to do a separate LLC for each property, but maybe one LLC per X properties. For example, 5 properties per LLC. Or maybe a certain total value per each LLC - for example, $1,000,000 worth of properties per LLC (whether that was 3 properties, 5 properties, or 10 properties). That being said, I was recently talking to a guy who owns 67 SFRs in the Dallas-Ft. Worth area, and I assumed he probably had them in a LLC. However, he said that every single property is in his personal name and he has a $5 million umbrella policy. His belief is that if he runs his business the right way and treats tenants the right way, the umbrella would cover any issues that might arise. Not saying that is right or wrong, but just throwing it out there. Best of luck.
  • Nate T.Pro Member
    Investor · Tempe, AZ · Member since 2014 · 146 posts · 74 votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Steve Boianelli:

    @Nate T.

    I have considered what you suggested regarding transferring title to my LLC after a refi. I am concerned about the due on sale clause. Has anyone out there done this? Transferred from personal to LLC? It seems risky to me to take the chance they'll call the note due. Can anyone touch on that?

    As for insurance premiums, I have one property that sites in the middle of two commercial buildings. My broker couldn't get me my typically personal rate since it was so close to businesses and the homes are in my LLC. I guess I can't complain about that. But in REI it's all about ROI, higher premiums over a few years adds up.

    We have done that type of transfer many times.  The banks do not know or care.  They do not have someone monitoring county records at all the counties in the country to see who is changing the title.  They just want their payments.

    If the bank did threaten to call your loan they would probably let you put the title right back into your personal name and not be an issue.  It would be more of a concern if you've done a subject-to deal where you wrapped someone else's loan and you're not able to put the title back in their name.

    However, I don't want to be cavalier.  If you do not have the means to pay off a loan that did get called, then you should think twice about it.  I don't think it's risky at all in the current environment, but if interest rates tripled or something then banks very well could become interested in calling loans.

  • Chandler, AZ · Member since 2017 · 174 posts · 269 votes
    8y

     I couldn't disagree more.  When those properties are in your name they are in the public record.  Enterprising blood-sucking-leaches, er, I mean lawyers, will search the public records looking for people who own multiple properties, and then find a reason to sue them.  Remember the lawsuit doesn't have to have merit.  The lawyer just needs to make it expensive for you to defend yourself so that it's cheaper for you to settle than take it to trial.
    Yes, you need good insurance.  And yes, you need to run an honest business.  But keeping your name off those properties is the first line of defense.  Even if/when a lawyer links all the LLCs back to you, that lawyer also knows that you have had some good legal advice and have set up entities that will make their job of suing you MUCH harder.  At this point the lawyer goes looking for a less savvy victim.

  • Medford, NJ · Member since 2017 · 96 posts · 34 votes
    8y

    Great points to consider @Nate T. if rates sky rocket and the banks want their money after I transfer title I would be in a bad position. Thanks for your insight. 

  • Chandler, AZ · Member since 2017 · 174 posts · 269 votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Steve Boianelli:

    Great points to consider @Nate T. if rates sky rocket and the banks want their money after I transfer title I would be in a bad position. Thanks for your insight. 

    This is one of those "difficult" things to talk about, especially in a public forum.  :)  I am NOT a lawyer, and past performance does not indicate future returns.

    Most mortgages have a due-on-sell clause that says they get paid off if you sell (or transfer) the property. But I have yet to meet a person who has had a due-on-sell clause activated when they transferred a property to an LLC. If a mortgage company did decide to do that, you could always just transfer the property back to your name. In fact you'll likely have to shuffle the property back and forth each time you refinance it.

    It's a bit quirky that you pretty much can't get a commercial loan unless you are buying the property under a legal entity such as a corporation.  Go figure.

  • Attorney and CPA · San Diego, CA · Member since 2017 · 590 posts · 422 votes
    8y

    @Sheri Cabral What city are you in?  What kinds of services do you need from your real estate attorney?

  • Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    8y
    Originally posted by @Nate T.:

    @Steve Boianelli

    When getting bank loans you can get them in your personal name and then change the title to an LLC. That way you have the better loan terms as well as the liability protection. Of course changing the title does violate the due on sale clause, but the likelihood of the loan getting called is minimal. So you can decide whether due-on-sale is a big enough risk to make it worth getting a more expensive commercial loan like you have been, or keeping the property title in your personal name.

    In my experience the insurance premiums are not affected by whether you own in your personal name versus LLC. Of course there's a price difference for owner occupied versus investment property.

    You'll want to check out this post from a few years ago that goes into more detail on how to transfer a home with a mortgage from your name to your LLC in such a way that does not put you at risk of piercing the corporate veil down the line.

    Or pay a lawyer and get the right answer for your state. 

    If its worth having an LLC, its probably worth paying for professional advice.

  • Mortgage Broker · Seattle, WA · Member since 2017 · 5 posts · 1 vote
    8y

    The main reason to use an LLC is to keep business liabilities out of your name. The other benefit of an LLC is for partnerships. Some states such as New York require NY LLC's to be able to have the full recourse of eviction laws.

  • Member since 2018 · 19 posts · 4 votes
    8y

    I just started with my first rental. After reading this thread I think I'm going to go the umbrella insurance route. An LLC seems to complicated and costly at the moment.

  • Rental Property Investor · Channahon, IL · Member since 2018 · 161 posts · 103 votes
    8y

    My first rental property I didn't know better, was put under our own name. We are now puting in a series LLC, per recommendation of other investors and our CPA. So far each property has its own series, but am thinking about grouping 2 or 3, depending on area and investment. I live in Illinois. To set it up the cost was less than 1,000.

  • Michael PlaksPro Member
    Tax Accountant / Enrolled Agent · Houston, TX · Member since 2014 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    8y

    @Chase Cline

    I noticed some misinformation here about TX Series LLC - here is an article from a well respected attorney.

    I will repeat myself that attorneys disagree with each other - from claiming that all LLCs are not much help for legal protection to claiming that Series LLC is the best invention since sliced bread, and anything in between. Opinions of non-attorneys, including myself, in all legal matters are pretty much worthless. "We do this in our company..." So? What if you're doing it wrong?

    Beware of online legal or medical advice, unless coming from attorneys or doctors.

    Another point which is in my area of expertise is LLCs and taxes. LLCs basically don't do anything for taxes on rentals, with rare exceptions. Whether you have one LLC, ten LLCs, no LLCs or one Series LLC - your taxes do not change.

    The issue of multiple bank accounts, complicated logistics and complicated bookkeeping is not an issue if you ask me. You can easily handle it with a single bank account and some simple bookkeeping practices.

  • Rental Property Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2018 · 191 posts · 432 votes
    8y
    I form an llc for each property. then a holding llc owns all the property llcs
  • Investor · Copper Center, Alaska/Indiana · Member since 2018 · 44 posts · 33 votes
    8y

    Thanks Ali Boone, I was wondering if someone in this thread would even consider an "umbrella policy" vs forming an LLC. As a new investor, I have been toying with the idea of which one provides the most asset protection.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.