Rental Property Investor · Manchester, NH · Member since 2017 · 45 posts · 51 votes
I understand the reasoning behind placing real estate in an LLC: for the owner to shield himself/herself from personal liability in the event of legal action.
However, is one LLC enough? Say an investor owns 10 properties in a single LLC and those properties' equity represents most of the investor's net worth. He/she has no personal liability if a tenant takes legal action, but the equity of all 10 properties is at risk. Since that's most of his/her wealth, the LLC doesn't appear to be that useful.
Given the above example, should investors break their portfolios into multiple LLCs? If so, how many properties should go into each LLC? There's a balance between legal protection and tax + LLC filing that needs to be struck. Would you name one LLC the holding company of the other smaller LLCs?
Use on LLC for all your assets is poor asset protection in my opinion.
Risk and value/equity should determine how your plan works.
How much are you comfortable losing?
Get insurance and an attorney or other professional that can help you develop an asset protection plan.
Insurance, debt, LLCs, homestead, trusts, single and multiple member entities, off shore trusts etc can help with isolation, ananymity, shields, deterrents, etc -some of the things you want to consider. Geography, as you mentioned, and Taxation are another concern that should be addressed.
What are your fears? And what lengths and expense are you willing to go?
@Nick Gray I get why you're curious, and that is a good thing. But ultimately, you don't even need 1 LLC to get started. Once you have a couple properties, talk to an attorney. Once you have a couple more, talk to him/her again.
You should look into Series-LLC and see if that's an option for you - then you don't need to worry about this question, as you can place a property in its own children Series-LLC that you can form when needed.
As for distribution, you can have one or more per LLC, and that depends on multiple factors:
- property class - you might not want to mix A class property with a D class property in the same LLC, due to different tenant level
- cash flow - you might want to keep your cash flow cow separate from the ones that barely produce
- equity - you might want to keep the one with large equity in its own LLC while you can group the ones with little equity in another LLC (let's say you have one with 50K equity in its own LLC and 3 other each with only 10K in another LLC, till their equity grows to your risk threshold when you move them out in their own LLC).
- number of units (in the case of MF)
- location of real estate
The investor has to decide what mix is optimal for their situation.