How Do You Handle Tenant Placement When Self-Managing From a Distance?

Question

Hey everyone!

We recently purchased a fourplex in Bowling Green, KY, about 1.5 hours from where we live. We self-manage our rental properties.

We're anticipating our first vacancy at this property and are trying to establish an efficient process for finding and placing tenants without having to make trips for showings.

For those who self-manage properties from a distance, I'd love to hear how you handle tenant placement.

• Do you use a local leasing agent or tenant placement service while continuing to manage the property yourself?
• Have you had success with self-guided showings using smart locks or lockboxes?
• Do you hire someone locally to conduct showings, and if so, how did you find them?

Do you use a local leasing agent or tenant placement service while continuing to manage the property yourself?

Have you had success with self-guided showings using smart locks or lockboxes?

Do you hire someone locally to conduct showings, and if so, how did you find them?

Ideally, we'd like to continue handling advertising, screening, applications, leasing, and ongoing management ourselves while finding a reliable solution for in-person showings.

Thanks in advance!

Malory Medaglia · Answer

Congrats on the fourplex!

We’re a leasing and management company in Beaufort, SC, and we use self-guided showings with lockboxes on a lot of our vacancies. It’s been a big win for us. Prospects can see the home on their own schedule, we fill units faster, and nobody is driving out for every showing.

A couple of things we do that have made a real difference. We always collect a copy of the prospect’s driver’s license before giving them access, so we know exactly who is in the property and when. We also limit self-showings to 8pm. Keeping them in daylight or early evening hours cuts down on issues and makes neighbors more comfortable with people coming and going.

Since you want to keep handling advertising, screening, and leasing yourselves, self-showings could fit really well with your setup. I’d still keep a local contact you trust (a handyman or another investor nearby) who can swing by if something comes up, like a door left unlocked or a lockbox issue.

It’s also worth knowing that a lot of companies like ours offer leasing-only services for a lower percentage, if you ever want help with placement but still want to manage day to day. If you go that route, make sure they offer detailed screening. Our applicants need a 600+ credit score, a clean criminal background check, a clean nationwide eviction check, and income of 3x the monthly rent (combined for married couples). Screening is honestly the most important part of placing a tenant, so whoever handles it should take it seriously.

Eric Kleinsasser · Answer

Renee, the showing ideas here are good, so I'll add the part that usually breaks when you're 1.5 hours away: keeping track of where each person is. I'd keep one simple log for the vacancy, one row per inquiry: date, name, pre-screen answers, showing time, who showed it, and next step. Share it with whoever does the showings so they write a quick note right after each one. That way you're not piecing it together from texts and emails, and you can see which listing sources bring the people who actually apply. How many units are you self-managing in total right now?

Clever Mukori · Answer

Renee, the showing side is well covered here, so I'll add the step after it, because move-in day is where remote owners usually get stuck. Sign the lease electronically and have the deposit and first month paid electronically, then wait until those funds have actually cleared before you release a key or a lockbox code. On move-in day, ask the new tenant to send a timestamped photo or video walkthrough of every room within the first day or two, and have them sign the condition checklist along with it. That gives you a solid record at move-out without having to drive down just to do the inspection yourself.

Jeremy White · Answer

Using the same written screening criteria for every applicant is what keeps a long distance process smooth, because it removes guesswork and keeps you consistent on fair housing. An online application with a credit and eviction check, plus a local helper or cleaner who can run showings with a lockbox, covers most of what you would do in person. Many owners at that distance also take a short video walkthrough of the unit before listing so applicants can see it before they travel.

Drew Sygit · Answer

You may want to look into TurboTenant

Willson Dinayen · Answer

Hi Renee — keeping advertising, screening, and leasing in your own hands is the right call. That's the part worth keeping.

For showings, split the job: one local person does only the in-person showing and walk-through. You send a one-time smart-lock or lockbox code for that showing window only, check ID before you send it, and ask for a same-day note back — who came, what they asked, anything they noticed in the unit.

I wouldn't start with self-guided showings for your first vacancy. Do the first few with a person, learn what prospects ask, then decide if self-guided is worth it. If you try it later, use a fresh code for every prospect and keep a spare key off-site. A dead battery on showing day is a bad lesson.

To find that person, ask your handyman, cleaner, or a local agent who does leasing-only work — someone already driving by the property is ideal. Pay per showing, and give them a one-page checklist so every prospect hears the same thing.

Allan C. · Answer

I’d never let another tenant handle business matters - that’s an awful strategy. Find a good leasing agent and pay them market rate to get the job done well.

You need to run this like a business if you want to stay in the game long term. A good agent will give you objective feedback on whether prospects will be the right tenant for you.

Do the math on extended vacancy, expensive turnovers and evictions, and you should conclude that it makes sense to properly screen your tenants.

Richard F. · Answer

If you "recently" bought the 4 plex, what do you actually know about the existing tenants that you would trust them with access to other units? Did you run a full screening process on all adults after closing? Interview the tenants and inspect their units to see how they actually care for your property? Do you plan to compensate them for showing prospects? You need to be certain you do not create an unintentional "employee" that becomes an IRS problem for you. Also, how do you ensure they don't just let a friend use the vacant unit for who knows what? This is all very risky. Do you know what an actual eviction costs in time and money for the locale? That would be critical info to have before making innocent decisions.

Proper Screening consists of much more than a three digit "score" and a background check that sources info from...where, exactly? Even if you hire a PM for some/all of the front end work, what actual details are THEY checking on? After all, they have no skin in the game. Once they turn over the keys, the tenants are your problem.

Jim Johnson · Answer

Since you want to keep handling the applications, screening, and leasing yourself, I'd look for a local agent who offers showing-only or tenant-placement services. You could also ask local property managers if they offer that separately from full management. Self-guided showings might save trips, but I'd be cautious with access and making sure the unit is secured afterward. For a fourplex, having someone nearby who can handle showings as needed seems like a good middle ground.

Leo Stein · Answer

Renee, one thing I'd add: write your screening criteria down once and send the exact same pre-screen to every inquiry, so whoever opens the door is only meeting people who already fit. It also keeps showings consistent if a local helper ends up covering for you. General info only.

How Do You Handle Tenant Placement When Self-Managing From a Distance?

How Do You Handle Tenant Placement When Self-Managing From a Distance?

Most Popular Reply

16 Replies