I recently had my first call to interview a potential property manager for my first long-distance investment property and it left me a bit discouraged to learn of the reality of the costs involved.
By my calculations this means that 3 months have to go by before the property owner ever sees any of the rent.
So let's do the math for a 1-year breakdown on a fictional property that rents for $750/m and would bring in $300/m in cash flow before property management.
Costs:
$750 (no rent while vacant)
$750 (cost to lease)
$750 (10% management fee for remaining 10 months)
$2,250
+ $3,600 (Annual Cash Flow Before PM)
- $ 750 (Lost Rent While Vacant)
- $1,500 (Paid to Property Manager)
$1,350 (Actual Annual Cash Flow)
... and this is only if the Property Manager never does anything except for collect the rent!
Is this really the reality... that the Property Management Company makes more than the property owner?
Hello @Skye Anderson. There are a lot of points to discuss on this thread. As a property manager for over 20 years, I have faced these arguments from investors many times. Hopefully I can help shed some light. Firstly, the initial vacancy is hard to avoid whether you have a professional management company or not. When you turn over a vacant property to a PM, they have to (hopefully) inspect the unit to make sure it is up to standards, market, show, screen prospects, qualify applications and generate the paperwork to move them in. Many tenant prospects are looking for something in advance. They don't want to move in the day they see and apply. Many prospects want to move within 1-3 weeks after application approval. Of course there are those who need something right away, but most responsible tenants will be proactive and try to set something up in advance of when they need to move from their current property. There are some PM's who will begin marketing and even showing units prior to the vacancy if all the planets align. Most PM's today do not do this because it brings up a lot of potential issues. Will your current tenant move when they say they will? How much work will be needed to get it in "rent ready" condition? If you sign a lease for the new tenant and things stall, who pays for the holdover rent for the new tenant to stay where they are? There are a lot of potential problems. My point is, the PM does not benefit from this vacancy. Most companies will not charge the management fee until they place the first tenant. Maybe they get a marketing fee.
One month's leasing commission and 10% is fairly normal in my area. However, if you shop around and get some referrals, you may be able to find something less expensive. For example, we are now offering 30% leasing commission and 5% management fees. Less than half of what you were quoted. Shop around to find a better deal.
The initial vacancy is simply a cost of doing business, and you should factor this in to your budget, as well as future vacancies. @Jason D. suggested PM's want the tenants to not renew, so they can charge another "placement fee". Perhaps some do, but it creates a lot more work that I don't feel is worth the hassle. Most PM's charge a minimum fee when it is vacant, but is not equal to the management fee while occupied, so they lose that amount. I would rather keep a good tenant happy , which in turns keeps the investor happy, and things run efficiently and without a lot of unnecessary work.
I feel PM's often get a bad rep. Yes, sometimes we get a beautiful property that runs so smoothly. We rarely ever hear from the tenant or the investor. Tenant pays every month, there are minimal repairs, and tenant has been in place for many years with reasonable yearly increases. However, these are few and far between. Many PM's have to deal with wacky tenants who call excessively about nothing, demanding owners who look to micromanage every move, constant collections efforts, no show prospects, incompetent vendors, tedious marketing efforts, software glitches, accounting nightmares, etc. It can be extremely time consuming.
A lot of problems could be resolved if there was a meeting of the minds regarding expectations of the owner and the property manager. Some owners expect PM's to inspect their property for no cost every month or so, or to at least drive by. We typically perform inspections every six months or so(for a small fee). This inspection can only be a snapshot of how they are maintaining your unit. Sometimes it looks good, then three months later when they move out the place is completely trashed and bug infested, as @Dennis M. noted. If a PM company has good screening criteria, and an applicant meets those criteria, they must approve the application. I'm sure there are plenty of families with 800 credit scores that have bed bugs and live in filth. Sometimes someone is approved but lose their job right after they move in. Life happens. Owner's should not blame the PM for renting to a dead beat tenant, provided they did everything they were required/should do when placing them. There are many tricks of the trade that can benefit the PM , but that's a story for another time. Hopefully this is not the first time they were dead beat tenants and the screening showed previous issues so they were not approved to move in your unit.
Finally I feel a good PM helps protect you legally. There may be a lot of legalities you are not aware of that the company practices daily. I've seen many Landlords get their rear handed to them in eviction court because they had non legal leases, etc. In some cases, the Landlord was stuck because the tenant did not have to move or pay until the Landlord was able to correct some infraction. Nightmares. They can also help protect you from Federal Fair Housing claims. Of course, there are plenty of PM's who get caught for violations. This is another reason to do your homework and find a company you feel comfortable with and is willing to work with you. Oftentimes that means a smaller company. I know that if I start to work with someone who ends up feeling I'm not meeting their expectations for some reason, I will let them out of the contract even if I did nothing wrong. I feel it's better to leave on decent terms than have them hold a grudge or stick them with an early termination penalty. It promotes good will. Best of luck with your search.
Yes, unfortunately what you were quoted seems to be the norm. In addition, service calls are rarely triaged before 3 Maytag men are called out, all with separate trip charges. My (sink, oven, a/c) is broke will cost YOU hundreds, where for me it is usually handled in 20 seconds over the phone.
The PM is so important that when I exchange out of some larger backyard holdings for OOS 1031s, I will locate the best PMs in the country first, then invest in their market. Most find their market then frantically seek the least bad PM, like you are finding.
On the side, I buy and sell real estate (mostly residential and small multi-family). I'm a partner in 20 rental units and am a CPM. I'm making my move into my own company and am fortunate that financially I have no rush or urgency.
I’ve given my notice to my company and they’ve been extremely supportive. Now, the decision on where to focus my company? PM, in which I am extremely trained and marketable. Residential brokerage where the median sales price is $400k ($12k per side on sales). Investing, which has been the biggest money driver. Or #3 and #4 you’ve stated above. I don’t have any experience besides the management of commercial, but the brokerage could be lucrative. The syndication is appealing as well. I’d love to hear your thoughts, if you were in my shoes, starting out. Thanks!
Since you're hijacking the thread and have been at a PM co for 7 years, what is your experience? Do you guys have the same PM-slanted profit model riddled with fees?
Hi Skye,
Costs vary depending where your property is located. I would call around and see what other PM companies in the area would charge. I'm surprised you didn't look into this before purchasing your property, but a good lesson in always preparing for all the costs involved in your investment before making it.
Using a property manager can definitely turn a cash flow property into a negative one as they take a % of your rental income each month even if there is nothing needed to be done.
My big gripes about PM companies as I"ve used one before as well:
1) they often won't have the same standards that you would have managing the unit. They don't care as much about the quality of the tenant in there since its not their place, as long as they pass the credit check and references, then they'll put them in. I had a tenant stay for 2 years in my apartment and they did more damage than when I lived there for 8 years (broke washroom door handle lock, toilet paper roll, bent blinds, tons of scuff marks on walls, granite counter top is somehow scratched, etc.)
2) They also won't negotiate rent increases well since they only take a %, an increase doesn't usually mean much to them at all. I had to tell them to ask for more before they actually did anything.
3) They will also markup a contractor's costs to repair something typically. I was charged a ridiculous $200 to replace a fire alarm battery which I did myself before when I lived in the unit and the battery was $5 from a store. I complained and they dropped it down to a $100 charge which was still absurd.
I'd always recommend managing properties yourself unless you can't due to time restrictions, quality of life, or long distance opportunities like this. In these instances, for long distance investing usually the opportunity would have to be very lucrative to help cover the additional risk and costs of using a long distance property manager
@Skye Anderson... yes, I taught and recorded a class in March where I went through the "Impact of Property Management Fees on Your Rental Portfolio" where I showed a number of things including how long it takes for you to make as much cash flow from the property as your property manager does (which... if I recall correctly was almost year 30 for properties in my market) and the total cost that a property manager has on your portfolio when you consider that they are siphoning off money you could be using to buy your next properties sooner.
Here are a couple charts from the presentation.
There are like 30 charts in total but the difference in terms of net worth is startling.
Skype, you can self manage a property in another state too. One of the biggest reasons with high turnover and vacancy is the the lack of communication with tenants and not addressing issues on a timely manner. If you make the property look good, spruce it up a bit, and put good tenants there, you will not have to worry about anything. If things go wrong, just go to Yelp and find a good rated contractor to go to the property and fix the problem.
I had a Pm for 2 properties in AZ and had a new tenant every two years and the properties were getting trashed all the time. I ended up losing money on them. Then about 4 years ago I fired the PM and started managing them myself. I just flew there for a weekend to do showings which I had set up ahead of time, and then selected the tenant and did the contract over emails. within a week I mailed them the key and they moved in. Both properties have had the same tenants for 4 years now and they love renting out from me. They even ask me to take care of minor issues themselves and send the bill for my approval upon which they subtract it from the rent payment. Needless to say my profit went up from 3% to over 20% annual average over 4 years.
Exactly why I self manage .. look at any horrIfIc posts on here by frustrated landlords wIth nightmare tenants that show a place trashed out and full of bed bugs and roaches .. 9 times out if 10 they had a professional property manager that never inspected the property ! I’m sure there are some good ones but if I only get say 20% in profits I’m not splitting that with a guy who sImply makes some calls , collects my rent ,and puts up paper notices on a door !
I hear you! And... I can't exactly self-manage when I live in a different state. Or can I?
You can but it take's WORK.
I was a Regional Facilities Manager for years. I had 27 commercial sites and only 2 or 3 had in house techs. So I'd have to call vendors, get pricing emailed to me, send purchase orders or pay over the phone.
I do it with my rentals now, the business is the same. It requires good follow up, and quality control. It is a LOT of work, but it's not really that hard. My tenants know I call after I send someone by, if they don't feel like picking up or getting back to me...I very sternly remind them if they complain again that they blew me off.
I'm not saying everyone can do it. You definitely need the mindset of being comfortable not knowing what's going on every second. Plus you have to learn how to ask for pictures...and not be afraid to send someone back for the pictures you asked for.
It's very easy for me, but I do also us PM's for some of our properties. I just make sure they know that I know what I'm doing and ask them politely to not give me a reason to take my property's back.
I self manage my Georgia properties, and even though still in Atlanta, they might as well be in another state. If you can manage across town without being on site for every little thing, you can do the same across country.
Best of luck!
@Skye Anderson I highly recommend reading "The Book on Rental Property Investing" by @Brandon Turner before going any further. He goes through a lot of the expenses that are realities of buy & hold investing, which people might overlook or not consider fully in their initial estimates. Vacancy and turnover are big ones, and are a reality regardless of who manages your property. There are a lot more that can catch you out, and his book is a great resource on how to plan, prepare, and invest realistically, to avoid expensive surprises that were actually preventable.
I've held two SFRs from out of state for seven years, and in my experience, the yield is never quite as rosy as my initial spreadsheets would have led me to believe (even though I thought I was being so realistic at the time!).
I self-managed for the first two years, and I am very happy with my decision to hire a professional property manager. I actually had longer vacancy periods than I do with a PM because they have experience and systems in place to identify and place good tenants. My PM also knows local contractors and specialists, so when something does come up, he has more bargaining power than I would, and is able to recommend reputable suppliers. The headache factor is worth something too. When work needs to be done, it's hard to get contractors and tenants to coordinate their schedules, and if you're managing from out of state, you can't be there to make things happen. Inspections also become a lot more expensive if you have to fly across the country to do them yourself.
Property management and vacancy aren't the only expenses you'll face, so plan for contingencies. Sometimes things tick along for a while without incident, and sometimes the roof on your house needs to be replaced and wipes out the cash flow for the whole year. Being an investor is a lot of fun, and there is money to be made, even with just a couple properties, but you have to be realistic with your numbers. So put some doomsday scenarios in your spreadsheets, and if they cause your projected yield to go negative, I would suggest seriously rethinking those purchases. Good luck!
You would not send your kids to a public school and expect that the school is taking care of all there education needs. Many did just that and we now have an army of Millennials that firmly believe there ancestors are Chimpanzees and that man is evolving upward.
For the same disastrous reasons, you do not assume that your livelihood is being managed by your PM. You will always be involved to some extent but the idea is that it is minimal once you have your PM trained in your expectations. For us this is a continual process as people change positions within the PM Company and things be forgotten.
well, got to go. calling our PM to let them know I will be up in the Rockies a week or 2.
Good luck to you all who are just getting started. May you be content with your cash flow.
Homes in the Hood,
I recently had my first call to interview a potential property manager for my first long-distance investment property and it left me a bit discouraged to learn of the reality of the costs involved.
By my calculations this means that 3 months have to go by before the property owner ever sees any of the rent.
So let's do the math for a 1-year breakdown on a fictional property that rents for $750/m and would bring in $300/m in cash flow before property management.
Costs:
$750 (no rent while vacant)
$750 (cost to lease)
$750 (10% management fee for remaining 10 months)
$2,250
+ $3,600 (Annual Cash Flow Before PM)
- $ 750 (Lost Rent While Vacant)
- $1,500 (Paid to Property Manager)
$1,350 (Actual Annual Cash Flow)
... and this is only if the Property Manager never does anything except for collect the rent!
Is this really the reality... that the Property Management Company makes more than the property owner?
Yep sounds just about right. This is exactly why I've never hired a property manager for my properties. Although, I did find myself lucky since my place of living is a great real estate market for investing, so I never really needed to invest out of my province/state. But it does sucks for those living in California for instance (insane market) and investing out of state.
I take the Franchise Approach.
Basically, most franchises want you to work in the entire operations so you get to understand every aspect of operating the franchise.
Some franchises will NOT let you buy one unless you work every part of the operations.
The chances of you becoming successful is exponentially increased when you understand the details of your operations before you become the hands off Manager.
For all my properties, I self-managed the entire operations, building up my portfolio slowly over 21 years in a City (NYC) which is completely biased towards the Tenants.
I learned it so well, I created my own Brokerage firm, trained and hired my own managers.
I brought down the cost of Management in an extremely difficult City for Tenants to about 5% of the Rent Roll.
The extra costs such as evictions are now insignificant as I implemented a very tough tenant screening approval process. I haven't done an eviction in 15 years.
Also, as the Rents move up, as it always does in NYC, the percentage of the cost of Management decreases as the pay for the workers in the Property Management firm stays close to the same.
If I need to change one of my managers, it's a piece of cake since I can pick up the slack myself until I find a good one.
It also gives me a clear advantage because I make changes to improve the management. For instance, implementing an online rent collection program such as Cozy. In my case, I use Avail.co which works EXCELLENT.
However, I still know some management firms that still collect checks! I think that's absolutely backwards in this day and age.
Now that I have a brokerage firm that does all the property management, expanding is a breeze. Once I buy a multi-family, my property management system onboards the new property.
Yes, it's a long road to achieve this level of functionality and expertise. But now I'm at the top looking down at a well oiled machine. I barely need to do anything in regards to the property.
So now I have time to create Real Estate Software and build a completely new business!
In fact, the advantages of having the Brokerage helps in many ways! I have even made money recently just by referring a relative to another Brokerage to sell his property, acquiring a Broker's referral fee!
The amount of different streams of income that you can create once you understand all the aspects of a business is incredible.
I know it's not for everybody, but I believe the best way to build up your Investments is to first understand the operations of the Investments. Then you will make it run smoothly and discover all kinds of ways to make more money!