Opinions on Hawaii Short Term Rentals

Opinions on Hawaii Short Term Rentals

Member since 2023 · 31 posts · 28 votes

Would like some feedback on options from people in the know on Hawaii (or Miami). Got about $5.3M to deploy somewhere through an LLC. Considering an all cash purchase to "park and profit," but open to debt. Considering Hawaii both for short term rentals (likely on the Big Island, in Kona; and/or Miami) and long-term multifamily in Honolulu, one unit I might live in. Open to potentially purchasing in all 2-3 locations simultaneously, depending on options. But I would like some feedback on these options available to me and what any of you would do in my shoes? I'm familiar with all the basic need-to-knows about these locations and their respective strategy implementation, but I'd appreciate any higher level feedback.

4Reply
302 views

Most Popular Reply

Sarah KensingerPro Member
Real Estate Consultant · OH · Member since 2023 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
2y

If your considering Miami, Fl for a STR, that's a tough place to have one due to restrictions. @Carson McGee Is the person to chat with about STR in Hawaii! From what he shared with me; I'd be parking a good bit of that money into a property there.

See this reply in the discussion

40 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Sarah KensingerPro Member
    Real Estate Consultant · OH · Member since 2023 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2y

    If your considering Miami, Fl for a STR, that's a tough place to have one due to restrictions. @Carson McGee Is the person to chat with about STR in Hawaii! From what he shared with me; I'd be parking a good bit of that money into a property there.

  • Ryan MoyerBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orlando Kissimmee Davenport Salt Lake City, Park City · Member since 2019 · 996 posts · 1k+ votes
    2y

    I don't own in Hawaii, but my perception from my research there is that it's not an ideal cash flow market right now but can be great for appreciation, which it sounds like would be a pretty good deal in your scenario.

    If I had that much cash to deploy personally I would be putting it into properties that are most likely to hold value and most likely to gain value.  To me that means properties that there is a limited supply of.  Hawaii is a good start on that front.  Beachfront in a premium market like Destin is another spot I'd be looking.

    Cosmic Vacations4.9177 Reviews
  • Rental Property Investor · Charlotte, NC · Member since 2021 · 71 posts · 49 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Sarah Kensinger:

    If your considering Miami, Fl for a STR, that's a tough place to have one due to restrictions. @Carson McGee Is the person to chat with about STR in Hawaii! From what he shared with me; I'd be parking a good bit of that money into a property there.


    I definitely agree with Sarah about restrictions, you need to know all local STR regulations. We have been getting creative and are still able to find opportunities to buy in Hawaii. The supply constraint (lack of land + zoning) helps not only with appreciation but also revenue growth. It is tough to find cash-flowing deals but not impossible.

    Alton, I'm happy to discuss specifics of what we are seeing in the market. Best of luck!

  • Member since 2023 · 31 posts · 28 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Sarah Kensinger:

    If your considering Miami, Fl for a STR, that's a tough place to have one due to restrictions. @Carson McGee Is the person to chat with about STR in Hawaii! From what he shared with me; I'd be parking a good bit of that money into a property there.


     I'll reach out; thanks!

  • Member since 2023 · 31 posts · 28 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Ryan Moyer:

    I don't own in Hawaii, but my perception from my research there is that it's not an ideal cash flow market right now but can be great for appreciation, which it sounds like would be a pretty good deal in your scenario.

    If I had that much cash to deploy personally I would be putting it into properties that are most likely to hold value and most likely to gain value.  To me that means properties that there is a limited supply of.  Hawaii is a good start on that front.  Beachfront in a premium market like Destin is another spot I'd be looking.


     Good advice, I am wary of hurricanes though, so kind of being drawn to Hawaii. If I could find a 10+ unit rental all cash and live in one while managing the rest, I could probably live on the cash flow it makes in Hawaii.

  • Michael BorgerPro Member
    Rehabber · San Diego, CA · Member since 2010 · 502 posts · 208 votes
    2y

    @Account Closed - Cash flow plays are indeed difficult in Hawaii. I've doing business in the islands for about 12 years but almost all flips via private lending or owner/creative financing. Even finding a distressed property rarely leads to enough cash flow to make it worthwhile, especially in today's high-rate environment. STR-zoned areas are available but are few, and most are condos which carry high monthly fees that significantly offset revenues. Distressed multi-unit? That's probably your best bet, but it'll take a fair amount of digging to find a worthy one in a zone that allows it.

  • Member since 2023 · 78 posts · 37 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Account Closed:

    Would like some feedback on options from people in the know on Hawaii (or Miami). Got about $5.3M to deploy somewhere through an LLC. Considering an all cash purchase to "park and profit," but open to debt. Considering Hawaii both for short term rentals (likely on the Big Island, in Kona; and/or Miami) and long-term multifamily in Honolulu, one unit I might live in. Open to potentially purchasing in all 2-3 locations simultaneously, depending on options. But I would like some feedback on these options available to me and what any of you would do in my shoes? I'm familiar with all the basic need-to-knows about these locations and their respective strategy implementation, but I'd appreciate any higher level feedback.

    Hey there! Sounds like you've got quite the budget to play with. Personally, I'd lean towards diversifying your investments across the different locations you're considering. Each market has its own dynamics and risks, so spreading your $5.3M across Hawaii (Kona), Miami, and Honolulu could be a solid strategy.

    For the short-term rentals in Kona, Hawaii, the tourism industry there is pretty robust, but do keep an eye on local regulations and potential changes in the vacation rental landscape. Miami is a hot market too, with a mix of short-term and long-term rental potential. As for Honolulu, multifamily properties can offer stable returns, especially if you plan to live in one unit.

    Consider the local economies, job markets, and future development plans in each location. Also, think about your risk tolerance and whether you prefer the stability of long-term rentals or the potential for higher short-term gains. It might be worth consulting with a local real estate expert in each area to get more nuanced insights.

    Given your budget, you could potentially diversify by allocating a portion to each location. This way, you're not putting all your eggs in one basket. Just my two cents, I don't own any properties in any of these locations, I'm just curious hehe – hope it helps!


  • Real Estate Agent · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2015 · 450 posts · 196 votes
    2y

    @Account Closed Another strategy you could consider is Mid Term Rental on a multi-unit, especially in desirable neighborhoods. I have an MTR-house hack in Kaimuki-Kahala area. You could get better cash flow than LTR, and don't have to stick to the legal resort zoned areas for STR. Also, there's less turnover so it's easier to self-manage. If you want to chat more about Oahu, let me know!

  • Rental Property Investor · Honolulu, HAWAII (HI) · Member since 2011 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    2y

    Remember In Hawaii, STRs come with extra taxes: a 10.25% Transient Accommodations Tax (TAT), a 4% General Excise Tax (GET), plus a 0.5% Oahu Surcharge Tax on gross income from rents. Even if you are out of state resident that GET tax is charged on Hawaii clients which is messed up.

    STRs are definitely in vogue, but they're not without risks. Across Europe, cities are cracking down with new bylaws to regulate and tax them. In some cases, they're banning them entirely. Take Toronto, for instance. They've recently outlawed STRs of secondary dwellings due to a lack of affordable rental housing. You can rent out your primary residence or a room in it, but there's an annual license fee and a nightly tax involved.

    Many investors jumped on the STR bandwagon, expecting the market to stay the same. Big mistake. They didn't account for regulatory changes or market saturation, which could lower prices. With historically low barriers to entry, STRs seemed like a golden opportunity. But now, many Toronto property owners are facing financial troubles, with the new rules set to kick in six months.

    Bottom line: Don't bank on the current market conditions staying the same, especially if you're making a 25-year financial commitment. Personally, I stay away from the mainstream trends where everyone who is priced out of traditional long term rentals are now trying to rent out a room or a whole house on the daily. 

  • Member since 2023 · 31 posts · 28 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Lane Kawaoka:

    Remember In Hawaii, STRs come with extra taxes: a 10.25% Transient Accommodations Tax (TAT), a 4% General Excise Tax (GET), plus a 0.5% Oahu Surcharge Tax on gross income from rents. Even if you are out of state resident that GET tax is charged on Hawaii clients which is messed up.

    STRs are definitely in vogue, but they're not without risks. Across Europe, cities are cracking down with new bylaws to regulate and tax them. In some cases, they're banning them entirely. Take Toronto, for instance. They've recently outlawed STRs of secondary dwellings due to a lack of affordable rental housing. You can rent out your primary residence or a room in it, but there's an annual license fee and a nightly tax involved.

    Many investors jumped on the STR bandwagon, expecting the market to stay the same. Big mistake. They didn't account for regulatory changes or market saturation, which could lower prices. With historically low barriers to entry, STRs seemed like a golden opportunity. But now, many Toronto property owners are facing financial troubles, with the new rules set to kick in six months.

    Bottom line: Don't bank on the current market conditions staying the same, especially if you're making a 25-year financial commitment. Personally, I stay away from the mainstream trends where everyone who is priced out of traditional long term rentals are now trying to rent out a room or a whole house on the daily. 


     I appreciate the insight. STRs are on my radar but I am definitely in it for the long term, so considering large multifamily and maybe living in one unit as a manager and off the rest of the cash flow.

  • Member since 2023 · 31 posts · 28 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Calvin Baughman:
    Quote from @Account Closed:

    Would like some feedback on options from people in the know on Hawaii (or Miami). Got about $5.3M to deploy somewhere through an LLC. Considering an all cash purchase to "park and profit," but open to debt. Considering Hawaii both for short term rentals (likely on the Big Island, in Kona; and/or Miami) and long-term multifamily in Honolulu, one unit I might live in. Open to potentially purchasing in all 2-3 locations simultaneously, depending on options. But I would like some feedback on these options available to me and what any of you would do in my shoes? I'm familiar with all the basic need-to-knows about these locations and their respective strategy implementation, but I'd appreciate any higher level feedback.

    Hey there! Sounds like you've got quite the budget to play with. Personally, I'd lean towards diversifying your investments across the different locations you're considering. Each market has its own dynamics and risks, so spreading your $5.3M across Hawaii (Kona), Miami, and Honolulu could be a solid strategy.

    For the short-term rentals in Kona, Hawaii, the tourism industry there is pretty robust, but do keep an eye on local regulations and potential changes in the vacation rental landscape. Miami is a hot market too, with a mix of short-term and long-term rental potential. As for Honolulu, multifamily properties can offer stable returns, especially if you plan to live in one unit.

    Consider the local economies, job markets, and future development plans in each location. Also, think about your risk tolerance and whether you prefer the stability of long-term rentals or the potential for higher short-term gains. It might be worth consulting with a local real estate expert in each area to get more nuanced insights.

    Given your budget, you could potentially diversify by allocating a portion to each location. This way, you're not putting all your eggs in one basket. Just my two cents, I don't own any properties in any of these locations, I'm just curious hehe – hope it helps!



     Yea, good advice; considering diversification!

  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Account Closed:

    Would like some feedback on options from people in the know on Hawaii (or Miami). Got about $5.3M to deploy somewhere through an LLC. Considering an all cash purchase to "park and profit," but open to debt. Considering Hawaii both for short term rentals (likely on the Big Island, in Kona; and/or Miami) and long-term multifamily in Honolulu, one unit I might live in. Open to potentially purchasing in all 2-3 locations simultaneously, depending on options. But I would like some feedback on these options available to me and what any of you would do in my shoes? I'm familiar with all the basic need-to-knows about these locations and their respective strategy implementation, but I'd appreciate any higher level feedback.


    if you have that amount, go buy house in Kukio, 30 min above Kona, avg price is 10-15 mil, your neighbour would be someone like Britney Spears. Dont care about cash flow , just STR it and you can double that 5 mil to 10 mil in few years. This is actually the hottest market in America IMO.

    With that level amount of money you have to play big and do NOT think small ( i am still small investor LOL)

  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Account Closed:
    Quote from @Lane Kawaoka:

    Remember In Hawaii, STRs come with extra taxes: a 10.25% Transient Accommodations Tax (TAT), a 4% General Excise Tax (GET), plus a 0.5% Oahu Surcharge Tax on gross income from rents. Even if you are out of state resident that GET tax is charged on Hawaii clients which is messed up.

    STRs are definitely in vogue, but they're not without risks. Across Europe, cities are cracking down with new bylaws to regulate and tax them. In some cases, they're banning them entirely. Take Toronto, for instance. They've recently outlawed STRs of secondary dwellings due to a lack of affordable rental housing. You can rent out your primary residence or a room in it, but there's an annual license fee and a nightly tax involved.

    Many investors jumped on the STR bandwagon, expecting the market to stay the same. Big mistake. They didn't account for regulatory changes or market saturation, which could lower prices. With historically low barriers to entry, STRs seemed like a golden opportunity. But now, many Toronto property owners are facing financial troubles, with the new rules set to kick in six months.

    Bottom line: Don't bank on the current market conditions staying the same, especially if you're making a 25-year financial commitment. Personally, I stay away from the mainstream trends where everyone who is priced out of traditional long term rentals are now trying to rent out a room or a whole house on the daily. 


     I appreciate the insight. STRs are on my radar but I am definitely in it for the long term, so considering large multifamily and maybe living in one unit as a manager and off the rest of the cash flow.


     in general:
    - multifamily both in big island and honolulu is lackluster investment
    -in general honolulu STR doesn't appreciate that much, kona STR is appreciating 'mildly'.
    - hilo is relatively flat.
    - as for regulation, you could buy multiple cashflowing condo STR in vacation-resort zone
    - but best total return is always single family home, again with 5 mil I would entirely do flip in the richest neighborhood day and night. Actually now if someone can pay me to do it, I would do it by now LOL .... this is way more profitable than chasing CF.


  • AJ WongBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Oregon & California Coast · Member since 2022 · 834 posts · 696 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Account Closed:

    Would like some feedback on options from people in the know on Hawaii (or Miami). Got about $5.3M to deploy somewhere through an LLC. Considering an all cash purchase to "park and profit," but open to debt. Considering Hawaii both for short term rentals (likely on the Big Island, in Kona; and/or Miami) and long-term multifamily in Honolulu, one unit I might live in. Open to potentially purchasing in all 2-3 locations simultaneously, depending on options. But I would like some feedback on these options available to me and what any of you would do in my shoes? I'm familiar with all the basic need-to-knows about these locations and their respective strategy implementation, but I'd appreciate any higher level feedback.


    There is no substitute for Hawaii. WIth that investment capital, one strategy to consider is a small boutique hotel with commercial zoning? Invest the rest on where you truly want to be into a legacy property. STR's are indeed a moving target in most coastal areas. There's oddly a lot of seasonal investors that travel between Hawaii and the Oregon Coast. We have some ridiculously productive oceanfront and waterfront luxury STR's here. I also am keen on a second home in Kauai at some point in the not too distant future..Unlikely to be a BNB though. Good luck!

    Sesemi | STR Brokers powered by Fathom Realty 521 Reviews
  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @AJ Wong:
    Quote from @Account Closed:

    Would like some feedback on options from people in the know on Hawaii (or Miami). Got about $5.3M to deploy somewhere through an LLC. Considering an all cash purchase to "park and profit," but open to debt. Considering Hawaii both for short term rentals (likely on the Big Island, in Kona; and/or Miami) and long-term multifamily in Honolulu, one unit I might live in. Open to potentially purchasing in all 2-3 locations simultaneously, depending on options. But I would like some feedback on these options available to me and what any of you would do in my shoes? I'm familiar with all the basic need-to-knows about these locations and their respective strategy implementation, but I'd appreciate any higher level feedback.


    There is no substitute for Hawaii. WIth that investment capital, one strategy to consider is a small boutique hotel with commercial zoning? Invest the rest on where you truly want to be into a legacy property. STR's are indeed a moving target in most coastal areas. There's oddly a lot of

    This is very true, with this large amount of capital, need to think big like NFL player level.

    I read financial proforma of class B hotel in Maui, it's pretty darn good, in fact it's perhaps the top ten best performing hotel in US in term of vacancy and RevPAR.

    STR and stuff like that is more for small investor like us with half to 1 mil buying power, but when it is above 5% you really need to talk to some serious developer/realtor in the island and understand the business.

    If I have that size of capital I would import contractor from California to finish my project in Kukio LOL 

    Currently in kona there're only few new construction that can still being built, I guess it is selling for 1.5mil and above.

  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    2y

    forget to mention , there's recent development to build new class B+/C hotel like BestWestern in the area of around Waikoloa, so it's starting.
    This island is missing the middle lower-class brand-name hotel due to very limited hotel approval but it's there in extremely very limited approval.

    I think most local would reject most development, hence Kauai and big island is still more natural compare to lets say oahu/honolulu....

  • V.G JasonPro Member
    Investor · Member since 2022 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    2y

    Hawaii wise-- Kihei and north shore of Oahu. I think that's we narrowed it down too but understanding restrictions are a bit confusing. Much like you, this is my real target of 2024. 

    Miami I don't know why you have in same bucket as Hawaii. Or is it just a price bucket?

  • Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2y

    Careful, the whole place may be underwater by 2050....   You could probably find a nice 10 unit apt building in Kalihi or Waianae for cheap but you'll need to hire security.

  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Henry T.:

    Careful, the whole place may be underwater by 2050....   You could probably find a nice 10 unit apt building in Kalihi or Waianae for cheap but you'll need to hire security.


    There are whole lot new project anticipating moving into that direction, such as building higher/stronger seawall.

    Folks that visited regularly notice would notice there would be much more lava big rock stone allocated in front of the beach.

  • Member since 2023 · 31 posts · 28 votes
    2y
    Quote from @AJ Wong:
    Quote from @Account Closed:

    Would like some feedback on options from people in the know on Hawaii (or Miami). Got about $5.3M to deploy somewhere through an LLC. Considering an all cash purchase to "park and profit," but open to debt. Considering Hawaii both for short term rentals (likely on the Big Island, in Kona; and/or Miami) and long-term multifamily in Honolulu, one unit I might live in. Open to potentially purchasing in all 2-3 locations simultaneously, depending on options. But I would like some feedback on these options available to me and what any of you would do in my shoes? I'm familiar with all the basic need-to-knows about these locations and their respective strategy implementation, but I'd appreciate any higher level feedback.


    There is no substitute for Hawaii. WIth that investment capital, one strategy to consider is a small boutique hotel with commercial zoning? Invest the rest on where you truly want to be into a legacy property. STR's are indeed a moving target in most coastal areas. There's oddly a lot of seasonal investors that travel between Hawaii and the Oregon Coast. We have some ridiculously productive oceanfront and waterfront luxury STR's here. I also am keen on a second home in Kauai at some point in the not too distant future..Unlikely to be a BNB though. Good luck!


     I appreciate the advice, though I'm not sure i could afford a commercial hotel! I will think about it though.

  • Member since 2023 · 31 posts · 28 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Henry T.:

    Careful, the whole place may be underwater by 2050....   You could probably find a nice 10 unit apt building in Kalihi or Waianae for cheap but you'll need to hire security.


     Got advice on dealing with crime in Hawaii? I've heard it's rampant in hotspots in Honolulu like chinatown. Thoughts?

  • Member since 2023 · 31 posts · 28 votes
    2y
    Quote from @V.G Jason:

    Hawaii wise-- Kihei and north shore of Oahu. I think that's we narrowed it down too but understanding restrictions are a bit confusing. Much like you, this is my real target of 2024. 

    Miami I don't know why you have in same bucket as Hawaii. Or is it just a price bucket?


     Mainly a focus on STRs in a beach environment, dealing with lots of regulation, etc.

  • Member since 2023 · 31 posts · 28 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Carlos Ptriawan:
    Quote from @Account Closed:
    Quote from @Lane Kawaoka:

    Remember In Hawaii, STRs come with extra taxes: a 10.25% Transient Accommodations Tax (TAT), a 4% General Excise Tax (GET), plus a 0.5% Oahu Surcharge Tax on gross income from rents. Even if you are out of state resident that GET tax is charged on Hawaii clients which is messed up.

    STRs are definitely in vogue, but they're not without risks. Across Europe, cities are cracking down with new bylaws to regulate and tax them. In some cases, they're banning them entirely. Take Toronto, for instance. They've recently outlawed STRs of secondary dwellings due to a lack of affordable rental housing. You can rent out your primary residence or a room in it, but there's an annual license fee and a nightly tax involved.

    Many investors jumped on the STR bandwagon, expecting the market to stay the same. Big mistake. They didn't account for regulatory changes or market saturation, which could lower prices. With historically low barriers to entry, STRs seemed like a golden opportunity. But now, many Toronto property owners are facing financial troubles, with the new rules set to kick in six months.

    Bottom line: Don't bank on the current market conditions staying the same, especially if you're making a 25-year financial commitment. Personally, I stay away from the mainstream trends where everyone who is priced out of traditional long term rentals are now trying to rent out a room or a whole house on the daily. 


     I appreciate the insight. STRs are on my radar but I am definitely in it for the long term, so considering large multifamily and maybe living in one unit as a manager and off the rest of the cash flow.


     in general:
    - multifamily both in big island and honolulu is lackluster investment
    -in general honolulu STR doesn't appreciate that much, kona STR is appreciating 'mildly'.
    - hilo is relatively flat.
    - as for regulation, you could buy multiple cashflowing condo STR in vacation-resort zone
    - but best total return is always single family home, again with 5 mil I would entirely do flip in the richest neighborhood day and night. Actually now if someone can pay me to do it, I would do it by now LOL .... this is way more profitable than chasing CF.



     Interesting, what makes multifamily in Oahu lackluster? I'm cautious about flips given the materials cost in Hawaii, but trying to manage it from the mainland where I currently live (though i'm considering moving to Hawaii to live in a multi-unit I may own). Any recommendations for neighborhoods to look at for flips, so I can do research? 

  • Member since 2023 · 31 posts · 28 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Carlos Ptriawan:
    Quote from @Account Closed:

    Would like some feedback on options from people in the know on Hawaii (or Miami). Got about $5.3M to deploy somewhere through an LLC. Considering an all cash purchase to "park and profit," but open to debt. Considering Hawaii both for short term rentals (likely on the Big Island, in Kona; and/or Miami) and long-term multifamily in Honolulu, one unit I might live in. Open to potentially purchasing in all 2-3 locations simultaneously, depending on options. But I would like some feedback on these options available to me and what any of you would do in my shoes? I'm familiar with all the basic need-to-knows about these locations and their respective strategy implementation, but I'd appreciate any higher level feedback.


    if you have that amount, go buy house in Kukio, 30 min above Kona, avg price is 10-15 mil, your neighbour would be someone like Britney Spears. Dont care about cash flow , just STR it and you can double that 5 mil to 10 mil in few years. This is actually the hottest market in America IMO.

    With that level amount of money you have to play big and do NOT think small ( i am still small investor LOL)


    I'm concerned I might run out of cash servicing the debt (I presume you were implying a take a loan and use the $5M to leverage into something bigger) and overall expenses of a massive, muti deca-million property, if it weren't a multifamily. I'm not sure how to attract the ultra high net worth clients that would want to vacation in a massive house like that, or how to price it. I like the idea of parking the capital, eating the expenses, and selling for massive payouts, but I am concerned about those problems. Recommendations?

  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Account Closed:
    Quote from @V.G Jason:

    Hawaii wise-- Kihei and north shore of Oahu. I think that's we narrowed it down too but understanding restrictions are a bit confusing. Much like you, this is my real target of 2024. 

    Miami I don't know why you have in same bucket as Hawaii. Or is it just a price bucket?


     Mainly a focus on STRs in a beach environment, dealing with lots of regulation, etc.


    Hawaii STR environment is actually very conducive because the supply is limited.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.