Opinions on Hawaii Short Term Rentals

Opinions on Hawaii Short Term Rentals

Member since 2023 · 31 posts · 28 votes

Would like some feedback on options from people in the know on Hawaii (or Miami). Got about $5.3M to deploy somewhere through an LLC. Considering an all cash purchase to "park and profit," but open to debt. Considering Hawaii both for short term rentals (likely on the Big Island, in Kona; and/or Miami) and long-term multifamily in Honolulu, one unit I might live in. Open to potentially purchasing in all 2-3 locations simultaneously, depending on options. But I would like some feedback on these options available to me and what any of you would do in my shoes? I'm familiar with all the basic need-to-knows about these locations and their respective strategy implementation, but I'd appreciate any higher level feedback.

4Reply
302 views

Most Popular Reply

Sarah KensingerPro Member
Real Estate Consultant · OH · Member since 2023 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
2y

If your considering Miami, Fl for a STR, that's a tough place to have one due to restrictions. @Carson McGee Is the person to chat with about STR in Hawaii! From what he shared with me; I'd be parking a good bit of that money into a property there.

See this reply in the discussion

40 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Account Closed:
    Quote from @Carlos Ptriawan:
    Quote from @Account Closed:
    Quote from @Lane Kawaoka:

    Remember In Hawaii, STRs come with extra taxes: a 10.25% Transient Accommodations Tax (TAT), a 4% General Excise Tax (GET), plus a 0.5% Oahu Surcharge Tax on gross income from rents. Even if you are out of state resident that GET tax is charged on Hawaii clients which is messed up.

    STRs are definitely in vogue, but they're not without risks. Across Europe, cities are cracking down with new bylaws to regulate and tax them. In some cases, they're banning them entirely. Take Toronto, for instance. They've recently outlawed STRs of secondary dwellings due to a lack of affordable rental housing. You can rent out your primary residence or a room in it, but there's an annual license fee and a nightly tax involved.

    Many investors jumped on the STR bandwagon, expecting the market to stay the same. Big mistake. They didn't account for regulatory changes or market saturation, which could lower prices. With historically low barriers to entry, STRs seemed like a golden opportunity. But now, many Toronto property owners are facing financial troubles, with the new rules set to kick in six months.

    Bottom line: Don't bank on the current market conditions staying the same, especially if you're making a 25-year financial commitment. Personally, I stay away from the mainstream trends where everyone who is priced out of traditional long term rentals are now trying to rent out a room or a whole house on the daily. 


     I appreciate the insight. STRs are on my radar but I am definitely in it for the long term, so considering large multifamily and maybe living in one unit as a manager and off the rest of the cash flow.


     in general:
    - multifamily both in big island and honolulu is lackluster investment
    -in general honolulu STR doesn't appreciate that much, kona STR is appreciating 'mildly'.
    - hilo is relatively flat.
    - as for regulation, you could buy multiple cashflowing condo STR in vacation-resort zone
    - but best total return is always single family home, again with 5 mil I would entirely do flip in the richest neighborhood day and night. Actually now if someone can pay me to do it, I would do it by now LOL .... this is way more profitable than chasing CF.



     Interesting, what makes multifamily in Oahu lackluster? I'm cautious about flips given the materials cost in Hawaii, but trying to manage it from the mainland where I currently live (though i'm considering moving to Hawaii to live in a multi-unit I may own). Any recommendations for neighborhoods to look at for flips, so I can do research? 

    because if you chase multifamily, then Hawaii would not offer the greater return due to cap rate. Hawaii is #1 most expensive state in US so it's more suitable for appreciation/flips play. If you wanna do multifamily best to go to Iowa/Ohio.
  • Member since 2023 · 31 posts · 28 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Carlos Ptriawan:
    Quote from @AJ Wong:
    Quote from @Account Closed:

    Would like some feedback on options from people in the know on Hawaii (or Miami). Got about $5.3M to deploy somewhere through an LLC. Considering an all cash purchase to "park and profit," but open to debt. Considering Hawaii both for short term rentals (likely on the Big Island, in Kona; and/or Miami) and long-term multifamily in Honolulu, one unit I might live in. Open to potentially purchasing in all 2-3 locations simultaneously, depending on options. But I would like some feedback on these options available to me and what any of you would do in my shoes? I'm familiar with all the basic need-to-knows about these locations and their respective strategy implementation, but I'd appreciate any higher level feedback.


    There is no substitute for Hawaii. WIth that investment capital, one strategy to consider is a small boutique hotel with commercial zoning? Invest the rest on where you truly want to be into a legacy property. STR's are indeed a moving target in most coastal areas. There's oddly a lot of

    This is very true, with this large amount of capital, need to think big like NFL player level.

    I read financial proforma of class B hotel in Maui, it's pretty darn good, in fact it's perhaps the top ten best performing hotel in US in term of vacancy and RevPAR.

    STR and stuff like that is more for small investor like us with half to 1 mil buying power, but when it is above 5% you really need to talk to some serious developer/realtor in the island and understand the business.

    If I have that size of capital I would import contractor from California to finish my project in Kukio LOL 

    Currently in kona there're only few new construction that can still being built, I guess it is selling for 1.5mil and above.


     I appreciate the recommendation. I'm kind of got analysis paralysis right now, trying to figure out what to do with this. I am wanting to think big, perhaps even considering self storage somewhere and making a real company out of this, buying more SS facilities over time. Dunno. I like Hawaii though and am attracted to it.

  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Account Closed:
    Quote from @Carlos Ptriawan:
    Quote from @Account Closed:
    Quote from @Lane Kawaoka:

    Remember In Hawaii, STRs come with extra taxes: a 10.25% Transient Accommodations Tax (TAT), a 4% General Excise Tax (GET), plus a 0.5% Oahu Surcharge Tax on gross income from rents. Even if you are out of state resident that GET tax is charged on Hawaii clients which is messed up.

    STRs are definitely in vogue, but they're not without risks. Across Europe, cities are cracking down with new bylaws to regulate and tax them. In some cases, they're banning them entirely. Take Toronto, for instance. They've recently outlawed STRs of secondary dwellings due to a lack of affordable rental housing. You can rent out your primary residence or a room in it, but there's an annual license fee and a nightly tax involved.

    Many investors jumped on the STR bandwagon, expecting the market to stay the same. Big mistake. They didn't account for regulatory changes or market saturation, which could lower prices. With historically low barriers to entry, STRs seemed like a golden opportunity. But now, many Toronto property owners are facing financial troubles, with the new rules set to kick in six months.

    Bottom line: Don't bank on the current market conditions staying the same, especially if you're making a 25-year financial commitment. Personally, I stay away from the mainstream trends where everyone who is priced out of traditional long term rentals are now trying to rent out a room or a whole house on the daily. 


     I appreciate the insight. STRs are on my radar but I am definitely in it for the long term, so considering large multifamily and maybe living in one unit as a manager and off the rest of the cash flow.


     in general:
    - multifamily both in big island and honolulu is lackluster investment
    -in general honolulu STR doesn't appreciate that much, kona STR is appreciating 'mildly'.
    - hilo is relatively flat.
    - as for regulation, you could buy multiple cashflowing condo STR in vacation-resort zone
    - but best total return is always single family home, again with 5 mil I would entirely do flip in the richest neighborhood day and night. Actually now if someone can pay me to do it, I would do it by now LOL .... this is way more profitable than chasing CF.



     Interesting, what makes multifamily in Oahu lackluster? I'm cautious about flips given the materials cost in Hawaii, but trying to manage it from the mainland where I currently live (though i'm considering moving to Hawaii to live in a multi-unit I may own). Any recommendations for neighborhoods to look at for flips, so I can do research? 


    My recommendation with that 5 mil play is to pursuit luxury house, this is almost no brainer. Most rich fellow and all tech guru is investing big in Hawaii, you may only need to flip few properties to generate profit over mil. Most issue I feel is lack of contractor so you may want to import your folks to work in there. The way I see it in term of risk/reward , I would do more flips in Maui/Big Island rather than in CA.

    With that kind of money that you have I would buy one simple STR to live in and use the rest of 5 mil to build flips empire or even hotel like suggested by someone. The sky is really the limit in there.

    Also I just throw an idea, if you open big business, lets say car repair facility in Kona, you only have few competitors. In contrary to popular believe I think Hawaii is the best place to do business because their lack of labour and infrastructure.

  • Member since 2023 · 31 posts · 28 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Carlos Ptriawan:
    Quote from @Account Closed:
    Quote from @V.G Jason:

    Hawaii wise-- Kihei and north shore of Oahu. I think that's we narrowed it down too but understanding restrictions are a bit confusing. Much like you, this is my real target of 2024. 

    Miami I don't know why you have in same bucket as Hawaii. Or is it just a price bucket?


     Mainly a focus on STRs in a beach environment, dealing with lots of regulation, etc.


    Hawaii STR environment is actually very conducive because the supply is limited.


     My thoughts too. Regulation is pincy though, so gotta be careful. you ever deal with hawaii regulation for STRs before?

  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Account Closed:
    Quote from @Carlos Ptriawan:
    Quote from @Account Closed:
    Quote from @V.G Jason:

    Hawaii wise-- Kihei and north shore of Oahu. I think that's we narrowed it down too but understanding restrictions are a bit confusing. Much like you, this is my real target of 2024. 

    Miami I don't know why you have in same bucket as Hawaii. Or is it just a price bucket?


     Mainly a focus on STRs in a beach environment, dealing with lots of regulation, etc.


    Hawaii STR environment is actually very conducive because the supply is limited.


     My thoughts too. Regulation is pincy though, so gotta be careful. you ever deal with hawaii regulation for STRs before?

    I have my STR in Kona, so I'm your competitor.
    I handle everything, when I bought the condo is not even have permit, so I purchase with LLC DSCR loan, then I apply for the permit, takes a while, everything is so slow in the island. But well yea, it's 99% vacancy to this day.

    What makes me happy is actually ticket from San Francisco to Kona is only $99-$120 one way, so I can many times work from the island, when it reached 5pm PST in California then I stopped working and jump to the sea and tidepool in front of me. It's perfect lifestyle for me. My longer term planning is 100% move to Kona or Hilo.

    If you want to know good furniture store then I can refer as well.

  • Investor · Minneapolis · Member since 2023 · 265 posts · 162 votes
    2y

    Hi Alton - some people say the number one thing to consider is building a great team around you, no matter where you invest.  You can get tons of hyperlocal detail from resources like Airdna, Pricelabs and Hotstats.com.  Definitely compare hotels as part of your competitive data set (comp set) as lots of tourists will consider both.  Putting the right people around you with expertise across state/local taxes/law, insurance (your Airbnb policy isn't all it's cracked up to be), good designers, photographers and more cleaners than you think you need is some of what people overlook.  

    Even if you check out popular STR podcasts like STR Secrets and Get Paid For Your Pad, the successful hosts building large portfolios will say it's the infrastructure you build around you that matters. Best of luck!

  • Rental Property Investor · Honolulu · Member since 2021 · 30 posts · 11 votes
    2y

    If you really want to invest in Hawaii, I would recommend partnering with a VERY EXPERIENCED local investor. There are many you can find here, or on Instagram. You can partner or PML their deals and learn the market. Luxury just makes it higher cost.

    With your resources, absolutely, get into a deal here. Buy a house or condo here. Or many. Just know that there are better returns for lower risk in MF on the mainland - and that may be where you "make most of your money" and you keep your Hawaii props as fun/vacation.

  • Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Account Closed:
    Quote from @Henry T.:

    Careful, the whole place may be underwater by 2050....   You could probably find a nice 10 unit apt building in Kalihi or Waianae for cheap but you'll need to hire security.


     Got advice on dealing with crime in Hawaii? I've heard it's rampant in hotspots in Honolulu like chinatown. Thoughts?


     Crime is rampant everywhere in Hawaii. Don't walk alone. There are some gated areas. But my advice is to stay away.  There are no crime stats in Hawaii, it's life blood is tourist dollars. Officially, for crime to count, it has to go thru the courts and end with a conviction. Otherwise, it didn't happen.

  • Member since 2023 · 5 posts · 3 votes
    2y

    Short-term rentals are great, just consider that the initial investment will always be more than expected and you need a great management team. It is probably the less 'passive' investment within real estate 

  • Property Manager · Kailua-Kona, HI · Member since 2017 · 20 posts · 9 votes
    2y

    @Account Closed,

    It looks like you have gotten a lot of different views and suggestions from everyone. A lot of them would probably work out great, but ultimately you need to do what works for you.

    I am a property manager here on the Big Island in Kona. We manage a large portfolio of homes(120+), and have managed units from $1,000/month to $30,000/night. As you have seen from others, each island has its own rules and regulations. It is somewhat imperative to have someone in the market that knows and keeps up with all of the rule changes if you are going to invest out here. There is a bill currently in legislation in Hawaii County that is changing several items that affect rentals. They are on the 7th draft of it.

    Appreciation is the obvious play out here on the Big Island. There are very few properties that cash flow if they were bought today, but that doesn't mean that they don't exist. The most common ways(and maybe only ways currently) to cash flow here are large, high priced & high performing STVR's, or multi-family properties. One of the STVR properties that we manage is actually on the market at $5,900,000 currently. The property usually averages about $400,000/year in bookings. Combine that with appreciation and it could be a viable option.

    I also know of two different multi family properties right near the heart of Kailua Kona that are on the market as well. One is a 10-unit complex, listed at $3,000,000, and the other is a 9-unit complex, listed at $2,700,000. They are actually side by side buildings. They are underperforming rent-wise at the moment, so would be a solid value-add play if you had the capital.

    Let me know if you have any questions on the Kona market and I would be happy to help out if I can. 

  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Clark Kahawaii:

    @Account Closed,

    It looks like you have gotten a lot of different views and suggestions from everyone. A lot of them would probably work out great, but ultimately you need to do what works for you.

    I am a property manager here on the Big Island in Kona. We manage a large portfolio of homes(120+), and have managed units from $1,000/month to $30,000/night. As you have seen from others, each island has its own rules and regulations. It is somewhat imperative to have someone in the market that knows and keeps up with all of the rule changes if you are going to invest out here. There is a bill currently in legislation in Hawaii County that is changing several items that affect rentals. They are on the 7th draft of it.

    Appreciation is the obvious play out here on the Big Island. There are very few properties that cash flow if they were bought today, but that doesn't mean that they don't exist. The most common ways(and maybe only ways currently) to cash flow here are large, high priced & high performing STVR's, or multi-family properties. One of the STVR properties that we manage is actually on the market at $5,900,000 currently. The property usually averages about $400,000/year in bookings. Combine that with appreciation and it could be a viable option.

    I also know of two different multi family properties right near the heart of Kailua Kona that are on the market as well. One is a 10-unit complex, listed at $3,000,000, and the other is a 9-unit complex, listed at $2,700,000. They are actually side by side buildings. They are underperforming rent-wise at the moment, so would be a solid value-add play if you had the capital.

    Let me know if you have any questions on the Kona market and I would be happy to help out if I can. 


     Kailua Kona appreciation is bit similar to Kihei appreciation. I would say Kona is mini version of Kihei. 

    What's interesting between these two markets are that there's sudden interest starting from 2016/2017 and the price elasticity is creating very smooth sloping in price chart, unlike Bay Area SF that has few curves of up and down market cycle.

    Why this is important is just simply meant that this market almost doesn't have market cycle. Every supply is just being taken. Occasionally I checked in 2000 there're few FS condo w/ 200k, now price is double in just 4 years.

    These are really the market where STR regulation is increasing the price. 
    Many of our baby boomers want to retire, and they may want to move to Kona, Captain Cook, Hilo or even Kau.

    What not to like if you can snorkel/diving only to drive 13 minutes to hike and you are on top of the mountain with the cloud. 

    Only Big Island can provide this, not even Maui or Thailand beach can provide the same geographical landscape diversity lol. This is very unique.

  • Member since 2023 · 2 posts · 1 vote
    2y

    We just stayed in an Airbnb in Kauai - I dont see how it's cash flowing. The property is worth 2.5 million, and the nightly rate is the same as my STR in Galveston, Texas. The owners did well on appreciation though - they purchased it in 2021 for about 1.7 million.

  • Ryan MoyerBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orlando Kissimmee Davenport Salt Lake City, Park City · Member since 2019 · 996 posts · 1k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Leena Karmout:

    We just stayed in an Airbnb in Kauai - I dont see how it's cash flowing. The property is worth 2.5 million, and the nightly rate is the same as my STR in Galveston, Texas. The owners did well on appreciation though - they purchased it in 2021 for about 1.7 million.


     A big difference is that their season is year round (and if anything, this is the low season right now) whereas I'm assuming Galveston is a ~6 month season with only 2-3 months of really peak rates.

    But I agree it's doubtful the properties are cash flowing at current prices/rates.  Seems like when Hawaii opened back up there was a huge temporary surge in demand which helped drive prices way up, and prices have stayed up even as demand has normalized.

    I keep pretty close tabs on prices in Lahaina as we love it there and anecdotally it seems like prices have started coming down there a bit.  I'm not sure how much of that is insulated to that market because of the fires (the prices didn't drop at all right after the fires).

    Cosmic Vacations4.9177 Reviews
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.