Need Help Deciding on Rental Strategy for New Construction in an "Up and Coming" Area

Need Help Deciding on Rental Strategy for New Construction in an "Up and Coming" Area

Member since 2021 · 7 posts · 6 votes

Purchased a new construction in my town - (Gallatin, a suburb of Nashville TN). Got a great price and decent rate with DSCR loan. The home is in a good location - 3 blocks from the up and coming revitalized "downtown square" with boutique shops, cute restaurants, coffee shops. It is also 4 blocks from a local (small-ish) hospital that employs about 10 to 12 travel nurses at a time.

The original strategy when purchasing the home was to purchase it as an MTR or STR. I listed it on FB marketplace as a Long Term Rental while it was under contract just to get the feelers out, and I got a lot of responses from people who wondered if I'd take Section 8.

The house is in an area with pockets of Section 8 housing. The area has a reputation for being "sketchy". But I believe this is an up and coming area - my home is one of the first tear-down-rebuilds in the area, with more remodels / tear-down-rebuilds in the works (there are a handful of remodels in the neighborhood). The downtown area has revitalized significantly in the last 5 years. I feel this house is on the early end of revitalization.

I also reached out to the hospital to try and connect with their travel nurse housing person, as well as a rural med school that sends med students to this hospital for their yearly rotations. I haven't had luck connecting with them yet to advertise my property to them as an MTR.

I've had it listed on Furnished Finder for a week - with no furnishings in it yet, but with comments that it will be furnished soon. I've had NO interest in it, not even to inquire about when it will be furnished.

My question is this: Do I take Section 8 or a lower rent for a year or so, and break even (the long term rent I could get would have me break even)? Or do I bite the bullet and invest in furnishing the property for a MTR or STR? I am nervous to furnish it then have it sit empty.

Are there strategies for furnishing or marketing it as an MTR/STR that will enhance the chances of it being booked?

I'd appreciate any other ways of looking at my rental strategy options. Thanks!

1Reply
177 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Broker · Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH · Member since 2013 · 31k+ posts · 20k+ votes
2y
Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:

Just because you may not do STR/MTR right away does not mean you are stuck with S8. Wait, be patient, and you will find a good regualr long-term renter.

Some people will do S8 because they've had decent luck. I would personally never touch it.

 Section 8 being viable is totally about the neighborhood. If you're in the ghetto, Section 8 tenants pose the lowest level of risk to the landlord when compared to cash paying tenants. If you're not in the ghetto, the opposite is true.

See this reply in the discussion

14 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Bruce WoodruffPro Member
    Contractor/Investor/Consultant · San Diego / Phoenix · Member since 2021 · 12k+ posts · 15k+ votes
    2y

    Just because you may not do STR/MTR right away does not mean you are stuck with S8. Wait, be patient, and you will find a good regualr long-term renter.

    Some people will do S8 because they've had decent luck. I would personally never touch it.

  • John UnderwoodPro Member
    Investor · Greer, SC · Member since 2014 · 13k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    2y

    Look for similar properties nearby on Vrbo and Airbnb to see how they are doing to see how this might fair as a STR.

  • Rental Property Investor · Phoenix, AZ and Rehoboth Beach DE · Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2y

    I hear Section 8 takes time for your house to be inspected and approved.  I also don't think you'll be able to get a Section 8 renter out easily when you feel like it or want to switch to MTR.  I would only do Section 8 if you intend to do it long term.  

    Are travel nurses who work odd hours going to feel safe in this area, since you say it's somewhat sketchy? 

  • Interior Decorator · Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 32 posts · 29 votes
    2y

    Congratulations on your new property! There’s definitely a strategy for designing your property to fill your calendar and attract dream guests. It would be difficult to get any inquiries for MTR with an empty property even if you note that it will be furnished because they don’t know what “furnished” is going to look like (style, comfort level, etc.)’

    If your ideal target market is travel nurses I would start there. Are there STRs/MTRs in the area? What type/size of property is it? For a single nurse or do you want to rent several private rooms?

    To attract travel nurses to your property, you would first have be conveniently located to the nearest hospital. So think walkable (bonus) or by public transportation, if not garage parking is a must for when they come home late. Especially if your area has a reputation for being sketchy.

    Next you’d want to look at the frequency of travel nurses coming to the area. An easy way to do that is look on booking platforms and read the reviews. Why did those guests visit and how long did they stay?

    Once you've verified that there's a strong market for travel nurses, you can move forward to the design portion. And in this phase simply put, prioritize comfort and convenience in every decision. This is what nurses look for when choosing a MTR for their contract. So things like choosing a visibly comfortable sofa instead of a cheap futon will help you stand out and attract bookings on autopilot. Knowing where to splurge and where to save is key to maximizing your ROI. It all boils down to your ideal guest. Knowing what they value and what unique experiences they're willing to pay premium for is key to a successful MTR. That along with unique design that stops the scroll.


    But from what you described, this property sounds like it would also work for STR guests that want to visit downtown but stay tucked away from the hustle and bustle.

  • Real Estate Agent · Nashville, TN · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    2y

    @Emily Runyan

    You're in one of the best up and coming areas in the greater Nashville market. Gallatin is poised for some serious growth. 

    In 2017 I too was first on a very up and coming area on Queen Ave in Nashville. I was the first developer to build new on that street. I had a TOUGH time getting the houses sold. So much so, that I ended up having to refinance and keep one of them as a rental. I ended up breaking even on the one house I sold and broke even on the rent I was getting on the house I kept. I ended up selling it 4 years later for a huge gain after several developers came in and built up the rest of the street. 

    If you're first in an area in the path of progress the process is tough and you have to be patient. 

    Personally, I wouldn't do MTR in your situation. I would make sure your property is properly marketed and that your rents are in line with the comps. I also wouldn't do a lease longer than 1 year because your rental comps in the area might rapidly increase as the area develops. 

    Patience is the key here....

  • Contractor · Sheboygan, WI · Member since 2016 · 921 posts · 266 votes
    2y

    @Emily Runyanask yourself why would people stay in an area as a STVR if it’s a sketchy, unsafe neighborhood?

    Does zoning allow STRs in that neighborhood?

  • Andrew SteffensBusiness Member
    Tampa, FL · Member since 2022 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    2y

    A lot of variables to give you a solid answer - but if you can financially weather a little turbulence I would stick to the the original STR/MTR plan, as long as there are STR comps that support this decision.

  • Member since 2021 · 7 posts · 6 votes
    2y

    Thanks for the responses everyone! 

    The area (because it's on the early end of "up and coming") has no STR or MTR zoning restrictions.

    It's somewhat sketchy by reputation of the locals, but anyone driving through the area would think differently. It's right next to the cute downtown square with a lot of modern shops. In my view it's not sketchy, just not high end. 

    Good insights @Luka Milicevic! Shortly after I published this post yesterday, I got a solid lead for a long term renter from my FB marketplace listing of the property. I could cash flow $300/month at the rent I'm asking for on Marketplace (I listed it higher than I thought I'd be able to get). I meet the potential tenant at the house this evening - fingers crossed! Also, the home appraised for $18K more than the purchase price, so I think that bodes well for the investment.

  • Real Estate Agent · Tampa Florida · Member since 2013 · 630 posts · 303 votes
    2y

    What about just doing it as LTR? What is the going rate for your area? If you don't want to invest in STR/MTR list it on Zillow unfurnished. I am in Tampa Florida and we have a shortage of rentals and honest prices.

  • Investor · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2017 · 94 posts · 32 votes
    2y

    @Emily Runyan

    Congrats! I like this area as well. I’m looking to employ a similar strategy as you on a house I am renovating in East Nashville currently. I’m torn between MTR and LTR.

  • V.G JasonPro Member
    Investor · Member since 2022 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    2y

    I'd do it as an STR, that way when permits/regulations come in you can be grandfathered in.

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH · Member since 2013 · 31k+ posts · 20k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:

    Just because you may not do STR/MTR right away does not mean you are stuck with S8. Wait, be patient, and you will find a good regualr long-term renter.

    Some people will do S8 because they've had decent luck. I would personally never touch it.

     Section 8 being viable is totally about the neighborhood. If you're in the ghetto, Section 8 tenants pose the lowest level of risk to the landlord when compared to cash paying tenants. If you're not in the ghetto, the opposite is true.

  • Karen WanamartaBusiness Member
    Investor · Knoxville TN · Member since 2024 · 55 posts · 17 votes
    2y

    @Emily Runyan Have you tried reaching out to ALE Solutions? Medium term housing for insurance claims. They pay well. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Denver, CO · Member since 2024 · 19 posts · 5 votes
    2y

    It does sound like it could be an attractive STR. How's the STR competition and do you have a sense of what you would pull in with ST v LT? There's so much you can do with decor and your marketing to make your STR standout over the competition as long as it's priced right. My Denver LTR is much more "set and forget" than my STR, which I manage myself. But the income from the STR far surpasses that of the LTR, so it's a trade off. If you think the area you're in is well-suited for travelers, I would go ahead and get settled as an STR before regulations come sweeping in like V.G. said. Best of luck! Keep us posted!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.