Rental Property Investor · SF Bay Area, CA · Member since 2014 · 352 posts · 543 votes
Lots of people have asked me how to start doing a "Rental Arbitrage" in STR (short term rentals - Airbnb is most popular but VRBO is another way).
Rental arbitrage is you as the investor rents a home and becomes the tenant. But the sole purpose of renting is to then sublease the home on Airbnb or VRBO or corporate rentals.
Here are the key rules of Rental Arbitrage:
1) You need to MAKE money/profit. Typical target for most Rental arbitrage investors is $1000 NOI (net operating income = revenue - expenses). Do your research to make sure you can make a profit. This is not easy work to find a property, lease a property, furnish the property, and manage it. You better not come up with a calculation that comes out to be less than $1000/month NOI or you may actually LOSE money.
2) You need to make sure everything is LEGIT/ABOVE BOARD/TRANSPARENT. You cannot hide the fact that the sole purpose for you to rent the home is to sublease. The owner must know from the beginning and in fact you need to include it in your lease agreement that the home is going to be subleased and that the owner agrees to allow this to happen.
3) City, county, local, HOA regulations must support what you are doing. You cannot go blindly into doing a rental arbitrage without knowing the restrictions. HOA is the trickiest. Typically the restrictive HOAs are condos, new construction communities.
4) Cost of furnishing needs to be factored into your calculations. Cost of furnishing is not limited to the cost of furniture but labor costs to furnish home can be high. Typical costs can vary widely depending on where you get your furniture, labor cost, etc. Remember your own labor cost.
Typically a 2 bedroom home can be furnished between $3000-8000. Remember the home is empty and filling it with all the amenities including (all kitchenware, bedding, etc..) are not cheap.
5) Extra expenses include - Utilities, Garbage, Internet, Streaming (Netflix, SlingTV, do NOT get cable).
Tricks and TIps - Best TV for STR = Roku TCL 4K TVs - as low as $250-350 per TV.
Watch for my next post: How to approach a Landlord to rent to you!
@Paul Sandhu while this may be enough for the particular traveler you’re renting to, this is nowhere near enough to furnish a house that the typical airbnb traveler has come to expect.
We have a list of 185 items that go into each rentals we design, many of them multiple times. Promoting the “spend as little as possible now and just deliver what they need” model is a money waster. We recommend people do it once and do it right. Travelers deserve—and expect—to be comfortable in their space. An unhappy traveler may leave a negative review, which has a direct impact on profit and listing standing.
For those who want to do this seriously, don’t cheap out on the furnishings. Buy quality so you’re not replacing every year. Buy white, cotton linens you can bleach (skip the polyester, it doesn’t breathe). Buy duvet covers you can launder with each flip. Don’t skimp on the mattress - everyone in the world wants a good night’s sleep.
A well-furnished/designed home makes more money, always.
Thank you for the clarification! In that case then I agree to a point but not entirely. I urge people to do things correctly the first time. That doesn’t mean buy luxury everything by any means. But it DOES mean doing a lot more than the list @Paul Sandhu previously provided, though it seems he’s catering to a far different demographic of traveler. Totally fine. Just not my wheelhouse.
Then again I'm not a huge fan of the arbitrage model. Too many variables that can't be—or are hard to—control. In that case you're totally right - go cheap, because you never know when the owner needs to move back in or the HOA changes or the legislation deems multi-tenant units illegal.
When it comes to airbnb arbitrage a lot of your properties may already be furnished which is a huge bonus for those just getting started.
After the obvious important stuff you want to have extra items for your guests such as cleaning supplies, soap, snacks, etc. This thoughtful gesture will go a long way in this business. BUT don't go overboard with it and spend $1,000 on nicknacks thinking that it's going to make a difference.
A minimalist approach is much better for beginners and experiences airbnb investors. But every property, market, season, location, etc. will be different and some areas may demand more of this.
@Mel "As the market continues to saturate, especially as the hotel chains get into this, the hosts who cater to the guest will be the ones still cashing in those big money checks."
AMEN
That is what these "do it on the cheap" "scale rapidly" "find pliable idiots to arb their apartments from" "Do I really need STR insurance" newbies don't get.
I think this is the 4th time I said it: I stayed in Newark, NJ airbnb's several times. $30 nightly. The NYC market! And it wasn't hard to find! The hosts are paying utilities, commissions, have vacancies, CC payments, insurance, mortgage or rent, cleaning, furnishing, maintenance, time spent, risk, etc.
They could make more money from longterm renters, Arbitrageurs!!!
We use PROPER INSURANCE LLC for our listings, but it depends on where you are and what companies service your area. If you do some research you'll probably find something that'll work for your needs.
@Kinohi Larey where do you purchase your short term rental insurance? We own our property and have HO insurance but I’m guessing we need this additional insurance. I like that it covers lost income due to natural disaster.
Sean describes himself as the Million $ Renter. He pays over $1,000,000 per year in rent for his arbitrage apartments. Many, many nuggets can be found in his videos. He also does clarity.fm for one-on-one calls.
I doubt I would use this tactic, but the "pathetic" description isn't to put motel guests down. It is to make his current(and especially future) house guests feel superior. And surely works for his target demo. Well played! lol
Do you find that a homeowner policy typically covers the owner's home? Or does the owner have to get a different type of policy before agreeing to lease to you in order to turn around and rent out?
I had to look into a different policy for my own coverage (CBIZ) and I feel that this would cause some owners some issues...
1) you are not netting 2k. You left out vacation rental insurance, you left out things like furnishings and maintenance. Or replacement cost or risk.
Also, an owner would be making a ton of equity if they owned outright.
2) I think this is the kind of strategy that works better in places with high rent and High house prices.
I paid 135000 for 2 Townhomes that grosses 65000 a year. Is a much better deal to own these then to try to sublease. And I get all the profits for the same amount of work. And I build equity and I'm not subject to the whims of landlords or property owners who change your mind or Etc
@Penny Griffus It's been going well! We are making very good margins. Of course not as good as some "mentors" online advertise, but still way better than If we were to purchase a property and have a mortgage. Here are some quick numbers for one of our units:
Our rent: $2,375
Other variable expenses (internet, toiletries, etc) ~ $120
Our average income from STR (After service fees, cleaning fees):
$4,750
So we're netting over 2k a month. Pretty decent margin if you ask me :)
Ken I hear what you are saying Sir and you have awesome valid points that I never even took into consideration. For that I would like to Thank you for people like you as well as your knowledge is what I love about this site. Thank you Brandon as well for putting all this together.
Anyway, I am an actual person who actually executes Airbnb arbitrages throughout the state of Massachusetts. I’ll be more than happy to prove it to you as well. The gentlemen, Jose is 1000% correct Sir with everything he said from a numbers game and what to offer.
I get your points, but being also a RE broker (Torrey and Associates is my Agency Business) I’ve seen all aspects of subleasing. With these Apps nowadays, we have great opportunities. You are correct Ken and I’m not discrediting you at all Sir, however you are totally ignoring the concept. I started off by calling slumlords in a city outside of Boston. When I say slum lords I'm not talking about the buildings like the movie "The Super" starring Joe Pesci. I digress. The cost of doing this, vary and is exclusively up to your clientele and what you can or cannot spend etc. I know one day he doesn't spend a freaking dime he goes to the nearest Walmart just like somebody said in one of these posts to supply his STR. Ohh yeah I basically get mine from IKEA. however I’m seeing figures like four to $8000 first off you guys are getting way too over your heads with this and making it way too difficult. Right now I have five portfolios all arbitrage throughout Massachusetts southeastern in North. I ask for 30 day minimum stay and minus my first one which was a slum LOL, they’re in decent areas
To get these places I gathered up chunks in chunks of landlords names numbers and email addresses skip trace as many as I could contact them and got a bunch of “No’s”. Even after I told them that I was an established broker in the city and they knew about my company some of them I actually knew who they were and they still said no. But why I think this gentleman talking hear about arbitrage is telling the truth of how he knows this stuff is because I employed it myself. probably not in the same way as him however I utilize the same tactics. I never offered him any profit share of what I make but what I did was do research about that particular landlord of course I didn't do it for the thousands of chunks of XL spreadsheet landlord list I had, But just being a broker and I have some sales people that do nothing but rentals I know where there's a lot of vacancies in the nicer areas as well. So over the years you get to know what's wrong with a certain area why is there so much turnover why is there a lot of vacancies are utilized my knowledge and I poked at it. For example, one of my portfolio rentals is owned by a landlord who is a great guy but he's out of town and this is an inherited property that he is so thickheaded not to get rid of. This makes it very hard for him to travel to fix things or to even call people in the area without being screwed of the job being done properly. And he didn't want to spend money on expensive property managers even though I knew a couple that were kind of affordable but I utilized my plan to take advantage. So I offered free property management in return to sublet 3 of his current vacancies. I sold it to them by I will look after three of those rental units, The common areas of the facility and the luxury of him not having to worry about vacancies because of his absence and remote management. I mean he will never have to worry about filling in a vacancy ever and I told him even if I don't have the place Sublett at any given time he will get his rent like clockwork every month and what she does until this day. 5 other STR I have and I offered free snow removal in the winter time And (4) free landscaping visits composed of 2 in spring and 2 in summer which my brother (who owned a landscaping company?) utilizes new workers he hired for these visits to see how good they are and what their strengths are. Haha he is more than welcome to practice on my properties LOL. Now for the math True Life
Landlord : Joe Lac
20 Rufus Street Brockton, MA 02301
Block 8 units corner of Quincy St and Court St.
2 units sublet each in return for small property management (minor repairs) and winter snow removal plowing)
Simple
My Rental Agreement is an At Will
So it’s month to month so if he ever decides to kick me out I have a contingency and I contract that if he does decide he needs to let me know 30 days before hand that he’s going to terminate my TENANCY AT WILL status on that so I don’t have a tenant out on his ***.
I’ve spent a little under $800 to make each unit presentable and my rent is $1350 a month- One time cost (so far)
Plowing is done again my my brother who I get a huge discount. Basically I give em $50 a visit.
My rentals are a minimum of 30 days and I target professionals conducting business in Boston ( NO I DIDN'T ATTRACT THESE PEOPLE AT FIRST WITH THE SLUM LORD LOL)
I charge $125.00 per night for 30 day minimum and usually booked out 5 months at a time.
My gross per month before rent=$3750
My net after paying $1350= $2,400
$28,800 per year
Minus other expenses snow removal etc $4500 through the year give or take $24,300
Not bad for not having to own anything and barely need to spend and ridiculous amounts of money. I also own 2 multi units too but I hire a property management company (I don’t play landlord? Sorry but I bet you don’t make $65k a year on your rental you own. Want to know how I know?
I support the 30 day plus nature of what you do. but $65k means nothing. there are people with million dollar properties.
But the two buildings i had to switch from str to ltr due to location were 135k (two townhomes) and 280k and are on target to gross 110k together. converting to str dollars (25-30% more due to many other expenses) that would be around 143k equivalent annual gross.
1 ) Its all about finding an undervalued apartment--- acquire apartments during slow months of the season to save 10-15% on rent. That will net you $2-5K per year.
2) Furnish cheaply. Thrift stores + 2nd hand + craigslist. Find good stuff for cheap.
3) Location, location, location.
4) hire a Professional to do the management. But hire one that knows what theyre doing and isnt charging 30%. ( I know a great mgmt company if you need one that is nationwide and puts all the "major" players to shame in terms of value/ service).
I have about 10 more "tips" I can share, but I usually charge for these.
Disclosure: I am a full-time STR Arbitrageur that also buys properties across the country. I have good insight into most of the major STR markets. I went from broke to making over $1m in my first year- not to brag, but to show you the potential. I also haven't taken a day off in 2 years, and am happier than I've ever been.
#4 makes no sense in most areas. And if the national one is evolve or vacasa, that is a mistake. perhaps you mean guesty?
PMs are an unnecessary expense. good software and automation can replace almost of what you do. good cleaner/handyman and you on the phone can handle the rest.
I can't believe this thread is still alive. What is the incentive of letting some other tenant parade a bunch of non-screened "tenants" in/out of their place so the actual "tenant" can make money from their asset? Why not just AirBnB it themselves? Or let a Property Manager do it if they don't want to be bothered? What does the "tenant" have to offer other than the fact that they don't have 2 nickels to rub together and thus have to squat on someone else's property to make money?
It is usually kept alive by newbies who see a cheap way to get rich, people who have some kind of commission incentive, or for the vast majority a collective misinformation campaign. Those who seek it's defense, usually seem to be those who already do it in mass which of course doesn't apply to someone new to the idea.
Arbitrage - all of the risk expense and work to get some of the profit (maybe)
There are mortgages out there at 5 and 6% easily. What in the world are people afraid of in going out and buying something and taking out most of the risk and getting all the appreciation and equity?
I can't believe this thread is still alive. What is the incentive of letting some other tenant parade a bunch of non-screened "tenants" in/out of their place so the actual "tenant" can make money from their asset? Why not just AirBnB it themselves? Or let a Property Manager do it if they don't want to be bothered? What does the "tenant" have to offer other than the fact that they don't have 2 nickels to rub together and thus have to squat on someone else's property to make money
@Mel Hignell I agree with you. I'm a firm believer in treating others as you would want to be treated. People love convenience and savings! When you put the two together, it's a win - win situation.