@Rick Goss welcome over. I self-manage long-term rentals, so I can't rank the STR platforms for you, but the per-property fee is the thing to model out. It looks small at two units and adds up fast at ten. I'd ask each one how they price as you scale and how easy it is to export your data if you leave. Switching later is the part nobody plans for. Hope we cross paths sometime.
@Rick Goss welcome over. I self-manage long-term rentals, so I can't rank the STR platforms for you, but the per-property fee is the thing to model out. It looks small at two units and adds up fast at ten. I'd ask each one how they price as you scale and how easy it is to export your data if you leave. Switching later is the part nobody plans for. Hope we cross paths sometime.
@Rick Goss welcome to BP! I run an STR/MTR hybrid on my own units and the ones I co-host, so I went through this same search recently.
I haven't found one that skips per-property pricing entirely. Most charge per listing or a percentage of revenue.
What changed my thinking was comparing the whole tech stack per property, not just the PMS line item. I moved from Guesty to Jurny because with Guesty I was paying a premium price and still bolting on a bunch of separate connected apps.
Now it's Jurny, Turno for cleanings and PriceLabs for pricing and calendar management, and the whole stack runs under $70 a month per property. Fair warning: Jurny may be more than a small portfolio needs, and they are not a fan of smaller portfolios. I was able to get on with them with a small portfolio because of a professional relationship I have.
Since you mentioned MTR, which is where most of my portfolio sits, a few things I'd test during any trial:
- How it handles a 30+ day booking: monthly payments, extensions, and longer-stay cancellation terms.
- Whether minimum stays and pricing are controlled by your pricing tool or the PMS, so the two don't fight each other. I manage mine in PriceLabs.
- How your guest screening and rental agreement flow works through it, if you plan to use one, especially with Airbnb's temporary phone numbers starting Oct 26 for connected software.
How many units are you running, and is it mostly your own or ones you manage for others?
@Rick Goss fair question. I can't speak to how it compared years ago, but I can tell you how I use it now, because for me the value isn't just the base price recommendation.
The biggest piece is minimum-stay control. Most of my units are set up for 30+ day stays, and PriceLabs handles the minimums for me. Dates well out after a mid-term booking carry a long minimum. As that guest's checkout gets closer, the minimum steps down, to 14 days and then lower, so I can fill short gaps without tying up the calendar or blocking a guest who wants to extend.
The other piece is the market data. Before I discount, I check that market's booking window in the Market Dashboards. If guests there book 3-7 days out, I'm not cutting rate a month ahead. I'd rather hold rate and watch pacing first.
So I'd think of it less as "trust the algorithm" and more as a rules engine you set up for your strategy. If you're mostly nightly and already have a pricing approach you like, it may not add much. If you're mixing in 30+ day stays, the minimum-stay automation is what I'd test.
On your PMS comment, I agree with you more than you'd think. They all do roughly the same thing, so it really becomes a personal choice. Besides the cost and all the add-on apps, the other big reason I left Guesty was their support, or lack of it, when I had issues. When something breaks with a guest waiting, how fast you can get a real person matters more than any feature list.
With OwnerRez, are you setting prices manually right now or using something built in?
I will explore Jurny today. I use Owner Rez and do the price reductions manually as part of my day. I have 10 STR/MTR's and they all have different peak seasonal rates. I am very fatigued from my Housekeepers - husband / wife - salt of the earth however - the wife is super passive / aggressive and plays the sweet role toward my wife and never me. Too old to play the games. - So I will explore Turno as well. They have left my homes in unforgiveable conditions and blame the hard water etc. It will refrain form pics. Anyhow- Thanks gentlemen for your time.
Oh man, that sucks. I have had decent luck with cleaners. I ended up with one who wants to do just the quick type turns and it was affecting the overall cleanliness. I just spent a small fortune to deep clean one and what she found was shocking.
I also cannot imagine doing the pricing manually. Bless you! I have found Pricelabs is worth it's weight for me. It is really allowing me to capture higher rates and occupancy. Let me know if I can be a resource for you on that.
Welcome to BP! Theres a ton of options out there but just about all of them price per listing in some way, a lot of the "all in one" ones just bury it in a tiered plan so it doesnt look per-property at first - might be worth figuring out which features you actually need (dynamic pricing, guest messaging, cleaner scheduling, owner statements, etc.) since that tends to narrow it down pretty quick. How many units are you running right now and are they mostly STR or a mix with MTR?
I’d ask each PMS to demonstrate one ordinary booking and one last-minute date change using your actual workflow. Does the change reach the cleaner, guest messages and access-code schedule without you fixing each separately? The monthly fee is easy to compare; those little manual handoffs are harder to spot until you’re using it.
I have been on Zoom calls w several co.'s and so far not very convinced they are not a redundant service- I use Owner Rez to consolidate my platform and use wholesale credit card processing company - .20 per transaction and .20 of gross - authorize.net - wholesale processing access. I can send a contact if it is of interest?