We just recently started house renovation and got red tagged by the city inspector. I guess he saw dumpster while driving around or maybe neighbors complained. So we learned never leave dumpster in city limits.
Much appreciated
Pull permits for any work requiring one...
@Bruce Woodruff Yeah I'm guessing every municipality is different, that just seems to be the norm in Ct. even when we do excavation on a property where a structure already exists we just have the occupant of the building slap it in the front window along with the crew on the job usually having a photocopy with them as well (which is just our company's protocol).
Another caveat around here, homeowners can pull some permits without a license for some tasks generally as long as it isn't major structural work, major electrical work and possibly major plumbing work (those require licensed contractors to pull). Some contractors will even offer pretty nice discounts if the homeowner pulls the permit. I however am not sure if the owner of a non-primary residence could also do that, they may require a license to pull any permit on investment properties, I have never tried as I always have my contractor pull or coordinate the pulling of permits.
@Bruce Woodruff Yeah I'm guessing every municipality is different, that just seems to be the norm in Ct. even when we do excavation on a property where a structure already exists we just have the occupant of the building slap it in the front window along with the crew on the job usually having a photocopy with them as well (which is just our company's protocol).
Another caveat around here, homeowners can pull some permits without a license for some tasks generally as long as it isn't major structural work, major electrical work and possibly major plumbing work (those require licensed contractors to pull). Some contractors will even offer pretty nice discounts if the homeowner pulls the permit. I however am not sure if the owner of a non-primary residence could also do that, they may require a license to pull any permit on investment properties, I have never tried as I always have my contractor pull or coordinate the pulling of permits.
These kind of information are extremely valuable especially for OOS investor that would like invest in certain market.
Regarding the investment properties, obviously there're much more serious scrutiny from the city, especially Multifamily with 2 units and larger. This is one of my biggest mistake in REI. By now I would rather buy turnkey ready-to-move Singe Family only in CF market. Class doesn't really matter as long as tenant and PMC is good, but city regulation is one aspect that we in BP many times forget to handle.
Don't be sneaky and shady....Get your permits. Maybe you don't care about your reputation and prey on people that don't do their homework before buying a house. If the buyers know major work was done and no permits were pulled (purposely in your case) they are going to consider that a huge red flag and shady af. Word travels fast these days....and in the real estate/construction world reputation is everything....
@Michael Feuerbach Exactly, when in doubt just ask the local building officials if you need a permit for the work you're about to do.
I could be wrong but I wouldn't be surprised if unpermitted work leads to damage in the future it seems that is something the insurance could use against a claim if they can dig deep enough to figure it out.
Massive facepalm. Do things the right way OP. It's not hard. Not wanting to pull a permit for installing an outlet or doing something extremely minor I can understand.
Not wanting to pull a permit for "extensive renovations" and then trying to sell the flip is one reason why I loathe house flippers. Might as well tell the world you love cutting corners (which is what I primarily see on flips). It's also why I rarely get to do them because I know the true costs involved in doing one correctly. Last one I did was nearly $220k in renovation and the house is now fantastic. If someone else bought it, they would have spent 100k slapping lipstick on a pig
@Alexander P. - in the city of Huntsville proper, if you perform what is deemed to be "substantial unpermitted work" on a house, it is technically illegal to sell the property for the first year after the work was performed. Granted, this would require the buyer to determine permits weren't pulled and file a lawsuit; but you would lose the suit by default. How do I know this? I pulled a permit myself in 2018 for an addition to my house; the inspectors office told me directly that either unpermitted work, and/or work that the final inspection was never signed off on, would result in the owner not being able to legally sell the property for one year after the work was deemed to have been completed.
So we have a choice to hire GC to pull permits for us or pull permit as homeowner/builder correct?
If we go with second choice, can we still use our contractors and hire GC only for consulting purposes to prepare for inspection/reinspection?
First, know the code. It's posted online under Construction Services for the municipality. What you don't know - like the dumpster thing - not only gets you red tagged but guess what else? Placed on the radar. That code enforcement guy - he'll be back. He knows you're rehabbing...
Second, don't tick off the neighbors. Make sure that your property is pristine on the exterior - no trash, no parking on the grass, no foul language, no 'guys' just hanging, and no dang dumpster. Know why? It's not who you see but who sees you...and once the neighbors see you and you have offended them, you're on the radar - yet again. They'll keep reporting you and reporting you and reporting you. And, that leads you to being the favorite target of code enforcement. See how this works.
Permit, don't permit...a little story to tell you. I had a client who decided not to pull a permit to rewire a MF property to avoid the $40k cost. No, why do that when you can hire an active meth user who has never held an electrician's license to do it for $8k? Even if you can forget that if the place burns down with tenants in it, you - yes, you - as the owner - are going to prison for a lifetime - yeah, let that go. Consider the work ethic of a drug user...they come, they go. What price can you put on your job being held hostage by a guy you can't find. Can't permit it once it's started - no one will touch it. Get another guy into finish it - not going to find that fool. Sometimes what you think is saving you money is actually costing you a whole lot more than if you had done it right the first time.
Reputation. Be the real deal. Those who want 'to appear to be' are only fooling themselves.
And, don't forget - you were outed by a dumpster.
Patricia, thanks for your exhaustive explanation.
So we have a choice to hire GC to pull permits for us or pull permit as homeowner/builder correct?
If we go with second choice, can we still use our contractors and hire GC only for consulting purposes to prepare for inspection/reinspection?
First, know the code. It's posted online under Construction Services for the municipality. What you don't know - like the dumpster thing - not only gets you red tagged but guess what else? Placed on the radar. That code enforcement guy - he'll be back. He knows you're rehabbing...
Second, don't tick off the neighbors. Make sure that your property is pristine on the exterior - no trash, no parking on the grass, no foul language, no 'guys' just hanging, and no dang dumpster. Know why? It's not who you see but who sees you...and once the neighbors see you and you have offended them, you're on the radar - yet again. They'll keep reporting you and reporting you and reporting you. And, that leads you to being the favorite target of code enforcement. See how this works.
Permit, don't permit...a little story to tell you. I had a client who decided not to pull a permit to rewire a MF property to avoid the $40k cost. No, why do that when you can hire an active meth user who has never held an electrician's license to do it for $8k? Even if you can forget that if the place burns down with tenants in it, you - yes, you - as the owner - are going to prison for a lifetime - yeah, let that go. Consider the work ethic of a drug user...they come, they go. What price can you put on your job being held hostage by a guy you can't find. Can't permit it once it's started - no one will touch it. Get another guy into finish it - not going to find that fool. Sometimes what you think is saving you money is actually costing you a whole lot more than if you had done it right the first time.
Reputation. Be the real deal. Those who want 'to appear to be' are only fooling themselves.
And, don't forget - you were outed by a dumpster.
Patricia, thanks for your exhaustive explanation.
So we have a choice to hire GC to pull permits for us or pull permit as homeowner/builder correct?
If we go with second choice, can we still use our contractors and hire GC only for consulting purposes to prepare for inspection/reinspection?
If you choose to act as Owner/Builder, you are the equivalent of a GC (but you can only do this on a home you own and reside in). You can sub-contract to anyone else with a license, including a GC. But why not just hire a GC and have him do everything? Don't be cheap, it will almost always end up costing you more money.
@Alexander P.
I wish my post was an exhaustive explanation - but it is far from it. And, no - you cannot pull a permit on a NON-OWNER OCCUPIED property unless you are a GC. Investment property owners are not eligible to act as their own contractor; only those owners who agree and certify that they will not sell and/or lease said property for one year have that option. All of this is readily available online for your state (http://www.nvcontractorsboard....)
The bottom line with all of this is once code enforcement knows you exist, you're on the radar. And, once you're on the radar, you can expect to be "visited" frequently. It is actually cheaper to pull permits than to have your project stopped, pay the fines, and endure court hearings before the magistrate court.
It's hard to overcome stupid. Don't date code enforcement...
@Alexander P.
I wish my post was an exhaustive explanation - but it is far from it. And, no - you cannot pull a permit on a NON-OWNER OCCUPIED property unless you are a GC. Investment property owners are not eligible to act as their own contractor; only those owners who agree and certify that they will not sell and/or lease said property for one year have that option. All of this is readily available online for your state (http://www.nvcontractorsboard....)
The bottom line with all of this is once code enforcement knows you exist, you're on the radar. And, once you're on the radar, you can expect to be "visited" frequently. It is actually cheaper to pull permits than to have your project stopped, pay the fines, and endure court hearings before the magistrate court.
It's hard to overcome stupid. Don't date code enforcement...
Love your posts, always spot-on! And I also mentioned that one cannot act an Owner/Builder except on their own residence. Other wise, no one would bother getting a license.
And yes, you can't fix stupid...... 馃ぃ
>Why wouldn't you pull permits? It's not that hard or expensive.....
Have you ever done an HVAC upgrade in California? I could tell some stories that would turn you off to permits forever. Look up HERS if you do not know what I am referring to.
In San Diego, many things do not require permits. Those that do require permits (outside of HVAC upgrade) seem reasonable. HVAC permit could easily double or triple the cost.
First, know the code. It's posted online under Construction Services for the municipality. What you don't know - like the dumpster thing - not only gets you red tagged but guess what else? Placed on the radar. That code enforcement guy - he'll be back. He knows you're rehabbing...
Second, don't tick off the neighbors. Make sure that your property is pristine on the exterior - no trash, no parking on the grass, no foul language, no 'guys' just hanging, and no dang dumpster. Know why? It's not who you see but who sees you...and once the neighbors see you and you have offended them, you're on the radar - yet again. They'll keep reporting you and reporting you and reporting you. And, that leads you to being the favorite target of code enforcement. See how this works.
Permit, don't permit...a little story to tell you. I had a client who decided not to pull a permit to rewire a MF property to avoid the $40k cost. No, why do that when you can hire an active meth user who has never held an electrician's license to do it for $8k? Even if you can forget that if the place burns down with tenants in it, you - yes, you - as the owner - are going to prison for a lifetime - yeah, let that go. Consider the work ethic of a drug user...they come, they go. What price can you put on your job being held hostage by a guy you can't find. Can't permit it once it's started - no one will touch it. Get another guy into finish it - not going to find that fool. Sometimes what you think is saving you money is actually costing you a whole lot more than if you had done it right the first time.
Reputation. Be the real deal. Those who want 'to appear to be' are only fooling themselves.
And, don't forget - you were outed by a dumpster.
Patricia, thanks for your exhaustive explanation.
So we have a choice to hire GC to pull permits for us or pull permit as homeowner/builder correct?
If we go with second choice, can we still use our contractors and hire GC only for consulting purposes to prepare for inspection/reinspection?
If you choose to act as Owner/Builder, you are the equivalent of a GC (but you can only do this on a home you own and reside in). You can sub-contract to anyone else with a license, including a GC. But why not just hire a GC and have him do everything? Don't be cheap, it will almost always end up costing you more money.
I have used owner builder permits on many properties that I am not OO and it is allowed in my jurisdictions.
However, the owner builder permit in the jurisdiction I deal with most (Escondido CA) dictates that I or employees do the work. I cannot obtain a owner builder permit and use a contractor. I can obtain owner builder permit and use employees. Seems strange, but I do not make the rules.
I have owner builder permits open currently for a patio cover, new gas line, new electrical outlets and a new AC condenser. The permit office is a pain to deal with, but it is the hoops that we must jump through.
I dont always pull a permit , heres why ? You need to pull a permit to change a wax ring on a toilet , Yup its in the code . So call the plumber , $150 , he pulls a permit $75 , he replaces was ring , wait for the inspector who only gives a day not a time $ 300 lost wages . So you are all in about $500 to replace a $8.00 seal .
Major rehabs , I pull permits .
As you know, I was a long-time builder that very county, and yes, I have pulled overall permits that included HVAC. Every permit actually. And yes, I agree that SD County is ridiculous in it's requirements. However that does not change the topic...if permits are required, you need to get them. And the overall cost is just a part of doing business....if people don't want to deal with permits, then they are in the wrong business.
I could tell you stories about permits and inspections that would curl your hair.....Lol...
I dont always pull a permit , heres why ? You need to pull a permit to change a wax ring on a toilet , Yup its in the code . So call the plumber , $150 , he pulls a permit $75 , he replaces was ring , wait for the inspector who only gives a day not a time $ 300 lost wages . So you are all in about $500 to replace a $8.00 seal .
Major rehabs , I pull permits .
Yeah, I think we all disregard the little crap. I even had an inspector once (at a remote job) cuss me out for making him drive all the way out there for a minor permit.
Ironic that I posted this morning and was then out on a job talking with my electrician . he is working for an out of state GC , who has traveling subs . These subs will put in 12 hour plus days because they have nothing else to do . The GC expected this from the electrician . He told them , absolutly not . The GC pushes and is in a rush , they paved the lot over the weekend ............... Except the inspector still had to inspect the trenches for the electric , water and sewer . The GC had the paving co fill them . They now have to tear up $120K of asphalt and expose the trenches AND pay a fine plus a stop work order . Not including the things they didnt get inspected in the building .
This will cost BIG time . Our inspectors around here dont cut any slack to out of area outfits .
@Matthew Paul Yes, it never helps to go up against the 'man'.
Even when the City, Inspector, Planning/Zoning are dead wrong, it is still better to try to get along....or at least until you can get over their heads to their bosses.
I had an Building Inspector once who would not pass me on anything, due to a previous dispute and words exchanged. I finally had to go to the City Manager to straighten this guy out.... (Funny story I can't tell here on the Forum)
@Alexander P. - in the city of Huntsville proper, if you perform what is deemed to be "substantial unpermitted work" on a house, it is technically illegal to sell the property for the first year after the work was performed. Granted, this would require the buyer to determine permits weren't pulled and file a lawsuit; but you would lose the suit by default. How do I know this? I pulled a permit myself in 2018 for an addition to my house; the inspectors office told me directly that either unpermitted work, and/or work that the final inspection was never signed off on, would result in the owner not being able to legally sell the property for one year after the work was deemed to have been completed.
So we have a choice to hire GC to pull permits for us or pull permit as homeowner/builder correct?
If we go with second choice, can we still use our contractors and hire GC only for consulting purposes to prepare for inspection/reinspection?
Sorry, I should have been more clear in my post - the permit I pulled myself was my own personal residence that I live in, and was not a rental property. However, all the licensed subs also had to pull permits for my house as well. But I was the 'GC' for the addition to my own home that I live in when we did the addition in 2018.
I have never tried to pull permits on any of our investment properties because my licensed GC does this.
@Alexander Parunin just pull the permits. The risk/reward does not pay off and is very short sighted. If you do things right and build a relationship with the inspectors, they won鈥檛 even inspect your property because they know you are doing it right.
If the numbers are so tight on your flips that permit fees are tipping the scales, then that鈥檚 not a good place to be to begin with.
We just recently started house renovation and got red tagged by the city inspector. I guess he saw dumpster while driving around or maybe neighbors complained. So we learned never leave dumpster in city limits.
Much appreciated
The out of pocket cost you will be liable for if a neighbor sues you, or the city issues citations is tenfold the price of the permits. Set yourself up for success now. Once you're on the cities radar, every future project you conduct could face repercussions.
Lots of Government Yes Men around here. I'm NOT going to pull a permit for anything unless I absolutley have to. That doesn't mean I won't do work to code, or that I won't hire competent people. I just don't feel the need to get the government involved in every aspect of my property.
That said -- common OP. You know you're not going to get tips on how to avoid inspections on BP. You're going to get comments like you saw. Your question is best asked, in person, to other investors who all likely do the same thing when not commenting publicly.
Lots of Government Yes Men around here. I'm NOT going to pull a permit for anything unless I absolutley have to. That doesn't mean I won't do work to code, or that I won't hire competent people. I just don't feel the need to get the government involved in every aspect of my property.
Funny guy....won't pull a permit for anything. And in SD County, no less. I guess I was just being dumb all those hundreds of times I pulled permits in that County, Lol...
So when a buyer calls down to the County and asks the permit history on the house that you're selling them....and it says nothing about the new kitchen, bath and moved walls, you won't mind not getting 50% of SF value?
Or the house catches on fire, through no fault of yours, but the Insurance Company tells you the claim is denied because of open permits, you're ok with that as well, I expect?
Or the local Code Inspector (Rick, nice guy BTW) drives up and shuts you down and red flags your project, no big deal, right?
Wow. Your picture looks like you're 30 and you claim 16 yrs experience, so you started as an investor when you were 14? Yeah, @Alexander P., listen to this guy.... 馃ぃ
1) I don't invest in San Diego (because I'm not a crazy person). I have a home here though (born and raised). A nice fat $5m home in Mission Hills I'm happy to say.
2) I'm not 30 but aww sucks that was a nice complement. And yes, I bought my first 8 unit in 2007 using savings from my 9-5 as a down payment. I now have almost 2,000 units and about $1.8m in monthly rent roll without taking on any outside investors. So yeah, you should 'listen to this guy' (insert emoji here).
3) Correct, I don't pull a permit for anything "unless I have to". Meaning if I'm adding a ceiling fan to a unit that has no ceiling lights (so we have to add a switch, run some cable), or swapping out a sink/vanity, or putting in new double pane windows to replace old crappy ones --- all of which need a permit -- No, I don't pull a permit.
But hey, congrats and good on you for being so obedient to the state. We need people like you.
Sadly though, your government buddy Rick won't to crap to me as I don't do any work in San Diego. So you and Rick can go threaten someone else.
@Bruce Woodruff and others have done a great job at covering this topic. As an architect, I have a couple experiences/anecdotes to add the dialog:
1. I was able to get $10,000 off the purchase price of my house because my realtor did some digging around and found out the previous owner didn't pull a permit for a simple structural modification. That double 2x12 should have cost him $800 in labor, material and permit fees! Once its known, the un-permitted work needs to be disclosed and will become part of the negotiation.
2. Once a year I get a phone call from a frantic homeowner wanting us to draw an existing addition, or some kind of modification that had been completed on the house. They did a major project on their house and can't sell it for what the market will allow because a permit was not pulled. I will not touch any of those projects.
3. I have a recent client who was warned by my firm not to start work without a permit. Needless to say a big pile of dirt and a dumpster on-site triggered some phone calls from neighbors, inspectors show up and flag the project. And now he's being sued by his neighbors...he hasn't even started building anything! The client can no longer afford the project (or my invoice) because of legal fees. His plans when up in smoke because he couldn't be patient and listen to some folks who may have some useful advice that will help him succeed.
4. Aside from the long-term financial benefit of pulling permits, I'm a huge proponent of doing it right, not merely from moral stand point, but that fact that the permit review folks and the inspectors (there's maybe 6-12 people looking at the project at the gov't level), are additional eyes on the project who want nothing more but to see the project succeed and not kill anyone.
Just my two cents....
My complaint about permits in my market are:
1) permits required for things that the need for permits has never been enforced. I have had a lot of water heaters replaced. Water heater replacement is supposed to have a permit. No one, even all the licensed plumbers I have used, ask if you desire a permit. No one wants the cost associated with the permit. It the lack of permit is never going to be enforced, why require the permit? Replacing toilets is another great example of this.
2) Absurd upgrades associated with some permits. I will cover 2 that are pet peeves: a) replace AC condenser of HVAC system. Due to HERS, virtually every time you will need to replace all ducting. This significantly raises the cost of the project and is reason to consider not getting a permit b) There is newish (actually been around many years, but not as old as many of my units) that require BR windows to be lower than used to be required. It is for easier ingress/egress which is a good thing. Replace the window requires lowering the bottom of the window. Note the existing window does not meet the newish ingress/egress requirement but replace it requires reframing, siding, stucco repair, drywall repair. IMO the current ingress/egress requirement should apply for any new window opening, but to replace a window that currently does not meet the ingress/egress requirement and requiring the new window to meet the ingress/egress requirement adds significantly to the cost and timeline. No licensed window contractor that I know of will replace a BR window without making it meet current ingress/egress requirements. If you want to simply replace the window without expanding the opening you will either need to do it yourself or use a handyman and not have a permit. I have never seen windows without permit get redflagged, but there is a first time for everything.
3) The bureaucracy of getting permits. I have various permits being worked currently and many in the past. I initially submitted the plans on one permit in 3 sets of plan documents. I was told that they had to be one plan document. they used an example someone who would submit 100 plan documents. I could see than being an issue, but 3 is no where near 100. I a different site plan on a duplex where both units have their own lot separated by a fence. The site plan I submitted only included the unit that the work was being performed on. I was told to resubmit the site plan depicting both units. I asked why and they did not provide an answer. I suspect it is solely because that is what they are used to. I submitted a plan for a patio cover that has all details including post and beam sizes, hardware, footing description, etc. The permit office requested I take their patio document and high light the aspects that applied to my patio. There was not a single thing in the patio document that was not already in my plan. This is just some of the crazy bureaucracy that I have encountered when getting permits.
The bureaucracy alone is a reason to consider not obtaining permits.
I have been tagged by code enforcement for unpermitted work. If the work is done correctly, it often is no more work to get the permit post work than prior to the work. Same crazy rules and same crazy bureaucracy.