When Selling a Flip, What Level of Realtor Service?

When Selling a Flip, What Level of Realtor Service?

Jason GrotePro Member
Developer · Austin, TX · Member since 2011 · 287 posts · 88 votes

I am curious what other flippers on BP think about hiring a real estate agent to market their flips. Do you hire a flat fee listing agent? Do you hire a full service agent? If so, do you only pay a discounted commission? What is your strategy balancing profit with good marketing?

0Reply
116 views

Most Popular Reply

Ned CareyPro Member
Moderator
Investor · Baltimore, MD · Member since 2008 · 17k+ posts · 13k+ votes
14y

Jason Grote I suspected that but wanted to clarify.

I will add to my previous answer. You should figure on the cost of using a full service agent. Even if you sell it yourself then you should make extra profit for doing the work of selling the property.

Finding, negotiating and rehabbing properties are all more profitable work than listing and selling properties. Let an agent do that.

See this reply in the discussion

32 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Ned CareyPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Baltimore, MD · Member since 2008 · 17k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    14y

    What do yo mean by Flip?

    I rarely hire an agent when wholesaling a house. However most rehabbers I know do use full service agents to market their rehabbed homes.

  • Jason GrotePro Member
    OP
    Developer · Austin, TX · Member since 2011 · 287 posts · 88 votes
    14y

    Ned Carey Sorry, I call fix n' flipping just "flipping" and wholesaling just "wholesaling"... and their is also "wholetailing" Just tried this out recently!

  • Ned CareyPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Baltimore, MD · Member since 2008 · 17k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    14y

    Jason Grote I suspected that but wanted to clarify.

    I will add to my previous answer. You should figure on the cost of using a full service agent. Even if you sell it yourself then you should make extra profit for doing the work of selling the property.

    Finding, negotiating and rehabbing properties are all more profitable work than listing and selling properties. Let an agent do that.

  • Real Estate Investor · South, FL · Member since 2011 · 66 posts · 16 votes
    14y

    On The three properties I've rehabbed this year, one was active on zillow less than a day before receiving a full cash offer, the next one I had a flat fee service lasted 12 days before receiving a full price cash offer, the third was a flat fee as well and lasted 8 days before I chose from the 6 full price offers.

    These are the results in my market due to very low inventory, you market may differ.

    The flat fee service cost us $199 for 6 months listing on the mls, plus we pay 3% to buyers agent. zillow is free, but you have limited exposure. I always list it there first before the mls. I usually deal in 150-200k ARV homes, so the 3% difference is significant

    Of course if you are not going use the services of a realtor, I recommend you have an attorney review any contract prior to signing. Also, you will have to play the role of realtor including screening calls, showing the property, reviewing and negotiating offers, and that can become very time consuming.

  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    14y

    As Eddie pointed out, in some markets and time periods, listing a house is essentially no work (we listed one for another investor this week and had 6 offers in 3 days...the highest was $13K over list price on a house listed at $115K). While some of those agents were agents that we marketed to directly, I have a feeling that if we had just plopped it on the MLS, our results would still have been great. Sometimes it's really just that easy...

    Unfortunately, it usually isn't...it doesn't always (or even generally) work that way. Generally, the number of offers you get, the DOM and the quality of offers is going to be directly related to the ability of your agent to market the property, negotiate the offers, weed out the less-than-serious buyers, and push the deal through the closing process.

    I'd be willing to bet that having a great agent saves/earns us well over the typical 3% fee on most of our properties, just in terms of lower holding costs, higher priced offers, better terms, higher appraisals, etc. And that doesn't take into account the reduced stress of not having properties sit on the market for more than a couple weeks in the worst case.

    If I were to need a new agent tomorrow, this is what I'd be looking for:

    http://www.biggerpockets.com/renewsblog/2010/08/11/is-your-agent-a-great-agent/

    And I'd happily pay 3% or more for that level of service...

  • Jason GrotePro Member
    OP
    Developer · Austin, TX · Member since 2011 · 287 posts · 88 votes
    14y

    J Scott Your reply is how I personally view an agent's value to an investor. Many times there is more to it than "plopping" it on the MLS. Here in Texas, we deal with the dreaded option inspection period that 99% of all buyers exercise. It has become more of a re-negotiation tool for many. So, having a good agent to me is a must.

    The reason for this post was because my wife was contacted by an investor that wanted to list his rehab and he went with a flat fee listing agent, and I personally thought it was a bad choice for him (not because he did not choose my wife) because he over rehabbed and needs to fully market this property to pinch out every dollar.

    I wondered if it was a common practice for other fix n' flippers to hire a flat fee listing agent. I guess not ;)

    Thanks for your input!

  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    14y
    Originally posted by Jason Grote:

    I wondered if it was a common practice for other fix n' flippers to hire a flat fee listing agent. I guess not ;)

    Actually, in my experience, a lot of new investors use flat fee because they think it saves them money.

    It seems that many of them come to the realization that it ultimately costs them money and then change to full service (or better yet get their own license) down the road.

  • Jason GrotePro Member
    OP
    Developer · Austin, TX · Member since 2011 · 287 posts · 88 votes
    14y

    J Scott Yeah, fortunately we figured this out pretty early in the game and my wife volunteered to go get her license. What a blessing it has been!

    BTW, just reading your site... love the wholesaler requirements page. I bet that cuts out some of the fluff and saves you some time! So, have you achieved the goals that you mentioned on your site in Atlanta?

  • Real Estate Investor · Vancouver, WA · Member since 2012 · 78 posts · 22 votes
    14y

    If your agent is a good one they will more than pay for themselves Besides it leaves you more time to being doing more important things. like working on your flips mangaging contractor etc.

  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    14y
    Originally posted by Jason Grote:

    BTW, just reading your site... love the wholesaler requirements page. I bet that cuts out some of the fluff and saves you some time! So, have you achieved the goals that you mentioned on your site in Atlanta?

    Thanks Jason!

    Actually, my "lofty" real estate goals have been put on the back-burner for a couple years while I focus on family (we have two little kids under the age of 3). Once the kids are both in school, we'll focus on the business and trying to do bigger things, but for now, we're just trying to stay consistent with 10-20 flips per year.

    That said, if I could find a lot of deals without having to look too hard, I'd take them! But, the wholesalers can't seem to meet my requirements very well... :)

  • Investor · Asheville, NC · Member since 2012 · 184 posts · 76 votes
    14y

    Having a really good agent is very important. In my case, that happens to be a flat fee agent. I don't use her because she is flat fee, I would happily pay 6% instead of $499 + 3%. I do have familiarity with the laws in NC and the perils of closing (to push here and there when needed). In NC, we use lawyers for every closing, so my lawyer has helped with closing hiccups as well. I'm guessing that the majority of flat fee agents suck just like the majority of regular agents do.

  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    14y
    Originally posted by Kama Ward:
    Having a really good agent is very important. In my case, that happens to be a flat fee agent.

    If she's truly full-service and truly a great agent, why wouldn't she charge 3% on her end instead of a flat fee?

    Does she really do all the things a full-service agent should do, like get the property ready for showings (turn on lights, open blinds, etc), follow-up on showings, help negotiate, deal with inspections/appraisals, vet the lender/broker, get weekly statuses on closing progress, etc?

    Not sure how you can pay the bills doing all that work and not charging for it!

  • Investor · Asheville, NC · Member since 2012 · 184 posts · 76 votes
    14y

    No she does not do all the things a full service agent does-- yet she is till the best by far. The core for me is:
    a. fast service and return calls
    b. come by before rehab to give input
    c. straight talk no pre-programmed speeches or condescension
    d. awesome up to date comps.
    e. good advice on any and all questions I may have
    f. good network of service people I can tap into if my normal people are not available- used to working with investors instead of retail

    She does follow up on showings. In this market, there is no problem with agents showing flat fee (as you mentioned in another thread). That might be a function of our small size. I have been around the block with the realtors here, since I bought my first property in this market 19 years ago.

    I don't advocate flat fee over full service! It works best for me now- I have experience selling in this market, my volume is small so I can turn on the lights etc. & the full service agents I have worked with simply are not as good with the basics. I'll be happy to switch if full service does me even better.

    My point was all flat fee agents are not scraping the bottom of the barrel or 'penny wise pound foolish'. Many are I'm sure! If you are a beginner, you might be best off with full service (as I advised a homeowner in another thread). Just evaluate each agent individually...

  • Investor · Asheville, NC · Member since 2012 · 184 posts · 76 votes
    14y

    ps. J Scott if you and your wife move up here, I'll definitely switch! I'm sure you would be the best by far! Hehe! I say it in fun- but I know it's the truth.

  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    14y
    Originally posted by Kama Ward:
    ps. J Scott if you and your wife move up here, I'll definitely switch! I'm sure you would be the best by far! Hehe! I say it in fun- but I know it's the truth.

    Honestly, we don't do this for other people (other than 1 investor who we work closely with in our immediate area)...even with 3% commission, the amount of work to do it right isn't worth the money.

    This is why I recommend that everyone get their real estate license...only you will be willing to do the work necessary to get your properties sold in an optimal fashion...

  • Jason GrotePro Member
    OP
    Developer · Austin, TX · Member since 2011 · 287 posts · 88 votes
    14y

    Kama Ward Beyond the things you mentioned, on nearly every property we have retailed through the MLS, we have dealt with an issue. For example, you accept an offer from a buyer who hired a rookie real estate agent, and they put fear in the buyer when the inspection report comes back or you have to hold the agent's hand through a deal because if their inexperience. Then there are lending issues or closing issues. I couldn't imagine having an agent on my team that wasn't full service.

    That being said, it does sound like you have it dialed in comfortably in your market, but you must have to pick up the baton more times than you would like! Thanks for your input!

  • Investor · Little Rock, AR · Member since 2010 · 628 posts · 251 votes
    14y

    I have always used a flat fee service on my "normal" flips. However, I have my own home on the market now which is about $150k over my flip price range. I have found the traffic to be more like "tire kickers" and may not be as serious as those looking at the flips. So, I have hired the agent that sold me my last project who impressed me very much. I simply don't have the time to be an investor, work a full time job, and be an agent as well any longer. So far, I am please with the progress; even though I have my flips under contract in the same length of time.
    Don

  • Investor · Asheville, NC · Member since 2012 · 184 posts · 76 votes
    14y

    "only you will be willing to do the work necessary to get your properties sold in an optimal fashion..."
    True. The flat fee allows me to do more for myself than full service (but less than if I had my own license).

    I've gone back and forth about getting my licence. Took the class in 97, but did not go on to get my licence. I like not having to disclose being a realtor. I've played up the nice young girl who loves your house for a long time. Getting too old for that finally!

  • Wholesaler · Salt Lake City, UT · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 401 votes
    14y

    I don't have a problem I am the broker and list it on the MLS and offer 3% to the selling agent, and depending on the market, etc. I offten times offer more. I want a quick sale and agent co-op and the commission is directly reduced by a shorter holding cost period.

    So I recommend a flat fee because of your supposed expertise and the fact you will be marketing the property yourself but co-oping with agents, don't be the BS investor offering 1 or 2 % fee, for a quality buyer, most agents will just show some other property and I don't blame them.

    One tip if co-oping don't use a for sale by owner sign, use a company sign or a for sale, broker co-op sign and avoid ticked off agents showing up with a buyer only to see a for sale by owner sign. Good agent relations is a good thing, many have given me good investment leads and all they gave other investors was the finger, of course I made it worth their while.

  • Jason GrotePro Member
    OP
    Developer · Austin, TX · Member since 2011 · 287 posts · 88 votes
    14y

    Brian P I agree, agents work hard and should be paid accordingly. I don't understand how a flat fee agent survives. They can not give much service to their client and make money it seems. As an investor selling a nicely remodeled flip property, I need the service and am willing to pay for it

  • Investor · Asheville, NC · Member since 2012 · 184 posts · 76 votes
    14y

    How do they survive? Here's my guess for my flat fee agent (numbers rounded for easy math): she spends about 5hrs per home for me. 1hr visit, 1hr comps, 1hr entering listing, 2hrs answering emails/calls from me agents and all other misc. etc.
    Her fee is $500 dollars= $100 hr. Not bad.
    But let's say I'm way, way off and she spends five times that much!
    That's $20hr. Not great, but if working full time that happens to be 40k per year. According to salary.com avg realtor salary= 36.5k to 47.5k.

    So that's how they survive. This says nothing about how good are they for investors, of course.

    In my market the avg home sold is about 200k, so a regular listing agent gets $3000 How many hours will an average agent spend selling a home? If they spend a total of 30 hr, that's $100/hour. Or if they spend 150 hrs, that's $20/hr.

  • Jason GrotePro Member
    OP
    Developer · Austin, TX · Member since 2011 · 287 posts · 88 votes
    14y

    Kama Ward Nice break down of the numbers.... That $20/hr. does not include cost of doing business, ie. phone, marketing, administrative, gas in the car, professional fees, Realtor association dues, etc. that will make that $20/hr become $10/hr! Self-employed individuals have to always make lots more than the employee! That is why I ask, how can they survive?

  • Investor · Asheville, NC · Member since 2012 · 184 posts · 76 votes
    14y

    Totally agree- for both flat fee and regular. A lot of them are just churning money, rather than making it, and of course many don't survive. If either one is close to the $100/hr, they make out just fine. Some people rather make 10$ and be their own boss- not smart but not as dumb as working in fast food! ha
    Just playing devil's advocate. It's not the business model- it's the person in business.

  • Real Estate Investor · Member since 2012 · 40 posts · 3 votes
    14y

    @JScott

    I am looking for my first rehab, but have had a license for a few years now.

    So I am wondering if you buy in your name and then list it yourself as well on the MLS?

    In my MLS you have to mark the listing type as "Owner Agent", which I think doesn't help you very much and can create unwanted attention.

    @Brian P.

    Are you having the co-opp agent, who also is a flat fee agent, list it for sale as primary agent and hence avoiding listing it as "owner agent" . If not, then what is the benefit to you to have a co-op agent and pay them even a flat fee?

    Thanks a lot !!! I look forward to getting involved in this forum.. really good people here. I can tell.

  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    14y
    Originally posted by Dash F.:
    @JScott

    I am looking for my first rehab, but have had a license for a few years now.

    So I am wondering if you buy in your name and then list it yourself as well on the MLS?

    In my MLS you have to mark the listing type as "Owner Agent", which I think doesn't help you very much and can create unwanted attention.

    We buy in our company name and list in our company name. My wife is the listing agent and I'm the co-listing agent.

    Not sure why you are averse to "unwanted attention"...I want my listings to get all the attention they can possibly get! :)

    In all seriousness, I've never had a single buyer or seller have an issue with he fact that we're licensed. And if anything, I would think most buyers would consider it a good thing. Think about it -- if you have the option to buy from some random person that may or may not have any integrity or buy from someone who is licensed and is to some degree overseen by one or more regulatory agencies, which would you choose?

    I'd much rather deal with licensed RE professionals than unlicensed investors when I have the opportunity.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.