Developer · Austin, TX · Member since 2011 · 287 posts · 88 votes
I am curious what other flippers on BP think about hiring a real estate agent to market their flips. Do you hire a flat fee listing agent? Do you hire a full service agent? If so, do you only pay a discounted commission? What is your strategy balancing profit with good marketing?
Jason Grote I suspected that but wanted to clarify.
I will add to my previous answer. You should figure on the cost of using a full service agent. Even if you sell it yourself then you should make extra profit for doing the work of selling the property.
Finding, negotiating and rehabbing properties are all more profitable work than listing and selling properties. Let an agent do that.
I agree J Scott, when my wife became an agent we were worried about this initially, but now I have no idea why! Kinda weird, but their seems to be some sort of stigma on investors. It is almost like we have to be incognito. Like J Scott said, the more attention the better.... especially when you are above board!
Good responses.
Our company does a quasi flat fee structure for a few investor clients (starting at $1,050)
While full service is sometimes needed, we bridge this with our product.
We rely mainly on the pricing and superior product to sell the house.
We do minor marketing campaigns and occasionally sell the home ourselves.
We typically visit the properties twice during the entire process.
I say all of the time that our job is to ensure a smooth transaction and sales process.
We spend approximately 10 hours per deal -- I would say we do a good job as we have done repeat business over and over with multiple clients.
But with that said, it's not the best option in every situation - as has been stated.
So, here is the situation that prompted this thread:
My wife gets an out-of-the-blue call from an investor in our area who has just rehabbed a house and is interviewing listing agents. The house happens to be 5 minutes from our home and we are very acquainted with the area.
I go with my wife to help evaluate the property. It is a very nicely remodeled house (about 2500 sq ft) on a large 1 acre lot. The size of house and lot is typical for this neighborhood that was developed in the late 70's and early 80's. Few have been remodeled in this neighborhood especially to the degree that this investor did.
In addition to the main house is a large second structure that could be a 1,200 sq ft guest house with its own driveway. This second home could rent for $1000/month. Unfortunately, the building was nearly gutted and just looked like an old workshop with a kitchen.
The investor asked my wife what we thought it would bring. We told him that as-is (the second home not finished) the property should be listed around $279k. Only one property has sold for more than $235k in this neighborhood except for a nearby home on 3 acres that sold for $320. We strongly suggested that he complete the remodel in the second house before listing it, and if so, he could list the home around $310k while strongly marketing the rental income from the second home.
Well, he ended up hiring a flat fee listing agent to save a few bucks and here's what he got:
1. The agent got his money up front to spend an hour (or less) placing the property on the MLS. So, the agent not being vested in the property, allowed the seller to name his price. He did so at $339k without completing the second house.
2. In the agents remarks, there is absolutely no verbage about the second structure and it's rental potential nor any of the properties unique features.
3. There are just a few photos posted and they are not very good. They were probably taken by the seller. They do not do the property justice. Pictures should make the property look better than it is if done correctly.
4. 24 hours later the agent lowers the price $15k.... This does not look good. It will tell every buyer's agent "Look, we have this property marked up very high, so come bring a low-ball offer please!"
This property being unique and needs top dollar should have never been listed with a flat fee agent. The seller will probably lose a few dollars by not having a vested real estate agent involved in the pricing, marketing, and negotiating.
Man, I sound like I am promoting real estate agents... Really, I am just saying that the system is set up to where they are invaluable (good agents that is) when it comes to getting top dollar for your property.
That is a great way to look at it. Good point. I am just a very private individual. :)
I just need to lay down my game plan correctly. Thanks for the input.
When you make an offer do you put your LLC on the offer or you put your personal name and then when contract is accepted you tell them you want to change to LLC?
And are you paying yourself a commission or you let the listing agent have both sides?
We always make offers in the name of the LLC (I've never seen any disadvantage to doing this).
As for commission, we'll always find a way to give something to the listing agent (and most of the REO listing agents know us these days, so they know that). Sometimes we'll do a broker to broker referral just sending them some or all of the commission; sometimes we'll send them a gift card for a couple hundred dollars; etc. It really depends on the rules the brokers put in place -- many of them won't allow their agents to get cash bonuses or commissions directly from selling agents anymore.
Also, we have our favorite listing agents and brokerages and we'll make an effort to send bagels, chocolate, etc to the whole office every once in a while just to keep our names top-of-mind for the agents. They always appreciate it and they always remember us.
your slightly confused, I don't list with flat fee agents because I am a broker. I suggest investors, which I am too, do it. Marketing a home requires exposure and to co-op with agents can get you the results you want and where do agents look daily? The MLS. And if you do find your own buyer great, but most of the time the MLS works and the quicker sale time is worth it and the price is better then a FSBO action.
I take that back I do use them on occassion in states I'm not licensed. In those states I do not have to say owner agent because I am not a licensed agent in those states. Secondly in my main state of California I am not required to say I am licensed, that is a contractual item in the Realtors Code of Ethics but not a state legal requirement.
But even when I have disclosed my license status most sellers/ buyers like the idea because they know I know what I am doing or at least they assume so, and that it will be done right.
And to the how do they stay in business thing, the main thinking is they are making pocket money to keep them going and for every sign they have up there is a chance they might get some buyer prospects and that will be their main money, selling buyers not interested in the listed property. But I don't know any wealthy discount brokers except for one, he is an investor who started the brokerage to list his own properties and make a few side bucks to basically get a free office, etc.