Tenant claims there is no heat, and it's Christmas

Tenant claims there is no heat, and it's Christmas

South beach, Miami · Member since 2023 · 33 posts · 8 votes

Hi there BP community, looking for your advice on the following please: i inherited a section 8 tenant who pays way below market, acts shady, had an issue with the leaky toilet for years, which damaged the floor and cost me $$$ to fix. She now says her heat is not working all of a sudden. A contractor was there that day to fix the floor, and said there was not problem with the heat. She denies and keeps texting me every day to "fix the furnace". With now being a weekend, and going on Christmas week, what would you suggest i do? I had a plumber inspect the furnace a couple of months ago and said it was in good shape. Thank you for your wisdom!

P.S. I am serving her a notice to vacate at the end of her lease in feb.

3Reply
120 views

Most Popular Reply

Chris SeveneyBusiness Member
Moderator
Investor · VA · Member since 2015 · 21k+ posts · 19k+ votes
1y
Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

Hi there BP community, looking for your advice on the following please: i inherited a section 8 tenant who pays way below market, acts shady, had an issue with the leaky toilet for years, which damaged the floor and cost me $$$ to fix. She now says her heat is not working all of a sudden. A contractor was there that day to fix the floor, and said there was not problem with the heat. She denies and keeps texting me every day to "fix the furnace". With now being a weekend, and going on Christmas week, what would you suggest i do? I had a plumber inspect the furnace a couple of months ago and said it was in good shape. Thank you for your wisdom!

P.S. I am serving her a notice to vacate at the end of her lease in feb.


 Let her know you will send someone out ASAP but if there are no issues with it she will be responsible for the costs. I would then get someone out there to do an inspection and confirm it is working and make sure they video record or take photos to prove its working.

7e investments53 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

57 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Ryan SpathBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Boise, ID · Member since 2017 · 614 posts · 389 votes
    1y

    If I were local, I would go by and confirm the furnace was working. If not I would send a person from my team there to confirm it working or not and if not I would get it repaired, best of luck!

  • Chris SeveneyBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Investor · VA · Member since 2015 · 21k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

    Hi there BP community, looking for your advice on the following please: i inherited a section 8 tenant who pays way below market, acts shady, had an issue with the leaky toilet for years, which damaged the floor and cost me $$$ to fix. She now says her heat is not working all of a sudden. A contractor was there that day to fix the floor, and said there was not problem with the heat. She denies and keeps texting me every day to "fix the furnace". With now being a weekend, and going on Christmas week, what would you suggest i do? I had a plumber inspect the furnace a couple of months ago and said it was in good shape. Thank you for your wisdom!

    P.S. I am serving her a notice to vacate at the end of her lease in feb.


     Let her know you will send someone out ASAP but if there are no issues with it she will be responsible for the costs. I would then get someone out there to do an inspection and confirm it is working and make sure they video record or take photos to prove its working.

    7e investments53 Reviews
  • Corby GoadeBusiness Member
    Investor · Boise, ID · Member since 2014 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

    Hi there BP community, looking for your advice on the following please: i inherited a section 8 tenant who pays way below market, acts shady, had an issue with the leaky toilet for years, which damaged the floor and cost me $$$ to fix. She now says her heat is not working all of a sudden. A contractor was there that day to fix the floor, and said there was not problem with the heat. She denies and keeps texting me every day to "fix the furnace". With now being a weekend, and going on Christmas week, what would you suggest i do? I had a plumber inspect the furnace a couple of months ago and said it was in good shape. Thank you for your wisdom!

    P.S. I am serving her a notice to vacate at the end of her lease in feb.


     A plumber said the furnace was working? What value does that have?

    It's the middle of the holidays and you own the property. Hire an HVAC contractor to go check it out, of course. 

    The fact that you think the tenant is a pain has nothing to do with how you maintain the property, you could be creating legal and maintenance problems for yourself by not taking action. 

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH · Member since 2013 · 31k+ posts · 20k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

    Hi there BP community, looking for your advice on the following please: i inherited a section 8 tenant who pays way below market, acts shady, had an issue with the leaky toilet for years, which damaged the floor and cost me $$$ to fix. She now says her heat is not working all of a sudden. A contractor was there that day to fix the floor, and said there was not problem with the heat. She denies and keeps texting me every day to "fix the furnace". With now being a weekend, and going on Christmas week, what would you suggest i do? I had a plumber inspect the furnace a couple of months ago and said it was in good shape. Thank you for your wisdom!

    P.S. I am serving her a notice to vacate at the end of her lease in feb.

     Send an HVAC tech out. Bill her for the service call if they are no issues with furnace. If she doesn't pay the bill refuse her next rent payment and evict her.

  • South beach, Miami · Member since 2023 · 33 posts · 8 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Corby Goade:
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

    Hi there BP community, looking for your advice on the following please: i inherited a section 8 tenant who pays way below market, acts shady, had an issue with the leaky toilet for years, which damaged the floor and cost me $$$ to fix. She now says her heat is not working all of a sudden. A contractor was there that day to fix the floor, and said there was not problem with the heat. She denies and keeps texting me every day to "fix the furnace". With now being a weekend, and going on Christmas week, what would you suggest i do? I had a plumber inspect the furnace a couple of months ago and said it was in good shape. Thank you for your wisdom!

    P.S. I am serving her a notice to vacate at the end of her lease in feb.


     A plumber said the furnace was working? What value does that have?

    It's the middle of the holidays and you own the property. Hire an HVAC contractor to go check it out, of course. 

    The fact that you think the tenant is a pain has nothing to do with how you maintain the property, you could be creating legal and maintenance problems for yourself by not taking action. 


    I guess i'm puzzled because the floor contractor said the unit was warm (the day she complained), and i question the urgency to find someone over Christmas, if there is even an issue. 

  • Corby GoadeBusiness Member
    Investor · Boise, ID · Member since 2014 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:
    Quote from @Corby Goade:
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

    Hi there BP community, looking for your advice on the following please: i inherited a section 8 tenant who pays way below market, acts shady, had an issue with the leaky toilet for years, which damaged the floor and cost me $$$ to fix. She now says her heat is not working all of a sudden. A contractor was there that day to fix the floor, and said there was not problem with the heat. She denies and keeps texting me every day to "fix the furnace". With now being a weekend, and going on Christmas week, what would you suggest i do? I had a plumber inspect the furnace a couple of months ago and said it was in good shape. Thank you for your wisdom!

    P.S. I am serving her a notice to vacate at the end of her lease in feb.


     A plumber said the furnace was working? What value does that have?

    It's the middle of the holidays and you own the property. Hire an HVAC contractor to go check it out, of course. 

    The fact that you think the tenant is a pain has nothing to do with how you maintain the property, you could be creating legal and maintenance problems for yourself by not taking action. 


    I guess i'm puzzled because the floor contractor said the unit was warm (the day she complained), and i question the urgency to find someone over Christmas, if there is even an issue. 


     You can question all you like, but if the unit isn't actually working and you do nothing, that's not cool. It's your job as a landlord to respond to these things in a professional manner. 

    In addition- if it's not working and the tenant takes legal action, the judge certainly isn't going to be on your side when you tell them a flooring contractor said it was warm in the house.

    This game is all about mitigating your risk by being proactive. It'll be well worth the $150 service call to know that you aren't going to end up in court. 

    And if it isn't working and you have a family in there on Christmas without heat...I mean...That's not very nice. 

  • Investor · Hendersonville, NC · Member since 2016 · 498 posts · 286 votes
    1y
    Quote from @Corby Goade:
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

    Hi there BP community, looking for your advice on the following please: i inherited a section 8 tenant who pays way below market, acts shady, had an issue with the leaky toilet for years, which damaged the floor and cost me $$$ to fix. She now says her heat is not working all of a sudden. A contractor was there that day to fix the floor, and said there was not problem with the heat. She denies and keeps texting me every day to "fix the furnace". With now being a weekend, and going on Christmas week, what would you suggest i do? I had a plumber inspect the furnace a couple of months ago and said it was in good shape. Thank you for your wisdom!

    P.S. I am serving her a notice to vacate at the end of her lease in feb.


     A plumber said the furnace was working? What value does that have?

    It's the middle of the holidays and you own the property. Hire an HVAC contractor to go check it out, of course. 

    The fact that you think the tenant is a pain has nothing to do with how you maintain the property, you could be creating legal and maintenance problems for yourself by not taking action. 


     This is a fantastic answer and I agree completely. Regardless of your feelings of the tenant, this isn't something you can ignore. If this is a problem tenant who continues breaking rules, that's something you can work on later but for right now you should do the right thing and look into this.

    God forbid if something bad happened to the tenant because of this, you'd be on the hook for negligence because they informed you of the problem. 

  • Realtor · Hanover Twp, PA · Member since 2018 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

    I guess i'm puzzled because the floor contractor said the unit was warm (the day she complained), and i question the urgency to find someone over Christmas, if there is even an issue. 


    What are you talking about?!? Is this unit in a warm climate where heat isn't important???

    It is WINTER in most of the continent right now and for 95% of homes heat is critically important. Where I am the current temperature is about 10 F right now.

    Add to that fact that the holiday is arriving so that they may have guests coming over. 

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH · Member since 2013 · 31k+ posts · 20k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Corby Goade:
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:
    Quote from @Corby Goade:
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

    Hi there BP community, looking for your advice on the following please: i inherited a section 8 tenant who pays way below market, acts shady, had an issue with the leaky toilet for years, which damaged the floor and cost me $$$ to fix. She now says her heat is not working all of a sudden. A contractor was there that day to fix the floor, and said there was not problem with the heat. She denies and keeps texting me every day to "fix the furnace". With now being a weekend, and going on Christmas week, what would you suggest i do? I had a plumber inspect the furnace a couple of months ago and said it was in good shape. Thank you for your wisdom!

    P.S. I am serving her a notice to vacate at the end of her lease in feb.


     A plumber said the furnace was working? What value does that have?

    It's the middle of the holidays and you own the property. Hire an HVAC contractor to go check it out, of course. 

    The fact that you think the tenant is a pain has nothing to do with how you maintain the property, you could be creating legal and maintenance problems for yourself by not taking action. 


    I guess i'm puzzled because the floor contractor said the unit was warm (the day she complained), and i question the urgency to find someone over Christmas, if there is even an issue. 


     You can question all you like, but if the unit isn't actually working and you do nothing, that's not cool. It's your job as a landlord to respond to these things in a professional manner. 

    In addition- if it's not working and the tenant takes legal action, the judge certainly isn't going to be on your side when you tell them a flooring contractor said it was warm in the house.

    This game is all about mitigating your risk by being proactive. It'll be well worth the $150 service call to know that you aren't going to end up in court. 

    And if it isn't working and you have a family in there on Christmas without heat...I mean...That's not very nice. 

    You obviously hate the tenant, which is fine. Tenant sounds like a turd. Nothing wrong with you hating them. I've hated many of my tenants in my career.

    Given your negative feelings on the tenant I think you will feel better looking at this another way. You aren't doing it for the tenant. You are doing it for yourself. If the heat isn't working, your pipes can freeze, then burst causing tens of thousands of dollars of damage to your property. You need to send the HVAC tech out to protect your investment.



  • South beach, Miami · Member since 2023 · 33 posts · 8 votes
    1y

    Thank you all for the replies. I have my HVAC guy scheduled for tomorow morning, and yet she tells me she has to work tomorrow morning. Prefers someone to fix overnight on sunday. whst do you say?

  • Severna Park, MD · Member since 2013 · 7k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

    Thank you all for the replies. I have my HVAC guy scheduled for tomorow morning, and yet she tells me she has to work tomorrow morning. Prefers someone to fix overnight on sunday. whst do you say?


     Tell the tenant that she has to have someone there to let the service guy in that morning .Thats the first time available .

  • Realtor · Hanover Twp, PA · Member since 2018 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Matthew Paul:
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

    Thank you all for the replies. I have my HVAC guy scheduled for tomorow morning, and yet she tells me she has to work tomorrow morning. Prefers someone to fix overnight on sunday. whst do you say?


     Tell the tenant that she has to have someone there to let the service guy in that morning .Thats the first time available .


    I think you mean to ASK the tenant IF they can be there to let someone in. Otherwise YOU as the landlord will take care of providing access for the service guy.

    If its not in the lease that the tenant has to let people in to do repairs, then the tenant could choose to bill you as the landlord for this work you're requesting if they wanted to be snotty about it.
  • Severna Park, MD · Member since 2013 · 7k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Kevin Sobilo:
    Quote from @Matthew Paul:
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

    Thank you all for the replies. I have my HVAC guy scheduled for tomorow morning, and yet she tells me she has to work tomorrow morning. Prefers someone to fix overnight on sunday. whst do you say?



     Tell the tenant that she has to have someone there to let the service guy in that morning .Thats the first time available .


    I think you mean to ASK the tenant IF they can be there to let someone in. Otherwise YOU as the landlord will take care of providing access for the service guy.

    If its not in the lease that the tenant has to let people in to do repairs, then the tenant could choose to bill you as the landlord for this work you're requesting if they wanted to be snotty about it.
    No I meant "Tell" the tenant .  And if a tenant were to " bill me "  for their time  , that would give me a good belly laugh 
  • Realtor · Hanover Twp, PA · Member since 2018 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Matthew Paul:
    Quote from @Kevin Sobilo:
    Quote from @Matthew Paul:
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

    Thank you all for the replies. I have my HVAC guy scheduled for tomorow morning, and yet she tells me she has to work tomorrow morning. Prefers someone to fix overnight on sunday. whst do you say?



     Tell the tenant that she has to have someone there to let the service guy in that morning .Thats the first time available .


    I think you mean to ASK the tenant IF they can be there to let someone in. Otherwise YOU as the landlord will take care of providing access for the service guy.

    If its not in the lease that the tenant has to let people in to do repairs, then the tenant could choose to bill you as the landlord for this work you're requesting if they wanted to be snotty about it.
    No I meant "Tell" the tenant .  And if a tenant were to " bill me "  for their time  , that would give me a good belly laugh 

    It would just mean the tenant is smarter than you. I would find that funny too and laugh heartily!

    They can just deduct it from the rent. They will have proof you requested the service, so as long as the charge is reasonable it should stand up in court if you tried to evict for nonpayment or something like that.

    For example, if they have to take 1/2 day off work and they earn $20/hour and they charge you $80, that would be hard for you to win IMO.

    Keep in mind, you are NOT in charge! 

  • Severna Park, MD · Member since 2013 · 7k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    1y

    Actually I am in charge of my rentals . If service is needed the tenant must let them in . Thats their responsibility . If they deduct it from the rent , they get charged for insufficent / late payment .

  • Real Estate Broker · Cleveland Dayton Cincinnati Toledo Columbus & Akron, OH · Member since 2013 · 31k+ posts · 20k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Kevin Sobilo:
    Quote from @Matthew Paul:
    Quote from @Kevin Sobilo:
    Quote from @Matthew Paul:
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

    Thank you all for the replies. I have my HVAC guy scheduled for tomorow morning, and yet she tells me she has to work tomorrow morning. Prefers someone to fix overnight on sunday. whst do you say?



     Tell the tenant that she has to have someone there to let the service guy in that morning .Thats the first time available .


    I think you mean to ASK the tenant IF they can be there to let someone in. Otherwise YOU as the landlord will take care of providing access for the service guy.

    If its not in the lease that the tenant has to let people in to do repairs, then the tenant could choose to bill you as the landlord for this work you're requesting if they wanted to be snotty about it.
    No I meant "Tell" the tenant .  And if a tenant were to " bill me "  for their time  , that would give me a good belly laugh 

    It would just mean the tenant is smarter than you. I would find that funny too and laugh heartily!

    They can just deduct it from the rent. They will have proof you requested the service, so as long as the charge is reasonable it should stand up in court if you tried to evict for nonpayment or something like that.

    For example, if they have to take 1/2 day off work and they earn $20/hour and they charge you $80, that would be hard for you to win IMO.

    Keep in mind, you are NOT in charge! 


     Doubtful this scenario comes into play. Tenant is having the taxpayer's pay for her rent after all. Having said that, the best course of action is to tell the tenant what day and time the appointment is and explain if she wants to be there for it that's fine, if she can't be there, that is fine too, the workers will be entering her property without her being there.

  • Realtor · Hanover Twp, PA · Member since 2018 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Matthew Paul:

    Actually I am in charge of my rentals . If service is needed the tenant must let them in . Thats their responsibility . If they deduct it from the rent , they get charged for insufficent / late payment .

    If that is in your lease, that is probably correct. If it is not then I don't think you are correct. Since you didn't mention this being in your lease, it sounds like you are incorrect.

    Its good that you find out now that you are NOT in charge! A lease is much like a deed, you have transferred legal rights to this property to the tenant and have taken on legal obligations for the maintenance on the property.

    So, you are NOT in charge as you have GIVEN certain rights to the property to the tenant. They aren't a guest like when you stay in a hotel. You have given the tenant many of your rights as an owner BUT only for a specific time period whereas a deed transfers rights permanently.

  • Realtor · Hanover Twp, PA · Member since 2018 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @James Wise:
    Quote from @Kevin Sobilo:
    Quote from @Matthew Paul:
    Quote from @Kevin Sobilo:
    Quote from @Matthew Paul:
    Quote from @Natalia Perlova:

    Thank you all for the replies. I have my HVAC guy scheduled for tomorow morning, and yet she tells me she has to work tomorrow morning. Prefers someone to fix overnight on sunday. whst do you say?



     Tell the tenant that she has to have someone there to let the service guy in that morning .Thats the first time available .


    I think you mean to ASK the tenant IF they can be there to let someone in. Otherwise YOU as the landlord will take care of providing access for the service guy.

    If its not in the lease that the tenant has to let people in to do repairs, then the tenant could choose to bill you as the landlord for this work you're requesting if they wanted to be snotty about it.
    No I meant "Tell" the tenant .  And if a tenant were to " bill me "  for their time  , that would give me a good belly laugh 

    It would just mean the tenant is smarter than you. I would find that funny too and laugh heartily!

    They can just deduct it from the rent. They will have proof you requested the service, so as long as the charge is reasonable it should stand up in court if you tried to evict for nonpayment or something like that.

    For example, if they have to take 1/2 day off work and they earn $20/hour and they charge you $80, that would be hard for you to win IMO.

    Keep in mind, you are NOT in charge! 


     Doubtful this scenario comes into play. Tenant is having the taxpayer's pay for her rent after all. Having said that, the best course of action is to tell the tenant what day and time the appointment is and explain if she wants to be there for it that's fine, if she can't be there, that is fine too, the workers will be entering her property without her being there.


    Agreed, unlikely scenario and I agree with your approach. Many tenants are willing to be there or prefer to be there which is great.

    Unfortunately a lot of landlords don't understand their rights an obligations well. They feel like a tenant is a guest who is there at the landlords pleasure more like a guest at a hotel. However, a tenant has legal rights transferred to them for the property. A lease is very much like a deed except that it transfers only certain rights to the property and only for a specific period of time.
  • Austin, TX · Member since 2019 · 5k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    1y

     This individual might have a furnace problem?

    When the furnace goes down it goes down- it's more likely to go down in the cold weather than during the summer when it's not being turned on.

    If you do not provide heat for this renter, will section 8 still send you your payment if the renter alerts section 8 that they have no heat and have tried to get you to repair it?

    How many days or hours does your local section 8 give you to respond to requests like this?

    It might be broken intermittently, I have had that happen on a zone heating system that used little computer boards and relays.

    And as @James Wise said, You need to think about protecting your investment from freezing because broken pipes which can be very expensive to have remediated.

    Good Luck!

  • Alecia LovelessPro Member
    Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    1y

    @Natalia Perlova Absolutly no to the Sunday repair. If you or your property manager has to let them in Monday morning so be it.

    Document, document that you’ve tried to fix the problem if you can’t get the technician in tomorrow.

  • Investor · Greenville, SC · Member since 2016 · 5k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    1y

    There is a lot of noise in this thread unrelated to the issue (section 8, pays below market, leaky toilet for years damaged the floor, Christmas week, furnace inspection a couple of months ago...all not relevant).  Just send your HVAC guy, provide advance notice, and he can let himself in if she's not there.  If the heat is working and she submitted a fraudulent service request, bill her.

  • South beach, Miami · Member since 2023 · 33 posts · 8 votes
    1y

    Thank you all! Very helpful!

  • Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Cody, WY · Member since 2010 · 28k+ posts · 41k+ votes
    1y

    If the tenant complains there is no heat, you should respond. If you can personally visit the property to confirm, do so. If you can't, then notify the tenant that she will be charged if the visit is unnecessary.

    The tenant does not get to choose when the vendor shows up. If the heat is important to her, she will be available when the vendor is available. There's nothing in the law that requires you to send someone on a Sunday evening at her convenience. Besides, she's Section 8 and I'm sure her schedule is wide open.

    The DIY Landlord Book4.7245 Reviews
  • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    1y

    Agree with the last two posts. In person is always better than sending a contractor, because you get to see the unit and talk to the tenant.

    Not sure where your property is located. In Milwaukee the weather can get pretty cold and we want to protect the tenant, but also the pipes in the property from freezing.

    For that reason we do have a stockpile of emergency equipment which includes electric space heaters. I like small units (they don't trip breakers) and they are cheap. If heat goes out in the winter we drop off several units, so they can be placed in different parts of the house - including every room with water like kitchen and bathrooms.

    We also have dehumidifiers, carpet blowers, shop vacs, puddle-sucker pumps, extra hoses, extra sump pumps with battery pack, squeegees, and portable AC units ready to deploy. 

    Selfishly, being able to respond fast, mitigates damage to the property (frozen pipes, mold!), takes the edge of the emergency and buys us time to get a contractor out without having to pay for emergency hour services. And tenants really appreciate it.

  • Realtor · Hanover Twp, PA · Member since 2018 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1y
    Quote from @Marcus Auerbach:

    Agree with the last two posts. In person is always better than sending a contractor, because you get to see the unit and talk to the tenant.

    Not sure where your property is located. In Milwaukee the weather can get pretty cold and we want to protect the tenant, but also the pipes in the property from freezing.

    For that reason we do have a stockpile of emergency equipment which includes electric space heaters. I like small units (they don't trip breakers) and they are cheap. If heat goes out in the winter we drop off several units, so they can be placed in different parts of the house - including every room with water like kitchen and bathrooms.

    We also have dehumidifiers, carpet blowers, shop vacs, puddle-sucker pumps, extra hoses, extra sump pumps with battery pack, squeegees, and portable AC units ready to deploy. 

    Selfishly, being able to respond fast, mitigates damage to the property (frozen pipes, mold!), takes the edge of the emergency and buys us time to get a contractor out without having to pay for emergency hour services. And tenants really appreciate it.


    Agree! I also have temporary emergency heat I can provide if needed. 

    In addition, I am considering changing my furnaces/boilers to have plug-in cords instead of being hard wired so that if there is a power outage in winter that I could power that heating system with a portable power station.
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.