Knoxville historic remodel that nearly took us out

Knoxville historic remodel that nearly took us out

Cory KingBusiness Member
Real Estate Agent · Knoxville, TN · Member since 2021 · 168 posts · 78 votes

In 2022 we took on a historic home near downtown Knoxville. We paid $170,000 for it. After inspections and due diligence we anticipated around $50k in rehab and about 4-5 months of time to turn over with an ARV (after repair value) around $325,000. Solid deal. Using a hard money loan to cover the purchase and rehab costs.

The inspection revealed some termite damage to about 2 floor joists that we could see and the rest of the place was seemingly surface level with the bathrooms and kitchens needing the most work. As we started peeling back the layers in those areas more termite damage showed itself. Joist after joist, stud after stud were basically turning to powder. In total 14 joists, countless studs, 1 girder, and new footers had to be replaced. In order to access the floor joists the floor itself had to come up. The home has these lovely caramel colored heart pine floors and removing them was the craziest game of operation I've ever played as to not damage them and fit back together. 

As the work and time started to add up the numbers were getting squeezed more and more. In total we'd invested $120,000 into the project and it took us 11 months to complete. Thankfully our lender was pretty flexible as we hit our 6 month deadline and were still short $60k in cash needed to complete the project. We paid an extra 2 points at refinance and got an extension for the deal for an added 4 months. I spent a lot of time hustling my *** off to generate the extra cash needed bc we didn't have it in reserves to just write the check. 

As we finished it up I was able to recoup a majority but not all of my invested cash, leaving about $40k in the deal. Prior to purchasing in 2022 when rates were rapidly rising, thankfully I did underwrite this deal at upwards of $100k in costs and 9% interest and it still penciled out. Glad I did bc that's pretty much were I ended up. First cash out refi resulted at a rate at 9.2%. Payment was $2400/mo and leased to students at $3200/mo 

We refinanced in 2024 at a much better rate, mid 7s.

As of now our note is $2300/mo and the property generates $3550/mo gross income renting to students at University of Tennessee. We also recently completed a cost segregation study to accelerate some depreciation and save on taxes which has now helped us get back the cash we'd originally left in the project. 

5Reply
164 views

2 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Jason WrayPro Member
    Banker · Nationwide · Member since 2020 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    Cory,

    My advice is increase your Network and add some more Bigger Pockets seasoned people on your team.  This story while a success looks like you got over charged on points and rate.  Be happy to connect and share some tips and loopholes.

    I have some friends/Realtors in Knoxville and the properties we found and closed on are great cash flow properties but the initial part should be more cost efficient.  

  • Investor · Chattanooga, TN · Member since 2023 · 182 posts · 111 votes
    1y

    Cory — brother, this one hit home. That’s not just a success story — that’s a survival story dressed in drywall dust. 💪

    You didn’t just remodel a house; you rebuilt your resilience. The way you owned the termite chaos, juggled the financing, and still walked away standing — that’s the real win. Anyone can underwrite a deal; few can lead one through the storm and still carry the lesson forward with gratitude.

    Love how you mentioned the cost seg study too — that’s the kind of strategic thinking newer investors skip when they’re only chasing flips. You turned a near knockout into a long-term cash flow play and reclaimed your capital. That’s next-level stewardship.

    Respect to you, man. Keep shining that light in Knoxville — stories like this keep the rest of us grounded and fired up at the same time. 🔥

    — Joshua I "Sarge" I Renewed Legacy Group

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.